Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutOrdinance No. 4475 Ordinance - Sidewalk, Driveway, Curb and Gutter Construction and Repair Secs. 9-5-1, 9-5-3 thru 8 ORDINANCE NO___________ AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE TITLE OF CHAPTER 9-5, AND AMENDING SECTIONS 9-5-1, 9-5-3, 9-5-4, 9-5-6, 9-5-7, AND 9- 5-8 OF CHAPTER 9-5 OF TITLE 9 OF THE ROCHESTER CODE OF ORDINANCES RELATING TO SIDEWALK, DRIVEWAY AND CURB AND GUTTER CONSTRUCTION AND REPAIR. THE COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ORDAINS: Section 1. Title Chapter 9-5 of Title 9 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: CHAPTER 9-5. SIDEWALK, DRIVEWAY APPROACH AND CURB AND GUTTER CONSTRUCTION AND REPAIR. Section 2. Section 9-5-1 of Chapter 9-5 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: Sec. 9-5-1. – Permit required. (a) No person shall locate, establish, begin to construct, construct or alter any concrete or asphalt sidewalks, driveway approaches, or curb and gutters, curb-cut, drive approach in the public right-of-way without first obtaining a permit from the city engineer as provided by this chapter. However, no permit shall be required for persons adjusting a sidewalk or driveway approach by realignment of an otherwise displaced, undamaged concrete panel by means of mudjacking, lifting, horizontal cutting, or grinding. Additionally, if any work described in this paragraph is being performed on behalf of the city or under contract with the city on approved plans and specifications, no permit is required. (b) Sidewalk and driveway approach adjustments must be completed in accordance with city sidewalk specifications. Any adjusted panels found to be defective as a result of adjustments will require replacement by the abutting property owner. (c) Construction, replacement, or adjustment of a curb and gutter, driveway approach, or sidewalk must be completed by a contractor holding a valid license as authorized by this Code. Section 3. Section 9-5-3 of Chapter 9-5 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: Sec. 9-5-3 – Permit fees. Each application shall be accompanied by a permit fee as established by resolution of the city council. When concrete or asphalt sidewalks, driveway approaches, or curb and gutters, curbs, curb-cuts or driveways are to be located, established, constructed or altered simultaneously, only one permit and one permit fee shall be required. Section 4. Section 9-5-4 of Chapter 9-5 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: Sec. 9-5-4. – Standards for issuance. (a) The city engineer shall issue a permit hereunder when the city engineer finds: (1) That the work will be done according to the standard specifications of the city for the same or similar public work and in accordance with specifications established by the city engineer for the type of work covered by this chapter; (2) That the concrete or asphalt sidewalks, driveway approaches, or curb and gutters, curb, curb-cut or driveway proposed will not constitute a traffic hazard or unreasonably impair or interfere with vehicular and pedestrian traffic, the demand and necessity for parking spaces, and the means of ingress to and from adjacent properties; (3) That the health, welfare and safety of the public will not be unreasonably impaired; and (4) That the person doing the work is properly qualified. (b) If a permit is denied, the city engineer shall forthwith notify the applicant in writing and shall set forth in such notice the reasons for denying the permit. Section 5. Section 9-5-6 of Chapter 9-5 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: Sec. 9-5-6. – Alterations. Whenever the safety, movement or accommodation of vehicular and pedestrian traffic or the use, convenience and necessity of the public require, the city engineer may order the owners or persons in possession of abutting property to alter, relocate, close or discontinue the use of any curb-cut or driveway approach in such manner as the city engineer finds reasonably necessary under the circumstances. Notice to alter, relocate, close or discontinue the use of any curb-cut or driveway approach shall be in writing, shall specify the change to be made, shall state the reasons for such change, shall require compliance within a reasonable time to be specified in the order and shall be served personally or by registered mail on the owner or person in possession of the abutting property. Upon failure of the owner or person in possession of the abutting property to comply with the order within the time specified or any authorized extension thereof, the city engineer shall take such action as deemed necessary with city or other forces to accomplish the purpose of the order. 2 Section 6. Section 9-5-7 of Chapter 9-5 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: Sec. 9-5-7. – Maximum driveway approach width (a) No driveway approach shall be constructed in the city wider than 32 feet at the sidewalk line, such width being measured perpendicular to the direction of travel on the driveway approach. Adjacent driveways approaches on the same lot or property shall be separated by a distance of at least ten feet. (b) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a) of this section, the common council may permit an applicant to construct a driveway approach wider than 32 feet upon a favorable recommendation from the city engineer. The construction of a driveway approach wider than 32 feet may be approved by the council upon the determination that the wider width can safely accommodate entrance and egress of large vehicles or heavy volumes of traffic. Section 7. Section 9-5-8 of Chapter 9-5 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is hereby amended to read as follows: Sec. 9-5-8. – Appeals to council. Any person aggrieved by any action taken by the city engineer in granting or denying a permit or in ordering the alteration, relocation, closing or discontinuance of the use of any curb-cut or driveway approach, may appeal to the council by filing in the office of the city clerk a notice of appeal specifying the grounds thereof. An appeal shall stay all proceedings in furtherance of the action appealed from. Such appeal shall be taken within 30 days of the date of the written notice of the city engineer denying a permit or ordering action under section 9-5-6. The person appealing shall be given an opportunity to be heard before the council or before a committee of the council to which the matter has been referred for review and recommendation. Thereafter, the council may affirm, reverse or modify the action of the city engineer. Section 8. This ordinance shall become effective from and after its publication. 3 PASSED AND ADOPTED BY THE COMMON COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF ROCHESTER, MINNESOTA, THIS __________ DAY OF _______________, 2022. ___________________________________ PRESIDENT OF SAID COMMON COUNCIL ATTEST: __________________________ CITY CLERK APPROVED THIS _____ DAY OF ______________________, 2022. ___________________________________ MAYOR OF SAID CITY (Seal of the City of Rochester, Minnesota) Ord20/9-5 SidewalkRepairEtc.docx 4 Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title temporart Site T Adoption Draft Unified Development Code Unified Development Code June 2022 Installment 1 Staff Draft Adopted Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code September 7th 2022 June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title Table of Contents Contents Chapter 60.100 General Provisions .......................................................................................1 Section 60.100.010 Title .......................................................................................................1 Section 60.100.020 Purpose .................................................................................................1 Section 60.100.030 Applicability ...........................................................................................1 A. General Applicability .....................................................................................................1 B. Compliance Required ...................................................................................................2 Section 60.100.040 Authority ................................................................................................2 Section 60.100.050 Transition Rules .....................................................................................2 A. Repeal of Land Development Manual ...........................................................................2 B. Repeal of Chapter in Rochester Code of Ordinances ....................................................2 C. Adoption of Existing Conditions of Approval ..................................................................3 D. Prior Development Approvals........................................................................................3 E. Pending Applications ....................................................................................................3 F. Prior Violations ..............................................................................................................3 Section 60.100.060 Effective Date ........................................................................................4 Section 60.100.070 Severability ............................................................................................4 Section 60.100.080 Clerical Errors ........................................................................................4 Chapter 60.200 Zone Districts ................................................................................................5 Section 60.200.010 Zoning Districts Established ...................................................................5 A. Summary Table of Zoning Districts ...............................................................................5 Section 60.200.020 Official Zoning Map ................................................................................6 A. General .........................................................................................................................6 B. Boundary Interpretation.................................................................................................6 Section 60.200.030 Base Districts.........................................................................................8 A. AG - Agricultural............................................................................................................8 B. R-1 – Mixed Single-Family ..........................................................................................10 C. R-2 – Low Density Small Lot .......................................................................................12 D. R-2x – Low Density Residential Infill ...........................................................................14 E. R-3 – Medium Density Residential ..............................................................................16 F. R-4 – High Density Residential ...................................................................................18 G. MX-N – Mixed Use Neighborhood Scale .....................................................................20 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title H. MX-S – Mixed Use Street-Oriented .............................................................................22 I. MX-C – Mixed Use Center ..........................................................................................24 J. MX-G – Mixed Use General ........................................................................................26 K. MX-I – Mixed Use Institutional.....................................................................................28 L. MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development ........................................................................30 M. MX-D – Mixed Use Downtown ....................................................................................36 N. BP – Business Park ....................................................................................................38 O. LI – Light Industrial ......................................................................................................41 P. SI – Special Industrial .................................................................................................43 Q. H - Holding ..................................................................................................................45 Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts ..................................................................................46 A. General Applicability ...................................................................................................46 B. APO -- Airport Protection Overlay ...............................................................................46 C. HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay .........................................................................46 D. DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay .....................................................................................52 E. FPO – Floodplain Overlay ...........................................................................................60 F. SDO – Shoreland District Overlay ...............................................................................78 Chapter 60.300 Use Regulations ..........................................................................................88 Section 60.300.010 Introduction ..........................................................................................88 A. Organization of the Table ............................................................................................88 B. Allowed Uses Table ....................................................................................................88 C. Unlisted Uses and Structures ......................................................................................89 D. Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws ....................................................................89 Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards .......................................................................97 A. Applicability .................................................................................................................97 B. Residential Uses .........................................................................................................97 C. Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses........................................................................... 102 D. Commercial Uses...................................................................................................... 104 E. Industrial Uses .......................................................................................................... 117 F. Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses ................................................................. 120 G. Accessory Uses and Structures ................................................................................ 128 H. Temporary Permits ................................................................................................... 139 Chapter 60.400 Development Standards and Incentives ................................................. 143 Section 60.400.010 Introduction and Applicability ............................................................. 143 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 143 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 143 Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards ...................................................................... 144 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 144 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 144 C. Multiple Non-Residential Buildings on a Lot .............................................................. 144 D. Application of Setbacks ............................................................................................. 144 2. Front Lot Lines on Private Roadways ........................................................................ 146 E. General Dimensional Standards ............................................................................... 148 F. Neighborhood Protection Standards ......................................................................... 151 G. Exceptions to the Dimensional Standards ................................................................. 153 Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards ....................................................................... 155 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 155 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 155 C. Subdivision Name ..................................................................................................... 155 D. Vertical Subdivision ................................................................................................... 156 E. Adequate Public Facilities ......................................................................................... 156 F. Access and Connectivity ........................................................................................... 161 G. Lot Design Standards ............................................................................................... 161 H. Roadway and Subdivision Design Standards ............................................................ 163 I. Boulevard Trees........................................................................................................ 163 J. Private Roadways ..................................................................................................... 163 K. Street Classification .................................................................................................. 164 L. Quadrant Street System............................................................................................ 164 M. Parkland Dedication .................................................................................................. 165 Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity .................................................................... 171 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 171 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 171 C. Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation ......................................................... 171 D. Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity ....................................................... 181 Section 60.400.050 Sensitive Lands, Wetlands, Stormwater, and Drainage ..................... 191 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 191 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 191 C. Relationship to Other Standards ............................................................................... 191 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title D. General Requirement for all Sensitive Lands ............................................................ 191 E. Wetlands ................................................................................................................... 191 F. Stormwater ............................................................................................................... 192 G. Erosion Control, Grading, and Stormwater Management .......................................... 193 Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences .............................................. 195 A. Boulevard Trees........................................................................................................ 195 B. General Landscaping ................................................................................................ 198 C. Parking Lot Landscaping ........................................................................................... 205 D. Bufferyards ............................................................................................................... 206 E. Fences, Walls, and Hedges ...................................................................................... 209 F. Alternative Equivalent Compliance ............................................................................ 210 Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design .................................................................... 210 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 210 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 211 C. Access and Connectivity ........................................................................................... 211 D. Parking ..................................................................................................................... 211 E. Site Design ............................................................................................................... 211 F. Building Design ......................................................................................................... 216 Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking ......................................................... 223 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 223 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 224 C. Compliance with Other City Ordinances .................................................................... 224 D. Calculation of Parking and Loading Requirements .................................................... 224 E. Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required ................................................... 225 F. Minimum Parking Adjustments .................................................................................. 230 G. Maximum Parking Adjustments ................................................................................. 233 H. Visitor Parking ........................................................................................................... 233 I. Small Car Percentage ............................................................................................... 234 J. Design and Location of Vehicle Parking .................................................................... 234 K. Use of Vehicle Parking .............................................................................................. 240 L. Loading and Stacking Areas ..................................................................................... 241 M. Bicycle Parking ......................................................................................................... 242 Section 60.400.090 Exterior Storage ................................................................................. 243 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 243 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title B. Requirements in Agricultural and Residential Districts .............................................. 243 C. Requirements in Mixed Use and Non-Residential Districts ........................................ 244 Section 60.400.100 Exterior Lighting ................................................................................. 244 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 244 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 244 C. Lighting for Parking Lots and Garages ...................................................................... 245 D. Method of Measurement ........................................................................................... 245 E. General Requirements .............................................................................................. 245 F. Luminaire Mounting .................................................................................................. 246 G. Maximum Permitted Illumination and Height ............................................................. 246 Section 60.400.110 Signs ................................................................................................. 247 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 247 B. Applicability ............................................................................................................... 248 C. Signs Not Requiring a Permit .................................................................................... 248 D. Signs Requiring a Permit .......................................................................................... 249 E. Prohibited Signs ........................................................................................................ 249 F. Sign Standards ......................................................................................................... 250 G. Billboards .................................................................................................................. 255 H. Temporary Signs....................................................................................................... 257 I. Murals and Other Displays ........................................................................................ 258 J. Message Substitution ................................................................................................ 259 K. Sign Measurements .................................................................................................. 259 Section 60.400.120 Incentives .......................................................................................... 260 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 260 B. Combination of Bonuses ........................................................................................... 260 C. Timing of Incentive Application and Decision ............................................................ 261 D. Summary of Incentives.............................................................................................. 261 E. Incentive Requirements ............................................................................................ 264 F. Criteria for Incentives ................................................................................................ 268 Section 60.400.130 Maintenance and Operation............................................................... 269 A. Compliance with Other City, State, and Federal Requirements ................................. 269 B. Specialized Report .................................................................................................... 269 C. Point of Measurement ............................................................................................... 269 D. Public Amenities ....................................................................................................... 269 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title E. Landscaping and Usable Recreation Areas .............................................................. 269 F. Exterior Storage ........................................................................................................ 270 G. Signs......................................................................................................................... 270 H. Odors ........................................................................................................................ 270 I. Heat .......................................................................................................................... 271 J. Fire and Explosion Hazards ...................................................................................... 271 K. Glare ......................................................................................................................... 271 L. Smoke ...................................................................................................................... 271 M. Particulates ............................................................................................................... 272 N. Vibration ................................................................................................................... 272 O. Noise ........................................................................................................................ 273 Chapter 60.500 Procedures and Administration ............................................................... 274 Section 60.500.010 Introduction and Summary Table of Procedures ................................ 274 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 274 B. Summary Table of Review Procedures ..................................................................... 274 Section 60.500.020 Review and Decision-making Bodies ................................................. 277 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 277 B. Community Development Director ............................................................................ 277 C. Planning Commission ............................................................................................... 278 D. Heritage Preservation Commission ........................................................................... 279 E. Zoning Board of Appeals ........................................................................................... 280 F. City Council ............................................................................................................... 280 Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures ......................................................................... 281 A. General ..................................................................................................................... 281 B. Pre-Submittal Activities ............................................................................................. 281 C. Public Hearings ......................................................................................................... 283 D. Application Submittal and Processing ....................................................................... 287 E. Review and Decision ................................................................................................ 293 F. Post-Decision Actions and Limitations ...................................................................... 299 Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council......................................................... 306 A. Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment ....................... 306 B. Growth Management Map Major Amendment ........................................................... 309 C. Annexation of Land ................................................................................................... 312 D. UDC Text Amendment .............................................................................................. 314 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title E. Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) ............................................................. 317 F. Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District ........................ 322 G. Major Land Subdivision Permit .................................................................................. 326 H. Final Plat ................................................................................................................... 331 I. Official Map Adoption ................................................................................................ 332 J. Public Street or Easement Vacation .......................................................................... 334 K. Criteria for Public Street Vacation Approval .............................................................. 335 L. Distinctive Development............................................................................................ 336 M. See Section 60.500.050A Conditional Use Permit for criteria. ................................... 339 N. Interim Use Permit .................................................................................................... 340 Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority ............ 342 A. Conditional Use Permit ............................................................................................. 342 B. Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration ...................................................... 347 C. Shoreland Protection Permit ..................................................................................... 348 Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director .......... 351 A. Zoning Certificate ...................................................................................................... 351 B. General Development Plan ....................................................................................... 353 C. Site Development Plan.............................................................................................. 356 D. Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration ...................................................... 358 E. Rental Housing Certificate ........................................................................................ 360 F. Temporary Permit ..................................................................................................... 361 G. Minor Land Subdivision Permit .................................................................................. 362 H. Floodplain Development Permit ................................................................................ 364 I. Grading Permit .......................................................................................................... 367 J. Lot Line Readjustment .............................................................................................. 369 K. Sign Permit ............................................................................................................... 370 Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief ........................................................................... 370 A. Minor Modification ..................................................................................................... 370 B. Major Modification ..................................................................................................... 375 C. Variance ................................................................................................................... 379 Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities ................................................................................. 382 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 382 B. General Authority to Continue ................................................................................... 383 C. Bringing a Nonconformity into Compliance................................................................ 383 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title D. Conditions on Nonconformities ................................................................................. 383 E. Nonconforming Use .................................................................................................. 383 F. Nonconforming Structure .......................................................................................... 386 G. Nonconforming Structure Created by Flood District Regulations ............................... 387 H. Nonconforming Lot .................................................................................................... 388 I. Nonconforming Site Feature ..................................................................................... 389 J. Nonconforming Signs ................................................................................................ 391 Section 60.500.090 Violations, Enforcement, and Penalties.............................................. 392 A. Responsibility ............................................................................................................ 392 B. City Policy on Compliance ........................................................................................ 392 C. Types of Violation ..................................................................................................... 393 D. Notification ................................................................................................................ 393 E. Investigation of Violations ......................................................................................... 393 F. Notice of Violation ..................................................................................................... 394 G. Discontinuance of Work ............................................................................................ 394 H. Enforcement After Expiration of Time Period ............................................................ 394 I. Penalties ................................................................................................................... 395 Chapter 60.600 Definitions ................................................................................................. 396 Section 60.600.010 Rules of Construction ........................................................................ 396 A. Purpose .................................................................................................................... 396 B. Rules of Construction ................................................................................................ 396 Section 60.600.020 Rules of Measurement ....................................................................... 396 A. Rounding of Numeral Requirements ......................................................................... 396 B. Parking Space Calculation ........................................................................................ 397 C. Computation of Time ................................................................................................. 398 D. Rules of Measurement Separation Requirements ..................................................... 398 Section 60.600.030 Definitions .......................................................................................... 399 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code June 2022 – Adoption Draft Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030A: General Applicability Section 60.100.010 Title Chapter 60.100 General Provisions Section 60.100.010 T ITLE The ordinance codified in this UDC shall be known, cited, and referred to as the “Rochester Unified Development Code” and may also be cited or referred to as the “Unified Development Code,” the “UDC,” the “Zoning Code,” or the “Subdivision Code.” Section 60.100.020 P URPOSE The general purpose of this UDC is to promote the public health, safety, and welfare by providing appropriate and reasonable controls for the development and use of lands in Rochester, while also protecting the rights of property owners. This UDC also is intended to: A. Implement the policies, goals, and strategies adopted by the City of Rochester, including those set forth in the Rochester Comprehensive Plan and other adopted plans; B. Establish and apply zoning districts guided by the Rochester Comprehensive Plan that regulate the location, height, bulk, and size of buildings; provide for a variety of housing types; and reduce congestion; C. Safeguard cultural resources and enhance the appearance and quality of development in Rochester; D. Facilitate the adequate provision of transportation, schools, parks, and other public infrastructure requirements; E. Reduce greenhouse gas emissions and prepare for the impacts of climate change on our community; and F. Sensitively fit the built environment into the natural environment with minimal disturbance to Rochester’s natural ecosystem by requiring planning, design, and development that is compatible with, preserves, and enhances sensitive natural areas such as steep slopes, floodplains, watercourses, drainage ways, and ridge lines; and natural topographic features. Section 60.100.030 A PPLICABILITY A. General Applicability 1. This UDC applies within the municipal limits of the City of Rochester and in any areas outside the established municipal limits where, through joint legislative agreement with the appropriate governing body, the UDC shall be put into effect. 2. This UDC applies to all development in the City. No development may be approved if it would result in a violation of City, County, state, or federal law. No City official or employee may knowingly issue a development permit or license if such issuance would result in a violation of City, County, state, or federal law. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 1 Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.030B: Compliance Required Section 60.100.040 Authority 3. The UDC is not intended to repeal, abrogate, annul, impair, or interfere with any existing easements, covenants, deed restrictions, agreements, rules, regulations, ordinances, or permits previously adopted or issued pursuant to law. However, wherever this UDC imposes greater restrictions, the provisions of this UDC shall govern unless otherwise prohibited by State or Federal law. 4. Tables and illustrations in this UDC are hereby made a part of this UDC and given the same force and effect as the text of this UDC. 5. Any appendices to this UDC and any standards or regulations related to this UDC that are adopted by resolution of the City Council shall be deemed to be part of this UDC and may be enforced by the City as if they were fully set forth in this UDC. B. Compliance Required 1. It shall be the responsibility of all property owners, architects, contractors, subcontractors, builders, and other persons involved in any development, before beginning any development activity to obtain any necessary permits or certificates and to comply with any conditions of approval imposed upon those permits or certificates. 2. For all applications filed under the regulations of this UDC, the burden shall be upon the applicant to provide the necessary information that will show that the proposed development will comply with the provisions of this UDC. Section 60.100.040 A UTHORITY Minn. Stat. Ch. 462, authorizes the municipality to administer planning and zoning activities, establish a Zoning Board of Appeals, enact official controls, and provide penalties for violations. Minn. Stat. Ch. 471.193, authorizes cities to establish and carry out heritage preservation programs. Minn. Stat. Chs. 103, 104, and 105 authorize minimum standards and criteria for the management of “Shoreland” and “Floodplain” areas within the City of Rochester. Minn. Stat. §87A.08, subd. 1(a) and MN Rules 7030 authorize standards for the regulation of Indoor Gun Ranges. Section 60.100.050 T RANSITION R ULES A. Repeal of Land Development Manual This UDC supersedes all other general and permanent ordinances enacted prior to its enactment unless specifically stated otherwise in this UDC. The previous Land Development Manual for the City of Rochester, as was amended and supplemented, is hereby repealed. B. Repeal of Chapter in Rochester Code of Ordinances This UDC repeals and replaces in its entirety Chapter 2-9, Planning and Zoning Commission, and Chapter 4-7, Heritage Preservation, of the Rochester Code of Ordinances. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 2 Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.050C: Adoption of Existing Conditions of Approval Section 60.100.050 Transition Rules C. Adoption of Existing Conditions of Approval This UDC adopts and incorporates by reference the stipulations and conditions from development plans, use permits, variances, stipulations, and conditions that currently apply to any parcel prior to the date of adoption of this UDC. D. Prior Development Approvals 1. Any development approved under regulations in effect prior to the effective date of this UDC may be carried out under the terms and conditions of the approval and the development standards in effect at the time of approval, provided the approval has not expired and the development complies with any applicable standards of this UDC regarding ongoing operations and maintenance. 2. If the prior approval expires without being established within any required time frame, is revoked, or otherwise becomes invalid, any subsequent development of the site shall be subject to the procedures and standards of this UDC. 3. Unless otherwise provided in the initial approval, any proposed amendment to a permit or other form of approval issued under prior regulations shall be reviewed based on the development standards in effect at the time of submission of a complete application for the amendment. 4. Without limiting the generality of Subsections 1, 2, and 3 above, development regulations approved by Ordinances number 2726, 3669, 4052, and 3534 (which are collectively referred to as the Medical Campus District) shall remain in effect and shall regulate the development or redevelopment of those lands to which they apply. When those Ordinances do not specify the procedure or criteria to amend an approved site or development plan, the proposed amendment will be reviewed and decided pursuant to Section 60.500.050A.5, Modifications to Approved Conditional Use Permits. 5. Without limiting the generality of Subsections 1, 2, and 3, Planned Unit Developments approved by the City before \[the effective date of this Code\] be governed by the terms of those approvals until they are amended or replaced, except that amendments to approved Planned Unit Developments shall be reviewed and decided pursuant to Section 60.500.050A.5, Modifications to Approved Conditional Use Permits. E. Pending Applications A development application that has been determined to be complete by the Community Development Director prior to the effective date of this UDC may be decided under the regulations in effect when the application was determined to be complete unless the applicant requests that the application be reviewed and decided under this UDC. Applications shall not be processed under a combination of prior regulations and this UDC. F. Prior Violations If a development or activity in violation of the prior development regulations fully complies with this UDC, it shall no longer be deemed a violation. Unpaid fees and/or penalties from Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 3 Chapter 60.100: General Provisions Section 60.100.050F: Prior Violations Section 60.100.060 Effective Date prior enforcement of violations may still be valid and may remain the responsibility of the violator under the prior regulations, as determined by the Community Development Director. Section 60.100.060 E FFECTIVE D ATE This UDC shall become effective on \[insert effective date of the UDC\]. All references in this UDC to the “effective date of this UDC” or to the “effective date” shall refer to that date unless otherwise stated. Section 60.100.070 S EVERABILITY If any section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of this UDC or the application of it to any person or place is held by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid under Minnesota law, unconstitutional under the Minnesota or United States Constitutions, or inapplicable in any way to the City, for any reason, such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining portions of this UDC or its application to other persons and places. The City Council hereby expressly declares that it would have adopted this UDC and each section, subsection, subdivision, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion irrespective of the fact that any one or more sections, subsections, subdivisions, sentences, clauses, or phrases may be declared invalid or unconstitutional. Section 60.100.080 C LERICAL E RRORS The Community Development Director is authorized to correct any clerical error in an ordinance, resolution, motion, or other action taken by any public body pursuant to the UDC. The Community Development Director is authorized to correct any clerical error in any document attached to, or referenced in, any such ordinance, resolution, motion or other action. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 4 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.010 Zoning Districts Established Section 60.200.010A: Summary Table of Zoning Districts Chapter 60.200 Zone Districts Section 60.200.010 Z ONING D ISTRICTS E STABLISHED A. Summary Table of Zoning Districts The zoning districts shown in Table 200.01-1 are hereby established. Table 200.01-1 Summary Table of Zoning Districts Prior District Name New District Name Agricultural and Residential Districts AG - Agriculture AG -- Agriculture R-1 -- Mixed Single-Family R-1 -- Mixed Single-Family R-Sa -- Mixed Single-Family Overlay R-1x -- Mixed Single-Family Extra R-2 -- Low Density Small Lot R-2 -- Low Density Residential R-2x -- Low Density Residential Extra R-2x -- Low Density Residential Infill R-3 -- Medium Density Residential R-3 -- Medium Density Residential R-4 -- High Density Residential R-4 -- High Density Residential CDC -- Central Development Core Residential subdistrict Mixed Use Districts B-2 -- Pedestrian Oriented Restricted Commercial MX-N -- Mixed Use Neighborhood Scale B-5 -- Residential Commercial B-1 -- Restricted Commercial MX-S -- Mixed Use Street Oriented -- MX-C -- Mixed Use Center B-4 -- General Commercial MX-G -- Mixed Use General MRD -- Mixed Redevelopment MX-I -- Mixed Use Institutional TOD – Transit-Oriented Development (Node and MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development (Node, Corridor subdistricts) Corridor, and Village subdistricts) CDC -- Central Development Core (Fringe, MX-D -- Mixed Use Downtown (Fringe, Business, and Medical, subdistricts) Business, and Medical subdistricts) Non-Residential Districts M-3 -- Low Intensity Mixed Commercial Industrial BP -- Business Park M-1 -- Mixed Commercial Industrial LI -- Light Industrial M-2 -- Industrial SI -- Special Industrial H -- Holding Zone H -- Holding Zone I -- Interim Zone Overlay Districts Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 5 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.020 Official Zoning Map Section 60.200.020A: General Rochester International Airport Zoning Ordinance APO -- Airport Protection Overlay (freestanding ordinance) Heritage Preservation Overlay District (Rochester HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay Code Section 4.7) Shoreland District SDO -- Shoreland District Overlay Decorah Edge Overlay District (Olmsted County DEO -- Decorah Edge Overlay Code Section 9.20) FF -- Flood Fringe District FPO -- Floodplain Overlay FP -- Flood Prone District FW -- Floodway District Section 60.200.020 O FFICIAL Z ONING M AP A. General 1. Zoning districts established by this UDC are bounded and defined as shown on the Official Rochester Zoning Map that, together with all explanatory materials contained on that map, is made a part of this UDC. 2. The Official Zoning Map is the latest version of the map reflecting the boundaries of those districts established by this UDC that is maintained on the City’s website and reflects all amendments to the map approved by Council. 3. The Community Development Director shall be responsible for maintaining the Official Zoning Map so that it reflects all amendments approved by Council and shall ensure that the City Clerk is able to access that map. B. Boundary Interpretation 1. The Community Development Director shall use the following rules to determine the precise location of any zone boundary shown on the Official Zoning Map: a. Boundaries indicated as approximately following governmental incorporation or extraterritorial jurisdiction boundaries shall be construed as following those boundaries. b. Boundaries indicated as following or approximately following the center lines of streets, highways, or alleys shall be construed to follow those centerlines. c. Boundaries indicated as approximately following platted lot lines shall be construed as following those lot lines. d. Boundaries shown as following or approximately following railroad lines shall be construed to lie midway between the main tracks of such railroad lines. e. Boundaries shown as following or approximately following the centerline of streams, rivers, or other continuously flowing water courses shall be construed as following the channel centerline of those water courses taken at mean low water, and in the event of a natural change in the location of such streams, rivers, or other water courses, the zone boundary shall be construed as moving with the channel centerline. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 6 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.020 Official Zoning Map Section 60.200.020B: Boundary Interpretation f. Boundaries shown as following shorelines of any lake shall be construed to follow the mean high waterline of the lake, and in the event of change in the mean high waterline, shall be construed as moving with the actual mean high waterline. g. Boundaries shown as following section lines, half section lines, or quarter section lines shall be construed as following those lines. h. Boundaries indicated as following the contours of certain elevations or soils of a particular type shall be construed as following the actual height or soil contour as determined by accepted surveying practice. i. Boundaries indicted as separated from, and parallel or approximately parallel to, any of the features listed in paragraphs one through eight above shall be construed to be parallel to those features and at such distances there from as are shown on the map. j. Where multiple districts apply on a lot, the standards applicable to the majority of the area shall apply. 2. A property owner or applicant may appeal the decision of the Community Development Director regarding a zoning district boundary under Subsection 1 above as described in Section 60.500.030F.2, Appeals. For the purposes of that Section, a zoning district boundary determination is not considered a use of property under Minn. Stat. 462.357, subd. 2(2). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 7 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030A: AG - Agricultural Section 60.200.030 B ASE D ISTRICTS A. AG - Agricultural 1. Purpose The AG district is intended to accommodate large lot rural residential and agricultural uses in annexed undeveloped areas. It is characterized by open areas of land, large planted areas, and detached residential uses surrounding more densely populated rural and urbanized areas of the community. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 8 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030A: AG - Agricultural 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-1 AG Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 35 Acres Lot Width 60 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 20 B Interior Side 6 Street Side 12 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards 16 C Rear 25 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 35 E Accessory Structure 45 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 9 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030B: R-1 – Mixed Single-Family B. R-1 – Mixed Single-Family 1. Purpose The R-1 district is intended to maintain and promote areas of low residential density where the emphasis is generally on the development of single-family dwellings of various styles. Uses supportive and in character with low-density residential are permitted. This district also provides opportunities for in-fill development in established areas through the efficient use of the existing housing stock and infrastructure. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 10 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030B: R-1 – Mixed Single-Family 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-2 R-1 Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 5,000 sq. ft. Lot Width 60 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side 5 Street Side 12 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards 12 C Rear 20 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 35 Accessory Structure 15 \[1\] NOTES \[1\]24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 11 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030C: R-2 – Low Density Small Lot C. R-2 – Low Density Small Lot 1. Purpose The R-2 district is intended to maintain and promote areas with a mixture of residential dwelling types that are of an overall low-density or are undergoing a conversion from predominantly single-family detached dwellings to duplexes and other attached dwellings. Certain supportive non-residential uses, and compatible infill development, consistent with the character of the area are permitted. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 12 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030C: R-2 – Low Density Small Lot 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-3 R-2 Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 3,000 sq. ft. Lot Width 30 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side 0 Street Side 11 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards 10 C Rear 10 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 35 Accessory Structure 15 \[1\] NOTES \[1\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 13 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030D: R-2x – Low Density Residential Infill D. R-2x – Low Density Residential Infill 1. Purpose The R-2x district is intended to maintain and promote areas with a mixture of residential dwelling types of overall low- to medium-density near the downtown core. This district is established to support residential infill and reinvestment that is compatible with the existing characteristics of development. Certain supportive non-residential uses may be provided within the district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 14 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030D: R-2x – Low Density Residential Infill 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-4 R-2x Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 2,000 sq. ft. Lot Width 30 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 20 B Interior Side 6 Street Side 10 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards 12 C Rear 20 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 45 E Accessory Structure 15 \[1\] NOTES \[1\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. 3. Additional Requirements a. The maximum length of a multifamily building façade facing any public street shall be limited to 80 feet. b. Each façade longer than 50 feet in length facing any public street shall be divided into modules consistent with Section 60.400.070F, Building Design. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 15 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030E: R-3 – Medium Density Residential E. R-3 – Medium Density Residential 1. Purpose The R-3 district is intended to maintain and promote predominantly multifamily residential dwellings. It is appropriate for medium-density areas or existing low-density areas where there is a need to encourage higher-density redevelopment. Certain supportive non-residential uses and civic uses, consistent with the character of the area are permitted. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 16 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030E: R-3 – Medium Density Residential 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-5 R-3 Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 3,500 sq. ft. Lot Width 30 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 20 B Interior Side 6 Street Side 12 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards 16 C Rear 25 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 48 Accessory Structure 25 3. Additional District Standards No commercial use shall have a gross floor area greater than 2,500 square feet, or 50 percent of the gross floor area of the ground floor of a multifamily dwelling building in which it is located, whichever is greater. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 17 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030F: R-4 – High Density Residential F. R-4 – High Density Residential 1. Purpose The R-4 district is intended to maintain and promote multifamily residential dwellings of the highest intensity along with certain supportive commercial and Non-Residential and civic uses of similar intensity. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 18 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030F: R-4 – High Density Residential 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-6 R-4 Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 6,000 sq. ft. Lot Width 60 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side 10 Street Side 7 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear 15 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 115 Accessory Structure 25 3. Additional District Standards No commercial use shall have a gross floor area greater than 2,500 square feet, or 50 percent of the gross floor area of the ground floor of a multifamily dwelling building in which it is located, whichever is greater. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 19 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030G: MX-N – Mixed Use Neighborhood Scale G. MX-N – Mixed Use Neighborhood Scale 1. Purpose The MX-N district is intended to maintain and provide for a mix of low-intensity commercial and residential uses in areas adjacent to more traditional residential districts. Typically, on corners near or at the edges of residential districts, the district contributes to the vitality and health of the community by providing walking, biking, and transit access to neighborhood-scale commercial areas and supporting pedestrian-friendly uses and design. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 20 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030G: MX-N – Mixed Use Neighborhood Scale 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-7 MX-N Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum or Maximum, in feet) A Front None to 15 (maximum) B Interior Side 5 Street Side 7 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards 10 C Rear 5 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 24 Accessory Structure 15 \[1\] NOTES \[1\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. 3. Additional District Standards a. Maximum Size of Non-Residential Uses 1) No non-residential use shall have a gross floor area greater than 5,000 square feet. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 21 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030H: MX-S – Mixed Use Street-Oriented b. Access Requirements for Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. H. MX-S – Mixed Use Street-Oriented 1. Purpose The MX-S district is intended to maintain and promote low to mid-intensity commercial uses that are located along streets near or at the edges of residential zone districts. This district contributes to the vitality and health of the community by providing walking, biking, and transit access to local commercial areas and supporting pedestrian-friendly uses and design. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 22 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts 0: 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-8 MX-S Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum or Maximum, in feet) A Front None to 15 (maximum) B Interior Side None Street Side 7 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear None Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 36 Accessory Structure 15 \[1\] NOTES \[1\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 23 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030I: MX-C – Mixed Use Center I. MX-C – Mixed Use Center 1. Purpose The MX-C district is intended to provide for pedestrian-friendly areas of medium-density residential development and compatible non-residential uses such as lodging, offices, retail, civic and community, and accessory uses. Development shall be at a walkable scale that is compatible with surrounding residential neighborhoods. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 24 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030I: MX-C – Mixed Use Center 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-9 MX-C Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side None Street Side None Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear 7 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 48 Accessory Structure 15 \[1\] NOTES \[1\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 25 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030J: MX-G – Mixed Use General J. MX-G – Mixed Use General 1. Purpose The MX-G district is intended to provide for areas of concentrated mid- to high-intensity commercial development, oriented toward either a street frontage or an intersection location where transit is not available, or service is infrequent. Uses in the district are generally sized and intended to serve a large number of residents in the entire region or community. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 26 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030J: MX-G – Mixed Use General 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-10 MX-G Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side None Street Side 7 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear None Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 60 Accessory Structure 25 3. Additional District Standards a. Industrial uses shall not occupy the ground floor street frontage of any building; b. No more than 50 percent of the gross floor area of any building shall be occupied by mechanical equipment or machinery engaged in manufacturing, finishing, or assembling activities (including space occupied by the machine operators); and c. Retail, wholesale, or office activities that are part of the business operation are permitted uses in that area of the building occupying the street level frontage. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 27 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030K: MX-I – Mixed Use Institutional K. MX-I – Mixed Use Institutional 1. Purpose The MX-I district is intended to accommodate institutional, civic, non-profit, and other campus types uses involving multiple related buildings such as universities and colleges, medical centers, resort complexes, and research centers, regardless of public or private ownership. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 28 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030K: MX-I – Mixed Use Institutional 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-11 MX-I Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side 10 Street Side 7 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear 8 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 70 Accessory Structure 25 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 29 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030L: MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development L. MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development 1. Purpose The MX-T district is intended to provide opportunities for transit-supportive and transit- oriented development (TOD). It requires intensities and patterns of development that support vibrant pedestrian activity, promote the use of transit, and discourage land uses and types of development that could interfere with transit ridership. The MX-T district has three subdistricts as described below. a. Purpose of Corridor Subdistrict The MX-T Corridor subdistrict is the least intensive of the three subdistricts. It is intended for areas adjacent to the transit stations and generally extends no more than one-quarter mile from the station. It includes high intensity businesses and high- density residential uses. Ground floor commercial uses will occur along most street frontages. b. Purpose of Node Subdistrict The MX-T Node subdistrict is the medium-intensity subdistrict. It is intended to create a transition in building height, development density, and range of uses between the Corridor subdistrict and the adjacent non-TOD developments and neighborhoods. This subdistrict contains mixed use development but is primarily characterized by residential uses. c. Purpose of Village Subdistrict The MX-T Village subdistrict is the highest-intensity subdistrict and is intended for areas that are in close proximity to a City park-and-ride facility. It permits taller and longer buildings than the other MX-T subdistricts in order to accommodate large parking garages enclosed by other uses, as well as freestanding residential and supporting commercial uses. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 30 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030L: MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-12 MX-T Lot and Building Standards Subdistricts Corridor Node Village Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None None None Lot Width None None None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front \[1\] 0 0 0 B Interior Side 5 0 5 Street Side 2 2 2 Minimum Sum of Interior 10 0 5 Side Yards C Rear 5 0 5 Building/Structure Height and Length (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 65 85 95 Accessory Structure 30 30 30 Building Length 300 300 300 NOTES \[1\] A front yard or street side yard equal in width to the front yard required in the adjacent residential zoning districts shall be provided on any lot abutting a side lot line of the R-1 or R-2 district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 31 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030L: MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development 3. Additional District Standards a. Building Placement At least 65 percent of the first floor of the front façade of each primary building shall be located not more than 15 feet from each front lot line. In cases where a recorded easement requires a larger setback, at least 65 percent of the first floor of the front façade of each primary building shall be located no further than the minimum distance required by the recorded easement. b. Building Design 1) Setback areas between a public or private street (excluding alleys) and the structure shall be occupied with pedestrian oriented space in compliance with Section 60.400.040D.11.d, Pedestrian Oriented Space. 2) Additional standards on building design can be found in Section 60.400.070, Site and Building Design. c. Minimum Building Height 1) In the MX-T Corridor subdistrict, portions of new primary structures located within 100 feet of N. and S. Broadway Ave, 2nd St SW., and 4th St SE shall be a minimum of 25 feet in height. 2) In the MX-T Node and Village subdistricts, portions of new primary structures located within 100 feet of N. and S. Broadway Ave, 2nd St SW, and 4th St. SE/Collegeview Rd. shall be a minimum of 40 feet in height. d. Building Entrances 1) Each primary structure shall have at least one pedestrian entrance on each façade facing a public right-of-way. If the lot has frontage on those portions of th N. and S. Broadway, 2nd St SW, 4th St SE/Collegeview Rd. SE, 12 St. SE or rd 3 Ave. SE, the required entrance shall face those streets. If the lot does not have frontage on the pedestrian entrance shall face the front lot line. 2) If there are multiple ground-floor tenant spaces facing a public right-of-way, each ground floor tenant space with 25 feet of frontage or more shall have at least one pedestrian entrance facing that public right-of-way. As an exception to this standard, a maximum of two abutting ground floor tenants may share a single pedestrian entrance facing that public right-of-way. 3) Each required pedestrian entrance shall open directly to the outside and have direct access to the adjacent sidewalk without requiring pedestrians to pass through a garage, parking lot, or a non-pedestrian area located between the pedestrian entrance and the street or right-of-way. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 32 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030L: MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development e. Windows 1) Each façade of a primary building facing a public right-of-way shall have transparent windows or other transparent glazed area covering: (a) 65 percent or more of the ground floor façade area, as measured between three and eight feet above sidewalk grade; and (b) 30 percent or more of each floor level of the façade above the ground floor, as measured between three and eight feet above each floor level. 2) Required ground floor window or glazed areas shall have a visible light transmittance ratio of 0.6 or higher and shall not include reflective or heavily tinted windows. f. Sidewalks, Pedestrian Circulation, and Vehicular Connectivity 1) The internal vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian circulation systems ("circulation systems") of each development shall be designed to allow vehicular, bicycle, and pedestrian cross-access between the circulation systems of the proposed development and the circulation systems of existing or allowable future development on adjoining lots. The Director may adjust or waive this requirement if the Director determines that it is unlikely that the cross-access provisions will be available on the adjoining lot within a reasonable period of time. 2) Sidewalks shall be provided on both sides of the street, and shall comply with the following standards: (a) On property fronting N. or S. Broadway, SW. 2nd. St, or SE. 4th thrd St./Collegeview Dr. SE, 12 St. SE, or 3 Ave. SE, sidewalks shall be a minimum of 10 feet in width, and a planting strip at least five feet in width shall be located between the sidewalk and the street. (b) On property fronting any street other those listed in Subsection (a) above, sidewalks shall be a minimum of seven feet in width, and a planting strip at least five feet in width shall be located between the sidewalk and the street. (c) At least one walkway shall be provided from an adjacent sidewalk to each building entrance. (d) Where a sidewalk, trail, or other walkway crosses a street, driveway, drive aisle, or parking lot, the crossing shall be clearly marked with a change in paving material, color, or height, decorative bollards, or similar elements. 3) Where a lot or development site includes more than one primary structure, an accessible pedestrian walkway at least five feet in width shall be provided between at least one accessible pedestrian entrance in each primary structure. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 33 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030L: MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development g. Bicycle Parking Bicycle parking shall be provided as required in Section 60.400.080M, Bicycle Parking. h. Pedestrian and Site Design Standards 1) All developments in the MX-T District shall comply with Section 60.400.040D.11, Pedestrian Design and Accessibility. 2) Where the standards of the MX-T District are in conflict with the Pedestrian Design and Accessibility standards, the provisions of this MX-T District shall govern. i. Consolidation or Subdivision of Existing Lots No consolidation of two or more existing lots into a parcel of one acre or larger shall be approved, and no subdivision of existing lots shall be approved, unless the applicant has submitted a General Development Plan demonstrating that a high level of pedestrian, bicycle, and motor vehicle connectivity will be maintained through the consolidated or subdivided parcel or parcels, and the City has approved that plan as consistent with the goals of the comprehensive plan and with any other approved connectivity plans for abutting or nearby properties. j. General Development Plan Required 1) Each property located in a MX-T Node or MX-T Village subdistrict that contains more than 10 acres of site area (taken individually or with adjacent parcels in common or related ownership) shall obtain approval of a General Development Plan prior to approval of a Site Development Plan or issuance of a building permit for construction of a new primary structure. 2) The General Development Plan required by Subsection I.1 above shall cover either: (a) All of the property in the MX-T Node or Village, or (b) All of the property in common or related ownership within the MX-T Node or Village, or (c) All of the property in common or related ownership within a portion of the MX- T Node bounded that is separated from other portions of the MX-T Node or Village by arterial or collector streets. 3) The General Development Plan required by Subsection I.1 shall designate the following: (a) One pedestrian-oriented street or walkway system extending from the nearest transit stop boundary no further than 300 feet that is located and designed to provide convenient accessible pedestrian access to the transit Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 34 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030L: MX-T – Transit-Oriented Development stop without requiring pedestrians to cross or walk along an arterial or collector street. (b) If a city-designated park and ride is included in the MX-T Node or MX-T Village, the General Development Plan shall include a street providing automobiles convenient access to that park and ride from collector or arterial streets within or adjacent to the MX-T District without crossing the designated pedestrian-oriented street or walkway system. k. Neighborhood Protection Standards Standards on neighborhood protection can be found in Section 60.400.020F, Neighborhood Protection Standards. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 35 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030M: MX-D – Mixed Use Downtown M. MX-D – Mixed Use Downtown 1. Purpose The MX-D district is intended to provide for the highest intensity of commercial, residential, and institutional development within the City, resulting in a mixture of uses that optimize public facilities and contribute to a vibrant downtown area. The MX-D district has three subdistricts as described below: a. Purpose of Fringe Subdistrict The MX-D Fringe subdistrict is intended for less intensive commercial and service uses that are necessary or tend to support and enhance the activities within the Central Business subdistrict. b. Purpose of Medical Subdistrict The MX-D Medical subdistrict is intended to preserve and enhance medical facilities and major public and quasi-public uses, along with related supporting uses, in the vicinity of the St. Mary’s Hospital and medical campus. c. Purpose of Business Subdistrict The MX-D Business subdistrict is intended to promote the goals of the Downtown Rochester Master Plan. It is intended for the highest intensity of concentrated and integrated retail, financial, office, service, and entertainment uses, with an emphasis on pedestrian amenities. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 36 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030M: MX-D – Mixed Use Downtown 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-13 MX-D Lot and Building Standards Subdistricts Fringe Medical Business Lot Dimensions (Minimum) A Lot Area None None None B Lot Width None None None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) C Front \[1\] None None None D Interior Side None None None Street Side None None None E Minimum Sum of Interior None None None Side Yards F Rear None None None Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) G Primary Structure 135 185 235 H Accessory Structure 30 30 30 NOTES \[1\] A front yard or street side yard equal in width to the front yard required in the adjacent residential zoning districts shall be provided on any lot abutting a side lot line of the R-1 or R-2 district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 37 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030N: BP – Business Park N. BP – Business Park 1. Purpose The BP district is intended to accommodate business park development with high levels of landscaping, a general park-level and individual site-level maximum rate of trip generation, restrictions on outside storage, signs, and lighting, and requirements for connectivity with the intent that such development will be compatible with and connected to adjacent residential development. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 38 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030N: BP – Business Park 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-14 BP Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 5 acres \[1\] Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 25 B Interior Side None Street Side 12 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear 10 \[2\] Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure None \[3\] Accessory Structure None NOTES \[1\] Except for sites that are bounded on all sites by arterial or higher level streets, streams, or other topographic constraints, existing development, land already included in an approved General Development Plan, or permanent open space that limits the inclusion of other abutting lands. \[2\] Rear setback may be reduced to 0 feet when abutting a railroad. \[3\] If within 100 feet of a residential district, then the maximum height shall be 35 feet for all structures. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 39 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030N: BP – Business Park 3. Additional District Standards a. Light Industrial Uses Only those light industrial uses that are not required by state or federal regulations to obtain state or federal level air quality permits are permitted uses in the BP district. b. Exterior Storage Exterior storage areas must be screened from view from adjacent streets and residential areas and shall not be located within 200 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District. c. Self Service Storage Facilities No Self Service Storage Facilities shall be located within 200 feet of Agricultural and Residential District. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 40 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030O: LI – Light Industrial O. LI – Light Industrial 1. Purpose The LI district provides an area for a mixture of commercial and industrial uses that do not generate significant adverse operational or traffic impacts, that are served by major thoroughfares providing direct access or a local street system with direct access to major thoroughfares, and with an adequate level of buffering, could be located in reasonable proximity to residential areas. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 41 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030O: LI – Light Industrial 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-15 LI Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 25 B Interior Side None Street Side 12 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear 10 \[1\] Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 40 \[1\] E Accessory Structure None \[2\] NOTES \[1\] Rear Yard may be reduced to 0 feet when abutting a railroad. \[2\] If within 100 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District, then 50 feet maximum height for accessory structures. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 42 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030P: SI – Special Industrial P. SI – Special Industrial 1. Purpose The SI district is intended to accommodate uses that are potentially incompatible with other districts because of the negative impacts they generate in terms of truck traffic, rail-related activities, late-night operation, or other operational characteristics. It is intended for areas where different levels of infrastructure and transportation improvements can be provided in a cost effective and efficient manner that serve the needs of industrial, transportation, and manufacturing uses. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 43 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030P: SI – Special Industrial 2. Dimensional Standards Table 200.03-16 SI Lot and Building Standards Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None Lot Width None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 25 B Interior Side None Street Side 12 Minimum Sum of Interior Side Yards None C Rear None Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 50 Accessory Structure None \[1\] NOTES \[1\] If within 200 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District, then 50 feet maximum height for accessory structures. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 44 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.030 Base Districts Section 60.200.030Q: H - Holding Q. H - Holding 1. Purpose The H district is intended to provide a temporary zoning classification for certain recently annexed lands where the determination of the permanent zoning classification has not been made by the City at the time of annexation. This district provides a period of time after annexation when permanent development or reuse of land is not permitted and affords the City the opportunity to establish the appropriate zoning district for the property. 2. Applicability The Holding Zone district may be established on property if it is determined by the City that the default designation of R-2 for the annexed property would be inappropriate because of the designation of the property on the Rochester Future Land Use Map, changing conditions applicable to the property or the general area that could result in modifications to the designation of the property on the Rochester Future Land Use Map, or the developed character of the area and the established land uses on the property suggest that a district other than R-2 would be more appropriate for the property. 3. Standards No building or structure shall be erected, enlarged, or moved and no change in the use of land or existing buildings or structures shall be made for properties in the H district except for expansions to existing uses in existing buildings. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 45 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040A: General Applicability Section 60.200.040 O VERLAY D ISTRICTS A. General Applicability These overlay districts described in this Section 60.200.040 supplement, but do not replace, the underlying base zone districts listed in Section 60.200.030, Base Districts. In the case of a conflict between the provisions of a base zone district and the provisions of an overlay district, the provisions of the overlay zone shall apply. Where multiple overlay districts apply to a property, development must comply with all overlay district provisions. In the case of a conflict, the stricter overlay provision shall apply. On topics where an overlay district is silent, the base zone district standards and any other applicable UDC requirements apply. B. APO -- Airport Protection Overlay 1. APO District Regulations The regulations, requirements, and procedures applicable to the APO – Airport Protection Overlay district are contained in Airport Zoning Ordinance Number 6, as that Ordinance may be amended from time to time through procedures described in that Ordinance. That Ordinance, as amended from time to time, is hereby incorporated into this UDC. To obtain the most recent Airport Protection Overlay ordinance please contact the Rochester Community Development Department or review the airport ordinances posted on the Minnesota Department of Transportation website. 2. APO District Map The map of the APO district is the Rochester International Airport zoning map referenced in and resulting from application of the Airport Zoning Ordinance referenced in Subsection 1. That map, as amended from time to time pursuant to the Airport Zoning Ordinance, is hereby incorporated into this UDC. 3. Administration Unless otherwise required by the Airport Zoning Ordinance referenced in Subsection 1, it shall be the duty of the Community Development Director of the City of Rochester to administer and enforce the regulations of this Section 60.200.040B within the boundaries of the city. C. HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay 1. Purpose The HPO district is intended to identify and safeguard properties that have historic value to the community and to: a. Encourage the preservation of properties and districts that reflect elements of the City's cultural, social, economic, political, visual, or architectural history; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 46 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040C: HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay b. Enhance the City's appeal and attraction to residents, visitors, and tourists while promoting its economic viability through the protection and promotion of its unique character as related to its history and heritage; c. Enhance the visual and aesthetic character, diversity, and interest in the City through attention to historic properties; d. Foster civic pride in the beauty and notable accomplishments of the past; e. Promote the preservation and continued use of historic properties for the education and general welfare of the people of the City; and f. Promote the environmental benefits of adapting and reusing buildings. 2. Applicability The HPO district applies to all properties identified as having or likely having historic significance, including those designated as “landmarks” and those listed on the inventory of historic properties maintained by the Heritage Preservation Commission. 3. Heritage Preservation Commission a. The Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC) is hereby established, with membership and operational requirements as described in Section 60.500.020E. b. The HPC shall: 1) Provide recommendations and consultation to the City for adoption, amendment, and administration of the heritage preservation program. 2) Prepare and maintain a comprehensive inventory of all properties within the City by identifying and evaluating properties for historic significance and possible designation. 3) Ensure that there is an updated list of all designated historic resources and properties (landmarks) in the HPO. 4) Recommend the allocation of such subsidies, tax abatements, grants, revolving loan funds, and other funds that may be provided by the City pursuant to the heritage preservation program. 5) Review proposed development and alterations for submitted permits and requests for Certificates of Appropriateness, involving designated properties. 6) Provide educational opportunities for heritage preservation, act in an advisory capacity to its citizens, and reflect the history of the many groups that make up the City's rich heritage; 7) Develop and maintain publicly available historic data, including surveys, investigations, historic context studies and other known publications, articles, books, pamphlets, policies, or other materials having a direct bearing on the heritage preservation program. 4. Identification and Inventory of Properties Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 47 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040C: HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay a. The Heritage Preservation Commission shall conduct, cause to be conducted, or accept submittals of surveys, studies, or investigations of property located within the City that have the potential to be designated landmark property. b. The Heritage Preservation Commission may compile and maintain a list of historic resources and properties that have not yet been fully evaluated and determined to meet the criteria for landmark designation, but historic data preliminarily supports designation. This list shall be known as the Historic Property Inventory. c. The Historic Property Inventory is intended to identify buildings, structures, sites, objects, landscapes and/or districts located in the City that meet the evaluation criteria in Section 60.200.040C.5 below. The location of a property listed on the Historic Property Inventory shall be designated in the HPO district. d. The Heritage Preservation Commission may place a property on the Historic Property Inventory when a phase I survey documenting how the property meets one or more of the criteria of Section 60.200.040C5 to support future landmark designation is completed. 1) The HPC’s decision to place a property on the inventory may be appealed to the City Council pursuant to Section 60.500.030F. 2) The inventory of historic properties shall be established and maintained for public review by the Community Development Department. e. Placement on the Historic Property Inventory provides protection from demolition. If a Demolition Permit application is submitted for a property on the Historic Property Inventory, the City shall: 1) For complete demolition, the property shall be evaluated for possible landmark designation pursuant to Section 60.500.040F, Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District. If landmark designation is recommended, the City Council shall determine whether designation will occur and if so, the Demolition Permit shall not be approved. The applicant may, upon submittal of the demolition permit application, or at the time of HPC recommendation to the City Council for landmark designation, submit materials 60.500.040F.4.b, 2) For partial demolition or alterations where proposed projects impact on the character defining features of the property, only such alterations which will not destroy the historic integrity of the property, will be approved. Such permit reviews shall be pursuant to Section 60.500.060D 5. Evaluation Criteria for Landmark Designation a. Landmark Property Historic properties under consideration for landmark designation must have maintained historic integrity, based on location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association. Additionally, such properties shall meet at least one of the following criteria: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 48 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040C: HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay 1) Its character, interest, or value as part of the development, heritage, or cultural characteristics of the city, state, or United States; 2) Its location as a place of a significant historic event; 3) Its location within and contribution as an element of an existing or possible future landmark district. 4) Its identification with a person who significantly contributed to the culture and development of the city; 5) Its embodiment of distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style, period, form, or treatment; 6) Its identification as the work of an architect or master builder whose individual efforts have influenced the development of the city or have contributed to the development of a nationally- or internationally-recognized style or movement; 7) Its embodiment of elements of architectural design, detail, material, or craftsmanship that represent a significant architectural innovation; or 8) Its location, scale, or other physical characteristics representing an established and familiar visual feature or a neighborhood, a district, the community, or the city. b. Landmark District For a landmark district designation, in addition to meeting one or more of the criteria in Subsection a above, the majority of the contributing properties in the district must also be located in a geographically-definable area that possess a concentration of identified historically significant resources. These must be united or linked by their interrelationship, by plan or physical development, aesthetically or through past events. 6. Designation of Landmark Properties A property may be designated as a landmark, as described in Section 60.500.040FE, Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District when the property meets the criteria in Subsection 5 above. 7. Removal of Landmark Designation A property owner may request removal of landmark designation, as described in Section 60.500.040F, Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District, when a landmark property no longer meets the criteria on which the designation was based. 8. Standards of Treatment for Designated Landmark Properties a. All property owners shall maintain designated properties to prevent deterioration and decay of the property. b. Alterations to the exterior of any designated landmark or to any property within a landmark district that requires a permit or approval under this UDC, or that requires a Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 49 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040C: HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay building permit, or that are paid for in whole or in part by City funds, shall comply with the following standards: 1) A Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration pursuant to Section 60.500.050B, or a Certificate of Appropriateness -- Minor Alteration pursuant to Section 60.500.060D is required for all actions affecting a landmark property or contributing property in a landmark district, unless exempted pursuant to Section 60.500.060D.2.b. 2) Emergency repairs to a landmark property or contributing property in a landmark district are permitted pursuant to Section 60.500.060D.2.b.6). c. Character Defining Elements Character defining elements of designated landmark, including those that may not be original but have acquired significance by virtue of age or craftsmanship, shall be restored, maintained, and/or preserved. d. Secretary of Interior Standards The Secretary of Interior Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties shall be used to determine appropriate treatment for all designated landmarks. Treatment options include Preservation, Rehabilitation, Restoration, or Reconstruction. The approach used depends on the property's historical significance, physical condition, proposed use, and mandated code requirements. In each case, the standards will be applied taking into consideration the economic and technical feasibility of each project. e. Rochester Heritage Preservation Design Guidelines Local design guidelines adopted by the Heritage Preservation Commission for the treatment of historic properties will provide further guidance in the determination of appropriate treatment to designated landmarks. 9. Demolition of Designated Structures No Demolition Permit for a designated landmark or a contributing property to a landmark district shall be approved before the City Council removes the landmark designation as described in Section 60.500.040F, Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District. 10. Incentives for Preservation, Rehabilitation, Restoration, or Reconstruction a. Designated properties are eligible for and have priority to participate in City incentive programs related to financial, development, or technical assistance that will serve to preserve, maintain, rehabilitate, re-use or enhance their historic and architectural character. b. Through grants or other sources of funding, the City may provide a historic marker of a standard design for any owner of a landmark property or property within a landmark district who has requested in writing a marker to install on their building. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 50 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040C: HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay The City may also develop a marker or signage program to recognize designated landmark districts. c. The City may authorize funding sources to create a financial incentive program for purposes of encouraging owners of a designated property or contributing property within a landmark district to preserve their property for purposes of heritage preservation. The Heritage Preservation Commission shall advise City Council on organization and administration for any local finance program. d. The assigned City personnel will provide guidance and assistance in applications for state and federal historic tax credit programs. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 51 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay D. Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay 1. Purpose The purpose of the Wetland Conservation and DEO district is to implement the Wetland Conservation Act of 1991 (Minn. Laws 1991 chapter 354), as may have been and will be amended from time to time ("WCA"), and the accompanying rules of the Board Of Water And Soil Resources (Minn. R. Ch. 8420, as amended), and to protect the biological diversity and water quality and water quantity benefits of wetlands and related features particularly in areas of the City with significant groundwater discharge, interflow, and recharge characteristics. 2. Applicability a. This Section 60.200.040D regulates impacts to or hydrologic alteration of wetlands or parts of wetlands and Edge Support Areas within the City. b. In the event that an inconsistency exists between the provisions of state law, the rules of the Board of Water and Soil Resources, and this section, the provision that provides the most wetland protection shall apply. c. Except as provided in Minn. R. Ch. 8420, wetlands within the City must not be impacted unless replaced by restoring, enhancing, or replacing wetland areas of at least equal public value. d. The Community Development Director shall rely on the most current published soil survey, unless supplemented by a first order soil survey, National Wetlands Inventory, and other relevant data sources, and by on-site investigation, as a guide to identifying areas to be investigated for wetlands and Edge Support Areas. 3. Incorporation of the Wetland Conservation Act The DEO district incorporates by reference the WCA and Minn. R. Ch. 8420. Except as provided in this Section, terms used in this Section, that are defined in the Act or the Rules, have the meanings given there. 4. Map a. Generally 1) The Community Development Director shall maintain current maps showing the approximate location and extent of the DEO district and update them as more reliable information becomes available. 2) Where detailed site investigation identifies more accurate information as to the location and extent of the Decorah, Platteville, or Glenwood formations and areas of associated groundwater movements in adjacent portions of the Cummingsville and St. Peter formations, the detailed site information shall apply. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 52 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay b. Decorah Edge Map Decorah Edge maps include those areas of the City within the boundary of the Decorah Edge, as defined in this UDC. c. Bedrock Geology Map 1) The bedrock geology map includes an adjacent area determined based on half the distance of the reported accuracy of the source map. 2) The bedrock geology map, the reported accuracy is 100 meters or 330 feet, resulting in an added dimension of 50 meters or 165 feet. 3) The dimension of the adjacent area shall reflect the accuracy of the source maps and is not intended as a buffer area. 5. Local Government Unit The City Council shall be the local government unit for the purposes of the Wetland Conservation Act and Minn. R. Ch. 8420. 6. Technical Evaluation Panel a. A technical evaluation panel is hereby recognized and authorized to participate in wetland determinations as identified in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0240. b. A representative appointed by the Community Development Director who is a technical professional with expertise in water resources management is hereby appointed to the technical evaluation panel to participate with the appointed persons from the Board of Water and Soil Resources and from the Soil and Water Conservation District within the county. c. For projects affecting public waters, public waters wetlands, or wetlands within the shoreland protection zone, the panel also includes a technical professional employee of the Department of Natural Resources. 7. High Priority Areas The City is designated a high priority area under Minnesota Rules. Decisions regarding sequencing, replacement plans, and banking shall particularly favor preservation, restoration, and creation of wetlands in high priority areas as identified in water management plans pursuant to Minn. R. pt. 8420.0835. Calcareous fens and wetlands, both natural and restored, located in Edge Support Areas are high priority areas. 8. Special Protection Areas a. Except as exempted in this Section, Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands and Edge Support Areas must not be impacted or altered hydrologically, wholly or partially. b. Development activities must be carried out in such a way as to maintain groundwater flow to or from a wetland, and to protect the quality, functions, and values of the wetland as determined by the latest functional assessment method acceptable to the state board of water and soil resources. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 53 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay 1) A No-Loss application is required for all development within the DEO. c. Special Protection Area Exemptions 1) Special protection area requirements shall not apply if the process described in Section 60.200.040D.12, Sequencing and Replacement Plan Decision is followed with the resulting determination that there exists one of the following findings: (a) The development activity involves the construction of local collectors or higher order streets, where the City Council has found in its approval of a General Development Plan that: (i) The traffic service standards cannot be met without providing for the street in question; (ii) The street in question is designated as a primary collector or higher order street, or the area served is designated as in need of a local collector in the ROCOG Long Range Transportation Plan; (iii) The proposed alignment causes the least disruption to groundwater discharge interflow and recharge characteristics in comparison with suitable and practical alternative alignments; (b) The development activity involves the modification, realignment, or other improvement of an existing public road by a Road Authority; (c) The development activity involves the construction of other infrastructure of a regional nature, such as regional trails, major power lines, regional stormwater ponds, water mains, or sewer interceptors, where the City Council has determined that the proposed alignment causes the least disruption to groundwater discharge, interflow, and recharge characteristics in comparison with suitable and practical alternative alignments; (d) The development activity involves the construction of park facilities in General Development Plans or subdivisions approved prior to October 1, 2006; (e) The development activity involves the construction of a new road in a development that is needed to provide secondary access to a residential area that would otherwise result in more than 50 homes relying on a single access, where the City Council has determined that the platted alignment causes the least disruption to groundwater discharge, interflow, and recharge characteristics, in comparison with suitable and practical alternative alignments and where the requirement for secondary access has not been waived; or (f) The development activity involves the alteration of Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands In conjunction with restoration or enhancement projects that are in accordance with Section 60.200.040D.12, Sequencing and Replacement Plan Decision. Enhanced or restored Groundwater Supported Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 54 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay Slope Wetlands must be of at least equal function and value as determined by the latest functional assessment method acceptable to the state board of water and soil resources located in the same geologic setting (fill or bedrock- dominated), and in the same minor watershed. 2) All areas of buildable lots identified either in plats or General Development Plans (excluding outlots) shall be exempt from the special protection provided to Edge Support Areas if: (a) The lot is part of a final plat approved prior to October 1, 2006. 3) All areas of buildable lots shall be exempt from the special protection provided to Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands if the lot is included in a development for which a replacement plan has been approved prior to October 1, 2006, addressing the Groundwater Supported Slope Wetland. 9. Exemptions a. Application 1) A landowner may apply for an exemption from the provisions of the WCA and this DEO district if the property to be impacted or hydrologically altered meets the wetland exemption criteria contained in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0420. Any Edge Support Area associated with an exempted Groundwater Supported Slope Wetland shall also be exempted. 2) A landowner intending to impact or hydrologically alter a wetland without replacement, claiming exemption, shall apply to the Community Development Director before beginning excavation, draining, or filling activities for determination whether or not the activity is exempt. b. Decision 1) Exemption decisions under Minn. R. pt. 8420.0420 shall be made by the Community Development Director. 2) The Community Development Director may seek the advice of the technical evaluation panel as specified in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0240(C). If the Community Development Director does not agree with the panel’s findings and recommendations, the detailed reasons for the disagreement must be part of the decision record. c. Appeal 1) The Community Development Director’s decision is final unless appealed to the City Council within 30 days after written notice of the Community Development Director's determination is mailed to the applicant. Following an appeal, the City Council must hold a public hearing and make a ruling within thirty (30) days of the filing of the appeal. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 55 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay 2) An exemption notice of decision shall be provided to the landowner within 15 days of the Community Development Director's or City Council's determination that the activity qualifies for exemption. 3) The authority granted by the notice of decision shall be stayed during the time an appeal is pending before the state board of water and soil resources. 10. Exceptions Requests for exceptions to provisions of this Section related to Edge Support Areas (where the applicant contends that the Section should not be applied to the property in question, in whole or in part) shall be heard by the City Council at the time of General Development Plan review, or at the time of wetland delineation if a General Development Plan is not required. Applicants may seek exceptions to restrictions on disturbance of Edge Support Areas on the basis of public safety concerns, other overriding public interest, unreasonable hardship, or constraints that deny a reasonable use of the property. 11. No Loss Decision a. Application A landowner unsure if proposed work will result in a loss of wetlands may apply for a no-loss decision as specified in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0315. b. Decision 1) No-loss decisions, under Minn. R. pts. 8420.0410 and 8420.0415, shall be made by the Community Development Director. 2) The Community Development Director may seek the advice of the technical evaluation panel on questions of wetland delineation and type. If the Community Development Director does not agree with the panel’s findings and recommendations, the detailed reasons for the disagreement must be part of the decision record. c. Appeal 1) The Community Development Director’s decision is final unless appealed to the City Council within 30 days after written notice of the Community Development Director's decision is sent to those required to receive notice of the decision. Following an appeal, the City Council must hold a public hearing and make a ruling within thirty (30) days of the filing of the appeal. 2) A notice of decision shall be provided to the landowner within 15 days of the Community Development Director’s or City Council’s determination. 3) The landowner applying for a no-loss decision is responsible for submitting the proof necessary to show qualification for this determination. The authority granted by the decision shall be stayed during the time an appeal is pending before the state Board of Water and Soil Resources. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 56 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay 12. Sequencing and Replacement Plan Decision a. A landowner intending to impact a wetland who does not qualify for an exemption or no-loss decision shall obtain approval of a replacement plan from the City Council. An applicant may either submit the information required for sequencing analysis as part of a replacement plan application or apply separately for a preliminary sequencing decision from the local government unit before preparing a complete replacement plan. b. The sequencing decision, where submitted separately from the replacement plan under Minn. R. pt. 8420.0325 and sequencing flexibility under Minn. R. pt. 8420.0520, subpt. 7a, shall be made by the Community Development Director. Replacement plans intended to mitigate wetland impacts within the City must involve the creation or restoration of wetlands located within the county. c. Replacement Plans 1) No person may impact a wetland, wholly or partially, without being eligible for an exemption or no-loss, or first receiving approval of a wetland replacement plan as specified in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0500. 2) A landowner proposing a wetland impact that requires replacement must apply to the City and receive approval of a replacement plan before impacting the wetland. d. Sequencing and replacement plan decisions under Minn. R. pts. 8420.0325, 8420.0330, and 8420.0500—8420.0544 and decisions regarding exceptions under Section 60.200.040D.10 Exceptions shall be made pursuant to the following procedures: 1) Application for wetland replacement plans must be submitted to the Community Development Director. The contents of the plan shall comply with Minn. R. pt. 8420.0330. 2) The Community Development Director must determine that an application is complete based on Minn. R. pts. 8420.0305—8420.0330. 3) The Community Development Director shall, within 15 days of a complete application, transmit a copy of the application and notice of application to members of the technical evaluation panel, the Commissioner, and members of the public who have requested a copy. 4) The Community Development Director may seek the advice of the technical evaluation panel as specified in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0240(C). 5) The Community Development Director shall schedule a public hearing and review before the City Council to consider the application. Prior to City Council review, the Community Development Director shall prepare a report recommending approval, approval with conditions, or disapproval of the proposed replacement plan. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 57 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay 6) The City Council shall hold a public hearing and act upon the application in conformance with Minn. Stats. 15.99. The City Council may approve, approve with conditions, or disapprove the replacement plan application. 7) The City Council must base its decisions on the replacement standards in Minn. R. pts. 8420.0500—8420.0544, and on the recommendation of the technical evaluation panel as specified in Minn. R. pt. 8420.0240. The City Council must consider comments received from those required to receive notice. If the technical evaluation panel was consulted and the City Council does not agree with the panel’s findings and recommendation, the detailed reasons for the disagreement must be part of the decision record. 8) All parties shall be notified of the Council’s decision within 10 business days. The mailing to the applicant must include information on the process and time period to appeal the decision of the City Council. 13. Monitoring Monitoring of replacement wetlands is the responsibility of the landowner of the property where the replacement wetland is located. The Community Development Director shall ensure that the replacement plan monitoring and enforcement requirements of Minn. R. pt. 8420.0810 shall be fulfilled. The technical evaluation panel must review replacement wetland monitoring reports as provided in Minn. R. pts. 8420.0800—8420.0820. 14. Wetland Monitoring a. Wetlands may be restored or created within the City for purposes of deposit in the wetland bank in accordance with Minn. R. pts. 8420.0700—8420.0755. The Community Development Director is responsible for approving bank plans, certifying deposits, and the monitoring of banked wetlands and enforcement under the Minnesota Rules. b. Only wetland credits from wetland banks within the county may be used for wetland replacement when wetland within the City is impacted. 15. Fees The City Council shall, by resolution, adopt a schedule of fees applicable to wetland delineation applications, no-loss applications, exemption applications, sequencing applications, replacement plan applications, banking plan applications, and monitoring reports submittals. The amount of the fees shall not exceed the reasonable value of the functions undertaken by the City. 16. Appeals a. Decisions made under this Section by the Community Development Director may be appealed to the City Council. An appeal must be filed within 10 days after the date that the decision is sent to those required to receive notice of the decision. Except for decisions related to Edge Support Areas, decisions of the City Council may be Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 58 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040D: Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay appealed to the state Board of Water and Soil Resources under Minn. R. pt. 8420.0905 after final determination by the City Council. b. A landowner or responsible party may appeal the terms and conditions of a restoration or replacement order issued according to Minn. R. pt. 8420.0905 to the state Board of Water and Soil Resources executive director within 30 days of receipt of the order. 17. Delegation The City may, by joint powers agreement, delegate to the Soil and Water Conservation District under Minn. Stats. §§471.59 and 103C.331, Subd. 19, the authority to administer all or any part of this Section. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 59 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay E. FPO – Floodplain Overlay 1. Purpose a. The purpose of the FPO district is to guide development in the flood hazard areas of Rochester consistent with the flood threat, to minimize loss of life and property, disruption of commerce and governmental services, extraordinary public expenditure for public protection and relief, impairment of the tax base and interruption of transportation and communication, all of which adversely affect the public health, safety and general welfare. b. The regulations are also intended to preserve the natural characteristics and functions of watercourses and floodplains to moderate flood and stormwater impacts, improve water quality, reduce soil erosion, protect aquatic and riparian habitat, provide recreational opportunities, provide aesthetic benefits, and enhance community and economic development. c. The FPO district regulations are adopted to comply with the authorization and policies contained in Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 103F; Minnesota Rules, parts 6120.5000 – 6120.6200 and the rules and regulations of the National Flood Insurance Program codified as 44 C.F.R. pts. 59 -78, as amended, to maintain the community’s eligibility in the National Flood Insurance Program. d. Floodway Subdistrict Purpose The purpose of the Floodway subdistrict is to ensure that adequate space is retained within the channel and adjoining floodplain to carry and discharge the regional flood, and to restrict or prohibit uses that are dangerous to health or safety, or result in economic loss, in times of flood. e. Flood Fringe Subdistrict Purpose The purpose of the Flood Fringe subdistrict is to ensure that uses and structures within the subdistrict are properly flood protected, consistent with accepted principles and standards for flood protection, resulting in developments that will suffer minimal damage from flooding and will have a minimal effect on the ability of the floodplain to discharge flood waters. f. Flood Prone Subdistrict Purpose The purpose of the Flood Prone subdistrict is to guide development in generally undeveloped areas of the floodplain in such a manner so as to reduce the loss of flood storage volume in the floodplain, and to avoid increases in downstream flood levels and in the velocity of flood waters. 2. Floodplain Development Permit Required Those activities listed in Section 60.500.060HG Floodplain Development Permit must obtain a permit pursuant to that Section before beginning any activity, development, or change to land or uses of property in the FPO districts. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 60 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 3. Designation a. General Requirements 1) Each individual flood subdistrict represents a set of regulations superimposed upon the existing zoning districts, superseding existing underlying regulations only to the extent that developments must meet the additional standards of the FPO district as well as those of the underlying district in order to be in compliance with this UDC. 2) The Floodway (FW), Flood Fringe (FF), and Flood Prone (FP) subdistricts are identified upon the zoning map, and reference to the status of any property located in one of the flood related districts is made by the district symbol (FW, FF, or FP) being post fixed to a use district symbol (examples R-l/FF, B- 4/FW, M-2/FP). Section 60.500.040E.2.d addresses zoning designation of property in the FW or FF annexed to the city. 3) To aid in the identification and designation of properties in the flood related districts, certain materials are attached and hereby adopted by reference and declared to be part of this UDC including the Flood Insurance Study for Olmsted County, Minnesota, and Incorporated Areas, and the Flood Insurance Rate Map for Olmsted County and Incorporated Areas, all dated April 19, 2017 and prepared by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, including the following panels: 27109C0141F, 27109C0142F, 27109C0143E, 27109C0144F, 27109C0153F, 27109C0154F, 27109C0155E, 27109C0158E, 27109C0161F, 27109C0162F, 27109C0163F, 27109C0164F, 27109C0166F, 27109C0168F, 27109C0169E, 27109C0282F, 27109C0301F, 27109C0302F, 27109C0303E, 27109C0304E, 27109C0306F, 27109C0307E, and 27109C0313E. Preliminary panels 27109C0282G and 27109C0295E, dated May 29, 2020, are also hereby adopted as best available data. b. Designation of the Floodway Subdistrict 1) The Floodway subdistrict standards shall apply to all lands designated as floodway on the Flood Insurance Rate Map adopted in Section 60.200.040E.2, Floodplain Development Permit Required. 2) The Floodway subdistrict also includes those areas designated as Zone A (that do not have a floodway designation) on the Flood Insurance Rate Map. 3) For lakes, wetlands, and other basins, the Floodway subdistrict includes those areas that are at or below the ordinary high-water level as defined in Minn. Stat. §103G.005, Subd. 14. c. Designation of the Flood Fringe Subdistrict 1) The Flood Fringe subdistrict includes those areas within Zone AE and designated as flood fringe, or within Zone AO on the Flood Insurance Rate Map Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 61 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay adopted in this Section and were within the corporate boundaries of the City prior to November 3, 1980. This district also includes any additional area encompassed by the horizontal extension of the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation, as specified in Section 60.200.040.E.7.b. 2) For lakes, wetlands, and other basins (that do not have a floodway designated), the Flood Fringe subdistrict includes those areas designated as Zone A or AE on the Flood Insurance Rate Map panels adopted in this Section that are below the 1 percent annual chance (100-year) flood elevation but above the Ordinary High Water Level as defined in Minn. Stat., §103G.005, Subd. 14. d. Designation of the Flood Prone Subdistrict The Flood Prone subdistrict includes those areas designated as floodway fringe on the Flood Insurance Rate Map adopted in this Section, as being within Zone AE but being located outside of the floodway, and were annexed on or after November 3, 1980. 4. Warning and Disclaimer of Liability a. The degree of flood protection intended to be provided by the UDC is considered reasonable for regulatory purposes and is based on engineering and other specific methods of study. b. Large floods may occur, or the flood height may be increased by man-made or natural causes, such as ice jams or bridge openings restricted by debris. c. The UDC does not imply that areas outside of designated floodplain districts or land uses permitted within such districts will always be totally free from flooding or flood damages. Nor shall the UDC create a liability on the part of or be a cause of action against the City or any employee thereof for any flooding or flood damages that may result from reliance on the UDC. 5. Reclamation Nothing herein shall be so construed as to prohibit the lawful rehabilitation or reclamation of any lands outside of the floodway, provided that no filling, draining, construction of levees, or other improvements intended to eliminate or reduce the danger of the flood or erosion shall be commenced until first reviewed and authorized by the Community Development Director and the Commissioner, and, if revisions to floodplain maps or designations are proposed, by the Federal Emergency Management Agency. 6. Right of Passage No person may obstruct the passage of water and watercraft nor restrict the lawfully permitted use by the public of the bed, banks, water, and floodway of any stream within the City. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 62 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 7. Floodplain Limits a. Where a conflict exists between the floodplain limits illustrated on the official zoning map and actual field conditions including the natural or pre-existing grades, the map flood elevations shall be the governing factor in locating the regulatory floodplain limits. b. The regulatory limits of the district boundaries shall be further extended outward based on the horizontal extension of the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation (RFPE) (below). 8. Designation of Floodway in A Zones In A zones, the floodway may be delineated using the following procedures. Areas identified through these procedures as flood fringe may then be reclassified as Flood Fringe subdistrict and will then be subject to the requirements of the Flood Fringe subdistrict. The area determined to be Floodway shall be subject to the requirements of the Floodway subdistrict. a. Upon receipt of an application for a permit or other approval, the Community Development Director must obtain, review, and reasonably use any regional flood elevation and floodway data available from a federal, state, or other source. b. If regional flood elevation and floodway data are not readily available, the applicant must furnish additional information, as needed, to determine the regulatory flood protection elevation and whether the proposed use would fall within the Floodway or Flood Fringe subdistrict. Information must be consistent with accepted hydrological and hydraulic engineering standards and the standards in Subsection c below. c. The determination of floodway and flood fringe must include the following components, as applicable: 1) Estimate the peak discharge of the regional (1 percent chance) flood. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 63 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 2) Calculate the water surface profile of the regional flood based upon a hydraulic analysis of the stream channel and overbank areas. 3) Compute the floodway necessary to convey or store the regional flood without increasing flood stages more than 0.5 foot. A lesser stage increase than 0.5 foot is required if, as a result of the stage increase, increased flood damages would result. An equal degree of encroachment on both sides of the stream within the reach must be assumed in computing floodway boundaries. d. The Public Works Director will review the submitted information and assess the technical evaluation and the recommended Floodway and/or Flood Fringe subdistrict boundary. The assessment must include the cumulative effects of previous floodway encroachments. The Public Works Director may seek technical assistance from a designated engineer or other expert person or agency, including the Department of Natural Resources. Based on this assessment, the Public Works Director may approve or deny the application. 9. Uses Permitted a. The regulations within this Section establish those uses that are permitted in each of the flood districts, subject to the further restriction that no proposed use is permitted if it is not permitted in the underlying zoning district. No person may establish a use in a flood district that is not otherwise permitted in that district by the following Subsections, or that is not permitted in the underlying zoning district, and for any person to do any grading or filling in the flood district without first obtaining all necessary permits and approvals. b. Any facility that will be used by employees or the general public must be designed with a flood warning system that provides adequate time for evacuation if the area is inundated to a depth and velocity such that the depth (in feet) multiplied by the velocity (in feet per second) would exceed a product of four upon occurrence of the regional (1 percent chance) flood. c. Flood Prone and Floodway Uses Permitted uses are the following uses that have a low flood damage potential and do not obstruct flood flows. These uses are permitted within the Floodway and Flood Prone subdistricts to the extent that they are not prohibited by the underlying zoning district or any other ordinance and provided they do not require structures, fill, or storage of materials or equipment. In addition, no use shall adversely affect the capacity of the channel or floodways of any tributary to the main stream, or of any drainage ditch or other drainage facility. 1) Agricultural uses such as general farming, pasture, grazing, outdoor plant nurseries, horticulture, truck farming, forestry, sod farming, and wild crop harvesting. 2) Industrial-commercial uses such as loading areas, parking areas, billboards, airport landing strips. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 64 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 3) Private and public recreational uses such as golf courses, tennis courts, driving ranges, picnic grounds, boat launching ramps, swimming area, parks, wildlife and nature preserves, fishing areas, recreational trails. 4) Residential uses such as lawns, gardens, parking areas, and recreation areas. 5) Channel Modifications requiring a DNR permit where there is no change in the flood profile. d. Flood Fringe Uses Uses permitted in the Food Fringe subdistrict are the same as those permitted by the underlying zoning district, subject to meeting the construction standards in this Section 60.200.040E. e. Floodway Conditional Uses The following uses involving structures (temporary or permanent), fill, or the storage of materials or equipment, are permitted in the Floodway subdistrict only after a Conditional Use permit is obtained. 1) Structures accessory to open space or conditional uses. 2) Placement of fill. 3) Extraction of sand, gravel, and other minerals. 4) Marinas, boat rentals, docks, and water control structures. 5) Railroads, streets, bridges, utility transmission lines and pipelines, provided that the Department of Natural Resources’ Area Hydrologist is notified at least 10 days prior to issuance of any permit. 6) Other uses similar in nature to uses described in Section 60.200.040E.9.c, Flood Prone and Floodway Uses or this Subsection that are consistent with the purpose of the Floodway subdistrict. f. Flood Prone Conditional Uses 1) In the Flood Prone subdistricts, uses permitted in the underlying zoning district are allowed subject to Planning Commission approval, subject to Subsection 2) below. 2) All developments are also subject to the applicable provisions of Section 60.200.040E.10, Flood Fringe Construction Standards. g. Adverse Effect on Floodplain Floodplain development should not adversely affect the hydraulic capacity of the channel and adjoining floodplain of any tributary watercourse or drainage system. h. Critical Facilities Critical Facilities are prohibited in the FPO district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 65 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 10. Flood Fringe Construction Standards Uses located in the Flood Fringe subdistrict, to the extent that they are not prohibited by any other portion of the UDC, shall be constructed as regulated by this Subsection and in such a manner so as to not adversely affect the capacity of any public water or any other drainage facility or system. a. Standard for Primary Buildings The following standards shall apply to the construction of primary buildings in the Flood Fringe subdistrict: 1) Dwellings (a) General (i) New dwellings shall be constructed on fill so that the lowest floor (including basement) is at or above the flood protection elevation. (ii) The finished fill elevation shall be no lower than one foot below the flood protection elevation and shall extend at such elevation at least 15 feet beyond the limits of any structure or building thereon. (iii) The lowest floor of residential additions of any size shall be constructed at or above the regional flood elevation. (iv) Residences that do not have vehicular access at or above an elevation not more than two feet below the flood protection elevation shall not be permitted. (v) If a variance to the access requirement is granted, the Board of Appeals must specify limitations on the period of use or occupancy of the structure for times of flooding and only after determining that adequate flood warning time and local flood emergency response procedures exist. (b) Dwellings in the AO Zone As an exception to Subsection 1)(a) above, new dwellings in the AO zone shall be constructed on fill so that the lowest floor (including basement) is elevated above the highest adjacent grade at least as high as one foot above the depth number specified in feet on the Rochester Flood Insurance Rate Map. 2) Non-Residential Uses (a) General New structures shall be elevated so that their first floor (including basement) is at or above the flood protection elevation. The finished fill elevation shall be no lower than one foot below the flood protection elevation. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 66 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay (b) Non-Residential Uses in the AO Zone As an exception to Subsection 1)(a) above, new structures shall be constructed on fill so that the lowest floor (including basement) is elevated above the highest adjacent grade at least as high as the depth number specified in feet on the Rochester Flood Insurance Rate Maps, or together with attendant utility and sanitary facilities be completely flood- proofed in accordance with the State Building Code to the FP-l or FP-2 classification without the utilization of dikes, dams or levee. b. Standards for Public Works The following standards shall apply to the construction of new public works in the Flood Fringe subdistrict: 1) Waste Treatment and Flood Control Structures (a) No new construction, addition, or modification to existing waste treatment facilities shall be permitted within the flood fringe unless emergency plans and procedures for action to be taken in the event of flooding are prepared, filed with, and approved by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. (b) The emergency plans and procedures must provide for measures to prevent introduction of any pollutant or toxic material into the flood waters. 2) Utilities, Railroad Tracks, Streets, and Bridges (a) (a) All utilities such as gas, electrical, sewer, and water supply systems to be located in the floodplain must be elevated and/or floodproofed to the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation (RFPE), be located and constructed to minimize or eliminate flood damage, and be designed to eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the systems and discharges from the systems into flood waters. All public utilities should be designed to minimize increases in flood elevations. New solid waste management facilities, as defined in Minnesota Rules, part 7035.0300, are prohibited in the one-percent annual chance floodplain. Water supply systems are subject to the provisions in Minnesota Rules, part 4725.4350. (b) Public utility facilities, roads, railroad tracks, and bridges within the Flood Fringe subdistrict shall be designed to minimize increase in flood elevations and shall be compatible with local comprehensive floodplain development plans. (c) Protection to the flood protection elevation shall be provided where failure or interruption of these public facilities would result in danger to the public health or safety or where such facilities are essential to the orderly functioning of the area. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 67 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay (d) Where failure or interruption of services would not endanger life or health, a lesser degree of protection may be provided for minor or auxiliary roads, railroads, or utilities. c. Standards for Accessory Uses and Structures The following standards shall apply to the construction of accessory structures and the use of land for accessory purposes: 1) Accessory Structures Such structures shall be constructed on fill so that the lowest floor is at or above the flood protection elevation or may be permitted below the flood protection elevation provided that such structures are: (a) Not designed for human habitation; (b) Designed to have low flood damage potential; (c) Constructed and placed on the building site so as to offer the minimum resistance to the flood or floodwaters; and (d) As an alternative to elevation on fill, accessory structures that constitute a minimal investment and that do not exceed 500 square feet for the outside dimension at ground level may be internally flood proofed to the FP-3 or FP-4 standards in accordance with the state building code. To meet this requirement, detached garages must be used solely for parking of vehicles and limited storage. All such structures must meet the following standards: (i) To allow for the equalization of hydrostatic pressure, there must be a minimum of two “automatic” openings in the outside walls of the structure, with a total net area of not less than one square inch for every square foot of enclosed area subject to flooding; (ii) There must be openings on at least two sides of the structure and the bottom of all openings must be no higher than one foot above the lowest adjacent grade to the structure. Using human intervention to open a garage door prior to flooding will not comply with this requirement for automatic opening; (iii) The structure must be adequately anchored to prevent flotation, collapse, or lateral movement of the structure and shall be designed to equalize hydrostatic flood forces on exterior walls; and (iv) Any mechanical and utility equipment in a structure must be elevated to or above the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation or properly flood proofed. 2) Storage of Materials The storage or processing of materials that are, in time of flooding, flammable, explosive, or potentially injurious to human, animal, or plant life is prohibited. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 68 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay Storage of other materials or equipment is allowed if readily removable from the area within the time available after a flood warning and in accordance with a plan approved by the Community Development Director. 3) Accessory Land Uses Accessory land uses for non-residential uses, such as storage yards and parking lots, that are at elevations below the flood protection elevation shall not be permitted without a flood warning system that provides adequate time for evacuation of the area if the area is inundated to a depth and velocity such that the depth (in feet) multiplied by the velocity (in feet per second) would exceed a product of four upon occurrence of the regional (one percent chance) flood. d. Alternate Construction Standards Alternate standards for the construction of residential and non-residential uses are permitted as follows: 1) Residential Uses (a) Where existing streets, utilities, or small lot size preclude the use of fill, other alternative methods of elevating the first floor (including basement) above the flood protection elevation may be authorized by the issuance of a Conditional Use Permit. (b) The alternative methods as referenced in paragraph (a) above may include the use of stilts, pilings, parallel walls, or above-grade enclosed areas such as crawl spaces or tuck-under garages. (c) The base or floor of an enclosed area shall be considered above-grade and not a structure’s basement or lowest floor if: (i) The enclosed area is above-grade on at least one side of the structure; (ii) It is designed to internally flood and is constructed with flood resistant materials; and (iii) It is used solely for parking of vehicles, building access or storage. (d) The above-noted alternative elevation methods are subject to the following additional standards: (i) The structure’s design and as-built condition must be certified by a registered professional engineer or architect as being in compliance with the general design standards of the state Building Code and, specifically, that all electrical, heating, ventilation, plumbing and air- conditioning equipment and other service facilities must be at or above the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation or be designed to prevent flood water from entering or accumulating within these components during times of flooding. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 69 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay (ii) Above-grade, fully enclosed areas such as crawl spaces or tuck-under garages must be designed to internally flood and the design must stipulate: a. The minimum area of openings in the walls where internal flooding is to be used as a flood proofing technique. There shall be a minimum of two openings on at least two sides of the structure and the bottom of all openings shall be no higher than one foot above grade. The automatic openings shall have a minimum net area of not less than one square inch for every square foot of enclosed area subject to flooding unless a registered professional engineer or architect certifies that a smaller net area would suffice. When openings are placed in a structure’s walls to provide for entry of flood waters to equalize pressures, the bottom of all openings shall be no higher than one foot above grade. Openings may be equipped with screens, louvers, valves, or other coverings or devises provided that they permit the automatic entry and exit of flood waters without any form of human intervention. b. That the enclosed area will be designed of flood resistant materials in accordance with FP-3 or FP-4 classifications in the state Building Code and shall be used solely for building access, parking of vehicles or storage. 2) Non-Residential Uses (a) All areas of Non-Residential structures, including basements, to be placed below the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation shall be flood proofed in accordance with the structurally dry flood proofing classifications in the state Building Code. (b) Structurally dry flood proofing must meet the FP-3 or FP-4 flood proofing classification in the state Building Code, without the use of dikes, dams, or levees, and this shall require making the structure watertight with the walls substantially impermeable to the passage of water and with structural components having the capability of resisting hydrostatic and hydrodynamic loads and the effects of buoyancy. Structures flood proofed to the FP-1 or FP-2 standards shall not be permitted. (c) Upon determination that a particular use may constitute an unusual hazard in the flood fringe, the Community Development Director will require a Conditional Use Permit as provided in Section 60.500.050A, Conditional Use Permit. e. Basements Basements shall be subject to the following: 1) Residential basement construction shall not be allowed below the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 70 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 2) Non-residential basements may be allowed below the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation provided the basement is structurally dry flood proofed in accordance with Section 60.500.060GE.10.d.2.b. f. Additional Development Standards The standards in this Subsection f shall apply to the uses indicated. These standards are imposed in addition to any other applicable FPO standards. 1) Manufacturing and Industrial Uses (a) Manufacturing and industrial buildings, structures and appurtenant works shall be protected to the flood protection elevation. (b) Measures shall be taken to minimize interference with normal plant operations, especially for streams having prolonged flood durations. (c) In considering permit applications, due consideration shall be given to needs of an industry whose business requires that it be located in floodplain areas. 2) Fill (a) Fill shall be properly compacted, and the slopes shall be properly protected by the use of riprap, vegetative cover, or other acceptable method. (b) Permanent sand and gravel operations and similar uses must be covered by a long-term Site Development Plan as approved under other provisions of this UDC. The cumulative placement of fill where at any one time in excess of 1,000 cubic yards of fill is located on the parcel shall be allowable only as a conditional use, unless said fill is specifically intended to elevate a structure in accordance with Section 60.200.040E.10 Flood Fringe Construction Standards. (c) When at any time more than 1,000 cubic yards of fill or other similar material is located on a parcel for such activities as on-site storage, landscaping, sand and gravel operations, landfills, roads, dredge spoil disposal or construction of flood control works, an erosion and sedimentation control plan must be submitted unless the community is enforcing a state approved shoreland management ordinance. In the absence of a state approved shoreland management ordinance, the plan must clearly specify methods to be used to stabilize the fill on site for a flood event at a minimum of the 100 year regional flood event. The plan must be prepared and certified by a registered professional engineer or other qualified individual acceptable to the Community Development Director. The plan may incorporate alternative procedures for removal of the material from the floodplain if adequate flood warning time exists. 3) Garbage and Solid Waste Disposal Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 71 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay There shall be no disposal of garbage or solid waste materials within Flood Fringe areas. No Conditional Use Permits for garbage and waste disposal sites shall be issued for Flood Fringe subdistrict. There shall be no further encroachment upon the floodplain at existing sites. 4) On-site Water Supply and Sewage Treatment Systems Where public utilities are not provided: (a) On‐site water supply systems must be designed to minimize or eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the systems and are subject to the provisions in Minn. R. Ch. 4725.4350, as amended; and (b) New or replacement on‐site sewage treatment systems must be designed to minimize or eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the systems and discharges from the systems into flood waters, they must not be subject to impairment or contamination during times of flooding, and are subject to the provisions in Minn. R. Ch. 7080.2270, as amended. 11. Floodway Construction Standards No structures (temporary or permanent); fill, including fill for roads and levees; deposits, obstructions, storage of materials or equipment; or other uses allowed as Conditional Uses that, acting alone or in combination with existing or future uses, cause any stage increase of 0.00 feet or greater of the one percent chance or regional flood or cause an increase in flood damages in the reach or reaches affected, as determined by a professional engineer or by using standard engineering practices, shall be permitted. This shall be demonstrated through hydrologic and hydraulic analysis performed by a professional engineer, or using other standard engineering practices (e.g. projects that restore the site to the previous cross-sectional area). This is commonly documented through a “no-rise certification.” Consideration of the effects of a proposed use shall be based on a reasonable assumption that there will be an equal degree of encroachment extending for a significant reach on both sides of the stream. In addition, all floodway conditional uses shall be subject to the regulations in the following paragraphs. a. Fill 1) Any fill deposited in the floodway shall be no more than the minimum amount necessary to conduct a Conditional Use listed in Section 60.200.040E.9.e, Floodway Conditional Uses. 2) Fill shall be limited to what is needed to grade or landscape for that use and shall not in any way obstruct the flow of flood waters or cause any increase in flood elevations. 3) Such fill or other material shall be protected against erosion by rip-rap, vegetative cover or bulkheading. Dredge spoil sites and sand and gravel operations shall not be allowed in the floodway unless a long-term Site Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 72 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay Development Plan is submitted that includes an erosion and sedimentation prevention element to the plan. b. Accessory Structures Accessory structures (temporary or permanent) approved by the Planning Commission shall be subject to the following standards: 1) Not designed for human habitation; 2) Designed to have low flood damage potential; 3) Constructed and placed on the building site so as to offer the minimum resistance to the flood or floodwaters; 4) Whenever possible, structures shall be constructed with the longitudinal axis parallel to the direction of flood flow; and 5) So far as practicable, structures shall be placed approximately on the same flood flow lines as those of adjoining structures. 6) Accessory structures shall be structurally dry flood proofed in accordance with the FP-3 or FP-4 flood proofing classifications in the state Building Code. All flood proofed accessory structures must meet the following additional standards as appropriate: (a) Accessory Structures in the Floodway require a Conditional Use Permit by Planning Commission. The structure must be adequately anchored to prevent flotation, collapse or lateral movement of the structure and shall be designed to equalize hydrostatic flood forces on exterior walls. (b) Any mechanical and utility equipment in a structure must be elevated to or above the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation or properly flood proofed. 7) As an alternative, an accessory structure may be internally/wet floodproofed to the FP-1 or FP-2 floodproofing classifications in the state Building Code provided the accessory structure constitutes a minimal investment and that does not exceed 500 square feet for the outside dimension at ground level. Designs for meeting this requirement must either be certified by a registered professional engineer or meet or exceed the standards in Subsection 6). To meet this requirement, detached garages must be used solely for parking of vehicles and limited storage. (a) To allow for the equalization of hydrostatic pressure, there must be a minimum of two “automatic” openings in the outside walls of the structure, with a total net area of not less than one square inch for every square foot of enclosed area subject to flooding; and (b) There must be openings on at least two sides of the structure and the bottom of all openings must be no higher than one foot above the lowest adjacent Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 73 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay grade to the structure. Using human intervention to open a garage door prior to flooding will not comply with this requirement for automatic openings. c. Utilities, Railroad Tracks, Streets, and Bridges 1) Public utility facilities, roads, railroad tracks, and bridges within the floodway district shall be designed to minimize increases in flood elevations and shall be compatible with local comprehensive floodplain development plans. Such facilities must comply with Section 60.200.040E.11, Floodway Construction Standards. 2) Protection to the flood protection elevation shall be provided where failure or interruption of these public facilities are essential to the orderly functioning of the area. 3) Where failures or interruption of service would not endanger life or health, a lesser degree of protection may be provided for minor or auxiliary roads, railroads, or utilities. d. Storage of Material and Equipment 1) The storage or processing of materials that are in time of flooding buoyant, flammable, explosive or that could be injurious to human, animal, or plant life, or that are likely to cause pollution of waters, as defined by Minn. Stat. §115.01, is prohibited. 2) Materials that, in time of flooding, are buoyant, flammable, explosive, or could be injurious to human, animal, or plant life shall be stored at or above the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation (RFPE), floodproofed, or protected by other measures as approved by the Director of Community Development. 3) Storage of materials likely to cause pollution of the waters, such as sewage; sand; rock; wrecked and discarded equipment; dredged spoil; municipal, agricultural or industrial waste; and other wastes as further defined in Minn. Stat. §115.01, are prohibited unless adequate safeguards approved by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency are provided. For projects not requiring approvals by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, adequate safeguards must be approved by the Director of Community Development prior to issuance of a permit. e. Garbage and Solid Waste Disposal No Conditional Use Permits for garbage and waste disposal sites shall be issued for floodway areas. There shall be no further encroachment upon the floodway at existing sites. f. Structural Works for Flood Control Structural works for flood control such as levees, dikes, floodwalls, and reservoirs shall be allowed after Council approval, and compliance with the following: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 74 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay 1) Any proposed structural work in the beds of public waters, as defined in Ch. 103G.245, that will change the course, current, or cross-section of the waters shall be subject to the provisions of Minnesota Rule, parts 6115.0150- 6115.0280, and other applicable statutes. 2) When necessary, a permit from the Army Corps of Engineers certifying compliance with Section 404 of the Clean Waters Act shall be obtained, along with any other necessary permits. g. On-Site Water Supply and Sewage Treatment Systems Where public utilities are not provided: 1) On‐site water supply systems must be designed to minimize or eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the systems and are subject to the provisions in Minn. R. Ch. 4725.4350, as amended; and 2) New or replacement on‐site sewage treatment systems must be designed to minimize or eliminate infiltration of flood waters into the systems and discharges from the systems into flood waters, they must not be subject to impairment or contamination during times of flooding, and are subject to the provisions in Minn. R. Ch. 7080.2270, as amended 12. Flood Prone Construction Standards The requirements applicable in the Flood Fringe subdistrict, shall apply in the Flood Prone subdistrict. In addition, the deposition of any fill or spoil from dredging of sand and gravel operations, the construction of any structure, or the grading or paving of any areas shall require certification by a registered professional engineer or hydrologist that the following conditions have been met: a. Fill deposited in the Flood Prone subdistrict shall be no more than the minimum amount necessary to conduct the use; b. No net loss of capacity for surface storage of flood waters shall result from the activity; c. Storage created to offset fill applied within the Flood Prone Subdistrict shall be located within the Flood Prone Subdistrict along the same stream reach; d. The effect of such activities in the Flood Prone area shall not result in an increase in erosion potential on the site; e. Compensatory storage and the associated disturbances to accommodate for it shall not be located within the Floodway or Shoreland Impact Zones. 13. Manufactured Homes and Recreational Vehicles Manufactured homes and manufactured home parks and the placement of travel trailers and travel vehicles in flood plain areas shall meet the following standards: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 75 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay a. Manufactured Home Parks and Subdivisions New manufactured home parks and subdivisions, and expansions to existing manufactured home parks and subdivisions are prohibited in any floodplain district. b. Placement 1) Placement or replacement of manufactured home units is prohibited in the Floodway District. 2) In the Flood Fringe, and Flood Prone Districts, placement or replacement of new or replacement manufactured homes in existing manufactured home parks or subdivisions, or on individual lots of record, will be treated as new structures and may be placed only if in compliance with this Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay. 3) All manufactured homes must be securely anchored to an adequately anchored foundation system that resist flotation, collapse and lateral movement. Methods of anchoring may include, but are not to be limited to, use of over-the-top or frame ties to ground anchors. This requirement is in addition to applicable state or local anchoring requirements for resisting wind forces. 4) If vehicular road access for preexisting manufactured home parks is not provided in accordance with Section 60.400.040C.3.a Hazards, then replacement manufactured homes will not be allowed until the property owner(s) develops a flood warning emergency plan acceptable to the Community Development Director. c. Recreational Vehicles 1) New recreational vehicle parks or campgrounds and expansions to existing recreational vehicle parks or campgrounds are prohibited in any floodplain district. 2) Placement of recreational vehicles in existing recreational vehicle parks or campgrounds in the floodplain is only permitted if all of the standards below are met. 3) The vehicle and associated use must be permissible in any preexisting, underlying zoning district. (a) The vehicle must have current licenses required for highway use. (b) The vehicle must be highway ready, which means that wheels or the internal jacking system are attached to the site only by quick disconnect type utilities commonly used in campgrounds and recreational vehicle parks, and the vehicle has no permanent structural type additions attached to it. (c) Accessory structures to recreational vehicles are not permitted within the Floodway District. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 76 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040E: FPO – Floodplain Overlay (d) Any accessory structure to recreational vehicles in the Flood Fringe and Flood Prone Districts must be constructed of flood-resistant materials and be securely anchored, meeting the requirements applicable to manufactured homes in Subsection b3) above. 4) Recreational vehicles permitted in existing recreational vehicle parks or campgrounds pursuant to Subsection 3) above shall lose the ability to remain in those locations if when development occurs on the parcel exceeding $500 dollars for a structural addition to vehicle or an accessory structure such as a garage or storage building. The vehicle and all additions and accessory structures will then be treated as a new structure and shall be subject to the elevation/flood proofing requirements and the use of land restrictions specified in this Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay. 14. Floodproofing Certification Following completion of the activities authorized by a Floodplain Development Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060HG and a Zoning Certificate pursuant to Section 60.500.060A, the applicant shall submit certification by a registered professional engineer, registered architect, or registered land surveyor that the finished fill and building elevations were accomplished in compliance with the provisions of this UDC. A registered professional engineer or architect shall certify that the flood-proofing methods are adequate to withstand the flood depth, pressures, velocities, impact, and uplift forces. Where a nonconforming structure is extended or substantially altered the certificate of zoning compliance shall specifically state how the nonconforming use or structure differs from the flood protection standards and criteria in this UDC. 15. Recordkeeping The Community Development Director shall maintain a record of the lowest floor (including basement) elevation of, and the floodproofing measures incorporated into, all new structures and alterations or additions to existing structures in any of the flood districts within the FPO district. Use of a FEMA Elevation Certificate is recommended for documenting as-builts, as these can be used for getting an insurance policy or an appeal from the federal mandatory insurance requirement. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 77 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay F. SDO – Shoreland District Overlay 1. Purpose a. The purpose of the SDO is to ensure that shoreland development on the public waters of Rochester are regulated consistent with the classifications assigned by the commissioner under MN Rules, part 6120.3300. b. The regulations are also intended to identify land uses that are compatible with the protection and preservation of shoreline resources to conserve the economic and environmental values of shoreland and sustain water quality, and to establish dimensional and performance standards that protect shoreland resources from the impacts of development. 2. Applicability The following standards related to the Protected Waters Inventory Map for Olmsted County, Minnesota, which is hereby adopted by reference as part of this UDC. This Shoreland Ordinance is adopted pursuant to the authorization and policies contained in Minn. Stat. Ch. 103F, Pts. 6120.2500-6120.3900 and the planning and zoning enabling legislation in Minn. Stat. Ch. 462. a. Where the SDO Applies and Classifications 1) The public waters of the City have been classified consistent with the criteria found in Minn. R. Pt. 6120.3300, and the Protected Waters Inventory Map for Olmsted County, Minnesota. 2) The following areas are included in the SDO as classified below and identified in the Official Zoning Map: (a) Urban South Fork Zumbro River - From 37th Street Northwest to North City Limit Boundary. (b) Agricultural South Fork Zumbro River - From Bamber Valley Road Southwest westerly to West City Limit Boundary. (c) Tributary All public rivers and streams shown on the Public Waters Inventory Map for Olmsted County in the City, a copy of which is adopted by reference, not given a classification above and not exempted in Section 60.200.040F.2.b shall be considered “Tributary.” b. Where the SDO Does Not Apply 1) Pursuant to Minn. R. Pts. 6120.2500 and 6120.3900, no lake, pond, or flowage less than 10 acres is required to be regulated by the local government's shoreland regulations. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 78 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay 2) A body of water created by a private user where there was no previous shoreland may, at the discretion of the governing body, be exempt from the shoreland provisions. 3) The following reaches of stream are exempt from the SDO: (a) South Fork Zumbro River from the centerline of the T.H. 52 bridge to the centerline of the 37th Street NW bridge. (b) Silver Creek corridor from the eastern boundary of Quarry Hill park to its confluence with the South Fork Zumbro River. (c) Bear Creek from the centerline of the T.H. 14 bridge downstream to its confluence with the South Fork Zumbro River. (d) Cascade Creek from the centerline of the T.H. 52 bridge downstream to its confluence with the South Fork Zumbro River. (e) Willow Creek from the centerline of 40th Street SW, downstream to the western boundary of Section 24, T106N, R14W, Rochester Township. (f) North Run of the North Fork Cascade Creek from the centerline of 7th Street NW to its confluence with Cascade Creek. c. Within the shoreland district overlay, a subdivision will not be approved where a later variance from one or more standards in Section 60.200.040F would be needed to use the lots for their intended purpose. 3. Uses Allowed in the Shoreland District Overlay All uses permitted in the base zoning district, as described in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table, shall be allowed within the Shoreland District Overlay, subject to the following exceptions: a. Intensive vegetation clearing of forest land for conversion to another use is not permitted in the Shoreland District Overlay. b. Agricultural production is not permitted as a principal use in the Shoreland District Overlay. c. Residential development that contains five or more dwelling units per acre of suitable land within the shoreland overlay district shall require a Shoreland Protection Permit as described in Section 60.500.050C. Suitable land shall exclude wetland, bluffs, road right-of-way, and areas below the ordinary high water level. d. Industrial uses require a Shoreland Protection Permit as described in Section 60.500.050C, in addition to any other approvals required by the base zoning district, as shown in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table. e. Accessory agricultural uses require a Shoreland Protection Permit, as described in Section 60.500.050C. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 79 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay 4. Lot Area, Width, and Density Standards All new lots must meet the requirements of this Section 60.200.040F.4. a. The use of private sewage disposal systems and private water supply to serve any new development within the City is subject to the requirements of 60.400.030E, Adequate Public Facilities, of the UDC. b. Lands within the Shoreland District Overlay shall meet the base zone district lot area requirements and the following lot width standards: Dwelling Type Agricultural River Urban Urban River/Tributary (On River/Tributary Public Sewer) (unsewered) Single 150 feet 75 feet 100 feet Duplex 225 feet 115 feet 150 feet Triplex 300 feet 150 feet 200 feet Quad 375 feet 190 feet 250 feet c. Only lands above the Ordinary High Water Level (OHWL) can be used to meet lot dimensional standards. d. Lot width standards must be met at both the OHWL and at the building line. e. Subdivisions of five or more dwelling units, may reduce lot width as described in part b, by 50%, to a minimum of 75 feet for agricultural streams, or 60 feet for urban/tributary streams, through a Shoreland Protection Permit process as described in Section 60.500.050C. 5. Setbacks, Design, and Height of Structures a. Setbacks 1) When more than one setback applies to a site, structures and facilities must be located to meet all setbacks. 2) Structure setbacks are dependent upon the type of sewage system, and shall be set back from the OHWL by at least the following distances: River Type Structure with No Sewer Structures with Sewer Sewage Treatment Systems Agricultural 100 feet 50 feet 75 feet Urban 100 feet 50 feet 75 feet Tributary 100 feet 50 feet 75 feet b. Additional Building Setbacks 1) The following additional minimum building setbacks also apply, regardless of the classification of the waterbody. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 80 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay Setback Type Minimum Setback Top of Bluff 30 feet Unplatted Cemetery 50 feet Right-of-way line of federal, 50 feet state, or county highway Right-of-way line of town road, 20 feet public street, or other roads not classified 2) In addition to the lowest floor, all service utilities must be elevated or water-tight to the elevation of three feet above the flood or record or OHWL, whichever is greater. 3) If elevation methods involving fill would result in filling in the Shoreland Impact Zone, then structures must instead be elevated through floodproofing methods consistent with FEMA technical bulletins 1, 2, and 3. c. Exceptions to Shoreland Requirements 1) Lowest Floor Elevations within the Shoreland District Overlay Structures shall be placed at an elevation consistent with Section 60.200.040E, FPO – Floodplain Overlay. Where these elevations are not known, the required lowest floor elevation, including basement, shall be placed or floodproofed at least three feet above the flood of record or at least three feet above the OHWL, whichever is greater. 2) Water-Oriented Accessory Structures Water oriented accessory structures may be located on parcels or lots with frontage on public waters provided that: (a) One water-oriented accessory structure or facility, designed in accordance with this ordinance, shall be set back a minimum distance of ten feet from the OHWL; (b) The structure does not exceed ten feet in height; (c) The structure does not exceed 250 square feet in area; (d) The structure does not exceed eight feet above grade at any point; (e) The structure is not located in the Bluff Impact Zone; (f) The structure is not to be designed or used for human habitation. The roof may be used as an open-air deck with safety rails, but must not be enclosed or used as a storage shed. (g) Water-oriented accessory structure or facilities must be designed to incorporate topographic and vegetative screening of parking areas and structures; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 81 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay 3) Decks Deck additions may be allowed without a Variance to a structure not meeting the required setback from the ordinary high water level if all of the following criteria and standards are met:. a. The structure existed on the date the structure setbacks were established; b. A thorough evaluation of the property and structure reveals no reasonable location for a deck meeting or exceeding the existing ordinary high water level setback of the structure; c. The deck encroachment toward the ordinary high water level does not exceed 15 percent of the existing setback of the structure from the ordinary high water level or does not encroach closer than 30 feet, whichever is more restrictive; and d. The deck is constructed primarily of wood, and is not roofed or screened. 6. Stairways, Lifts, and Landings Stairways and lifts are the preferred alternative to major topographic alterations for achieving access up and down bluffs and steep slopes to shore areas. Stairways, lifts, and landings require a zoning certificate, with approval based on the findings for Shoreland Protection Permits, as described in Section 60.500.050C, and must meet the following design requirements: a. Stairways and lifts shall not exceed four feet in width. b. Landings for stairways and lifts on residential lots must not exceed 32 square feet in area. Landings larger than 32 square feet may be used for commercial properties, public-space recreational uses, and planned unit developments; c. Canopies or roofs are not allowed on stairways, lifts, or landings; d. Stairways, lifts, and landings may be either constructed above the ground on posts or pilings, or placed into the ground, provided they are designed and built in a manner that ensures control of soil erosion; e. Stairways, lifts, and landings shall be located in the most visually inconspicuous portions of lots, as viewed from the surface of the public water assuming summer leaf-on conditions, whenever practical; and f. Facilities such as ramps, lifts, or mobility paths for persons with disabilities are also allowed for achieving access to shore areas, provided that they comply with the dimensional and performance standards of subitems (a) to (d) above, in addition to the requirements of Minn. R. Ch. 1341. 7. Water Supply and Sewage Treatment a. Any public or private supply of water for domestic purposes must meet or exceed standards for water quality of the Minnesota Department of Health and the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 82 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay b. Any premises used for human occupancy must be connected to a publicly-owned sewer system, where available, or comply with Minnesota Rules, Chapters 7080 – 7081. 8. Forest Management The harvesting of timber and associated reforestation must be conducted consistent with the applicable provisions of the Sustaining Minnesota Forest Resources: Voluntary Site- Level Forest Management Guidelines for Landowners, Loggers and Resource Managers. 9. Signs in the Shoreland Impact Zone a. Signs are not permitted in the Shoreland Impact Zone 10. Lighting in the Shoreland Impact Zone a. Lighting may be located within the Shoreland Impact Zone or over public waters if it is used to illuminate potential safety hazards, and is shielded or otherwise directed to prevent direct illumination across public waters. 11. Shoreland Alterations a. Vegetation Alterations 1) Removal or alteration of vegetation is only permitted: (a) As necessary for the construction of structures and sewage treatment systems with a valid permit having been issued for these facilities; (b) For the construction of public roads and parking areas, as permitted by this ordinance; and (c) For forest management uses. 2) Removal or alteration of vegetation shall comply with the following standards: (a) If woody vegetation is cleared for construction purposes, it shall be restored with native, deep-rooted vegetation. Grading activity cannot begin without a planting removal and replacement plan approved by the Community Development Director. (b) Mature trees shall not be removed unless permitted by the Community Development Director through the approval of a planting removal and replacement plan. (c) Intensive vegetation clearing in the shore and bluff impact zones and on steep slopes is prohibited. (d) Limited clearing of shrubs and cutting, pruning, and trimming of trees is allowed to provide a view to the water from the primary or accessory use and to accommodate the placement of stairways and landings, provided that: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 83 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay (i) Vegetation is maintained to screen structures, vehicles, or other facilities by at least 50% as viewed from the water, assuming summer, leaf-on conditions. The maximum view corridor shall be less than 50 feet or one- third of the parcel width, whichever is less. (ii) The Existing shading of water surfaces is preserved; (iii) Cutting debris or slash shall be scattered and not mounded on the ground; (iv) Perennial ground cover is retained; (v) Removal of trees, limbs, or branches that are dead, diseased, dying, or pose safety hazards is allowed without a permit. (vi) Fertilizer and pesticide runoff into surface waters must be minimized through use of vegetation, topography, or both; and (vii) Picnic areas, access paths, beaches and watercraft access areas are prohibited in Bluff Impact Zones. 3) Violations of the vegetation standards shall be subject to a Restoration Order following the administrative procedures in Section 60.500.090. This vegetation restoration plan shall be subject to a three-year maintenance plan prepared by the land owner and approved by the zoning administrator. Near shore or highly erodible locations are to be restored with a mix of deep-rooted woody and herbaceous vegetation with high stem-density, suitable for the location. b. Grading Activity When in the shoreland district the following standards shall supplement, but not replace, the standards for grading of land that are generally applicable in the City, as described in Section 60.400.050, Sensitive Lands, Wetlands, Stormwater, and Drainage. 1) A Grading Permit shall be required for: (a) The movement of more than 10 cubic yards of material on steep slopes, and in Bluff Impact Zones; (b) The movement of more than 50 cubic yards of material outside of steep slopes, and in Bluff Impact Zones; (c) Any grading in the Shoreland Impact Zone 2) All construction permits, Grading Permits, Conditional Use Permits, variances, and subdivision approvals shall require compliance with the following standards: (a) Grading within any wetland area shall meet the applicable requirements of the Minnesota Wetlands Conservation Act; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 84 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay (b) Placement of retaining walls, including boulder walls within the SIZ and BIZ provided that: 1. if the project includes work at or below the OHWL, the commissioner has already approved or permitted the project. 2. the structures are used only to correct a documented existing erosion problem and not for aesthetic reasons. 3. the height and length are the minimum necessary to control the erosion problem and are not higher than 4 feet or longer than 10 feet, unless the zoning administrator determines that a larger wall is necessary to correct the erosion problem; and 4. The disturbances created adjacent to the wall will be replanted with deep rooted and woody vegetation to help retain soil. (c) Alterations shall be designed and conducted in a manner that ensures only the smallest amount of bare ground is exposed for the shortest time possible; (d) Mulches or similar materials shall be used, where necessary, for temporary bare soil coverage, and a permanent vegetation cover shall be established as soon as possible; (e) Methods to minimize erosion and to trap sediments before they reach any surface water feature shall be used, incorporating natural materials whenever possible; (f) Altered areas shall be stabilized to meet the erosion control policies in Section 60.400.050G.2, Erosion Control; (g) Fill or excavated material shall not be placed in a manner that creates an unstable slope; (h) Plans to place fill or excavated material on steep slopes shall be reviewed by qualified professionals for continued slope stability and shall not create finished slopes of 30 percent or steeper; (i) Fill or excavated materials shall not be placed in bluff or shore impact zones; (j) Any alterations below the Ordinary High Water Level of public waters shall first be authorized by the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources under Minn. Stat. §103.G.245; (k) Alterations of topography shall only be allowed if they are accessory to permitted or conditional uses and do not adversely affect adjacent or nearby properties; and (l) Placement of natural rock riprap, including associated grading of the shoreline and placement of a filter blanket, is permitted if the finished slope does not exceed three feet horizontal to one foot vertical, the landward extent Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 85 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay of the riprap is within 10 feet of the OHWL, and the height of the riprap above the OHWL does not exceed three feet. 1. Placement of natural rock rip rap, including associated grading of the shoreline and placement of a filter blanket is permitted if: a. if the project includes work at or below the OHWL, the commissioner has already approved or permitted the project; b. the finished slope does not exceed three feet horizontal to one-foot vertical; c. the landward extent of the riprap is within ten feet of the ordinary high water level; and d. height of the riprap above the ordinary high water level does not exceed three feet e. A vegetative buffer, consisting of deep rooted and woody vegetation, is to be established at a distance no less than ten feet from the landward extent of the riprap. c. Connections to Public Waters Excavations where the intended purpose is connection to a public water, such as boat slips, canals, lagoons, and harbors, shall comply with Minnesota Rules, Chapter 6115 . Permission for excavations may be given only after the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources has approved the proposed connection to public waters. 12. Placement and Design of Roads, Driveways, and Parking Areas Public roads are regulated by Section 60.400.030, Subdivision Standards, of this UDC, and parking areas are regulated by Section 60.400.080, Parking, Loading, and Stacking, of this UDC. The following additional standards shall apply within the SDO – Shoreland District Overlay. They are intended to supplement, not replace, the aforementioned standards. a. Roads, driveways, and parking areas shall meet building setbacks and may not be placed within Bluff Impact Zone and/or Shoreland Impact Zone, and shall in no case be closer than 25 feet to the OHWL. b. Public and private roads and parking areas shall be designed to minimize earthwork, and to take advantage of natural vegetation and natural topography to achieve maximum screening of view from public waters. c. Roads, driveways, and parking areas shall meet erosion control standards as described in Section 60.400.050G.2, Erosion Control, as well as the requirements of any other applicable design standards, ordinances and permits. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 86 Chapter 60.200: Zone Districts Section 60.200.040 Overlay Districts Section 60.200.040F: SDO – Shoreland District Overlay 13. Stormwater Management a. Stormwater shall be managed in accordance with all applicable City Engineering Standards, ordinances, and permits. b. Within the Shoreland District Overlay boundary, impervious surface coverage of lots shall not exceed 25 percent of the lot area. c. No net increase from the pre-project conditions is permitted pursuant to section 6-4- 12(1)a, Stormwater Management Criteria for Permanent Facilities and BMPs, of the Rochester Code of Ordinances. d. No net increase in flood rate, velocity or elevation during the 100 year event from the pre project conditions is permitted. e. When constructed facilities are used for stormwater management, documentation shall be provided by a qualified individual that they are designed and installed consistent with the City Engineering Standards. f. Newly constructed stormwater outfalls to public waters shall provide for filtering or settling of suspended solids and skimming of surface debris before discharge and shall be consistent with Minnesota Rules, part 6115.0231. g. Stormwater treatment facilities and the associated disturbances to accommodate for them should not be located within the floodway or the Shore Impact Zone. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 87 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010A: Organization of the Table Chapter 60.300 Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 I NTRODUCTION A. Organization of the Table 1. The regulations of this Section 60.300.010 identify the uses allowed in each zone district and the general standards that shall apply to the development of specific uses within each district. Each use listed in Table 300.01-1, Allowed Uses Table, has a corresponding definition located in Section 60.600.030, Definitions. 2. In Table 300.01-1, Allowed Uses Table, land uses are classified into general use categories and specific uses based on common functional, product, or physical characteristics such as the type and amount of activity, how goods or services are sold or delivered, and site conditions. This classification provides a systematic basis for assigning present and future land uses into appropriate zoning districts. 3. For certain uses, Use-Specific Standards above those imposed by the other Sections of the UDC are applied to address impacts that the specific use may have. In the Allowed Uses Table, an asterisk denotes if a Use-Specific Standard applies. B. Allowed Uses Table 1. A “S” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates the use is permitted after Staff confirmation that the use is available in that zone district and that the use complies with the Use-Specific Standards cross-referenced in the right-hand column of that row of the table. A use that is listed as an S use is also permitted as an accessory use in that zone district. 2. A “P” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates the use is subject to Planning Commission approval pursuant to Section 60.500.050A Conditional Use Permit in that zone district, subject to compliance with the Use-Specific Standards cross-referenced in the right-hand column of that row of the table. A use that is listed as an S use is also permitted as an accessory use in that zone district. 3. A “C” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates the use is subject to City Council approval pursuant to Section 60.500.040NL, Conditional Use Permit Approved by City Council, in that zone district, subject to compliance with the Use-Specific Standards cross-referenced in the right-hand column of that row of the table. The approval of a Conditional Use may not be limited to a stated period of time, but approval of a time- limited interim use may be available as described below in provision 5 of this subsection. A use that is listed as an S use is also permitted as an accessory use in that zone district. 4. A “V” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates that the use is subject to Planning Commission approval pursuant to Section 60.500.050A, Conditional Use Permit, provided that it takes place in an existing building or structure that the applicant Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 88 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010C: Unlisted Uses and Structures documents has been vacant for a period of five consecutive years and that it complies with any Use-Specific Standards referenced in the final column of the permitted use table and with all other applicable requirements of the LDM. All uses that were permitted by right when they were established, but that are now listed as a “V” uses will be deemed to have already obtained approval and the City will issue written confirmation of that fact at the request of the property owner. 5. A “I” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates that the use is permitted as an interim primary use subject to any Use-specific Standards referenced in the right-hand column of that row of the table. Interim uses require approval by City Council, any approval must state a period of time during which the use may operate. 6. A “A” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates that the use is permitted as an accessory use only in support of a permitted use on the site, and subject to the Use- Specific Standards cross-referenced in the right-hand column of that row of the table. 7. A “T” in a cell of the Allowed Uses Table indicates that the use is permitted subject to the issuance of a temporary permit, subject to the Use-Specific Standards cross-referenced in the right-hand column of that row of the table. 8. A “*” next to a use in the Allowed Uses Table indicates that a Use-Specific Standard cross-referenced in the right-hand column of the table applies to the use in the zoning district where the “*” appears. Details about the Use-Specific Standards are in Section 60.300.020. 9. A blank cell in the Allowed Use Table indicates that the use is not permitted in that zoning district. C. Unlisted Uses and Structures When a proposed primary, accessory, or temporary land use is not explicitly listed in the Allowed Use Table, the use is not permitted in Rochester, unless the Community Development Director determines that it is included in the definition of a listed use or is so similar to a listed use that it shall be treated as the same use. The Director shall make that determination based on a comparison of the size, scale, operating characteristics, multi- modal traffic impacts, storm drainage impacts, utility impacts, and neighborhood impacts of the proposed use with other uses listed in the Allowed Use Table. The Director’s interpretation shall be made available to the public and shall apply to future uses with the same characteristics until the Director makes a different interpretation or this UDC is amended to treat the use differently. D. Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws 1. Pursuant to authority by Minnesota Statues, Section 462.3593. Subdivision 9, the City opts-out of the requirement of Minnesota Statues 462.3593 that defines and regulates Temporary Family Health Care Dwellings. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 89 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws 2. All uses required by any local, state, or federal government to have an approval, license, or permit to operate are required to have that local, state, or federal approval, license, or permit at the time the use is established. 3. Allowed Uses Table Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Residential Uses Household Living Dwelling, Single- S S S S Family Detached Dwelling, Twin- S S S S S Home Dwelling, Attached S S S S S S S S S S S S Dwelling, Duplex, S S S S S S S Same Lot Dwelling, Triplex S S S S S S S Dwelling, Fourplex S S S S S S S Dwelling, Section S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* Multifamily 60.300.020B.3 Dwelling, S S S S S S S S S S S Live/Work Dwelling, Cottage Section S* S* S* S* S* S S S S S Development 60.300.020B.2 Manufactured Section P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* Home Park 60.300.020B.4 Group Living Congregate Section S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S Housing 60.300.020B.1 Dormitory Section P P P 60.300.020B.1 Medical Stay S S S S S S S S S S S S S Dwelling Unit Nursing Home Section P* P* P S* S* P S S S S S S S S S S 60.300.020B.5 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 90 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Offender Section C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* Transitional 60.300.020B.6 Housing Residential Care S/S/S/S/S/ Section S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* Facility P* P* P* P* P* 60.300.020B.7 Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses Art Gallery, P P P P S S S S S S S S S S S S S Museum, and Library Cemetery Section P* P* P* P* P* P* 60.300.020C.1 College or P P P P P P P P P P P University Community Center Section P* P* P* P* P* P* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* 60.300.020C.2 Community Section S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* Garden 60.300.020C.3 Correctional C C C C Facility Day Care Facility S/S/S/S/S/S/ Section S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* P* P* P* P P* P* P* P* P* 60.300.020C.4 Emergency Section P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* S* S* S* P* P* P* P* P* P* S* S* S* Service 60.300.020C.5 Funeral Home Section P P P S* S* S S S S S S 60.300.020C.6 Medical Facility Section P* P* P* P* P* S* S S S S S S S S S S 60.300.020C.7 Place of Worship Section S S S S S S S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* 60.300.020C.8 Public Park S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S P School Section S* S* S* S* S* S* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* 60.300.020C.9 Social Services Section P P* P* P* P* S* S S S S S S S S S S S 60.300.020C.10 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 91 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Specialized S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S Education Commercial Uses Agricultural and Animal Uses Agriculture Section S P* P* * S S Production 60.300.020D.2 Agriculture Retail S S P S S Veterinary and Section S* S S S S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* Animal Services 60.300.020D.27 Entertainment and Recreation Adult Section S* S* S* S* S* S* S* Entertainment 60.300.020D.1 Auditorium or P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P P Civic Center Campgrounds or Section P* P* RV Park 60.300.020D.8 Indoor Section P* P* S* S* S S S S S S S S S S S Entertainment or 60.300.020D.12 Recreation Indoor Gun Range Section C* C* C* 60.300.020D.13 Outdoor Section P* P* S* S* P* P S* Entertainment or 60.300.020D.18 Recreation Food, Beverage, and Lodging Bar or Tavern Section P* S S S* S S S S S* S S P P* 60.300.020D.5 Bed and Breakfast Section P* P* P* P* S S S S S 60.300.020D.6 Fast Food Section P* P* S* S S S S S S S S S S S S Restaurant 60.300.020D.9 Hotel or Motel S S S S S S S S S S P Neighborhood Section P S S S S* S* S S S S S S S S S Food and Service 60.300.020D.16 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 92 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Standard Section P* S S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S S* S S* S* Restaurant 60.300.020D.22 Office, Business, and Professional Services Art Studio and Section V S S S S S S S S S S S S Workshop 60.300.020D.4 Business or Section S* S* S* S* S* S S* S* S S S S S S S S Personal Service 60.300.020D.7 Construction Section P* S* S* Office 60.300.020D.9 Financial S S S S S S S S S S S S S Institution Office Section S P* S* S* S S S S S S S S S S S 60.300.020D.17 Research and Section P S S S S S P* S P S S S Testing 60.300.020D.21 Retail Sales Retail, Section S V S S* S* S S S S S S S S S Neighborhood 60.300.020D.23 Retail, Small Section P* P* S* S* S S S S S S S S S S 60.300.020D.24 Retail, Medium Section P S* S S S S S S S S 60.300.020D.25 Retail, Large Section P S* P* S* S* S* S* S* P S* 60.300.020D.26 Vehicles and Transportation Air Transportation Section C* C* P* P* 60.300.020D.3 Automotive Center P P S S S S S Automotive Repair P S P S S Services, Major Fueling Station Section P* S* S* A* S S* S* 60.300.020D.11 Motor Freight and Section P S* P P S* S* Warehousing 60.300.020D.14 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 93 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Motor Vehicle Section S S* S* S* S Sales, Leasing or 60.300.020D.15 Storage Parking Garage Section A* A* A* S* C* C* C* C* C* C* A* A* A* 60.300.020D.19 Parking Lot Section A A* A* A* A* A* A* A* S S S C* C* C* I I I S S S 60.300.020D.20 Public S P P P S P P S S S Transportation Dispatch Facility Railroad S Transportation Industrial Uses Manufacturing, Processing, and Commercial Services Artisan S S S S P S S S S S S Manufacturing Heavy S S P P S S Commercial Services Heavy Industry Section S* 60.300.020E.1 Light Industry P S S S Recycling Transfer S S S P S S Facility Repair and Section P* S* S* S* S* S* S* S* S S S Maintenance Shop 60.300.020E.4 Storage and, Distribution, and Wholesaling Junkyard Section C* 60.300.020E.2 Self Service Section P* S* S P* P* S* S Storage Facility 60.300.020E.6 Wholesale Facility Section S* S* P S* S* S* 60.300.020E.7 Resource and Extraction Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 94 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Landfill C Quarry Section C* C* C* 60.300.020E.3 Sand or Gravel Section I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* I* C* C* C* Excavation 60.300.020E.5 Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses Commercial Wireless Telecommunicatio n Service (CWTS) Section Co-Located on A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020F.1 Existing Structure Freestanding P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* P* Stealth on Existing A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Structure Communications P P P P P P P S P P S S S Tower Geothermal P A* A* A* A* A* A A A A A A A A A A A A P P Energy System Solar Collector, Section P* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* P* P* P* Ground- or 60.300.020F.2 Building-Mounted Utility, Major Section C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* C* 60.300.020F.3 Utility, Minor A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Wind Energy Conversion Section P* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* P* P* P* System (WECS), 60.300.020F.3 Ground- or Building- Mounted Section Accessory Uses and 60.300.020G.1 Structures Accessory Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Dwelling Unit 60.300.020G.5 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 95 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.010 Introduction Section 60.300.010D: Relation to Local, State, or Federal Laws Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Animal Husbandry Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020G.6 Billboard Section A* A* 60.300.020G.7 Drive-in Facility Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020G.8 Electric Vehicle A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Charging Station Fuel Tank Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020G.9 Garage Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020G.10 Greenhouse Section A A* A* A* A* A* A A A A A A A A 60.300.020G.11 Home Occupation Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020G.12 Outdoor Eating Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Area 60.300.020G.13 Recreational Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Vehicle Parking 60.300.020G.14 Recycling Drop Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Box 60.300.020G.15 Related Service Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Facility 60.300.020G.16 Residence for Section A* A* A* A* A* Caretaker or 60.300.020G.17 Security Guard Residential Section A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* A* Management or 60.300.020G.18 Sales Office Swimming Pool or Section A A* A* A* A* A* A A A A A A A A A A A A A A Tennis Court 60.300.020G.19 Urban Agriculture Section A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A A 60.300.020G.20 Temporary Uses Carnival or Section T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* Festival 60.300.020H.1 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 96 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020A: Applicability Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table S = Staff approval; P = Planning Commission approval; C = City Council approval; V = vacant use; I = interim use; A = accessory use; T = temporary permit; Blank cell = prohibited; Uses with an * = use-specific standards apply Non- Residential and Mixed Use Residen- Agricultural tial Zoning districts TD -- and Use-Specific MXMX subdistricts Standards (where applicable) NSCGI ----- 122x34 ----- AG R R R R R MX MX MX MX MX CorridorNodeVillageFringeMedialBusinessBP LI SI Contractor's Office Section T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* and Yard 60.300.020H.2 Food Truck Section T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* 60.300.020H.3 Garage Sale Section T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* 60.300.020H.4 Seasonal Sales Section T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* 60.300.020H.5 Storage Container Section T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* T* A* A* A* A* A* 60.300.020H.6 Section 60.300.020 U SE-S PECIFIC S TANDARDS A. Applicability The Use-Specific Standards listed in this Section 60.300.020 apply to those uses listed on the same line of the Allowed Uses Table, regardless of whether the uses are shown as Staff, Planning Commission, or City Council approvals, and regardless of whether they are Primary, Vacant, Accessory, or Interim. B. Residential Uses 1. Congregate Housing and Dormitory Developments shall meet the standards applicable to permitted Multifamily Dwelling, based on the computation that three rooming or sleeping units equal one dwelling unit. 2. Dwelling, Cottage a. Maximum development size is two acres. b. Cottage developments have a separation requirement of one-quarter mile from other cottage developments. c. Each cottage development may have a maximum 16,000 square feet of gross floor area in cottage units per acre. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 97 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020B: Residential Uses d. A shared private common space containing at least 10 percent of each cottage development shall be provided. e. Individual cottage lots or portions of cottage development may not be subdivided or sold individually. f. Zone district lot and setback requirements shall apply to the cottage development, but not to individual cottage dwelling sites. g. Each cottage development shall maintain a vegetated buffer, meeting the standards in Section 60.400.060D, Bufferyards, applicable to multifamily dwellings, along each side and rear lot line, and no portion of any primary or accessory structure may be located in that buffer area. h. The applicant shall submit a Site Development Plan identifying individual cottage dwelling sites, streets, parking areas, stormwater management facilities, common areas and facilities, and any other features required to be identified by this UDC. 3. Dwelling, Multifamily a. Where a multifamily structure shares a lot line with any Household Living use other than another multifamily structure, the multifamily structure is subject to Neighborhood Protection Standards, as described Section 60.400.020F. b. See Section 60.400.070E.8, Usable Recreation Area, for requirements on recreational areas in Multifamily Dwellings. 4. Manufactured Home Park a. General Requirements 1) At the time of application Owner/applicants must comply with the licensing requirements for manufactured home parks under Chapter 4630 of the Rules of the Department of Health in the Minnesota Statutes. 2) Each manufactured home sited on a lot in a manufactured home park shall conform to all Minnesota Statutes including but not limited to Chapter 327 and shall bear an installation seal as defined in Minn. Stat. Ch. 327.31, Subd. 12. b. Dimensional Standards The following table states the applicable dimensional standards for manufactured home parks in all districts. Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 2,000 sq. ft. / manufactured home space Lot Width 250 ft. / manufactured home space Usable Open Space 200 sq. ft. / manufactured home space Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) A Front 15 B Interior Side 5 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 98 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020B: Residential Uses Street Side 10 C Rear 10 Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) D Primary Structure 26 c. Development Standards 1) Manufactured homes that are not installed on a permanent foundation shall be skirted with materials similar in color, texture, and appearance to the siding of the manufactured home. 2) Anchorages and tie-downs constructed to comply with Articles 14-1 and 14-3 of ROA 1994 (Uniform Administrative Code and Uniform Housing Code) shall be provided on each manufactured home space or lot to prevent overturning or uplift of the manufactured home. 3) Carports, patios, decks, and accessory buildings may be located in side and rear setback areas of individual manufactured home sites. Such accessory buildings may not be located in any setbacks, usable open space, or landscape buffers required for the manufactured home community. 4) Storage sheds, accessory buildings, and carports shall be constructed of weather-resistant materials. 5) All yard areas and other open spaces not otherwise paved or occupied by structures shall be landscaped and maintained. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 99 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020B: Residential Uses 6) In cases where the owner of a manufactured home community intends to change the use resulting in expiration or termination of resident occupancy, the owner shall comply with Rochester City Code Section 5-18. 5. Nursing Home In the R-1, R-2, R-2x, R-3, and R-4 Districts, Nursing Home uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 6. Offender Transitional Housing a. Offender Transitional Housing in Residential Districts Offender Transitional Housing may be established in an Agricultural and Residential District if separated from other Offender Transitional Housing as shown in the table: District Separation Required R-1 1,000 feet or greater R-2 and R-2x 600 feet or greater R-3 400 feet or greater R-4 No minimum separation b. Offender Transitional Housing in Non-Residential Districts 1) There shall be no required minimum separation distance between Offender Transitional Housing uses in Non-Residential districts. 2) In Non-Residential districts, proposed Offender Transitional Housing that is within 500 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District may not cause the sum of the population capacity (rooming or sleeping units) of Offender Transitional Housing to exceed 10 percent of the sum of dwelling units and lodging units in parcels within a radius of 500 feet of a proposed Offender Transitional Housing use, except that where the sum of dwelling and lodging units within 500 feet is fewer than 100, the population capacity of Offender Transitional Housing units shall not exceed 10 persons. c. Offender Transitional Housing for Sex Offenders Any Offender Transitional Housing providing or intending to provide housing to a designated predatory offender as defined by state law or administrative rule must meet the separation requirements provided in this Section. Except where otherwise specified, the separation distances shall be measured from the property lines of both the offender housing and the facility from which it shall be separated. 1) Separation by a distance of not less than 1,000 feet is required from the following facilities: (a) Outdoor youth facilities in existence or included in approved General Development Plans; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 100 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020B: Residential Uses (b) Public active recreation parks under 10 acres in size in existence or planned; (c) The playground area of any existing or planned public active recreation park over 10 acres in size that is equipped with one or more playgrounds; (d) A licensed child day care facility except for a family day care facility; (e) Existing public or private childcare facility, elementary schools, and secondary schools; and (f) Quarry Hill Park in its entirety. 2) Separation by a distance of not less than 500 feet is required from a day care or a residential care facility licensed to operate as of the date of Conditional Use Permit application for the Offender Transitional Housing use. 7. Residential Care Facility a. Licensing and Approval 1) Residential Care Facility shall be licensed under the State of Minnesota and proof of such licensing is required prior to Zoning Certificate approval. 2) In all districts, a Residential Care Facility serving six or fewer dependents is a permitted use and may be approved by Staff provided that the proposed use meets the requirements for Single-Family Detached Dwellings. Where single- family dwellings are not permitted, the proposed use must meet the requirements for the R-2 District. 3) Residential Care Facility serving between 7 and 16 dependents is a permitted multifamily use and may be approved by Staff approval in the R-3 and R-4 Districts, provided that the proposed use meets the requirements applicable to Multifamily Dwellings. In the R-1 and R-2 Districts, such development shall be a conditional use subject to Planning Commission approval. 4) Residential Care Facilities serving more than 16 dependents in Agricultural and Residential District require Planning Commission approval of a Conditional Use Permit as described in Section 60.500.050A. b. Spacing Requirements No two Residential Care Facilities that require Planning Commission approval may locate within one-quarter mile of each other unless the two uses are separated by a physical barrier such as an arterial street, Non-Residential zoning, or topographical features that could mitigate the need for separating the uses. In such instances the request for a Zoning Certificate shall be processed with Planning Commission approval. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 101 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020C: Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses C. Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses 1. Cemetery Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 2. Community Center Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 3. Community Garden a. Structures 1) Greenhouses and hoop houses are limited to a maximum height of 15 feet, shall be located at least 10 feet from any lot line, and may not cover more than 25 percent of the property. 2) Cold frames are limited to a maximum height of 12 feet and shall be located at least 10 feet from any abutting lot with an occupied residential use. b. Operational Standards 1) Retail sales are not a permitted use on the Community Garden site, except for the sale of produce grown on that site. c. Soil Quality Food products grown in soil native to the site may be sold if the applicant can provide documentation to the Community Development Director that the following standards are satisfied: 1) A composite sample of the native soil, consisting of no less than five individual samples, has been tested for lead content and the lead content in the soil is determined to be at or below the residential screening levels for soil exposure, direct-contact for lead established by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency; and either: (a) Proof through maps, deeds, prior permits, or a combination of those sources that the site has only been used for residential or agricultural activities in the past; or (b) A composite sample of the native soil, consisting of no less than five individual samples, has been tested for metal content using the US EPA 3050B, 3051, or a comparable method and that the metals arsenic, cadmium, mercury, molybdenum, nickel, selenium, and zinc are determined to be at or below the residential screening levels for soil exposure, direct-contact established by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 102 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020C: Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses 2) If metal content in soil exceeds established thresholds, food products may only be grown in raised beds filled with clean topsoil. 3) As an alternative to meeting the above standards, food products may be grown in clean soil brought to the site without completing a soil test of the soil native to the site. 4. Day Care Facility a. Licensing and Approval 1) Day Care Facilities must be licensed by the State of Minnesota and proof of such licensing shall be required prior to Zoning Certificate approval. 2) In all Agricultural and Residential District, a day care facility serving 14 or fewer dependents is permitted and may be approved by Staff provided that the use meets the requirements for Single-Family Detached Dwellings. In zoning districts where single-family dwellings are not permitted, the applicable requirements shall be those of the R-2 district. 3) A Day Care Facility serving between 15 and 20 dependents is permitted and may be approved by Staff in the R-3 and R-4 districts, provided that the use meets the requirements for Multifamily Dwellings. In the R-1 and R-2 Districts, such use must be approved by the Planning Commission. 4) Day care facilities serving more than 20 dependents require Planning Commission approval as described in Section 60.500.050A, Conditional Use Permit, in Agricultural and Residential districts. b. Locational Requirements The portions of the lot or parcel on which the day care center is situated must be located 300 feet or more from any Heavy Industry use. The day care center may be an internal part of, attached to, or freestanding from the structure housing the primary use on the lot or parcel. 5. Emergency Service The site must provide direct access to a collector, arterial, or expressway. 6. Funeral Home a. Location Requirements in the R-3 District The use must be located at the intersection of a collector street and a higher order street. b. Location Requirements in the R-4 District The site must provide direct access to a collector, arterial, or expressway. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 103 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses 7. Medical Facility a. Access Requirements in the R-1, R-2, R-2x, R-3, and R-4 Districts Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. b. Location Requirements in the MX-N District The site must provide direct access to a collector, arterial, or expressway. 8. Place of Worship Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 9. School th Schools that provide educational services to Kindergarten through 5 Grade can be located on any street. All other Schools shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 10. Social Services a. In Agricultural and Residential districts, the use must be located at the intersection of a collector street and a higher order street. b. For social services providing overnight shelter, the facility shall be located along a regularly serviced transit route, at the discretion of the Community Development Director. D. Commercial Uses 1. Adult Entertainment a. Compliance with the Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 5-11 is required. b. The use must be located at the intersection of a collector street and a higher order street. c. All adult entertainment uses shall be located not less than 750 feet from any Agricultural and Residential District boundary, place of worship, school, or youth facility. d. No adult entertainment establishment shall locate within 750 feet of another adult entertainment use. 2. Agriculture Production In all districts except the AG district: a. Agriculture production is not permitted outside of the AG District. b. The animal density shall not be greater than one animal unit per one acre of pasture; and any structure used for the housing of livestock or poultry shall be located a minimum of 50 feet from any property line. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 104 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses c. Changes to the operation of existing nonconforming Animal production that expand or intensify existing uses are permitted and may be approved by Staff, however City Council approval is required where the Community Development Director determines that: 1) the operations constitute an industrial use involving the compounding, processing and packaging of products for wholesale or retail use involving more than five outside employees; or 2) the use is within 400 feet of any residential use; and a) the changes may create safety hazards or b) the changes may cause an increase in the emittance of noise, odor, or other nuisance 3. Air Transportation a. General Requirements in All Districts 1) All required state and federal approvals including but not limited to the Federal Aviation Administration for design and operation of the facility shall be obtained and maintained in effect at all times when the facility is in operation. 2) Air transportation facilities shall be designed so as to discourage trespassing by unauthorized personnel. 3) The use shall not include any retail, service, or advertisement activity that is not directly related to the operation of the facility unless the underlying land is zoned to permit such use. 4) Landing strips shall have a clear zone of 1,000 or more feet provided at the end of the runway that shall be controlled and maintained by the owner of the facility and kept free of uses or structures not associated with operation of the landing facility. 5) Landing pads shall have a planted area maintained around the perimeter of the pad by the owner of the facility to minimize noise, dust, and other hazards where necessary to protect surrounding residential properties. b. Access Requirements in the MX-G, MX-I, and LI Districts Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 4. Art Studio and Workshop In residential districts and in the MX-N district, the maximum allowed area for an Art Studio and Workshop is 4,000 square feet. 5. Bar and Tavern a. Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 105 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses b. In the MX-N district, 1) The use shall not be located on a lot abutting a residential district; and 2) Shall not be located adjacent to a single-family use, unless separated by an arterial street. 6. Bed and Breakfast In the R-2, R-2x, R-3, and R-4 districts, a Bed and Breakfast shall comply with the following criteria: a. The proprietor of a Bed and Breakfast must also be the owner and occupant of the property. b. In the R-2 district, Bed and Breakfast will be limited to a maximum of three double occupancy guest rooms, unless the lot for the proposed bed and breakfast is 20,000 square feet or larger in area, in which case, a maximum of five double occupancy guest rooms is permitted. c. In the R-3 and R-4 districts, Bed and Breakfast will be limited to a maximum of five double occupancy guest rooms. d. In Agricultural and Residential districts, one small, unlighted sign, not exceeding two square feet of display area is permitted. Such signs shall be attached to the front of the dwelling. In the R-3 and R-4 districts, one sign not exceeding four square feet shall be permitted, except on a lot that has public road frontage along a collector or higher level street or on a lot that directly abuts a Non-Residential zoning district. In those instances, one sign not exceeding 12 square feet is permitted. e. No Bed and Breakfast facility shall be permitted on a lot that is less than 10,000 square feet in size. f. One off-street parking space plus one parking space for each guest room shall be provided, in the R-2x district only one-half of a parking space shall be provided for each guest room and shall meet the provisions of Section 60.400.080E Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required. g. The dwelling proposed for a Bed and Breakfast must consist of at least 1,500 square feet of habitable floor area. h. Guest stays are limited to no more than 14 consecutive days. i. A distance separation of at least 500 feet must be maintained between bed and breakfast uses in the R-2 district. No distance separation is required in the R-2x, R-3, and R-4 districts. 7. Business or Personal Service a. Access Requirements in the R-2x, R-3, R-4, and MX-N Districts Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 106 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses b. Hours of Operation Restrictions Business and Personal Service uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation R-2x 7AM -- 9PM R-3 7AM -- 9PM R-4 7AM -- 10PM MX-N 6AM -- 10PM MX-S 6AM -- 10PM 8. Campground or RV Park a. The density of proposed developments shall not exceed 20 sites per acre. b. Spaces for trailers shall be at least 25 feet wide, and a 30-foot separation between any designated site and a residential zoning district boundary shall be maintained. c. Recreational space equal to 10 percent of the site area shall be provided, with no single recreational area smaller than 400 square feet in size. 9. Construction Office a. Construction offices shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. b. Storage of materials, vehicles, and other equipment associated with the operation of the business shall only be permitted in the side or rear yards, outside of any required bufferyard area c. Any exterior storage associated with a Construction office is subject to all applicable standards in Section 60.400.090, Exterior Storage. 10. Fast Food Restaurant a. Location Requirements in the R-4 and MX-N Districts The use must be located at the intersection of a collector street and a higher order street. Use not permitted abutting a single family or duplex residential use. b. Hours of Operation Restrictions Fast Food Restaurant uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation R-4 6AM -- 10PM MX-N 6AM -- 11PM MX-S 6AM -- 11PM 11. Fueling Station Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 107 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses a. Site area improvements devoted to the dispensing of fuels are permitted to encroach within any required yard, but no closer than five feet from any property line. b. Fuel pumps shall be no closer than 15 feet from any right-of-way line or property line. 12. Indoor Entertainment or Recreation a. Location Requirements 1) In the R-3, R-4, and MX-N districts, the site must provide direct access to a collector, arterial, or expressway. 2) In the R-4 and MX-N districts, any establishment containing over 15,000 square feet of gross floor area shall be located at the intersection of a collector or higher order street with another collector or higher order street. b. Hours of Operation Restrictions Indoor Entertainment or Recreation establishments may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation R-3 6AM -- 10PM R-4 6AM -- 10PM MX-N 6AM -- 10PM MX-S 6AM – 10PM 13. Indoor Gun Range Each Indoor Gun Range shall comply with the following standards. a. The building and method of operation shall comply with Minn. Stat. Ch. 87A, included but not limited to the noise standards in Minn. Stat. Ch. 87A and MN Rules 7030. b. An Indoor Gun Range shall not sell or dispense an Alcoholic Beverage, nor shall it be located in a building that contains a business that sells or dispenses an Alcoholic Beverage. An Alcoholic Beverage shall not be sold, stored, or consumed on the premises of the Indoor Gun Range at any time. c. The design and construction of the Indoor Gun Range shall completely confine all ammunition rounds within the building and in a controlled manner. d. The design of the Indoor Gun Range shall be performed by a professional engineer registered in the state of Minnesota and such design must contain specification as to thy ammunition to be used in such Indoor Gun Range. e. No ammunition shall be used in the Indoor Gun Range that exceeds the certified design and construction specifications of the Gun Range. f. Each Indoor Gun Range shall have a clear and concise safety plan. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 108 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses g. The applicant shall provide and maintain proof of liability insurance that shall require the insurer to notify the Community Development Director in writing of a cancellation of the policy, a change in the limit of the policy, and/or a change in policy ownership. The policy shall be executed and provided to the Community Development Director prior to the issuance of the certificate of occupancy and shall be available for inspection by the Community Development Director. h. Signs shall be posted in the entry of the structure and within the Gun Range space specifying that minors shall be accompanied by an adult at all times. This includes firearm safety classes that must be supervised by an adult instructor. i. Applicant shall operate and manage the Indoor Gun Range in conformance with all federal, state, and local laws and regulations related to the use, sale, rental, and transportation of firearms. j. The most current edition of the National Rifle Association's Range Source Book: A Guide to Planning and Construction shall serve as best practices for shooting range performance standards. k. Required Certificate of Occupancy Documentation Prior to occupying the building, requesting a temporary certificate of occupancy, or a final certificate of occupancy the applicant shall provide a certified inspection from the engineer that demonstrates compliance all provisions in this section including but not limited to those related to building construction, containment design and construction, caliber of firearms for which indoor gun range is certified, noise requirements, and executed proof insurance. l. Hours of Operation Restrictions Indoor Gun Range uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-G 7AM -- 10PM LI 7AM -- 10PM SI 7AM -- 10PM 14. Motor Freight and Warehousing In the MX-G, LI, and SI districts, uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 15. Motor Vehicle Sales, Leasing or Storage a. Outdoor display areas for vehicles are only permitted in the BP, MX-G, and LI districts. b. Outdoor storage areas for vehicles that are not for sale or lease are only allowed in LI district. 16. Neighborhood Food and Service Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 109 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses a. Access Requirements in the MX-N District Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. b. Hours of Operation Restrictions Neighborhood Food and Service uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-N 6AM -- 10PM MX-S 6AM -- 10PM 17. Office a. Location Requirements in R-4 District Offices shall be limited to: 1) The ground floor of a multi-story building; or 2) If located in a freestanding building, shall not exceed 2,000 square feet of gross floor area. b. Access Requirements in the R-4 and MX-N Districts Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. c. Hours of Operation Restrictions Office uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation R-4 7AM -- 10PM MX-N 6AM -- 10PM MX-S 6AM -- 10PM 18. Outdoor Entertainment or Recreation a. Design Requirements in All Districts 1) Sound amplification systems shall be designed so that the noise level at the property line does not exceed the maximum decibel level permitted in the zoning district applicable to the adjacent property. 2) The development shall be designed so that no bulb or light source in a ground level fixture is visible from any public right-of-way or adjacent residential properties. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 110 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses 3) Incidental commercial facilities, such as refreshment stands or pro shops, are permitted subject to the condition they are operated primarily for the patrons of the facility and no outdoor advertising of business or products is maintained. 4) Parking areas and other areas of intense activity, such as bleachers or rides, shall be setback at least 30 feet from any other property line, and parking surfaces shall have an all-weather surface. b. Requirements for Uses Involving Firearms 1) If the proposed use is an open range or gun club involving the use of firearms, all shooting stations shall be at least 1,000 feet from property lines unless designed so as to baffle noise and provide protection from accidental or stray ammunition discharge for surrounding properties. 2) The most current edition of the National Rifle Association's Range Source Book: A Guide to Planning and Construction shall serve as best practices for shooting range performance standards. c. Access Requirements in the MX-G, MX-I, LI, and SI Districts Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. d. Location Requirements for Certain Uses Outdoor Entertainment or Recreation uses that are of greater intensity than conventional outdoor athletic facilities because of 1) the noise and traffic volumes they may generate; 2) the glare they produce; or 3) the potential danger they may create from flying objects or the use of weapons. Uses in this category include, but are not limited to, amusement parks, racetracks (auto, go-cart, motorcycle) or ranges (skeet, rifle, or archery). This category of uses must provide direct access to a collector, arterial, or expressway. e. Hours of Operation Restrictions Outdoor Entertainment or Recreation uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-S 6AM -- 11PM LI 6AM -- 11PM SI 6AM -- 11PM 19. Parking Garage a. Compliance with Development Standards In addition to the parking standards in Section 60.400.070F.5, Iconic Building Alternatives, parking lots shall comply with the following requirements as applicable. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 111 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses b. General Requirements 1) Façade openings that face any public right-of-way or publicly accessible open space shall be vertically and horizontally aligned and all floors fronting on such façades shall be level. 2) Parking structures shall be designed to conceal the view of all parked cars below hood level, and to conceal internal light sources, from adjacent public rights-of-way and publicly accessibly open space. 3) The ground floor of each parking structure façade facing a public or private street shall be designed with a minimum floor to ceiling height of 13 feet, and with no driving aisle located within 20 feet of the street facing façade (except for required vehicle entryways) to allow those ground floor frontages to be used or converted to non-parking uses permitted in the zone district in the future. c. Additional Standards for the MX-T District No primary use parking garage unrelated to a park and ride location shall be located within the MX-T district, except in the MX-T Village subdistrict. In park and ride locations designated by the City: 1) The street-facing façade of the parking garage shall have a minimum floor-to- ceiling height of 13 feet for a depth of at least 30 feet from the street to allow for conversion to a non-parking use in the future. 2) The façade of a parking structure facing a street shall comply with the design standards in Section 60.400.070F.5, Iconic Building Alternatives. 20. Parking Lot a. Compliance with Development Standards In addition to the parking standards in Section 60.400.070F.5, Iconic Building Alternatives, parking lots shall comply with the following requirements as applicable. b. General Requirements for Primary Use Parking Lots 1) In the MX-S district, the only type of parking lot permitted is a public parking lot. 2) In the MX-N district, the only type of parking lot permitted is a public parking lot that is approved by Planning Commission. The street frontage of a parking lot in the MX-N district shall not exceed 60 feet and shall be screened from public view by a solid wall three feet in height constructed of durable maintenance free material or a dense evergreen hedge three feet in height. c. Spacing Requirements in the MX-N District Parking lot uses must be located at least 1,500 feet from each other. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 112 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses d. Standards for the MX-T District 1) No primary use surface parking lot unrelated to a park and ride location designated by the City shall be located within the MX-T district. 2) Primary use surface parking lots in park and ride locations designated by the City, and required or permitted accessory parking lots shall comply with the following standards: (a) No portion of the parking lot shall be located within 20 feet of any lot line facing a public or private street (not including alleys), or closer to any public or private street (not including alleys) than the façade of a primary structure, whichever requires the greater distance from the front lot line. (b) An area of at least six feet in width shall be located between each edge of the parking lot facing a public or private street and that street. Such area must be occupied by a pedestrian gathering space with seating, a bicycle parking area, or a landscaped buffer. (c) Surface parking lots with more than 100 parking spaces shall be organized into smaller modules that contain 50 or fewer spaces each and that are visually separated from other parking modules by buildings or landscaped areas. (d) Surface parking lots and structures containing more than 50 parking spaces shall provide clearly identified pedestrian routes between parking areas and the primary pedestrian entrance(s) to the building(s) served by the parking areas. The pedestrian routes shall be designed and located to minimize the pedestrian routes interface with traffic circulation routes, and to provide pedestrian walkways with direct pedestrian access to the primary building entrance(s). 21. Research and Testing In the Medical Subarea of the MX-D district, Research and Testing uses shall be related to the medical community/industry either by providing support services to existing institutions within the subdistrict or by providing research in the field of medicine on an independent basis. 22. Standard Restaurant a. Location Requirements in the R-4 District The use must be located at the intersection of a collector street and a higher order street. b. Hours of Operation Restrictions Standard Restaurant uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 113 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses District Permissible Hours of Operation R-4 6AM -- 10PM MX-N 6AM -- 11PM MX-S 6AM -- 11PM 23. Retail, Neighborhood a. Access Requirements in the MX-N District Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. b. Outdoor Displays Outdoor displays related to the retail use are permitted for a period of not more than 14 consecutive days on portions of the lot that are not needed to meet minimum parking standards, do not occupy required landscaped areas, do not occupy required front setbacks, and do not obstruct sidewalks or walkways. c. Hours of Operation Restrictions Neighborhood Retail uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-N 6AM – 10PM MX-S 6AM – 10PM 24. Retail, Small a. Access and Location Requirements 1) Requirements in the R-2x and R-3 District (a) Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. (b) The site must provide direct access to a collector, arterial, or expressway. 2) Requirements in the R-4 District The use must be located at the intersection of a collector street and a higher order street. b. Outdoor Displays Outdoor displays related to the retail use are permitted for a period of not more than 14 consecutive days on portions of the lot that are not needed to meet minimum parking standards, do not occupy required landscaped areas, do not occupy required front setbacks, and do not obstruct sidewalks or walkways. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 114 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses c. Hours of Operation Restrictions Small Retail uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation R-2x 6AM – 7PM R-3 6AM – 7PM R-4 6AM -- 10PM MX-N 6AM -- 11PM 25. Retail, Medium a. Outdoor Displays Outdoor displays related to the retail use are permitted for a period of not more than 14 consecutive days on portions of the lot that are not needed to meet minimum parking standards, do not occupy required landscaped areas, do not occupy required front setbacks, and do not obstruct sidewalks or walkways. b. Hours of Operation Restrictions Retail Trade uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-S 6AM -- 10PM MX-C 6AM -- 10PM 26. Retail, Large a. Outdoor Displays Outdoor displays related to the retail use are permitted for a period of not more than 14 consecutive days on portions of the lot that are not needed to meet minimum parking standards, do not occupy required landscaped areas, do not occupy required front setbacks, and do not obstruct sidewalks or walkways. b. Building Entrances Large retail buildings shall have clearly defined, highly visible customer entrances featuring no less than three of the following elements: 1) Canopies or porticos; 2) Overhangs; 3) Recesses/projections; 4) Arcades; 5) Raised corniced parapets over the door; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 115 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020D: Commercial Uses 6) Peaked roof forms; 7) Arches; 8) Outdoor patios; 9) Display windows; 10) Architectural detail such as tile work and moldings integrated into the building structure and design; or 11) Integral planters that incorporate landscaped areas and places for sitting. c. Building Articulation 1) Large retail buildings shall incorporate two or more of the following design elements on each façade visible from a street: (a) Changes in wall plane, such as projections or recesses, having a wall offset of at least one foot depth, and located a minimum of every 40 feet. Each required offset shall have a minimum width of 10 feet; (b) Distinct changes in texture and color of wall surfaces; (c) Variations in roof form and parapet heights; (d) Vertical accents or focal points. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 116 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020E: Industrial Uses 2) Side walls exceeding 30 feet length shall have façade articulating elements such as columns and/or changes in plane, texture, or masonry pattern. 27. Veterinary and Animal Services a. In the MX-N and MX-S districts animals shall be kept in a completely enclosed building at all times. b. In other districts, outdoor exercise runs are permitted provided they are enclosed on four sides by a sight obscuring fence or wall at least six feet in height, and that animals are kept indoors from 9 p.m. until 7 a.m. E. Industrial Uses 1. Heavy Industry Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 2. Junkyard a. General Requirements 1) The junkyard operation shall be conducted within a building or within a yard enclosed on all sides by a wall or solid fence at least eight feet in height. 2) Openings equipped with a gate or door not exceeding 24 feet in width, or not exceeding the minimum width needed to allow access to railroad lines or spurs serving the property, are permitted to allow vehicle access into the site. 3) Openings for vehicle access shall be closed when the establishment is not open for business. b. Access Requirements 1) Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 2) Uses shall not take access to any local or collector street where access to the site from the primary street system (arterials, expressways, and freeways) by way of the collector or local results in traffic passing through a residential area. c. Hours of Operation Restrictions Junkyard uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation SI 5AM – 11PM 3. Quarry a. Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 117 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020E: Industrial Uses b. Uses shall not take access to any local or collector street where access to the site from the primary street system (arterials, expressways, and freeways) by way of the collector or local results in traffic passing through a residential area. c. Storage of materials, vehicles, and other equipment associated with the operation of a business shall only be permitted in the side or rear yards setbacks, outside of any required bufferyard area, and controlled by bumper stops or other means so as not to cross over the lot line. 4. Repair and Maintenance Shop a. All operations and storage must be conducted within an enclosed structure. b. Repair and Maintenance Shops uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-N 6AM – 10PM MX-S 6AM – 10PM 5. Sand or Gravel Excavation a. Exterior Storage Storage of materials, vehicles, and other equipment shall only be permitted outside of any required bufferyard area and controlled by bumper stops or other means so as not to cross over the lot line. b. Environmental Review Required 1) A proposed excavation activity shall be subject to appropriate Environmental Review pursuant to Section 60.500.030D.1.a Environmental Review below and, where determined by the Community Development Director to be necessary, Environmental Review Program documents shall be prepared by the applicant. 2) Environmental Review Program documents may include, among other things, Environmental Assessment worksheets and Environmental Impact Statements. 3) The documents shall be reviewed prior to final action by the City on any development related permit needed for the proposed excavation activity. c. Access Requirements 1) Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. 2) Uses shall not take access to any local or collector street where access to the site from the primary street system (arterials, expressways, and freeways) by way of the collector or local results in traffic passing through a residential area. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 118 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020E: Industrial Uses 6. Self Service Storage Facility a. Standards in Agricultural and Residential Districts 1) No Self-Service Storage Facility shall be used for any commercial activity (including for hire transfer and storage operations), repair and maintenance activity, or any industrial operations. 2) Storage of flammable liquids or combustible, corrosive, explosive, radioactive, or other and hazardous materials is prohibited. 3) Exterior areas for the storage of recreational vehicles are permitted. 4) This use shall only be approved in an Agricultural and Residential District if: (a) There are natural buffers separating the site from surrounding residential uses that will be retained as part of the site development, or (b) The property abuts an existing Non-Residential district, and natural features of the site, such as shallow bedrock or poor subsoil conditions, make the development of residential uses on the site economically unfeasible. b. Standards in Mixed Use and Non-Residential Districts 1) Drive aisles between structures must be a minimum of 18 feet between the nearest points of buildings. 2) In addition to the main access one emergency access must be provided on the site. The emergency access must consist of a gate and drive over curb. 3) Where access to the facility is provided by a card reader or otherwise controlled two stacking spaces must be provided between the card reader and the lot line. 4) A minimum setback of 10 feet from the nearest point of the building to the lot line is required to allow for emergency vehicle access. 5) Accessory uses permitted include only outdoor vehicle storage and resident manager dwelling. 6) Storage of flammable liquids or combustible, corrosive, explosive, radioactive, or other and hazardous materials is prohibited. 7) If the facility is located in the MX-G or MX-D districts all storage shall be contained within a fully enclosed structure that: (a) Is at least a two-story structure with climate-controlled storage units on upper floors only with access doors to storage units accessed from interior hallways; and (b) Does not have any garage doors or access doors to any storage unit facing any public street, park, or open space, unless the doors are screened from all visible public streets, parks, and open spaces. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 119 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses c. Hours of Operation Restrictions SSSF uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-G 6AM -- 11 PM where use is adjacent to a residential zoning district BP 6AM -- 11 PM where use is adjacent to a residential zoning district 6AM -- 11 PM where use is adjacent to a residential LI zoning district 7. Wholesale Facility a. Loading Requirements Sufficient off-street loading space to handle anticipated vehicles shall be provided, along with the sufficient room on-site to allow maneuvering of vehicles so as to preclude the need to use the public right-of-way for backing movements. b. Access Requirements in the MX-S, MX-C, MX-G, LI, SI, and BP Districts Uses shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. c. Hours of Operation Restrictions Wholesale Facility uses may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-G 6AM – 10PM F. Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses 1. Commercial Wireless Telecommunication Service The following regulations shall apply to all Commercial Wireless Telecommunication Services (CWTS) in any zone district, unless specified otherwise: a. Small Wireless Facility Construction Criteria The installation or attachment of an antenna or other wireless communications equipment using small cell technology to stand-alone streetlight poles shall be subject to the criteria set forth below. 1) General Requirement In all cases, the existing pole shall be replaced with a replacement pole. 2) Pole Criteria (a) Only one installation per pole on a first come, first served basis is permitted. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 120 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses (i) The wireless equipment is not permitted to protrude more than five feet above the streetlight luminaire itself. (ii) The mounting height of the luminaire on the streetlight pole shall be no more than 35 feet. (iii) The mast arm length of a replacement pole shall match the existing streetlight pole being replaced. (iv) The color and surface treatment of the replacement pole shall match the surrounding area poles. Color criteria for poles shall be as follows: a. In the MX-T and MX-D districts, 30 feet height – black finish b. All districts except the MX-T and MX-D, 30 feet height – galvanized or gray finish c. All districts except MX-T and MX-D, 20 feet height – stainless steel finish (no paint) d. Shoppes on Maine Area, 14 feet and 25 feet height – dark green (v) No Company signs are permitted to be placed on a streetlight pole, including a replacement pole, except to the extent required by local, state, or federal law or regulations. (vi) All pole attached wireless equipment must be a minimum 10 feet from the sidewalk elevation. (vii) All ground based wireless equipment, including, but not limited to, equipment cabinets or power pedestals, shall be placed at the back of the right-of-way whenever possible. (viii) All pole-mounted equipment shall match the color of the replacement pole. (ix) For each individual pole type or style used to support the wireless equipment, one spare replacement pole shall be provided by the applicant to the City at the end of the project so that the pole can be replaced promptly in case of a knockdown. (x) All plans shall be signed and sealed by a Professional Civil and Electrical Engineer. (xi) All other details in the City Street Light Design Standards shall apply. (xii) The replacement pole and the wireless equipment attached to the pole shall not increase the diameter of the existing pole that is replaced by more than 60 percent, not to exceed eight inches total, or increase the height of the existing pole by more than 10 percent, not to exceed four feet. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 121 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses (xiii) Antennas shall be limited to snug-mount, canister-mount, and concealed antennas and mounted no more than six inches off the pole. (xiv) All cables or wires for the attached wireless equipment shall be located inside the pole except where such cables or wires attach to the ports in the antenna. (xv) When wireless equipment is attached to a replacement pole, the primary purpose of the pole shall remain as a pole structure supporting a streetlight luminaire and related streetlight fixtures used to provide lighting to the City right-of-way. 3) Equipment Cabinets (a) Equipment cabinet locations shall comply with the height and development standards of the underlying zoning district. (b) Equipment cabinets with air-conditioning shall be enclosed by walls and setback a minimum of 15 feet from lots where the existing or planned primary use is a single-family dwelling. (c) No more than one equipment cabinet and/or power pedestal shall be located at and serve any one pole site. 4) Additional Information Required for Above-Ground Utility Structures All permit applications to place or install above ground structure greater than 24 inches must be accompanied by the following information: (a) Evidence or documentation that, where the above-ground structure is over 36 inches in height, given its proposed location, the structure will comply or be in compliance with applicable City regulations and this UDC. (b) City will provide documentation that identifies a potential site for replacement within neighborhood. The site will be selected on the basis of aesthetics and technical/engineering restrictions. (c) Evidence that the structure shall be placed on the same side of the right-of- way as refuse containers or utility poles. The structure shall not block trash truck access and alley access. (d) Verification of sight-triangle compliance. (e) Three photographs of the proposed structure, one at 90 degrees, the other two at 45 degrees on either side of the proposed location. Identify the location of the proposed structure, mark the location with white tape, and/or use an orange traffic cone. (f) Evidence or documentation of the dimension of the structure. (g) Evidence or documentation that the structure shall not exceed 36 inches in height in front of the front yard of a residential home. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 122 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses (h) Information as to the specifications of the structure, if available. b. Stealth Design (Concealment) Required 1) Any proposed CWTS, excluding co-locations of antennas on existing unconcealed towers and public utility co-locations, shall use concealed technology. 2) The CWTS shall be the least visually and physically intrusive as possible and shall have the least adverse visual effect on the environment and its character, existing vegetation, and nearby residences. 3) In the R-1, R-2, R-2x, and R-3 districts, concealed installation on an existing building shall only be permitted on a permitted Non-Residential structure. 4) A CWTS is considered concealed if the Community Development Director determines that the facility is: (a) Aesthetically integrated with existing buildings, structures, and landscaping to blend in with the nature and character of the built and natural environment, considering height, color, style, massing, placement, design, and shape. (b) Located on existing vertical structures, including utility poles and public utility structures to the maximum extent practicable. (c) Located in areas where the existing topography, vegetation, buildings, or other structures provide the greatest amount of screening of the CWTS. (d) Located so that it is not readily visible or identifiable as a CWTS. 5) Consistent with federal law, these concealment requirements shall not be administered so as to have the effect of prohibiting the provision of wireless telecommunications services. c. Maximum Height 1) Co-locations on any existing unconcealed CWTS tower or existing structure: 75 feet. 2) Freestanding CWTS: 65 feet. 3) Stealth Facilities on Existing Structures: No taller than the existing structure, unless fully screened from view from all streets abutting the property, in which case the CWTS may exceed the existing structure height by 10 feet. d. Location and Separation of Freestanding CWTS 1) A freestanding CWTS is prohibited in the following locations: (a) Within 100 feet of the property line of any Residential zone district. (b) Within 50 feet of an existing right-of-way. (c) Within any setback required by the underlying zone district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 123 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses 2) New freestanding CWTS shall be located a minimum of 1,000 feet from any other freestanding CWTS, as measured from the wall or fence of each freestanding CWTS. This requirement does not apply to a freestanding small- cell CWTS. 3) No new freestanding CWTS shall be allowed unless the Community Development Director determines, upon the applicant’s demonstration, that no existing tower, structure, or public utility structure can be used in lieu of new construction to accommodate the applicant’s proposed CWTS. Evidence that demonstrates that co-location or public utility co-location cannot be used in lieu of new construction to reasonably accommodate the proposed CWTS shall consist of an affidavit with supporting exhibits submitted by the applicant addressing all of the following: (a) That no existing tower, structure, or public utility structure within a ½ mile radius meets the minimum engineering requirements and/or lacks available space to support the proposed CWTS. (b) That co-location or public utility co-location of the proposed CWTS would cause unavoidable electromagnetic interference with the antenna(s) on the existing towers, structures or public utility structures, or the antenna(s) on the existing towers, structures, or public utility structures would cause interference with the applicant’s proposed CWTS. (c) That there are other limiting factors that render existing towers, structures, or public utility structures within the ½ mile radius unsuitable. (d) That the owners of existing towers, structures, or public utility structures within the ½ mile radius will not allow the applicant to place its CWTS on that facility, or such owners are requiring payments for such placement that substantially exceed commercially reasonable prices. e. Lighting and Signage 1) Only security lighting or lighting required by a state and/or federal agency is permitted, however additional lighting is permitted provided all of the following conditions are met: (a) The location and cut-off angle of the light fixture shall be such that it does not shine directly on any public right-of-way or any lot containing a residential use. (b) The lighting shall not have an off-site luminance greater than 1,000 foot lamberts at any point and shall not have an off-site luminance greater than 200 foot lamberts measured from any private property in any Residential zone district. 2) Only signage required by state or federal law is permitted. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 124 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses f. Abandonment Any CWTS that is not in use for three consecutive months shall be removed by the CWTS owner within the following three months. 1) Upon removal, the site shall be revegetated to blend with the existing surrounding vegetation. 2) If there is no vegetation on a CWTS site, the site shall be returned to its preconstruction condition. 3) The facility owner shall notify the City when removal of the facility occurs. g. Interference Every CWTS shall meet the regulations of the Federal Communications Commission, or any successor of that agency, regarding physical and electromagnetic interference. h. Health Issues Every CWTS shall meet health and safety standards for electromagnetic field emissions as established by the Federal Communications Commission or any successor of that agency, and any other state or federal agency. i. Co-location 1) Co-locations are encouraged. 2) Co-location on a concealed CWTS shall maintain the concealed nature of the facility. Otherwise, such co-locations are not subject to the concealment requirements in Section 60.300.020F.1.a. 3) The installation or attachment of an antenna or other wireless communications equipment using small cell technology to stand-alone streetlight poles shall be subject to the criteria set forth below. 4) Stealth Design (Concealment) Required, but shall be done in the least visibly intrusive manner, to blend in with the existing structure and its surroundings. 5) The equipment cabinet(s) shall be not more than three feet by four feet by 18 inches deep, at least 10 feet and no more than 20 feet high. 6) No provision of this UDC shall be interpreted to prevent a co-location of CWTS as required by the Federal Telecommunications Act and Middle Class Tax Relief and Job Creation Act (2012) (as amended and interpreted by the federal courts), including without limitation processing of applications for approval of “eligible facilities” and treatment of Telecom Facilities that do not propose “substantial changes” to existing facilities, as those terms are defined in the Act. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 125 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses j. Landscaping and Screening 1) All freestanding CWTSs shall be surrounded by an opaque wall or fence at least six feet and not more than nine feet high. 2) All freestanding CWTSs shall include vegetation that is planted and maintained to screen ground equipment facilities from public view. 3) Freestanding small-cell CWTSs are not subject to the landscaping requirements in Subsections 1 and 2 above, but must comply with the following requirements: (a) Equipment shall be screened by a wall, fence, or other method including but not limited to an equipment cabinet, or decorative feature that fully screens the equipment with opaque material. (b) Equipment and screening materials shall not block pedestrian pathways and sidewalks. 2. Solar Collector, Ground- or Building-Mounted a. General Standards for All Solar Collectors 1) All exterior electrical lines shall be buried below the surface of the ground when possible. 2) All systems shall comply with all City and state building and electrical codes. 3) The property owner shall notify the electrical utility where the solar system is connected to the electrical utility system. 4) If the solar collector system ceases to perform its originally intended function for more than 12 consecutive months, the property owner shall remove the collector, mount and associated equipment and facilities by no later than 90 days after the end of the 12-month period. b. Accessory Ground-Mounted Solar Collectors Accessory ground-mounted solar collectors shall: 1) Be located in a side or rear yard setback only; 2) Be set back at least six feet from the side and rear property line; 3) Not be located within an easement; 4) Be located so as to minimize glare visible from abutting properties; 5) Not exceed 15 feet in height with panels oriented in a vertical position; and 6) Be included in determining the maximum coverage of structures on the lot. c. Accessory Building-Mounted Solar Collectors Accessory building-mounted solar shall: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 126 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020F: Utility, Communication, and Energy Uses 1) Not extend more than 18 inches above the maximum height permitted in the zoning district in which it is located; 2) If mounted to a portion of the roof ending at, or extending over, the front façade of the building, shall be mounted so that the edge of the device is set back at least one foot from the edge of the roof closest to the front lot line; and 3) If mounted to the wall of a building, may extend into or over no more than 33 percent of the depth of a minimum yard or setback that is required along a side lot line but shall not extend closer than four feet to a side lot line. d. Principal Ground-Mounted Solar Collectors Principal ground-mounted solar collectors shall: 1) Be set back at least 25 feet from any property line abutting a residential zoning district, and at least 15 feet from any property line if adjacent to Mixed Use or Non-Residential zoning district. 2) Not exceed 25 feet in height when oriented at maximum tilt; 3) Be located so as to minimize glare visible from an abutting property; and 4) Be considered in determining the maximum coverage of structures on the lot. 3. Utility, Major Utility uses required in connection with a Major Utility use do not require additional approvals. 4. Wind Energy Conversion System (WECS), Ground or Building Mounted a. Height Limitation 1) Ground-Mounted WECS shall not exceed the height permitted in the applicable zoning district. 2) Building-Mounted WECS may not exceed the height permitted in the applicable zoning district by more than five feet. b. Setbacks 1) A ground-mounted WECS located on a single lot shall be set back from each property line at least 1.1 times the total height of the WECS. 2) A ground-mounted WECS located on a project site that contains two or more abutting properties shall be set back from each project site boundary shown in the application at least 1.1 times the total height of the WECS. 3) Each ground-mounted Small Utility WECS shall be set back from each on-site dwelling unit at least 1.1 times the total height of the WECS. 4) A WECS that is placed on a primary or accessory structure and does not exceed the maximum height in the applicable zoning district shall meet the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 127 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures minimum setback for the primary or accessory structure in the zoning district where it is located. 5) If a WECS attached to a primary or accessory structure receives approval for additional height through the Section 60.500.070CA Variance process, the WECS shall be set back from each property line at least 1.1 times the total final height of the WECS. 6) The blades of a WECS placed on a primary building shall not extend beyond the property line in any operational position. 7) Substations, facility buildings, and other accessory structures that are part of the WECS shall comply with the required primary building setbacks for the zoning district in which the project is located. c. Separation Distance 1) Each ground-mounted WECS with blades that spin on a horizontal axis and with a height of more than 100 feet shall not be located within 600 feet of any state wildlife management areas, other Minnesota Department of Natural Resources lands, Types 3-5 wetlands, and flood control reservoirs. 2) No components of a WECS shall be located within or encroach within 10 feet from any power line. d. Number of Systems in Agricultural and Residential Districts No more than one ground-mounted WECS is permissible per development site in the R-1, R-2, and R-2x districts. G. Accessory Uses and Structures All accessory uses shown in the Allowed Uses Table shall comply with the following standards unless an exception is provided elsewhere in this UDC. 1. General a. No accessory use or structure shall be established or constructed unless a Zoning Certificate has been issued that establishes compliance with all applicable provisions of this UDC. b. Inadequate Dwelling Facilities: No garage, tent, trailer, recreational vehicle, accessory building, basement or cellar shall at any time be used as a dwelling, except as provided for within this UDC. 2. Limitation on Establishment No accessory use or structure shall be constructed or established on any lot prior to the time of the substantial completion of construction of the primary use or structure to which it is accessory. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 128 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures 3. Accessory Structures in Agricultural and Residential Districts The following general regulations apply to detached garages, accessory buildings, and accessory structures in all Agricultural and Residential districts. a. Location 1) Detached garages, accessory buildings, and structures accessory to a residential use must be located in a side or rear yard area, but not closer than 18 inches of any side or rear lot line, and not in any area where the building or structure is prohibited by Subsection b below. 2) Additional location requirements The following are in addition to Subsection a above: (a) No accessory structure may be located within five feet of an alley; and (b) No accessory building that provides street-accessed parking for vehicles or recreational vehicles shall be located closer to any side lot line than one-half of the side setback required for the primary structure on the lot. b. Lot Development Standards 1) Location Requirements Unless otherwise permitted, garages or accessory structures that are attached to and an integral part of the primary structure or building shall be located in the buildable area. 2) Setback Requirements Garages or accessory structures that are attached to and an integral part of the primary structure or building may encroach 20 percent into the minimum rear yard setback. 3) Coverage Requirements a. When located in the rear yard setback, accessory structures shall occupy no more than 35 percent of the rear yard setback area. b. If any part of the accessory structure is located in the side yard, the accessory structure shall occupy no more than 15% of the lot area. c. Detached accessory buildings or structures shall not exceed the size of the primary structure. 4) Floor Area and Separation Requirements (a) The sum of the individual gross floor area of each primary and accessory building on a lot shall not exceed the maximum floor area ratio, if any, for the applicable zoning district, unless otherwise provided by an exception in this UDC. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 129 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures (b) A roof may not extend beyond the wall more than six inches where located within 18 inches of a side or rear lot line. (c) Separation of accessory structures from primary structures shall be as required by the Building Code. 4. Accessory Structures in Non-Residential Districts a. Accessory buildings and structures associated with a non-residential use shall meet all setback requirements for the primary building on the lot and shall not interfere with provision of required landscaping on the lot. b. No accessory building in a Non-Residential district shall exceed the height of the primary building unless provided for in this Section. c. The combined lot coverage of accessory buildings or structures and the primary building or structure located on the same lot or site shall not exceed the permitted lot coverage for the district. Structures under 200 square feet in floor area are exempt from the lot coverage computation. 5. Accessory Dwelling Unit a. General 1) There shall be no more than one accessory dwelling unit on a lot. 2) If the accessory dwelling unit is located in a district that only allows a single principal dwelling unit on the lot, either the principal dwelling unit or the accessory dwelling unit must be the primary permanent residence of the owner of the lot. 3) An accessory dwelling unit must not contain more than 1,000 square feet of gross floor area. 4) No portion of a lot on which an accessory dwelling unit is located may be subdivided from or legally described differently than the lot containing the principal dwelling unit, and no portion of a structure containing an accessory dwelling unit may have ownership different from the ownership of the principal dwelling unit. 5) Recreational vehicles and storage containers may not be used as accessory dwelling units. b. Additional Standards for Attached Accessory Dwelling Units 1) An attached accessory dwelling unit shall maintain the architectural design, style, appearance, and character of the principal dwelling by incorporating design elements of the principal dwelling such as similar façade materials, façade colors, window style, and roof design and pitch, and shall not have a primary entrance to the accessory dwelling unit located on the front façade of the principal dwelling. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 130 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures 2) An attached accessory dwelling unit must meet the same setbacks as the principal dwelling unit on the lot. c. Additional Standards for Detached Accessory Dwelling Units 1) Detached accessory dwelling units shall only be located in the rear or side yard. 2) The detached accessory dwelling unit shall be located no closer than 6 feet to the principal dwelling, or the minimum separation distance as required by Building Code. 3) The detached accessory dwelling unit must meet the same side setbacks as the principal dwelling unit, and may be no closer than 10 feet to an alley or the rear lot line. 4) The architectural style of the accessory dwelling unit, including but not limited to massing, roof shape, and exterior appearance shall be compatible with that of the principal dwelling unit on the lot. 5) The accessory dwelling unit shall be connected to the closest adjacent right-of- way by a paved pedestrian pathway of at least three feet in width. 6. Animal Husbandry Horses, llamas, and animals that typically weigh more than 100 pounds when mature or that are typically raised for sale or profit are only permitted in the AG district. 7. Billboard a. Spacing All billboards erected after December 22, 1992, shall comply with the following spacing standards: i. No billboard shall be located within 1,000 feet of another billboard located on the same side of the street. Distances between billboards shall be measured along the adjacent right-of-way line of the street or highway where the billboard is directed as shown in Figure 1a. ii. No billboard shall be located within a 100 foot radius from the intersection of the rights-of-way of two or more streets or highways as shown in Figure 1b. iii. No billboard shall be located within 200 feet of the intersection of a street and a railroad right-of-way. The distance shall be measured from the center point of the street-railroad intersection to the nearest edge of the billboard as shown in Figure 1c. iv. No billboard shall be located within 300 feet of a Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility. This distance shall be measured from the nearest edge of the billboard to the Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility to the closest point on any boundary line of the Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility property as shown in Figure 1d. This restriction only applies to Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility properties that abut the same right-of-way where a Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 131 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures billboard is oriented, regardless of whether the billboard is located on the same side or the opposite side of the right-of-way as the Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility. v. No billboard shall be located within 250 feet of a boundary of an Agricultural and Residential district. This distance shall be measured from the nearest edge of the right-of-way to the closest point on any boundary of the Residential district as shown in Figure 1e. vi. No billboard shall be located within 300 feet of and oriented toward the following portions of the following streets and highways within the City: 1) County State Aid Highway 22 from trunk Highway 52 at Apache Mall westerly th and northerly to Trunk Highway 52 at 55 Street NW, 2) County State Aid Highway 22 from Trunk Highway 14 at the University Center th northerly and westerly to Trunk Highway 63 at 37 Street NW; and th 3) 55 Street NW from Trunk Highway 52 easterly to County Road 133 (West River Road). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 132 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures Figure 1a Figure 1c Figure 1b Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 133 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures Figure 1e Figure 1d 8. Drive-In Facility a. That portion of the site area used for vehicle circulation and parking shall be hard- surfaced to control dust and shall be setback at least 30 feet from any other property line. b. Waste receptacles shall be provided at all exits where readily disposable goods or materials are offered for sale and pick-up through the drive-through. c. Devices such as speakers shall be designed so that the noise level at the property line does not exceed the maximum decibel level permitted in the zoning district applicable to the adjacent property or the existing ambient noise level as measured at the property line, whichever is greater. d. The development shall be designed so that no ground level light sources are visible from any public right-of-way or adjacent residential properties. e. Incidental commercial facilities, such as refreshment stands, are permitted subject to the condition they are operated primarily for the patrons of the facility and no outdoor advertising of business or products is maintained. f. MX-T and MX-S District Requirements Drive-in facilities in the MX-T and MX-S Districts shall not: 1) Be located or designed so that vehicles using the drive-in facility pass between any public or private street and any portion of any façade of the primary building facing that street; and 2) Be accessed directly from, or be located on a lot(s) with a driveway approach ndth onto, N. or S. Broadway, SW. 2 St., or SE 4 St./Collegeview Rd. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 134 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures 9. Fuel Tank a. An accessory fuel tank may be permitted in any zoning district for the purpose of heating on site structures. b. Such fuel tanks shall be located in the buildable area of the lot or the required rear yard setback, subject also to the fire protection regulations, and shall be screened from adjacent properties with low hedges, evergreens, or other plant materials in association with a fence. 10. Garage a. General 1) Unless stated otherwise in this UDC, detached garages for residential uses shall be excluded from the floor area ratio calculation. 2) Detached garages for residential uses shall be included in the calculations to determine lot coverage by buildings, structures, and paved surfaces. 3) The location and size of detached garages for residential uses shall not interfere with installation of all required landscaping on the lot. b. Attached Garages Garages attached to a dwelling unit, which face the front property line, must maintain a 19 foot minimum setback 11. Greenhouse In Agricultural and Residential districts, greenhouses are limited to a maximum height of 15 feet, shall be located at least 10 feet from any lot line, and may not cover more than 25 percent of the property. 12. Home Occupation All Home Occupations require Staff approval and may only be approved if the following standards are met. a. The Home Occupation may not involve the use of an accessory building, dwelling unit, or structure on the lot, except for uses using recreational facilities such as swimming pools or tennis courts. b. The Home Occupation shall not occupy more than 25 percent of the livable area of the dwelling unit or 1,000 square feet, whichever is less. c. The Home Occupation shall not involve internal or external alterations or construction features not normally found in dwellings and shall not include a separate entrance. d. Other than a member of the family residing in the dwelling unit, only one outside employee may be engaged in the Home Occupation. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 135 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures e. No Home Occupation may involve the boarding of animals or keeping of fowl or farm animals, except as otherwise provided by any provision of the Rochester Code of Ordinances. f. No Home Occupation may use a mechanical equipment or process that creates noise, vibration, glare, fumes, odors, or electrical interference detectable off the premises, including those that create visual or audible interference on any radio or television receiver located off the premises. g. No exterior storage of equipment or materials in connection with the Home Occupation and no display of products, goods, or services that is visible from outside the dwelling unit are permitted. h. Only articles made or originating on the premises shall be sold, unless the articles are incidental to a permitted commercial service. i. Traffic that may be generated shall not be of such magnitude as to have a significant detrimental effect on the capacity of streets in the area. j. Only one vehicle used in connection with the Home Occupation shall be stored or stopped on the premises, and such vehicle shall not be a dump truck, wrecker, or fuel oil delivery truck, or other truck with a gross vehicle weight of over 10,000 pounds. k. Any permit approving a Home Occupation is valid for only the person, the business, and the location named in the application, and may not be transferred to another person, business, or location. l. In the R-1 and R-2 districts, one small, unlighted professional sign, not exceeding two square feet of display area, and attached to the front of the dwelling, is permitted. m. In the R-3 and R-4 districts, one sign not exceeding four square feet shall be permitted, except on a lot that has public road frontage along a collector or higher level street or on a lot that directly abuts a Non-Residential zoning district, one sign not exceeding 12 square feet is permitted. n. Each individual home occupation sign within a Multifamily Dwelling shall be no greater than two square feet in size, and there shall be no more than a cumulative total of 12 square feet of signage permitted for the Multifamily Dwelling. 13. Outdoor Eating Area Outdoor eating areas located on a public right-of-way shall comply with the following standards: a. No sale or service shall be permitted in any portion of a street designated for vehicular travel or circulation. b. Structures and equipment shall not be permanently installed in the public right-of- way. c. Sidewalks shall be swept and washed daily by the permit holder. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 136 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures d. Trash disposal and electricity must be provided from within the establishment. e. A minimum of five feet of sidewalk width must remain unobstructed for passage by pedestrians. f. A permit is required for all uses located on public property or rights-of-way pursuant to the Rochester Code of Ordinances, Chapter 9-8. 14. Recreational Vehicle Parking The parking and storage of recreational vehicle and recreational equipment on a lot is permitted subject to the following restrictions. a. In the R-1, R-2, and R-2x districts only one RV may be stored on a lot. b. Parking and storage are permitted at all times within an enclosed building or within the rear yard. c. Recreational vehicles under 18 feet in length and seven feet in height, or recreational equipment under 18 feet in length, may be parked on an established driveway in a required front or side yard meeting the provisions of Section 60.400.020E, General Dimensional Standards. d. Recreational vehicles and equipment over 18 feet in length, or seven feet in height may be parked on an established driveway, provided they are set back a minimum of 20 feet from the back of the curb, where present, or the paved area of the street. e. Recreational vehicles or equipment that require licensing must have a valid current license in order to be stored outside upon a property within a residential zoning district. f. Recreational vehicles may not be used as permanent accessory structures within any residential zoning district or as an accessory dwelling unit. 15. Recycling Drop Box a. A recycling drop box may be located anywhere on a lot except in a required traffic visibility area or a required bufferyard. b. Each recycling drop box shall be setback from all property lines a distance equal to the height of structure. 16. Related Service Facility a. The gross floor area of all retail and service facilities within a Multifamily Dwelling shall not be greater than 25 percent of the gross floor area of all the dwelling units in that structure or 4,000 square feet, whichever is less. b. The facility shall be operated only for the residents, employees, or guests of the primary use and their guests. When provided in the R-4 District, such facilities are exempt from this requirement and may be open to the public on a fee or other basis. 17. Residence for Caretaker or Security Guard a. A residence for caretaker of security guard is permitted for any commercial or industrial use for the purpose of security. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 137 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020G: Accessory Uses and Structures b. The residence may be either an integral part of the primary building or detached from it. 18. Residential Management or Sales Office a. In any multifamily or manufactured housing development, one dwelling unit may be devoted to use as an office for management of the development or as a headquarters for sales, leasing, or management of other dwelling units in the development. b. One freestanding sign not to exceed six square feet in size shall be permitted for identification purposes. c. Off-street parking equal to that required for office uses shall be provided. 19. Swimming Pool and Tennis Court No swimming pool or tennis court shall be allowed in any Agricultural and Residential District unless it complies with the following requirements. a. The pool or court shall not be operated as a business or private club, except when allowed as a permitted home occupation. b. The pool or court shall not be located in any required front or required side yard and shall not be closer than 10 feet to any property line of the property. c. Pump and filter installations for pools shall not be closer than 20 feet to any property line. d. For an in-ground or surface swimming pool, the pool or the property where the pool is located shall be enclosed by a fence of a type that effectively controls the entrance by children to the pool area. For an in-ground pool, a mechanically controlled cover can be used in lieu of fencing requirements. e. For an above ground swimming pool, the pool shall be equipped with an automatically retractable type ladder, a retractable ladder, a removable ladder or shall be fenced in as stated in this Section. The ladder must be removed or retracted when the pool is not being attended. f. Enclosed pools and courts shall be considered as structures for purposes of regulations limiting lot coverage. 20. Urban Agriculture a. Compliance with other City Regulations Urban Agriculture uses must comply with the Rochester Code of Ordinances Title 3. b. Structures 1) Greenhouses and hoop houses are limited to a maximum height of 15 feet, shall be located at least 10 feet from any lot line, and may not cover more than 25 percent of the property. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 138 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020H: Temporary Permits 2) Cold frames are limited to a maximum height of 12 feet and shall be located at least 10 feet from any abutting lot with an occupied residential use. c. Operational Standards 1) Retail sales shall be prohibited on the Urban Agriculture site, except for the sale of produce grown on that site. 2) The site drainage and maintenance shall prevent water and fertilizer from draining onto adjacent property that is not part of the contiguous land in the Urban Agricultural use. 3) Compost piles shall not exceed six feet in height. Refuse and compost area shall be enclosed at ground level to be rodent-resistant. 4) No outdoor work activity that involves power equipment or generators may occur between sunset and sunrise. H. Temporary Permits 1. Carnival or Festival a. No structure or equipment shall be located within 100 feet of any residential property line. b. May occur on Non-Residential primary uses such as places of worship, community centers, and schools. c. In Agricultural and Residential districts, the permit is limited to events of 200 or fewer participants that are less than two days. 2. Contractor’s Office and Yard a. General Requirements 1) Permitted in any district where it is incidental to a construction project. 2) The office or shed shall not contain sleeping or cooking accommodations and shall be removed upon completion of the construction project. b. Access Requirements in the MX-S, MX-N, MX-G, and MX-I Districts Shall not have vehicle access points from or channel a majority of the traffic generated by the use onto a Local residential street. c. Hours of Operation Restrictions Contractor’s Offices and Yards may only operate during the times specified in the table below. If a district is not listed, then no hours of operation restrictions apply. District Permissible Hours of Operation MX-N 6AM -- 10PM MX-S 6AM -- 10PM Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 139 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020H: Temporary Permits 3. Food Truck Compliance with the Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 5-21 is required. 4. Garage Sale Garage sales are limited to no more than three sales per calendar year at any one property, and each sale may not exceed three consecutive calendar days. 5. Seasonal Sales a. Sale areas shall be set back a minimum of 20 feet from any right-of-way. b. Seasonal sales are only permitted for a period of 45 days or less. 6. Storage Container a. General 1) No storage container shall be located on a lot before a Site Development Plan review has been completed and a Zoning Certificate has been issued, unless the storage container is already shown on an approved Site Development Plan. 2) No storage container may be used for temporary or permanent human occupancy. b. Standards in Agricultural and Residential Districts All storage containers in Agricultural and Residential Districts shall: 1) Only be permitted on site containing a Park, School, Place of Worship, and for a period not to exceed six months per year. 2) Be set back at least 50 feet from each property line abutting a residentially zoned lot. 3) Be set back at least 25 feet from each public street. 4) Be set back at least 50 feet from each property line abutting a street when residential dwellings are located across the street. 5) Be an earth tone color and may have an identification sign with no more than two square feet of sign area. c. Standards in Mixed Use and Non-Residential Districts Container storage area in Mixed Use and Non-Residential Districts must meet the following requirements. These standards do not apply to truck trailers or semi-trailers that are actively being used for the transportation of merchandise and are temporarily located adjacent to loading docks of a primary structure. 1) Container Storage as a Primary Use of Land (a) This primary use of land shall comply with all standards applicable to Heavy Commercial Services in the LI and SI districts. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 140 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020H: Temporary Permits (b) A Site Development Plan review and Zoning Certificate is required for this use. 2) Container Storage as an Accessory Use of Land Storage containers are a permitted accessory use only within the MX-G, LI, and SI districts for those use categories that permit exterior storage or display in the applicable zoning district. Container storage of merchandise is permitted only when incidental to the permitted use located on the same lot. 3) Storage Container Location (a) Storage containers must meet Exterior Storage standards as specified in Section 60.400.090. (b) Storage containers may be located within the buildable area of a lot, provided that: (i) They shall be set back from each public right-of-way by at least 25 feet. (ii) The container storage area shall not be located on any part of a yard between the front or side street lot line and the primary structure or building. (iii) They shall not be located on utility or drainage easements. 4) Maximum Permitted Heights The maximum height permitted shall be nine and one-half feet above the finished grade. 5) Site Impact The area of a lot designated for storage containers shall be included as a part of the floor area and all related calculations including floor area ratio and landscape area. The area on a property designated for storage containers shall not exceed the outer dimensions of the primary structure or 10 percent of the gross floor area, whichever is less. Where Large Retail use or a Heavy Commercial Services Use proposes to use storage containers, the containers shall be located within the permitted exterior storage area and must be calculated as part of the exterior storage area as regulated by the district and by Section 60.400.090, Exterior Storage. 6) Site Improvements (a) In the MX-G, LI, and SI districts, the area designated for storage containers shall be required to provide a bufferyard as required for a Heavy Commercial Services use. (b) In the MX-G and LI districts, the storage container shall be completely enclosed by a solid wall made of the same material and the same appearance as the primary structure, and a gate that blocks the view of the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 141 Chapter 60.300: Use Regulations Section 60.300.020 Use-Specific Standards Section 60.300.020H: Temporary Permits storage area. The wall shall be 10 feet in height. The gate shall be securable. A wall will not be required where a Large Retail or Heavy Commercial Services use proposes to use storage containers and the containers are located within the exterior storage area as regulated by the district, and by Section 60.400.090, Exterior Storage. 7) General Standards (a) Storage containers shall not be connected to utility services. (b) Storage containers may not be used to store mixed municipal waste or other solid waste or hazardous, flammable, explosive, corrosive, or biologically infectious or contagious materials. (c) The area used to park the storage containers shall be located on a lot that allows the units to be moveable. (d) No object may be stacked or stored on top of a storage container. (e) Storage containers shall not be stacked vertically. d. Temporary Placement 1) Storage Containers may not be located at an individual property for longer than: (a) 14 days if the property is located in a residential zone district or on a property with a residential primary use in a Mixed Use district; (b) 90 days if the property is located in a special purpose zone district or on a property with a Non-Residential primary use in a Mixed Use district; or (c) The time period between the issuance of the first building permit for construction of new primary building or a major addition to an existing primary building and the issuance of the last certificate of occupancy or use for the new or expanded primary building. 2) Storage containers may not block fire lanes, no-parking zones or restrict emergency vehicles, delivery, or other vehicle circulation. 3) The placement of the container shall not block the visibility for vehicles or pedestrians entering or exiting the site. 4) No solid or hazardous waste or hazardous material is permitted in or around the storage containers. 5) No materials may be stacked or stored on top of the storage container. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 142 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.010 Introduction and Applicability Section 60.400.010A: Purpose Chapter 60.400 Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.010 I NTRODUCTION AND A PPLICABILITY A. Purpose This Chapter includes standards that regulate the physical layout and design of development within Rochester. These standards address the physical relationship between development and adjacent or abutting properties, public streets, neighborhoods, and the natural environment, to implement the vision of a more attractive, sustainable, equitable, and livable community laid out in Rochester’s Comprehensive Plan. B. Applicability This Chapter 60.400 applies to new developments and changes of uses as stated in Table 400.01-1 Applicability of Development Standards. Table 400.01-1 Applicability of Development Standards Major Minor Distinctive General Site Change of UDC Standard UDC Section SubdivisioSubdivisioDevelopmeDevelopmenDevelopmen Use n n nt t Plan \[1\] t Plan Dimensional Section In some Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Standards 60.400.020 cases Subdivision Section Yes Yes No No No No Standards 60.400.030 Access and Section Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Connectivity 60.400.040 Sensitive Lands, Section Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Stormwater, 60.400.050 and Drainage Landscaping, Section Bufferyards, No No Yes Yes Yes Yes 60.400.060 and Fences Site and Section In some Building No No Yes Yes Yes 60.400.070 cases Design Section Parking No No Yes Yes Yes Yes 60.400.080 Exterior Section No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Storage 60.400.090 Exterior Section No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Lighting 60.400.100 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 143 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020A: Purpose Table 400.01-1 Applicability of Development Standards Major Minor Distinctive General Site Change of UDC Standard UDC Section SubdivisioSubdivisioDevelopmeDevelopmenDevelopmen Use n n nt t Plan \[1\] t Plan Signs Section Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 60.400.110 NOTES \[1\] Review of standards in this Chapter is not required for Comprehensive Plan amendments initiated by a party other than the City if a Subdivision or Site Plan Development approval will be required prior to development. Section 60.400.020 D IMENSIONAL S TANDARDS A. Purpose This Section 60.400.020 is intended to provide dimensional standards and uniform methods of measurements for interpretation and enforcement of the lot and building standards in this UDC. B. Applicability All development shall comply with this Section 60.400.020, unless another provision of this UDC modifies these standards. Modifications of these dimensional standards may be found in Section 60.200.040, Overlay Districts, Section 60.400.120, Incentives, Section 60.400.020F, Neighborhood Protection Standards or in other Sections of this UDC. C. Multiple Non-Residential Buildings on a Lot The following requirements apply when more than one building is proposed on a single lot, and none of those buildings include a residential primary use. 1. The floor area shall not exceed the highest maximum floor area ratio applicable in the zoning district where the development is located. 2. Where two or more buildings are developed on a single lot, the most restrictive appearance and bufferyard standards shall be applicable to the entire development unless the development is designed such that each building has a separately defined area on the lot where different appearance and bufferyard standards can be reasonably applied. 3. Adequate access to each building or structure for Emergency Vehicles and apparatus shall be provided. 4. The site design of the development shall take into account the potential for future subdivision of the site so that adequate access by way of easement or lot pattern may be provided to each building in the future. D. Application of Setbacks Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 144 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020D: Application of Setbacks 1. General Requirements a. The principal building or principal use on a lot may not be located in a required setback or in areas designated for private or common space on an approved Site Development Plan. b. On lots where the existing right-of-way width of an adjacent street is not consistent with the planned right-of-way width as shown on an adopted Official Map or on the Long Range Transportation Plan, the required front setback shall be measured from the right-of-way line of such street as designated on the Official Map or Long Range Transportation Plan or official map. c. On lots where all adjacent streets have not yet been platted but are shown in an approved General Development Plan, the required front setback shall be measured from the future right-of-way lines shown in the General Development Plan. d. For earth sheltered and earth bermed buildings, yards shall be measured from the exterior surface of the building regardless of whether it is above or below grade. e. The minimum front setback shall be provided on a lot or site between the front lot line and a front yard line established at a distance equal to the required front yard or setback. f. On a corner lot: 1) The owner shall designate one street frontage as the front lot line, and all other street frontages shall be designated as side street lot line(s), except as noted in Subsection 2) below. 2) If the lot is subject to lot width standards, and one or both street frontages do not meet those requirements, the street frontage that comes closest to meeting lot width standards shall be designated as the front lot line. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 145 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020D: Application of Setbacks g. On a flag lot or a lot with no frontage, the Community Development Director shall designate a front lot line by reference to the following design features: 1) The location of the structure’s primary entrances. 2) The orientation of the primary windows required by the Building Code or the structure. h. The minimum rear setback shall be provided on a lot or site between the rear lot line and a rear yard line established at a distance equal to the required rear yard or setback. i. On a triangular-shaped lot, the rear yard line is established by points located on the intersecting lot lines (or that would intersect if extended to form a true triangle) that are equidistant from the apex (or imaginary apex if a non-intersecting lot line were extended to intersect) and that, when connected, create a line equal in width to the minimum width at the building line. j. The minimum side yard or setback is provided on a lot or site, between all side lot lines and a side yard line established at a distance equal to the required side yard or setback and extending from the front yard line to the rear yard line. k. On corner lots where potential front and side lot lines create a continuous curve, a radial line intersecting the midpoint of the curve shall be deemed the boundary between the yards. l. In no instance shall a setback greater than that established for the district be required. 2. Front Lot Lines on Private Roadways Where a development uses private roadways to provide access to individual buildings within the development, the front lot line shall be: a. In the case of an access roadway, a line parallel to the edge of the roadway at a distance from the edge of the roadway equal to the greater of: 1) Seven feet (to accommodate snow storage); 2) One foot for every five feet of roadway surface width; or 3) For any portion of the façade occupied by a garage or carport accessed from the private street, at least 20 feet; b. In the case of a limited access roadway, a line established at the edge of the roadway surface; c. In the case of a common driveway, the lot line if one is established or the centerline of the driveway; or d. In the case where a building is bounded on two or more sides by an access roadway or limited access roadway, one side shall be considered a front yard and the remaining side shall be considered a side street yard. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 146 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020D: Application of Setbacks 3. Front Yards on Cul-de-Sacs On lots fronting a cul-de-sac or curvilinear street, the front yard setback shall be: a. A straight line that is located as close as possible to the curved front lot line, but at no point is closer to the front lot line than a distance that is 80 percent of the required front yard; or b. A line that is parallel to the front lot line at the required setback distance. 4. Through Lots On through lots, the lot line closest to the primary windows and entrances shall be considered the front lot line. The opposite frontage shall be treated as a side street lot line. 5. Existing Small Lots On any residential lot of record in existence as of January 1, 1992 that does not meet the minimum lot size or dimensional standards for the zoning district in which it is located, the depth of the minimum rear and side yard may be reduced by the same ratio that the actual lot size bears to the minimum required lot size in the district where the lot is located, but the reduction shall not exceed one-half of the minimum required rear or side yard depth, as applicable. 6. Application of Setbacks on Alleys When a side yard or rear yard on a lot abuts an alley, one-half of the width of the alley may be counted towards meeting the side or rear yard setback requirement, but shall not Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 147 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020E: General Dimensional Standards result in a building or structure being erected closer to the alley than half the distance of the minimum required yard or, in the case of a rear yard, closer than three feet from the right-of-way line. E. General Dimensional Standards The following tables establish the dimensional standards for Agricultural and Residential, Mixed Use, and Non-Residential districts. All development shall comply with the standards in Table 400.02-1 Agricultural and Residential Zoning Districts, Table 400.02-2 Mixed Use Zoning Districts, and Table 400.02-3 Non-Residential Zoning Districts unless otherwise stated in this UDC or another adopted City regulation. The dimensional standards in Tables in Table 400.02-1 Agricultural and Residential Zoning Districts, Table 400.02-2 Mixed Use Zoning Districts, and Table 400.02-3 Non-Residential Zoning Districts may be modified by standards in Section 60.200.040, Overlay Districts, Section 60.400.120, Incentives, Section 60.400.020F, Neighborhood Protection Standards or by other provisions of this UDC. 1. Agricultural and Residential Zoning Districts Table 400.02-1 Agricultural and Residential Zoning Districts AG R-1 R-2 R-2x R-3 R-4 Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 35 acres 5,000 sq. ft. 3,000 sq. ft. 2,000 sq. ft. 3,500 sq. ft. 6,000 sq. ft. Lot Width 60 feet 60 feet 30 feet 30 feet 30 feet 60 feet Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) Front 20 15 15 20 20 15 Street Side \[1\] \[2\] 12 12 11 10 12 7 Interior Side \[3\] 6 5 0 6 6 10 Sum of Interior 16 12 10 12 16 None Sides Rear, Primary Building/Structure 25 20 10 20 25 15 \[4\] Rear, Accessory Building/Structure 6 6 6 6 6 6 on Corner Lots \[5\] Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) Primary Structure 35 35 35 45 48 115 Accessory 45 15 \[6\] 15 \[6\] 15 \[6\] 25 25 Structure Other Standards Maximum Floor None None None None 1.5 None Area Ratio Maximum Length None None None 80 feet None None of Building Façade Fronting a Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 148 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020E: General Dimensional Standards Table 400.02-1 Agricultural and Residential Zoning Districts AG R-1 R-2 R-2x R-3 R-4 Public Right-of- Way Minimum None 50% 40% 40% 35% 25% Landscape Area NOTES \[1\] A lot that has a street side yard within 25 feet of a front yard on an adjacent lot shall be set back 25 feet from the common lot line and the street side yard line. \[2\] On any lot where a street side setback abuts a side lot line in any district other than and R-1 or R-2 district, the street side setback within 25 of the abutting side lot line, a setback at least equal to one-half the width to the front yard setback on the abutting lot shall be provided. On any lot where a street side setback abuts a side lot line of a lot in the R-1 or R-2 district, a setback at least equal in width to the front yard required in the adjacent R-1 or R-2 district shall be provided. \[3\] Lots on cul-de-sacs must also comply with Section 60.400.040C.3.f, Cul-de-Sacs. \[4\] See Section 60.400.020D.5, Existing Small Lots. \[5\] Accessory buildings/structures facing a street shall be setback a minimum of 10 feet from the street side lot line, except for garages accessed from the side street, which shall be set back a minimum of 20 feet from the street side lot line. \[6\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. 2. Mixed Use Zoning Districts Table 400.02-2 Mixed Use Zoning Districts MX-T \[1\] MX-D MX-N MX-S MX-C MX-G MX-I Node Fringe Village Medical Corridor Business Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area None None None None None None None Lot Width None None None None None None None Building Setbacks (Minimum/Maximum, in feet) Front 0 / 15 0 / 15 None 15 15 None None Street Side 7 7 None 7 7 2 None \[2\] Interior 5 None None None 10 5 None Side Sum of Interior 10 None None None None 10 0 5 None Sides Rear 5 None 7 None 8 5 0 5 None Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) Primary 24 36 48 60 70 65 85 95 135 185 235 Structure Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 149 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020E: General Dimensional Standards Table 400.02-2 Mixed Use Zoning Districts MX-T \[1\] MX-D MX-N MX-S MX-C MX-G MX-I Node Fringe Village Medical Corridor Business Accessory 15 \[3\] 15 \[3\] 15 \[3\] 25 25 30 30 30 30 30 30 Structure Other Standards Maximum Building None None None None None 300 300 300 None Length Maximum Floor Area 0.5 2.0 0.7 1.0 1 4 5 5 None Ratio Minimum Landscape 25% 15% 20% 15% 20% 5% 5% 5% 5% 8% 0% Area NOTES \[1\] Section 60.200.030L.3, Additional District Standards contains additional limits on minimum building height, maximum building setbacks, and requirements for the creation of pedestrian-oriented spaces in the front setback area. \[2\] On any lot where a street side setback abuts a side lot line in any district other than and R-1 or R-2 district, the street side setback within 25 of the abutting side lot line, a setback at least equal to one-half the width to the front yard setback on the abutting lot shall be provided. On any lot where a street side setback abuts a side lot line of a lot in the R-1 or R-2 district, a setback at least equal in width to the front yard required in the adjacent R-1 or R-2 district shall be provided. \[3\] 24 feet for Accessory Dwelling Units. . 3. Non-Residential Zoning Districts Table 400.02-3 Non-Residential Zoning Districts BP LI SI Lot Dimensions (Minimum) Lot Area 5 acres \[1\] None None Lot Width None None None Building Setbacks (Minimum in feet) Front 25 25 25 Street Side \[2\] 12 12 12 Interior Side None None None Sum of Interior Sides None None None Rear 10 \[3\] 10 None Building/Structure Height (Maximum in feet) Primary Structure None \[4\] 40 \[5\] 50 \[5\] Accessory Structure None None \[6\] None \[7\] Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 150 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020F: Neighborhood Protection Standards Table 400.02-3 Non-Residential Zoning Districts BP LI SI Other Standards Maximum Floor Area 0.5 0.5 1 Ratio Minimum Landscape 15% 8% 5% Area NOTES \[1\] Applies to minimum area of contiguous land, rather than individual lots, and may be reduced by the Community Development Director to reflect constraints such as sites bounded by arterial or higher level streets, streams, or other topographic constraints, existing development, land already included in an approved General Development Plan, or permanent open space that limits the inclusion of other abutting lands. \[2\] On any lot where a street side setback abuts a side lot line in any district other than and R-1 or R- 2 district, the street side setback within 25 of the abutting side lot line, a setback at least equal to one-half the width to the front yard setback on the abutting lot shall be provided. On any lot where a street side setback abuts a side lot line of a lot in the R-1 or R-2 district, a setback at least equal in width to the front yard required in the adjacent R-1 or R-2 district shall be provided. \[3\] Rear Yard may be reduced to 0 feet when abutting a railroad. \[4\] If within 100 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District, then the maximum height shall be 35 feet for all structures. \[5\] Maximum height only applies to new primary structures constructed after the Effective Date of the UDC. \[6\] If within 100 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District, then the maximum height is 50 feet for all structures. \[7\] If within 200 feet of an Agricultural and Residential District, then the maximum height is 50 feet for all structures. F. Neighborhood Protection Standards 1. Purpose This Section 60.400.020F is intended to preserve the character of established residential uses in Residential zoning districts by requiring that development on abutting Mixed Use and Non-Residential properties take additional steps to mitigate their visual and other impacts on the Residential zone district. 2. Applicability The standards in this Section 60.400.020F apply to each Regulated Lot, as defined below. a. Protected Lots A Protected Lot is any lot in an Agricultural and Residential District that contains: 1) A Household Living use of 4 units or less, or 2) A Group Living use occupying a Single-Family Detached Dwelling. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 151 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020F: Neighborhood Protection Standards b. Regulated Lots A Regulated Lot is any lot in a Mixed Use or Non-Residential district, or a lot containing more than four residential units in a Residential district, that is abutting to a Protected Lot. 3. Building Setbacks Along their common property line, the minimum side or rear building setback on each Regulated Lot shall be 20 feet. 4. Building Height Stepdown a. On each Regulated Lot, the maximum height of any portion of a primary or accessory building within 100 feet of any common lot line with a Protected Lot shall be the maximum height of a primary structure containing residential uses in of the zoning district of the Protected Lot. b. Subsection (a) shall not apply if the maximum height of a primary structure in the zoning district where the Regulated Lot is located is no greater than the maximum height of a primary structure in the zoning district where the Protected Lot is located. 5. Outdoor Lighting Stepdown On each portion of a Regulated Lot that is located within 100 feet of a common lot line with a Protected Lot a. The maximum height of each light pole and each outdoor lighting fixture shall be 15 feet. b. The exterior lighting standard shall conform to the lighting standard of the Protected Lot. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 152 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020G: Exceptions to the Dimensional Standards 6. Bufferyards Along any common lot line with a Protected Lot, each Regulated Lot shall install a bufferyard meeting the standards of a Level 4 bufferyard in Table 400.06-4, Bufferyard Levels, or buffering of equal or greater effectiveness in mitigating the impacts of noise, lighting, glare, odor, and vehicle activity, as determined by the Community Development Director. 7. Parking and Drive-through On a Regulated Lot containing 10,000 square feet of gross lot area or more, no surface parking area or drive-through lane shall be located within 50 feet of any common lot line with a Protected Lot. 8. Trash Storage On a Regulated Lot, no waste, debris, or garbage storage shall be stored within 50 feet of any common lot line with a Protected Lot. G. Exceptions to the Dimensional Standards 1. Exceptions to Maximum Height Standards In addition to any exceptions for uses listed in Section 60.300.020, Use Specific- Standards, steeples, bell towers, chimneys, roof-mounted mechanical equipment, elevator equipment enclosures, and similar architectural and mechanical elements, may exceed the maximum height of the applicable zoning district by no more than 25 percent of the applicable maximum height. 2. Exceptions to Minimum Setback Standards a. The setback exceptions in Table 400.02-4 Authorized Exceptions to Setback Requirements shall not authorize the encroachment of any development across property lines or into a public right-of-way or over any easement that prohibits such encroachment. Setback exceptions require a revocable permit in compliance with the Public Works Engineering Standards. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 153 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards Section 60.400.020G: Exceptions to the Dimensional Standards b. Every part of a required setback shall be unobstructed from ground level to the sky except as follows: Table 400.02-4 Authorized Exceptions to Setback Requirements Type of Exception Extent of Exception Porches, balconies, canopies, stairways, Allowed to extend no more than 33 percent of the steps, and necessary landings and decks, depth of a minimum yard or setback that is covered patios, enclosed courts, eaves, required along a front, side, or rear lot line, but not awnings, bay windows, fire escapes, closer than four feet to a side lot line chimneys, and steps Allowed to extend no more than 33 percent of the depth of a minimum yard or setback that is Climate controlled vestibule to prevent heat required along a front, side, or rear lot line, but no loss when entering or exiting a primary closer than 4 feet to a side lot line, and not to structure extend along more than 33 percent of the façade on which it is located Allowed up to 18 inches in any minimum side or rear yard or setback but not closer than 10 feet to Uncovered terraces, patios, and other any front lot line. uncovered paved areas such as stoops Customary yard accessories, ornaments, and Allowed in any yard or setback area. Shall not furniture, such as freestanding flag poles, exceed accessory structure height restriction of statues, fountains, swings, picnic benches, the district. lawn tables, chairs, and seats Allowed in the minimum front and street side Signs and gasoline pump islands yards Appurtenant structures that do not generate Allowed in any required yard or setback along a noise, such as submerged pumps, television side or rear lot line, but only bus shelters are and radio antennas, satellite dishes, permitted to extend closer than three feet to any underground fallout and blast shelters, bus side lot line shelters on private property, or clothes lines Fence, wall, column, pier, post or any similar type of structure, or any combination of such Allowed in any required yard or setback structures Appurtenant structures that may generate Allowed in any front, side, or rear setback, but not noise, such as air conditioning units, air closer than four feet to any property line exchangers, or heating units located at grade Shall not be located in a required yard or setback Private easement areas providing access for abutting a residential side lot line, and shall cross lots with no frontage or where multiple required front yards at right angles to the longest dimension of the required yard unless part of an buildings are located on one lot approved off-street parking area Allowed in any Agricultural and Residential Equipment for a Geothermal Energy System, District to project into the side or rear yard up to Ground-Mounted Solar Collector, and five feet but not closer than five feet to any Ground-Mounted Wind Energy Conversion property line. See Section 60.300.020F.2 and System Section 60.300.020F.3 for applicable use-specific standards Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 154 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030A: Purpose Table 400.02-4 Authorized Exceptions to Setback Requirements Type of Exception Extent of Exception Wall projections required by Section Allowed in any front, side, and/or rear setback 60.400.070F, Building Design Garages, carports, recreational vehicle Allowed within required setbacks and allowed to shelters or storage facilities for abutting lots, attach across lot lines, provided (1) they do not when both lots are in common ownership constitute impediments to visibility at intersections of streets or the intersections of driveways with streets, and (2) they do not increase fire hazards, and (3) the applicant records a deed restriction on both lots prohibiting the sale of either lot independently of the other until the improvement is brought into compliance with required setbacks Section 60.400.030 S UBDIVISION S TANDARDS A. Purpose This Section 60.400.030 establishes standards to guide the design and review of proposed developments involving the layout of new lots and streets and the installation of new public facilities, or revisions to existing platted lot lines. The requirements of this Section 60.400.030 identify approvals that will be required to authorize any subdivision activity that is defined as a subdivision by statute or City ordinance. B. Applicability 1. This Section 60.400.030 shall apply to all subdivisions and land divisions located wholly or partially within the City unless exempted by another UDC provision. 2. In case of a conflict between these provisions and applicable provisions of state law, the provisions of this UDC shall be modified to the smallest degree necessary to comply with state law. C. Subdivision Name 1. The proposed name of a subdivision shall be approved by Staff and shall not use a word that is the same as, similar to, or pronounced the same as a word in the name of any other subdivision in the City except for the words “court,” “addition,” “place,” “heights,” “hills,” and similar words, unless the land platted is contiguous to and platted by the same applicant that platted the existing subdivision bearing the name, or the applicant has obtained the written consent of the party who platted the subdivision bearing that name, or Staff requires the use of the same name for purposes of clear identification. To bear the same name as an existing subdivision, the new subdivision must be contiguous. 2. Subdivision names and numbering shall be meet the requirements in Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 9-1. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 155 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030D: Vertical Subdivision D. Vertical Subdivision 1. Purpose The vertical subdivision is intended to allow a lot to be split into new lots that are defined by complex multi-dimensional volumes. 2. Applicability An applicant may request a Vertical Subdivision as part of Final Plat. 3. Approval Criteria In the consideration of a Vertical Subdivision, City Council must consider the demand for adequate public facilities generated by subsequent phases of the development and must require a development agreement as to the design and construction of adequate on-site or off-site public or private facility improvements required to serve the subsequent phases. 4. Complex Vertical Subdivision a. Prior to the submittal of a Vertical Subdivision application, the developer must have first obtained approval of a Site Development Plan; a Conditional Use Permit; or an Incentive Development in accordance with the applicable procedures in Chapter 60.500, Procedures and Administration. b. Prior to submittal of a Vertical Subdivision application, the developer must have obtained approval from the Community Development Department and City Fire Department. c. All Vertical Subdivisions filed with the Community Development Director shall be subject to the Final Plat procedure and subject to all other applicable requirements in this UDC. E. Adequate Public Facilities 1. Purpose This Section 60.400.030D establishes standards for required infrastructure improvements associated with any subdivision or resubdivision. To be adequate, facilities must be appropriate in type, availability, and capacity. 2. Public Facilities a. In a proposed subdivision, the required public facilities include, but are not limited to, parkland, boulevard trees, streets, sidewalks, public sanitary sewer and water extensions, storm water management facilities, soil erosion and sedimentation control, and monumentation. Other items that are necessary or material to the project, such as school sites, may be identified during the development approval process. b. An applicant may seek to stage or phase development to link the timing of development with the adequacy of public facilities. However, City Council shall consider the demand for adequate public facilities generated by subsequent phases Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 156 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030E: Adequate Public Facilities of the development and must require a development agreement as to the design and construction of on-site or off-site public or private facility improvements to serve those subsequent phases. c. No subdivision or resubdivision may be approved unless the public facilities in existence or to be constructed pursuant to an executed development agreement are adequate to handle the demand on those public facilities generated by the development. 3. Use of Private Individual wells and Sewage Treatment Systems a. Public facilities and utilities shall be installed according to the standards adopted by the City or the agency providing the facility or utility. The use of private on-site sewage treatment systems or private water supply to serve any new development or the use of new or replacement on-site sewage treatment systems or private water supply to serve existing development shall not be permitted unless: 1) City Council has determined that public utilities will not be reasonably available and private utilities will not impair the ability to extend services in the future; and 2) The responsible Olmsted County Staff as identified in the Olmsted County Environmental Services Administrative Ordinance finds that proposed geologic and soil conditions and lot sizes are adequate to support the proposed use of private utilities. b. There shall be adequate area to relocate any drain field in the case of a system failure for any lot authorized for on-site sewage treatment. c. City Engineer approval shall be required for all planned work involving the use of public facilities or public right-of-way. d. City Engineer approval shall be required for all requests to connect private facilities to public facilities. 4. Funding of Required Improvements Required improvements reasonably related to the development shall be installed at the sole expense of the applicant. Assessment of costs to subsequent users or payment of costs by the City may be permitted as part of a development agreement approved by City Council. 5. Guarantees for Improvements a. Bonds, letters of credits or surety deposits shall be required in the amount necessary to cover the cost of installation, unless waived prior to commencing activity involving the installation of public improvements as part of a development agreement approved by City Council. b. Any unexpended portion of a Guarantee shall be returned to the applicant upon satisfactory completion of the public improvements. c. The Community Development Director and Parks and Recreation Director will waive the requirement for a cash escrow, surety bond, or letter of credit related to Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 157 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030E: Adequate Public Facilities Boulevard Trees provided that the City and the developer have entered into a Boulevard Trees Green Facilities Agreement that includes a private covenant providing for boulevard tree planting, the proposed planting meets the standards of Section 60.400.030I, Boulevard Trees and the agreement has been recorded, and where provision is made to assess for any unpaid costs for assessments in accordance with Section 60.400.030DE. 6. Timing of Grading and Clearance Land clearance prior to development of a parcel is prohibited. The owner of an undeveloped tract may remove not more than 10 percent of the trees or other vegetation on a site for the purpose of providing access for site survey and evaluation. This Section precludes unauthorized land clearance and timber removal and is not intended to interfere with the normal management of landscaping. Except as provided in this Section, no grading, removal of trees or other vegetation, land filling, construction of improvements, or other material change shall commence on the subject property without written approval of the City Engineer until the applicant has: a. Received the approval of the Construction Plans and all necessary permits from the Community Development Director and City Engineer; b. Entered into a development agreement with the City or otherwise arranged for completion of all required improvements; or c. Received approval of a Grading Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060IG.4.f Grading Permit 7. Maintenance a. Maintenance of newly installed public facilities shall remain with the applicant for a period of two years from final inspection or as otherwise defined in an owner contract or development agreement, except that, for boulevard trees, the period shall be one year. b. Following the expiration of the required maintenance period, the City shall assume responsibility for maintenance and upkeep of public facilities. 8. Dedications Required a. Development plans, construction plans, land subdivisions, and Site Development Plans shall identify needed right-of-way or easement locations necessary for the provision of utilities, drainage, shoreland and vehicular or pedestrian circulation within the development and connecting to adjacent development that meet specified levels of service called for in adopted City plans and regulations. b. When a land or easement dedication is a condition of subdivision approval, the approval must provide easements over natural drainage or ponding areas for management of stormwater and significant wetlands. c. Easements and/or deeds shall be granted, and rights-of-way dedicated to the public by the applicant as part of the development approval process or through separate instrument, which shall be in a form approved by the City Attorney. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 158 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030E: Adequate Public Facilities 9. Cost Sharing The City Engineer shall advise City Council regarding costs and right-of-way widths for major streets. The applicant shall provide rights-of-way in accordance with the adopted Long Range Transportation Plan, Official Zoning Map, and other applicable standards. 10. Modification of Construction Plans All installations of improvements and all construction shall conform to the approved construction plans. If the applicant chooses to make minor modifications in design and/or specifications during construction, such changes shall be made at the applicant's own risk, but only with the written approval of the City Engineer. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to notify the City Engineer in advance of any changes to be made from the approved drawings. If actual construction work deviates from that shown on the approved construction plans and such deviation was not approved in advance by the City Engineer, the applicant may be required to correct the installed improvements to conform to the approved construction plans. In addition, the City may take such other actions deemed necessary including, but not limited to, revocation of permits already issued and/or withholding of future approvals and permits. 11. Record Drawings Record drawings shall be consistent with the engineer’s standards adopted by Public Works in conjunction with the development of subdivisions. 12. Inspection and Acceptance of Improvements a. All improvements required by these regulations shall be inspected by the City Engineer, except as agreed to pursuant to an owner contract or development improvement agreement. Improvements made under the jurisdiction of other public agencies, shall be inspected by engineers or inspectors of such agencies. Where inspections are made by other agencies, the applicant shall provide the City Engineer with written reports of each final inspection. b. It shall be the responsibility of the applicant to notify the City Engineer of the commencement of construction of improvements 24 hours prior before construction begins. Inspections shall be required at each of the following stages of construction or as otherwise determined through and owner contract or development improvement agreement: 1) Site grading/erosion control completion; 2) Underground utility installation; 3) Subgrade preparation prior to aggregate base installation; 4) Aggregate base compaction; 5) Concrete curb and gutter installation; 6) Bituminous binder placing; and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 159 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030E: Adequate Public Facilities 7) Final surfacing prior to seal coat. c. Installation and construction of improvements shall be consistent with the engineering standards adopted by Public Works. d. Approval of the installation and construction of improvements by the City Engineer shall constitute acceptance by the City of the improvement for dedication purposes. e. Except for the removal of snow from substantially completed streets, the City shall not have any responsibility with respect to any street, or other improvement, notwithstanding the use of the same by the public, unless the street or other improvements shall have been accepted. f. When improvements have been constructed in accordance with the requirements and conditions of these regulations and the specifications of the City, and the applicant has submitted as-built reproducible drawings or electronic files to the City Engineer, the City Engineer shall accept the improvements for maintenance by the City, unless another entity has agreed in writing to be responsible for such maintenance, and the City has approved in writing that agreement or arrangement in writing. 13. Conditions on Approval a. During consideration of subdivision application, the City may consider alternative potential conditions, and no discussion of potential conditions shall be deemed an attempt or intent to impose any condition that would violate the state or federal constitutions, statutes, or regulations. Discussions of potential conditions to mitigate the impacts of a development do not reflect actions by the City unless and until the City takes formal action to attach that condition to a subdivision approval. b. All conditions imposed by the City as a part of the approval process shall be reasonably related to the anticipated impacts of the proposed subdivision or land use and to the purposes of this UDC. c. Where mitigation of the impacts of a proposed subdivision requires an applicant to dedicate land or pay money to a public entity in an amount that is not calculated according to a formula applicable to a broad class of applicants, any dedication or payment imposed shall include an individualized determination and shall be roughly proportional in nature and extent to the anticipated impacts of the proposed development, as shown through an individualized determination of impacts. 14. Drainage Easements Required Drainage easements needed for stormwater management as indicated on an approved drainage or grading plan shall be provided. The document Engineering Standards for Public Works in Conjunction with the Development of Subdivisions, Commercial, and Industrial Property, available from the Public Works Director, should be consulted for current design standards adopted by the City. 15. Utility Easements Required The following standards apply to public utility easements in all zoning districts. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 160 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030F: Access and Connectivity a. Public utility easements as required by the various public utilities shall be provided. b. Except in the MX-T and MX-D Districts, public utility easements adjacent to public rights-of-way and private streets shall measure a minimum of ten feet in width, unless a deviation requiring a greater or lesser width is approved by the Community Development Director in consultation with Rochester Public Utilities (RPU) and Public Works. c. In the MX-T and MX-D districts, public utility easements adjacent to public rights-of- way and private streets, shall measure a minimum of five feet in width, unless a deviation requiring a greater or lesser width is approved by the Community Development Director in consultation with Rochester Public Utilities (RPU) and Public Works. When the development provides private utilities within the building, consultation with individual utility companies may be required. d. Transformer location shall be identified and approved by RPU on site plans, where applicable, and may require a width that exceeds the otherwise minimum easement width for the remainder of the site. e. Vegetation located on utility easements shall be placed so that it does not interfere with the free movement of service vehicles, or placement and operation of utility facilities. Ground cover, grass, and native grasses, or hedges under three feet in height may be installed in or permitted to remain in the public utility easement. f. Plantings in utility easements shall be placed at the risk of the property owner, and shall not interfere with reasonable access to the utility facility. Utility companies will not replace plantings or landscaping removed or damaged during work within the easement area. g. Non-utility structures, above or below ground, shall not be placed within utility easements. h. Temporary signs in compliance with MN statute 211B.045, are permitted within utility easements at the risk of the property owner. i. Above ground pedestrian amenities that do not require footings may be installed at the risk of the property owner, upon obtaining a revocable permit and shall not interfere with reasonable access to the utility facility. F. Access and Connectivity All development subject to this Section 60.400.030 shall comply with all applicable standards in Section 60.400.040, Access and Connectivity. G. Lot Design Standards 1. Corner Lots Side lot lines of lots abutting a public or private right-of-way should, to the maximum extent practical, run at right angles to the right-of-way line, or in the case of a cul-de- sac or curvilinear street rights-of-way radial to the curve. 2. Through Lots Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 161 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030G: Lot Design Standards Through lots shall be avoided, except where dictated by topographical conditions or where necessitated by a lot layout that restricts access to abutting collector, arterial, expressway, or freeway streets. 3. Adequate Frontage Required a. Frontage requirements for access purposes need to comply with the requirements of Section 60.400.040D and may, at the discretion of the City, be met through provision of direct access or the use of joint access agreements. b. A limited number of flag lots and lots with no frontage may be authorized to enable the more efficient use of irregularly shaped parcels of land, or where the integrated nature of multiple buildings on a site dictates the need for such lots. c. In the case of lots with no frontage, access for vehicles, utilities, and emergency vehicles shall be insured through the use of common area agreements or private easements available for use by all governmental and quasi-governmental vehicles. 4. Individual Requirements for Each Type of Lot a. Full Frontage Lots 1) Lot frontage must be the same as the required minimum lot width for the district where the lot the is located, as stated in Section 60.400.020, Dimensional Standards unless an exception in this UDC applies. 2) Full frontage lots shall provide adequate spacing of access points for the type(s) of street(s) on which they have frontage. b. Cul-de-Sac Lots Cul-de-sac lots shall: 1) Be at least 50 percent of the minimum required width in the district where they are located, but not less than 25 feet; and 2) Meet the minimum required lot width at the building line (if one is specified). c. Flag Lots 1) Flag lots and other irregularly shaped lots are discouraged in new and existing subdivisions. 2) When there is no reasonable alternative, flag lots will be approved if the following standards are met. (a) The length of the flagpole portion of the lot shall not exceed 300 feet and shall comply with all other standards and measurements of this UDC. (b) A maximum of one lot or five percent of the lots in a development, whichever is greater, may be flag lots. There is no limitation on the number or percentage of lots in a development in the case of redevelopment or infill development of lots developed initially in reliance upon individual sewage treatment and having a lot size of 0.75 acres or greater. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 162 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030H: Roadway and Subdivision Design Standards (c) In the case of flag lots developed by subdivision in reliance upon individual sewage treatment, all lots must be covered by a utility connection agreement providing for municipal services. H. Roadway and Subdivision Design Standards 1. The requirements of this Section 60.400.030H shall be used in conjunction with the City’s adopted engineering standards for public works in conjunction with the development of subdivisions to guide the design of roadway improvements within the City. 2. Streets shall be graded to the full width of the right-of-way in accordance with grades submitted to and approved by the City Engineer. 3. All street grading and gravel base construction shall comply with approved plans. 4. Where necessary, street grading shall be completed prior to the installation of applicable underground utilities, and gravel base construction undertaken after the installation of the utilities. 5. Following the City Engineer’s approval of street grading and utility installation, streets shall be surfaced and provided with adequate stormwater facilities consistent with the engineering standards adopted by the City applicable to the development of subdivisions. I. Boulevard Trees All development subject to this Section 60.400.030 shall comply with all applicable standards in Section 60.400.060A, Boulevard Trees. J. Private Roadways 1. Private roadways or streets developed as part of a subdivision shall be of adequate width to serve anticipated traffic and proposed parking conditions and shall be designed for the safe operation of vehicles on the roadway. 2. The applicant for any subdivision including private streets shall be required to: a. Notify future property owners through deed restrictions and covenants which streets in the development are private streets. The City will not accept the dedication of any private street until it is brought into conformance with City street standards at the expense of property owners. b. Ensure in writing the maintenance and repair of all private streets by an entity other than the City, through the use of documents approved as to form and content by the City. c. Install, at its own expense, traffic signs and street signs that comply with applicable City requirements at all intersections along each private street and shall ensure in writing the maintenance and repair of those signs through the use of documents approved as to form and content by the City. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 163 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030K: Street Classification 3. The applicant or subsequent owners of the roadway are responsible for installation and maintenance, including replacement of the roadway name signs. 4. The width of a private roadway shall comply with the City’s adopted Private Roadway Standards and Fire Access Minimum Standards. 5. Private roadways shall comply with the minimum Connectivity Index standards as described in Section 60.400.040C.4. K. Street Classification 1. Approval Classification of an existing or proposed street not already identified on the Long Range Transportation Plan, for the purpose of determining the appropriate design of a roadway or development, or for the purpose of determining the appropriateness of a location for a proposed use, shall be done by the Community Development Director in consultation with the City Engineer. 2. Classification Factors a. In determining the classification of a street, factors to be considered include the following existing or proposed features: 1) Facility geometrics, including the number and width of traffic lanes, turning lanes, and parking lanes; 2) Access conditions, including any restrictions on access, the spacing of private accesses, and average lot frontages; 3) Traffic characteristics, including design volume, percentage of trucks, design speed, percentage of turning movements, origin-destination characteristics of the traffic, and peak hour characteristics of traffic; and 4) Adjacent land uses. b. Using this information in conjunction with the Long Range Transportation Plan Map and the narrative descriptions for each roadway classification provided in the Long Range Transportation Plan Document, the Community Development Director shall determine which of the Long Range Transportation Plan designations apply to the street under consideration. L. Quadrant Street System The numerical quadrant system is hereby adopted as the primary basis for identifying all public roadways within the City, including without limitation public roadways created by plat, deed, easement, or user. Names may be used when the roadway alignment does not permit the use of numbers. In that case, the Community Development Director or their authorized representative must approve the names in accordance with Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 20-16. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 164 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030M: Parkland Dedication 1. City Divided into Quadrants a. For the purposes of roadway identification and unique E911 addresses, the City is divided into four quadrants of NW, SW, SE, and NE. Any roadway that forms the dividing line between quadrants will be identified as N, S, E, or W. b. The dividing line separating east from west extends north along the centerline of Highway 63, from its intersection with the southernmost city limits, to a point at the intersection of U.S. 63 and East River Road N.E., thence due west to the imaginary intersection with the Zumbro River, thence north along the centerline of the Zumbro River, to the northern most city limits. c. The dividing line separating north from south extends east from the intersection of Country Club Road West with the western most city limits, then east along Country Club Road West (County Road 34) to its intersection with Wimbledon Hills Drive S.W. Then north to the center of Section 33, Cascade Township. Then easterly along the quarter section line to the section line. Then southeasterly to the western end of West Center Street. Then east along West Center Street to East Center Street and thth its intersection with 19 Avenue S.E., thence south along 19 Avenue S.E., to an intersection with College View Road East (County Road 9), thence east along College View Road East to an intersection with the eastern most city limits. 2. Administration The Olmsted County Public Works Director shall assign street names consistent with the Street Naming Definitions in Chapter 60.600, Definitions. M. Parkland Dedication 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.030M is to: a. Ensure that lands suitable for economical neighborhood park development are identified and preserved for public use as a park during the land subdivision and development process in order to compensate for the impact of the development process and not developed for other purposes; b. Ensure that the impact of development on the need for parkland created by that development is compensated for in order to serve the recreational needs of future local residents; c. Maintain a high quality of life in the City; d. Retain adequate open space land, protect wildlife habitats, and cleanse the air and stormwater runoff; and e. Exercise the authority granted pursuant to Minn. Stat. Ch. 462.358(2)(b) require that a reasonable portion of any proposed subdivision of lands within the City be dedicated to the public or preserved as neighborhood parks, playgrounds, or open space; or that a reasonable cash payment be received from the applicant in lieu thereof in order to facilitate development of similar facilities. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 165 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030M: Parkland Dedication 2. Applicability This Section 60.400.030M applies to each application for a subdivision or resubdivision that will increase demands on the City’s park system. a. This Section 60.400.030M shall only require the dedication of parkland or payment of cash-in-lieu of parkland dedication to the extent the increased demands on the City’s park system caused by the proposed subdivision or resubdivision has not been previously addressed in a development agreement approved by the City. b. In case of a conflict between the provisions of this Section 60.400.030M and any provision of state or federal law, the provisions of this Section shall be modified to the smallest degree necessary to comply with state or federal law. 3. General Requirements a. Reservation of Future Parkland 1) At the discretion of the City Council, upon recommendation by the Director of the Parks and Recreation Department, an applicant may dedicate more land than would be required by the formulas established by this Section 60.400.030M and receive a written credit against future parkland dedication requirements. 2) Where an applicant or property owner dedicates land against future requirements, the development that is relieved of all or part of its mandatory parkland dedication requirement must be in the same quadrant of the City as where the credit lands are dedicated. 3) The credit shall attach to the relieved land and remain with the relieved land, regardless of change in ownership of all or part of that land. b. Development Changes after Plat Approval In the event an applicant deviates from the approved Major Land Subdivision in a final plat, or replats property already platted, in ways that increase the projected population over the earlier population projections, the owner or applicant shall be obligated to provide additional parkland or pay a cash-in-lieu equivalent to compensate for the increased demands on the City’s park system before issuance of a building or occupancy permit. c. Phasing 1) Whenever an applicant applies for approval of a final plat that contains only a portion of the land encompassed in the approved Major Land Subdivision or an applicant proposes to complete only a portion of the overall development on a previously platted lot(s), the applicant shall dedicate parkland or make a cash- in-lieu equivalent for each phase of the subdivision or portion of the development as it receives development approval. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 166 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030M: Parkland Dedication 2) If the land dedication required for one phase of a subdivision or part of a development is part of a single proposed larger park area or facility that is also intended to serve later phases of a subdivision or part of a development, the entire park area shall be dedicated concurrent with the first phase of the subdivision or part of the development, and a credit shall be provided to the applicant for land dedications otherwise required for later phases of the subdivision or parts of the development. 3) As an alternative to Subsection 2), the City will approve a development agreement allowing the applicant to dedicate an amount of land that is proportionate to the expected population or occupancy in a phase of a subdivision or part of a development with the approval of that phase or part of the development, if the City determines that partial dedication of a single park area or facility will not create adverse impacts on the construction or operation of the City’s park system. The terms of any such development agreement shall supersede any inconsistent provisions of this UDC related to the timing of required parkland dedications. d. Quantity and Amount of Land Required to be Dedicated When the Director of Parks and Recreation determines that a parkland dedication is required due to the impact of the proposed development on the need for parkland, applications for Household Living uses and Group Living uses shall provide parkland at a rate of eight acres per 1,000 projected residents (which is: 0.008 multiplied by the number of persons per dwelling unit multiplied by the number of dwelling units allowed in the subdivision) based on the anticipated number of persons living in each residential density range, as shown in Table 400.03-1. In the case of already platted land, the required dedication will be measured by the number of additional residents created by the proposed development. The amounts in the table below are presumed to be in proportion to the need for parkland created by development, but may be amended by the City Council upon determination of the Director of Parks and Recreation that such measures do not accurately reflect the need for parkland created by the proposed development. Table 400.03-1 Parkland Dedication Ratio Density in Dwelling Units per Gross Estimated Number of Persons per Acre of Residential Land Area Dwelling Unit 0 to 5.99 du/ac 3.05 6 to 11.99 du/ac 2.22 Over 12 du/ac 1.98 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 167 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030M: Parkland Dedication e. Minimum Standards of Land Dedicated At least 50 percent of the gross area of the land required to be dedicated pursuant to Section 60.400.030M.3.d shall: 1) Have a natural slope of four percent or less; 2) Be largely clear of forest vegetation; 3) Not be located in an existing watercourse, a 100-year floodway, drainage easement, or water ponding area; and 4) Have a cover of six inches or more of topsoil suitable for the seeding and cultivation of grass. f. Dedication of Non-Buildable Land 1) If land is proposed to be dedicated and is considered non-buildable (i.e., steep slopes, wetlands, drainage ways, high rock, high water table, limited or no access) the applicant may dedicate the property to the City to meet all or a portion of the required parkland dedication, subject to this Section 60.400.030M,3,f. 2) The Director of Parks and Recreation will review the dedication and give a recommendation as to whether the City should accept the dedication. If the City chooses to accept the dedication of the non-buildable land, credit against required parkland dedication will be awarded at a rate of 20 percent of the buildable land equivalent. 3) The following example lays out the dedication scenario: development required land dedication is 10 acres. Currently five acres has slopes of four percent or less. Two acres can be made to meet the four percent slopes or less. The remaining three acres of dedication may be met through the use of non- buildable land. However, to meet the three-acre requirement the owner would need to dedicate 15 acres of non-buildable property (15 acres X 20% = 3 acres of equivalent buildable acres). g. Forbidden Activities Following the dedication of lands, no person shall remove trees, vegetation, or topsoil from the dedicated land, nor shall the dedicated lands be used for the purpose of stockpiling of earth or construction material, or disposal of construction debris, without the written consent of the Director of Parks and Recreation. 4. Marketability of Title a. General Requirements 1) Prior to dedication, the applicant shall deliver to the City for examination an up- to-date abstract of title or registered property certificate for examination, or a title opinion by a person licensed to practice law in Minnesota. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 168 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030M: Parkland Dedication 2) If the examination of title by the City, or the title opinion, indicates that title is not marketable, no subdivision of the land shall occur until the applicant shall take those steps needed to permit marketable title, subject to the exceptions set forth in Section 60.400.030M.4.b, to be conveyed to the City by dedication upon the lands’ subdivision or by a subsequent separate conveyance. b. Exceptions The title to lands proposed to be subdivided shall not be deemed unmarketable by virtue of the fact that a mortgage or other equitable interest in the lands is held by a person other than the applicant; or that the lands are subject to the lien of a special assessment provided that the applicant removes any such equitable interest or mortgage prior to or simultaneously with the later transfer of title to the City. c. Special Assessments and Real Estate Taxes The City shall be responsible for the payment of any special assessments levied on the lands dedicated, after the actual dedication has occurred. Payment of real estate taxes owing on the land dedicated in the year of dedication shall be prorated between the City and the person subdividing the property. 5. Cash Payment-in-lieu of Land Dedication a. The requirement of dedication imposed by Section 60.400.030M.3.d may be satisfied by a payment of cash by the applicant to the City or suitable provision in a development agreement entered into under Section 60.500.030E.8, Development Agreement, if in the judgment of the Parks and Recreation Director the quantity of land to be subdivided is of a size or configuration that dedication of a portion of that land: 1) Is not feasible or practical; 2) Will not create a parcel suitable for neighborhood park development or for usable open space or trail thoroughfares; or 3) The land is adjacent or readily accessible to already existing or planned public park and recreation facilities, or publicly maintained open space managed by the Parks and Recreation Department. b. Payment may include fees for land acquisition, preparation, and all other applicable purposes and uses. c. Payment shall be made prior to recording the Final Plat of the subdivision in an amount equivalent to the fair market value of land that would otherwise be required to be dedicated. d. Calculation of Cash Payment 1) The Director of the Parks and Recreation Department shall establish the fair market value per acre of the land proposed to be development or redeveloped, considering the value assigned to the proposed development land and similarly Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 169 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.030 Subdivision Standards Section 60.400.030M: Parkland Dedication situated land by the County Assessor at a time no later than the time of final approval. 2) The required payment shall be computed by multiplying the value per acre of land by the number of acres required to be dedicated. e. Funds Established 1) All payments collected pursuant to Section 60.400.030M.5 shall be placed in the appropriate neighborhood park acquisition and development fund established for the quadrant of the City where the lands subdivided are located and may only be disbursed for purposes consistent with the acquisition and development or improvement of neighborhood parks in that quadrant, as City Council may from time to time direct. 2) For purposes of administration of this Section 60.400.030M, the City shall be divided into four quadrants -- northwest, northeast, southeast, and southwest, that are defined as follows: (a) The northwest quadrant shall contain all the lands of the City lying north of nd the alignment of West Center Street extended to TH 52 and north of 2 Street south lying west of TH 52 to the westerly municipal limits, and west of Broadway Avenue. (b) The northeast quadrant shall contain all of the lands of the City lying east of Broadway Avenue, and north of the alignment of East Center Street, th extended to the intersection of 4 Street/County Road 9 then to the easterly municipal limits. (c) The southeast quadrant shall contain all of the lands of the City lying east of Broadway Avenue, and south of the alignment of East Center Street extended the intersection of 4th Street/County Road 9 then to the easterly municipal limits. (d) The southwest quadrant shall contain all those lands of the City not otherwise contained in the other quadrants. 6. Effective Date and Credits Any parkland dedication credits created and previously authorized by the Parks and Recreation Director between January 1, 1988 and January 1, 2019 remain in effect until used. Credits proposed to be created after January 1, 2019 shall be formally authorized by the Board of Park Commissioners and may only be approved in connection with dedications of lands meeting the standards set forth in this UDC for park purposes or in return for conveyance of such lands to the City at a price less than fair market value. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 170 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040A: Purpose Section 60.400.040 A CCESS AND C ONNECTIVITY A. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.040 is to develop safe and adequate vehicular access while reducing vehicle miles traveled and related greenhouse gas emissions by integrating sidewalks and bicycle routes in new development and redevelopment, and by providing for shorter and more direct routes between many destinations. B. Applicability All new development must comply with the standards in this Section 60.400.040 unless exempted by another provision of this UDC. Applications involving the subdivision or resubdivision of land shall comply with the standards in Section 60.400.040C; applications for development on existing platted lots shall comply with the standards in Section 60.400.040D. C. Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation 1. Purpose This Section 60.400.040C is intended to: a. Promote street and block patterns with a clear hierarchy of well-connected streets that distribute traffic over multiple streets and avoid traffic congestion on principal routes. b. Accommodate the safe, efficient, and convenient movement of vehicles, bicycles, and pedestrians through each development, and provide ample opportunities for linking adjacent neighborhoods, properties, and land uses. c. Provide multiple direct connections to and between local destinations such as parks, schools, and shopping. 2. Development Design Standards Additional requirements on site design standards can be found in Section 60.400.070, Site and Building Design. 3. Street Layout Standards a. Hazards 1) To the maximum extent practicable, streets shall be routed to avoid hazard areas such as floodways, cliffs, or ravines. 2) A secondary means of access may be required when the only means of access into a subdivision traverses a floodplain area. If required, the secondary access shall be elevated to remain passable during the 100-year storm. b. Limits on Access to Arterials, Expressways, and Freeways 1) Lots adjacent to arterial, expressway, or freeway streets shall access frontage roads, parallel streets, or service drives to eliminate the need for direct access. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 171 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation 2) Vehicular access restrictions shall be noted on final plat documents. c. Access to Public Water Bodies When a proposed development abuts a public body of water and the City’s adopted plans or policies support the need for public access to the water, the City may require that public access to the water body be provided subject to the requirements in Section 60.400.030E.13. When required, the right-of-way width of the access shall be at least 66 feet in width to accommodate access by pedestrians, bicycles, cars, and emergency vehicles. d. Street Hierarchy Streets shall be designed to create a hierarchy of streets according to the following standards. The City Engineer may recommend design modifications where such modifications are consistent with an adopted access management plan or necessary by reason of natural features or existing development, and do not create safety hazards or increased maintenance costs. 1) Residential local streets shall intersect with higher order streets using designs and alignment that discourage through traffic. 2) Local streets shall intersect with a higher order street to prevent local street traffic from exceeding 1,000 average daily trips. 3) Local collector streets shall intersect with two streets of equal or higher classification. 4) Alleys shall intersect with local collector or local streets. 5) Frontage roads shall be designed so that stacking areas of sufficient depth are provided at primary intersections. When located along collectors, such primary intersections should be at least 300 feet apart, while on higher order streets the separation shall be as recommended by the City Engineer. 6) The City may require a street to be of a Primary Collector level design where the anticipated average daily trips will exceed 3,000 trips, in order to collect and distribute traffic to the major street system identified on the Long Range Transportation Plan. 7) Intervals between access points can be reduced as recommended by the governing Road Authority. When access to an arterial or expressway is permitted, the City may require that the property provide a public street or other public access to adjoining lands. 8) Reserve strips (i.e., a narrow parcel between a road and another lot) and cul- de-sac streets that interfere with street connections needed to serve existing or planned development are prohibited. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 172 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation 9) Cul-de-sac, circle, and lane streets serving single-family or duplex residential development shall be designed to serve development that is projected to generate no more than 300 average daily trips. 10) Secondary access shall be required for any residential development that is projected to generate more than 500 average daily trips. The need for secondary access for Non-Residential development fronting on a collector or higher order street shall be determined based on a Traffic Impact Study. e. Street Extensions 1) Where necessary to give access or to permit the reasonable future subdivision of adjacent land, rights-of-way, and improvements shall be extended to the boundary of the development. 2) Construction of a temporary turnaround shall be required where the dead end exceeds 150 feet in length. 3) The platting of partial width rights-of-way shall be prohibited except where the remainder of the necessary right-of-way has already been platted, dedicated, or established by other means. f. Cul-de-Sacs 1) Cul-de-Sacs must connect to the closest local or collector street, to adjacent cul-de-sacs, and to any adjacent public open space, Public Park, or School via a 15-foot pedestrian connector easement or right-of-way that includes a sidewalk or multi-use trail, unless deemed impracticable by the Community Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 173 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation Development Director. The pedestrian easement or right-of-way shall be indicated on the subdivision plat, and interior side yard setbacks applicable to the district where the cul-de-sac is located shall apply to the lots abutting the easement or right-of-way. 2) Any block exceeding 600 feet in length must provide a public pedestrian connection to maintain connectivity between and through subdivisions, except where unique topographical conditions make this connection infeasible. g. Alleys 1) Alleys may be used to reduce the need for individual site access to collectors, arterials, and expressways, or to reduce the need for individual driveway access points onto local streets. 2) Blocks platted with alleys shall be platted to allow alley access to required vehicle parking areas, and shall not permit vehicle access to parking areas through front or side lot lines. 3) Where alleys are platted: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 174 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation (a) In Residential districts alleys shall be a minimum in 16 feet in width (b) In Mixed Use and Industrial Districts alleys shall be a minimum of 18 feet in width, unless a minimum of 20 feet is required for fire equipment access. 4. Connectivity Index a. General Requirement The roadway connectivity shall meet a minimum ratio as decided by the number of lots on a development, excluding outlots. Additional pedestrian links shall be provided to increase the overall connectivity index to the minimum required connectivity ratio, should the development fail to meet the minimum using roadway connections. Proposed subdivisions must meet the access requirements as required by the Fire Code, Complete Streets Policy, and all Ordinances pertaining to access management and roadway placement. b. Minimum Required Connectivity Ratio 1) Developments with 10 lots or fewer shall be required to meet a connectivity ratio of 1.0 or greater. 2) Developments with more than 10, but fewer than 50 lots shall be required to meet a ratio of 1.2 or greater. 3) Developments with greater than 50, but fewer than 100 lots shall be required to meet a ratio of 1.4 or greater. 4) Developments with more than 100 lots shall be required to meet a ratio of 1.5 or greater. c. Connectivity Index Calculation 1) Arterial streets shall not be included in the calculation except when it is necessary to travel along the arterial street to reach any two nodes in the subdivision. 2) Exterior intersections outside of the development area shall not be counted as a node. However, streets extending into the development from these intersections shall be counted as links. 3) Stub streets that will eventually be connected from the subdivision to a future abutting subdivision or arterial or collector street shall not be counted as a node. The segment of the stub street shall be counted as a link. 4) Alleys shall not be counted as a link, and locations where an alley intersects with a street shall not be counted as a node. 5) Any location where a street creates a T-intersection with a street of any classification shall be considered a node. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 175 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation d. Allowed Adjustments 1) A subdivision may have a roadway connectivity index of less than the required minimum where specific features or constraints of the land being subdivided makes strict compliance impossible or impractical. Such features include the following: (a) Natural features such as bodies of water, severe elevation changes (12 percent slope or greater), Decorah Edge, hydric soils, or presence of wetlands. (b) Important cultural or archeological features such as historic landmarks or burial grounds. (c) Adjacent subdivisions that do not provide stub streets or other opportunities to connect to the proposed subdivision. (d) Situations where intersections, access management, and driveway separation requirements prevent the ability to provide additional connections to a public road. 2) If the applicant is unable to meet the required minimum ratio, then the applicant shall attach to the General Development Plan application an explanation of how the connectivity of the proposed development is hindered by the presence of any of the features listed above or similar features. The Community Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 176 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation Development Director shall recommend the application for approval or approval with conditions if it determines that the connectivity of the proposed subdivision cannot meet the minimum index requirements due to the site constraints. 3) The Community Development Director may recommend denial if it determines that the proposed development’s connectivity can be reasonably improved despite the presence of constraining features. 4) If requested by the City, cross-access and maintenance agreements associated with the interconnections shall be provided prior to or simultaneously with approval of the associated subdivision or development application. 5. Cross-Access between Adjacent Mixed Use and Non-Residential Uses All subdivisions or reconfigurations of contiguous platted lots for mixed use or non- residential development shall comply with the following standards. a. To the maximum extent practicable, each lot layout shall be designed to allow for cross-access to adjacent property to encourage shared parking and access points on public or private streets. This may be established by one or more of the following: 1) Connecting streets and drives; 2) Coordinating parking structure and parking lot entrances; 3) Common service/delivery areas; 4) Legally shared parking structures and parking lots; 5) Linkages between parking lots and parking structures; or 6) Providing shared driveways for two abutting lots from public rights-of-way to minimize driveway approaches. b. When cross-access is deemed impractical by the Community Development Director and/or City Engineer on the basis of topography, the presence of natural features, or vehicular or pedestrian safety, this requirement may be waived provided that appropriate bicycle and pedestrian connections are provided between adjacent Mixed Use or Non-Residential developments or land uses. 6. Pedestrian and Bicycle Connectivity and Circulation All subdivisions and reconfigurations of lots shall comply with the following standards. a. General Requirements All required sidewalks, bikeways, and multi-use trails shall comply with the standards in this Section 60.400.040C.6, unless a modification from these standards is permitted in pursuant to Section 60.500.070A. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 177 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation 1) Sidewalks Sidewalks shall be required along both sides of all arterial, collector, and local streets including cul-de-sacs, and within and along the frontage of all new development. 2) Bikeways Designated bicycle lanes are required in the design of all arterial and collector streets where low traffic speeds and volumes allow bicyclists and motorists to share the road safely. 3) Multi-Use Trails To the maximum extent practicable, multi-use trails, separated from automobile traffic, are required where indicated on an adopted City plan. The Community Development Director may modify requirements for sidewalks and/or bikeways in this Section 60.400.040C.6 in exchange for the development of multi-use trails that comply with the requirements of Section 60.400.040C.6.b.3). 4) Connection to Sidewalks, Bikeways, and Multi-Use Trails Each extension or connection of a public street or right-of-way to an abutting property, street, or right-of-way shall include the extension or connection of associated bikeways, sidewalks, and multi-use trails. b. Pedestrian and Bicycle Connectivity Design Standards 1) Standards for Sidewalks (a) Sidewalks shall be constructed to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act, AASHTO requirements, and all applicable adopted City standards including the standards in this Section 60.400.040C.6.b. (b) Sidewalks shall be constructed of durable, smooth, and skid resistant material approved by the City and a minimum width of five feet. (c) External sidewalks shall be located a minimum of one foot inside the public right-of-way or within a pedestrian easement along all abutting street frontages. (d) Internal sidewalks shall be provided that link abutting streets to primary entrances of primary buildings on the site, link separate facilities within the site to each other, and provide access to adjoining transit stops. Internal sidewalks shall not be required for lots containing primary Single-Family, Duplex, Triplex, or Fourplex Dwelling uses. (e) Sidewalks shall have a minimum separation of five feet from the curb, or edge of pavement where no curb exists. In situations where the minimum separation cannot be achieved due to constraints such as limited public right- of-way, mature trees, or unsuitable topography, the sidewalk location may be designed to avoid the constraints, provided that a pedestrian easement is Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 178 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation established for any locations where the sidewalk is not within the public right- of-way, and that the minimum five-foot separation is maintained. (f) In situations where the sidewalk must be located within a pedestrian easement on private property, the portions of the sidewalk within the pedestrian easement shall not count toward the maximum impervious surface coverage for the property. (g) In situations where the City Engineer and/or the Director of the Community Development Director has determined that a pedestrian easement is not feasible due to right-of-way width constraints or site elevation constraints, the Director of the Community Development Director will approve the following design options: (i) A 10-foot-wide sidewalk with reduced vegetation plot width; or (ii) An integral sidewalk with a minimum six-inch curb and six-foot wide sidewalk. 2) Standards for Bikeways (a) Bikeways shall be constructed to comply with the City’s Active Transportation Master Plan, the National Association of Transportation Officials (NACTO) Urban Street and Bikeway Design guides, AASHTO Bicycle Facilities requirements, and all applicable adopted City standards. (b) Striped bikeways shall be located at the outer edge of the street or adjacent to the curb. (c) Street and driveway crossings shall minimize potential crossing hazards using colored pavement markings, raised pavement, signs, bollards, or other means to increase motorist awareness at conflict points, as determined necessary by the City Engineer. 3) Standards for Multi-Use Trails Multi-use trails shall: (a) Be a minimum of: (i) 12 feet in width if adjacent to a street or other public land; or (ii) 30 feet in trail width easement between the rear or side lot lines of a parcel; (b) Connect to the street system in a safe and convenient manner; (c) Be well-signed with destination and directional signing; (d) Be located and designed to minimize motor vehicle crossings to the maximum extent practicable. Significantly minimized. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 179 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040C: Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation c. Use of Sidewalks, Bikeways, and Multi-Use Trails 1) Sidewalks, Bikeways, and Multi-Use trails shall comply with the City’s adopted Public Works Design Requirements. 2) Vehicle parking, garbage containers, merchandise storage or display, utility boxes and poles, signs, trees, and other obstructions shall not encroach into the required minimum width of any required sidewalk, bikeway, and/or multi-use trail. 3) Sidewalks, bikeways, and multi-use trails required by this Section 60.400.040C.6 shall be maintained in usable condition throughout the year. d. Parkland Dedication Credits 1) Credits for parkland dedication may be granted for land that is voluntarily dedicated for multi-use trails or other trails if the Parks and Recreation Director determines that the use of that trail will reduce demand on the City’s park system. 2) Credits shall not be given for land that is dedicated for trails adjacent to roadways. 7. Consistency with Driveway Spacing Standards Land subdivisions and General Development Plans shall be designed to facilitate compliance with the site level driveway spacing standards in Section 60.400.040D and each of the following access design standards. a. Proposed subdivisions fronting on freeways or expressways shall be designed so as to have access available via a lower-level street. b. Where feasible, subdivisions shall be designed so that access to a development is not solely dependent on a roadway or driveway that intersects with an expressway as designated on the Long Range Transportation Plan. c. Where lots in a proposed subdivision front on an arterial street as designated on the Long Range Transportation Plan, options for designing access that meets the standards of this Section 60.400.040C include the potential use of cross access easements and the use of lower-level streets to provide secondary access. d. Vehicular ingress and egress restrictions along the frontage of arterial or higher-level streets may be imposed by requiring subdivision plats to dedicate to the proper Road Authority access control authority. 8. Documentation on Subdivision Plats or Master Plans Unless limited or prohibited by state law, the City may require that required connectivity and circulation, permitted access, and/or limitations on access be reflected on subdivision plats prior to recording. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 180 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity D. Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.040D is to balance the need for providing access to individual private properties with the need to preserve an adequate level of capacity on the streets providing access. 2. Relation to Subdivision Plats Site level driveways, access, and connectivity shall be consistent with those shown on approved subdivision plats and master plans where the property is located, unless a modification of those requirements is approved pursuant to Section 60.500.070BA, Major Modification. 3. Driveway Permit Required a. A driveway permit approved by the applicable Road Authority is required prior to the construction of any new or modified access point. b. Where a traffic study is required for any proposed development, no driveway permit shall be issued until the traffic study process has been completed. c. A new driveway permit will be required when any change to a non-residential use results in: 1) An increase of greater than 50 peak hour directional trips; 2) A 10 percent increase in average daily trips; or 3) Over 20 additional daily vehicle trips made by vehicles exceeding 30,000 pounds in gross vehicle weight. 4. Property Boundary Evaluation Changes in property boundaries or ownership do not create the right to obtain additional access that is inconsistent with the standards of this Section 60.400.040 and plans, policies, or regulations adopted by the City for access management. For the purposes of evaluating driveway permit requests, the boundary of a site is considered to be: a. All contiguous parcels under common or related ownership; b. All parcels included as part of a single development plan; c. Where the application is for the first development on a property involving the erection of a building, the lot where that building is to be located together with any adjacent lots or adjacent parcels on which lots may be created after the adoption date of this UDC; or d. The entirety of a Lot of Record prior to an application to divide that lot. 5. Access Spacing Standards a. The minimum spacing between adjacent access locations or a proposed access location and an adjacent street intersection shown in Table 400.04-1 shall apply to Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 181 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity the maximum extent practicable. Where the indicated spacing is met, there is a presumptive understanding that access will be permitted subject to satisfying the design objectives of Section 60.400.040D. Table 400.04-1 Access Spacing Standards Minimum Separation Minimum Separation Between Driveways and Road Classification \[1\] Between Driveways \[2\] Intersection Streets \[3\] Residential Local and Local Collector 8 feet 35 feet Streets (projected traffic <3,000 ADT) Other Local and Local Collector Streets, And One-Way Frontage Streets 60 feet 75 feet (projected traffic >3,000 ADT and <6,000 ADT) Collector and Frontage Roads (projected 125 feet 150 feet traffic >6,000 ADT) Arterial (projected traffic <15,000 ADT) 400 feet 480 feet Expressway and Arterial (project traffic 1,000 feet 1,200 feet >15,000 ADT) \[4\] NOTES \[1\]Roadway types refer to anticipated cross sections based on and defined by the Long Range Transportation Plan and Comprehensive Plan Street Classification Map. All traffic volumes refer to the functional classification and street design volumes. \[2\] Access separation between driveways shall be measured from edge to edge. \[3\] Access separation between a driveway and intersecting street shall be measured from the centerline of the driveway and the nearest point of curvature of the intersecting street. \[4\] May require installation of turn lanes. b. One Way Driveways The minimum separation between driveways may be reduced through the use of one-way driveways where the applicant can demonstrate that the one-way driveway provides a higher level of safety or improved traffic operations, as determined by the City Engineer. c. Interchange Management Areas Spacing of access within one-quarter mile of ramp junctions along the minor crossroad of any interchange area will be addressed on a case-by-case basis to ensure that any resulting access locations protect the safety and operational efficiency of the interchange area and do not compromise the functioning of the ramp operations. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 182 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity 6. Emergency Vehicle Access a. All developments that do not have frontage on a public street shall provide access for fire vehicles and emergency apparatus from a public street that complies with the adopted fire regulations pf the City. b. Except as described in Subsection c, fire lane and fire apparatus access road locations and construction and design standards shall comply with the Rochester Fire Code and all related standards adopted by the City. c. In lieu of meeting the standards in Subsection b above, an applicant may substitute alternative means (including but not limited to fire resistant roofs, fire separation walls, space separation, and automatic fire extinguishing systems) to mitigate risks from fires that the Fire Department determines will provide equal or better protection from fire risks than strict compliance with those standards in Subsection b. d. The City of Rochester shall not be liable for damage to underground utilities beneath fire access lanes caused by firefighting equipment. 7. Substandard Access Where access meeting the standards in this Section 60.400.040D cannot be provided, the City Engineer shall: a. First determine whether alternate access is available. Alternate access includes: 1) Access to another street that meets the standards of this UDC; and 2) Access provided jointly with an adjacent property that will meet the standards of this UDC. b. If the City Engineer determines that alternative access is available, the City Engineer may require that the alternative access be used, rather than modifying the minimum spacing standards. c. If the City Engineer determines that alternative access is not available, and that a modification of spacing standards will not create material risks to pedestrian, bicycle, or motor vehicle safety, the City Engineer will grant that modification and approve substandard access. d. If the City Engineer determines that no alternative access exists, and that no modification of spacing can meet the criteria in Subsection c above, the applicant may apply for a variance pursuant to Section 60.500.070CA, Variance. The Zoning Board of Appeals will approve a variance from minimum access spacing standards if the following criteria are met. 1) Conditions or circumstances exist that limit the strict application of this UDC, including the lack of a secondary access to another public street, the inability to use joint access, and the lack of engineering or construction solutions that can be applied to mitigate the condition; 2) The proposed access will not result in undue delay or congestion or be detrimental to the safety of motorists on the roadway; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 183 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity 3) Limiting access will create an exceptional and undue hardship on the applicant and that the permit issued will allow a reasonable use of the property; and 4) The applicant has mitigated the negative impacts of proposed substandard access to the maximum extent practicable. 8. Temporary Access An applicant shall not be denied a Zoning Certificate where the access requirements of this UDC cannot be met because adjoining segments of planned street are not yet constructed, in which case the Community Development Director will approve temporary access to another street, which right to access shall expire when the access required by this UDC becomes available for use. 9. Driveway Design Standards A driveway approach permit for any Non-Residential or Multifamily use may be approved if the City Engineer determines that the permit will allow reasonable access to the property and that all of the following standards have been met to the maximum extent practicable: a. A driveway approach permit for any Non-Residential or Multifamily use may be approved if the City Engineer determines that the permit will allow reasonable access to the property and that all of the following standards have been met to the maximum extent practicable: 1) Adequate corner clearance from any adjacent street intersections has been provided to preserve the functional integrity of the intersection, and spacing from adjacent driveways is sufficient to safely minimize conflicts between traffic entering and exiting adjacent driveways; 2) Adequate stopping sight distance and intersection sight distance is provided; 3) Auxiliary lanes are provided as needed to: (a) Minimize speed differentials with mainline highway traffic; (b) Prevent the encroachment of turning vehicles on mainline traffic; and (c) Prevent the queuing of inbound traffic from impacting mainline traffic. 4) Sufficient vehicular stacking distance between the curb line and the first point of conflict for traffic on the site is provided to prevent the spill back of traffic onto Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 184 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity public streets. This distance shall be a minimum of 25 feet, adequate to absorb the maximum peak period inbound traffic during the normal weekday; 5) Appropriate conflict reduction measures have been provided to safely manage inbound and outbound left turning traffic. Median design features and driveway channelization shall be used as appropriate to accomplish conflict reduction; 6) Access locations have been properly offset from driveways or street intersections located across the roadway in order to limit conflicts within the mainline or median of the street; 7) The design of the access satisfies standard geometric guidelines for turning radii, driveway slope and angle of entry, design speed, and width. The drainage design of the access should not interfere with the drainage system in the public right-of-way; 8) The access provides for the safe crossing of pedestrians, bicyclists, and persons with disabilities; 9) The installation of necessary traffic control devices for the safe and proper operation of the access complies with the requirements of the Manual of Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) and, in the case of traffic signals, are located so as to allow for proper signal coordination and adequate left turn storage needs at the access and nearby intersections; and 10) The access will not create conflicts with abutting roadway traffic. 11) Driveway approach will be a maximum of 25 feet depending on the turning movements from parking lot unless otherwise designated by the City Engineer for all non-residential and multifamily. 12) Driveway must be tapered to match driveway approach at the back of the walk per the Engineering Standards. 13) Edge of driveway approach at sidewalk line must be within the lot served. 14) All driveway approaches shall be constructed per Engineering Standards b. A driveway approach permit for any single-family detached, duplex, or triplex dwellings may be approved if the City Engineer determines that the permit will allow Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 185 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity reasonable access to the property and that all of the following standards have been met to the maximum extent practicable: 1) Driveway approach will be less than or equal to the width of the garage structure, with a maximum width of 32 feet, unless otherwise designated by the City Engineer. 2) Driveway approach with no garage structure will be a maximum of 20 feet not to exceed the width of the driveway pad for all single-family detached, duplex, and triplex dwellings. 3) Driveway must be tapered to match driveway approach at the back of the walk per the Engineering Standards. 4) Edge of Driveway approach at sidewalk line must be within the lot served. 5) All Driveway approaches shall be constructed per Engineering Standards. 6) Secondary driveway approach will only be allowed if the following conditions are met (a) Side street lot lines are at least 90 feet in length. (b) Located on a corner lot. (c) Driveway approach leads directly to a garage structure. 10. Conditions of Approval If necessary to ensure compliance with the approval criteria in Subsection 7 above, the City Engineer may require: a. That unobstructed and unencumbered access be provided from the approved access point to adjacent properties. Where such a requirement is made a condition of approval, the property owner shall record an easement with the deed allowing cross access to and from other designated properties to be served by the joint use driveway or access; b. That an access point that does not comply with one or more of the objectives in this Section 60.400.040C be designated as temporary access, and that when an alternative means of access is available that better meets the objectives of this Section 60.400.040C is available, the temporary access be eliminated, altered, or limited to certain turning movement; and/or Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 186 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity c. That the applicant be required to participate in the cost of design, installation, operation, and maintenance of the access construction and any associated traffic operation equipment required for the functioning of the access point. 11. Pedestrian Design and Accessibility The following standards apply to all new development and redevelopment in all districts except Household Living uses in structures with less than 8,000 square feet of gross floor area. a. Access and Walkways 1) Walkways shall be provided to connect each primary pedestrian entrance of a primary building to at least one public sidewalk along a property frontage, and shall be designed to provide convenient access to any bus or transit stops located within 1,000 feet of the lot boundary. 2) Walkways shall be located and aligned to connect areas or points of pedestrian origin and destination directly and continuously and shall not be located and aligned solely based on the outline of a parking lot configuration unless such a configuration allows for direct pedestrian access. 3) A sidewalk shall be provided immediately adjacent to the exterior wall of a new building greater than 100 feet in length when the wall is located next to a street or parking lot. This standard does not apply if the edge of the building is within 20 feet of a public sidewalk and the building entrance is connected to the public sidewalk by an on-site pedestrian walkway, or if the edge of the building is bordered by a perimeter of landscaping that does not exceed 30 feet in width and an on-site pedestrian walkway is constructed at the outer edge of the landscaped area. 4) Pedestrian walkways shall be designed to maximize pedestrian security, incorporating features such as lighting to illuminate crossings and/or create backlighting to make the pedestrian silhouette clearly visible from primary building entrances and/or public streets, and shall provide clear sight lines between two feet and six feet above grade from primary building entrances to public street frontages. 5) Walkways shall have a paved surface width of not less than five feet. The material and layout shall be continuous as the pedestrian walkway crosses driving lanes or aisles, with a break in continuity of the driveway paving and not in the pedestrian walkway paving. 6) Pedestrian and bike ramps shall be located at convenient and safe locations for persons with disabilities, bicyclists, and people pushing strollers or carts. The location of pedestrian and bike ramps shall avoid crossing or directing traffic through loading areas, drive-in lanes, and solid waste storage and collection areas, to the maximum extent practicable. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 187 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity b. Pedestrian Entrances Properties in the MX-T and MX-D districts shall also comply with the standards in Section 60.200.030L.3.d, Building Entrances. All other properties subject to this Section 60.400.040D.9 shall comply with the standards in this Section 60.400.040D.11.b. 1) One primary pedestrian entrance shall be provided for every façade facing a street. 2) To the maximum extent practicable, an entrance shall be provided every 30 feet on the ground floor. 3) To the maximum extent practicable and excluding building façades for ground floor residential uses, corner lots shall provide a primary entrance at the corner. 4) All ground level residential units along all street-facing sides of the building will be provided direct access entries from the building exterior. The Community Development Director will waive this requirement for some or all of the units, upon determination that an alternative design will provide a better pedestrian orientated space. 5) Traffic calming design shall be incorporated into the site design, which shall minimize potential hazards and conflict points in areas with highest concentrations of pedestrian traffic 6) The pedestrian entrance shall contain at least three of the following architectural details: (a) Pilasters or façade modules; (b) Mural; (c) Prominent building address, building name, and lighting; (d) Raised corniced entryway parapet; or (e) Buttress and arched entry. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 188 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity 7) The features installed to comply with Subsection 5 above may also be used to comply with the requirements of Section 60.400.070F.1.e, Roof-Mounted Equipment Screening. 8) Roof-mounted mechanical equipment shall be: (a) Integrated into the design of the structure so that the equipment is not visible from ground level on any street-facing property boundary; or (b) Screened by a parapet wall or similar feature that is an integral part of the building’s architectural design, with a parapet wall height sufficient to screen the mechanical equipment from all sides when viewed from ground-level on each street-facing property boundary. 9) To reduce visual impacts on abutting properties, the color of roof-mounted equipment shall be the same color as the roof or the same color as an adjacent wall. 10) Commercial Wireless Telecommunication Service equipment, Building- Mounted Solar Collectors, and other alternative energy systems are exempt Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 189 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.040 Access and Connectivity Section 60.400.040D: Site Level Driveways, Access, and Connectivity from any portion of these screening requirements that would impair their functions. c. Pedestrian Weather Protection Each development shall provide pedestrian weather protection in public spaces such as transit stops, building entries, along display windows, and over outdoor dining areas. Required pedestrian weather protection features shall comply with the following standards: 1) Weather protection at least five feet deep is required over all primary building, individual business, and individual residence entries. This may include a recessed entry, canopy, porch, marquee, or building overhang; 2) Canopies, awnings, or other similar weather protection features must not be higher than 15 feet above the ground elevation at the highest point or lower than eight feet at the lowest point. The street-side edge of the canopy or awning shall be at least eight feet above the walking surface; 3) Business centers must use a variety of weather protection features to emphasize individual storefronts and reduce the architectural scale of the building; and 4) West and south exposures with plazas, patios, entries, or pedestrian areas shall be designed with architectural and landscape shade elements. d. Pedestrian Oriented Space Each development shall provide a pedestrian-oriented space that includes: 1) Landscaping that does not act as a visual barrier between the primary building entrance and the pedestrian-oriented space; 2) At least one type of artwork, fountains, or other similar aesthetic feature; 3) Visual and pedestrian access (including access for persons with disabilities) into the site from a public or private street or internal roadway; 4) Paved walking surfaces of either concrete or other approved paving material; 5) At least two square feet of seating area, such as a bench or ledge, or one individual seat per 60 square feet of plaza area or open space, whichever is greater; and 6) Lighting that complies with the standards in Section 60.400.100E.6, Pedestrian- Oriented Lighting. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 190 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.050 Sensitive Lands, Wetlands, Stormwater, and Drainage Section 60.400.050A: Purpose Section 60.400.050 S ENSITIVE L ANDS, W ETLANDS, S TORMWATER, AND D RAINAGE A. Purpose This Section 60.400.050 establishes standards that regulate earthwork, stormwater, drainage, and grading, to reduce pollution into waterways and to protect, preserve, and enhance the natural environment. B. Applicability This Section 60.400.050D applies to all subdivision and Site Development Plan approvals unless the Community Development Director determines that review of the Site Development Plan is not necessary because the application complies with avoidance and mitigation measures already applicable to the property due to prior development approvals. C. Relationship to Other Standards The standards in this Section 60.400.050 apply in addition to other applicable standards, including but not limited to those listed in Subsections C.1 through C.3 below. In case of a conflict between standards applicable to the same land or activity subject to this Section 60.400.050, the stricter regulation shall govern unless otherwise required by state or federal law. 1. State or Federal Laws or Regulations The standards in this Section 60.400.050 apply in addition to any applicable standards in state or federal law and applicable regulations adopted pursuant to those laws. 2. Overlay Districts The standards in this Section 60.400.050F apply in addition to any applicable standards in Section 60.200.040D, Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay. Section 60.200.040E, FPO – Floodplain Overlay, and Section 60.200.040F, SDO – Shoreland District Overlay. 3. Adopted Engineering Standards The standards in this Section 60.400.050F apply in addition to any applicable engineering standards including stormwater discharge requirements in Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 6-3, Wetland Conservation, and 6-4, Stormwater Discharges. D. General Requirement for all Sensitive Lands Development of lands that are subject to periodic inundation, subsidence of the earth’s surface, high water table, or have difficult topography, unstable soils, wetlands, lateral groundwater flow occurring within the depth of construction activities, or other natural or human-created hazards to life or property shall be avoided. E. Wetlands In addition to complying with Subsection D above: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 191 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.050 Sensitive Lands, Wetlands, Stormwater, and Drainage Section 60.400.050F: Stormwater 1. A wetland buffer area extending 25 feet from a delineated wetland is required on all delineated wetlands after the effective date of this ordinance. 2. No temporary or permanent structure shall be allowed within 25 feet of a delineated wetland. 3. Draining, dredging, or filling of a delineated wetland is prohibited without a Wetland replacement plan, approved by the LGU, with the SWCD, DNR BWSR and the Corps of Engineers on the Technical Evaluation Panel utilizing BWSR-WCA Rules chapter 8420. 4. A wetland delineation is required for all development that has Decorah Edge soils or groundwater supported wetlands on the Decorah Edge overlay Map and or Hydric Soils based on the USDA Soil Survey in section 60.200.040E. 5. Stormwater drainage into a wetland shall not be increased over, or substantially reduced below, its pre-development rate or volume. F. Stormwater 1. Protection of Wetlands Stormwater runoff from a construction site directed to a wetland shall be substantially free of silt and debris and shall be discharged at a rate that will not disturb vegetation or increase turbidity. 2. Runoff Reduction Requirements a. Increases in the rate or volume of runoff from 2-year, 10-year and 100-year frequency storms due to development, redevelopment, or change of use activity on the site shall be detained within the development and released at a rate no greater than existed prior to the development unless otherwise permitted by the City Engineer as described below. b. Greater runoffs may be permitted by the City Engineer if downstream stormwater management facilities are adequate for the conveyance or if the development is adjacent to a receiving body of water such as a lake or river and proposed runoff is consistent with the Comprehensive Stormwater Management Plan. c. On-site management of stormwater shall be accomplished through the use of bioswales, raingardens, and other best management practices identified by the City to the maximum extent practicable. 3. Overland Drainage The use of overland drainage and retention to control stormwater runoff is allowed subject to approval by the City Engineer, provided that it is consistent with the Stormwater Management Plan, benefits groundwater recharge, and reduces long-term maintenance costs. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 192 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.050 Sensitive Lands, Wetlands, Stormwater, and Drainage Section 60.400.050G: Erosion Control, Grading, and Stormwater Management 4. Channel Restrictions Prohibited a. No fences or structures shall be constructed across an open drainage channel or easement that could reduce or restrict the flow of water, unless part of an approved retention or detention facility or a revocable permit has been approved to allow the fence or structure. If a revocable permit is required, conditions attached to that permit may require mitigation of impacts related to the crossing. b. All stormwater management facilities shall be designed and constructed in conformance with the City’s Comprehensive Stormwater Management Plan and other public works design criteria. c. The City may require any water course or stormwater management facility to be located within a dedicated drainage easement that provides sufficient width for maintenance. G. Erosion Control, Grading, and Stormwater Management 1. Compliance with Adopted Plans and Local Agencies Required Stormwater Management and grading plans shall be designed to comply with the standards of the Rochester Stormwater Management Plan and adopted drainage or stormwater policies and this Section 60.400.050. 2. Erosion Control a. Grading Permit Grading Permits shall address how soil erosion and sedimentation will be minimized during construction and following final completion of a development. The areas to be addressed include, but are not limited to, erodible slopes, streambanks and shorelines, drainageways, borrow and stockpile areas, and drainage structures such as culverts, drop structures, and stormwater detention and retention practices. b. Erosion Control Standards The plans for erosion and sedimentation control shall conform with the Comprehensive Stormwater Management Plan, City engineering standards, the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency’s Construction Stormwater Permit, and the following standards. 1) Compliance with the MPCA Construction Stormwater Permit is required of all activities requiring a grading permit regardless of disturbance area. 2) An acknowledgment that all local, state, and federal requirements have been met shall be noted on the plans. c. Stockpiling of Fill in Right-of-Way Prohibited Material excavated from or to be used as fill on any lot under development shall not be stockpiled or deposited on any improved public right-of-way. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 193 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.050 Sensitive Lands, Wetlands, Stormwater, and Drainage Section 60.400.050G: Erosion Control, Grading, and Stormwater Management 3. Grading Plans and Requirements a. When Required An approved grading plan shall be required: 1) As part of an application for a Final Plat; 2) As part of an application for a Zoning Certificate or conditional use that involves a development that was not included in a previously approved grading plan and will disturb over 10,000 square feet of area; and 3) When any land disturbing activity involving the excavation or fill of earth material on a site equals or exceeds an accumulative total of 50 cubic yards of material. 4) Whenever a Comprehensive Surface water Management Plan is required. b. Exemptions The excavation for footing/foundation does not require an approved grading plan. Installation of utilities not involving other surface grading. c. Grading Plan Requirements 1) In the design of site grading plans, the provision of adequate buildable areas and areas for off-street parking is required. The site grading plan shall also take into account the potential need for accessory buildings and, in the case of Multifamily Dwellings, required recreation area. 2) Developments shall be designed and constructed with a positive drainage flow away from buildings towards approved drainage facilities. 3) Plans for stormwater management facilities are subject to City Engineer approval. 4) All interim and permanent stormwater management facilities shall be designed and constructed in accordance with the standards established in the City’s Stormwater Management Plan and all applicable city, state and federal regulations and standards. 4. Stormwater Management Plans and Requirements a. When Required A Stormwater Management Plan shall accompany an application for: 1) A General Development Plan or Site Development Plan involving an increase in impervious surface area. The Stormwater Management Plan for a General Development Plan is conceptual in nature but provides enough engineering to establish proof of concept; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 194 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060A: Boulevard Trees 2) A Major Land Subdivision of land where no Stormwater Management Plan has been prepared; 3) The master plan of any multi-phase development requiring only Zoning Certificate or conditional use approval; 4) Any lands not covered by a detailed Stormwater Management Plan including lands subdivisions; and 5) Other development requiring a grading plan, unless waived by the City Engineer. b. Stormwater Management Plan Requirements 1) A Stormwater Management Plan shall be prepared to demonstrate compliance with all applicable rules, regulations, and standards. It shall present all engineering calculations performed and assumptions used to design the site, site grading, and stormwater management for the development. 2) The plan shall be consistent with the Rochester Stormwater Management Plan or adopted drainage or stormwater policies. 3) Where the use of pervious pavers are approved by the City, areas covered by pervious pavers shall be calculated as impervious areas. 4) Plans for stormwater management facilities are subject to City Engineer approval. Section 60.400.060 L ANDSCAPING, B UFFERYARDS, AND F ENCES A. Boulevard Trees 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.060A is to establish trees on boulevards on public streets in all areas of the City. 2. Standards a. General Requirements 1) Boulevard trees shall be required for the following types of proposed development: (a) Final subdivision plats that require City Council approval; (b) Subdivisions that require Planning Commission approval; (c) Conditional use permits; or (d) Site Development Plans. 2) Boulevard trees shall be installed prior to or concurrent with the development of the property, unless otherwise allowed by the terms of the development Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 195 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060A: Boulevard Trees agreement, the terms of a Boulevard Tree Green Facilities Agreement as described in Section 600.400.060E, or a prior payment-in-lieu is made to the City as described in Section 600.400.060A,4. 3) All boulevard tree installation shall meet the minimum standards Section 60.400.060B.12. A Boulevard Tree Planting Permit must be obtained from the Parks and Recreation Director prior to planting within the boulevard. 4) The planting plan must be submitted and approved prior to final action by City Council or as part of a Staff level development permit approval (Site Development Plan approval or Zoning Certificate/building permit). 5) The Parks and Recreation Director shall review and approve a complete planting plan. 6) The number of required planting spaces is determined by the standards of Section 60.400.060A, Planting Standards. 7) Boulevard tree placement shall comply with the Parks and Recreation Department Policy on Boulevard Tree Placement and for Standards Associated with New Commercial Buildings with Business Signs to the maximum extent practicable. 8) The Parks and Recreation Director may authorize deviations from the submitted planting plan based on unusual or newly discovered site conditions. b. Boulevard Preparation and Paving The following provisions apply except in the MX-D districts and in areas of the City covered by a corridor plan identifying boulevard infrastructure as a City or other Road Authority responsibility. 1) No boulevard shall be paved by the property owner or applicant outside of the area established for the sidewalk required for the property and driveway approach, unless found to be consistent by the Public Works Director with a long-term plan for pavement improvements. 2) Where the City permits paving within the boulevard by separate permit, each tree location shall have a minimum of 60 square feet of non-paved permeable surface surrounding each tree. 3) All boulevards must be vegetated with turf grass or other approved landscaping outside of the allowed pavement for sidewalk and driveway approach. 4) Development requiring planting of boulevard trees shall be required to apply the standards and specifications for turf restoration and boulevard treatment as established by the Public Works Director. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 196 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060A: Boulevard Trees c. Planting Standards Planting of boulevard trees shall comply with the following standards to the maximum extent practicable. 1) Tree spacing shall average 50 feet between trees located within the boulevard for residential properties and 35 feet between the trees located within the boulevard for commercial properties. 2) A minimum separation of seven feet shall be provided from edge of driveways as measured at the property line. 3) A minimum separation of 12 feet shall be provided from above-ground utility equipment. 4) A minimum separation of 20 feet shall be provided from roadway street lighting. 5) A minimum separation of 25 feet between a boulevard tree and the intersection of sidewalks (normally measured from the property line). 6) Planting on slopes steeper than 60 degrees requires additional review by the Parks and Recreation Director and may be denied or subject to conditions to mitigate potential impacts on tree health or nearby areas. 3. Road Authority This Section 60.400.060A does not apply where the Road Authority determines that boulevard trees will not be permitted. 4. Payment-in-lieu of Boulevard Tree Planting a. Applicability A payment-in-lieu of the requirement to plan boulevard trees as described in this Section 60.400.060A will be permitted if the Director of Parks and Recreation determines that installation of boulevard trees as required by this Section 60.400.060A.4 is not desirable because the trees would interfere with sign visibility or with infrastructure. b. Sign Visibility If the Parks and Recreation Director determines that compliance with this Section 60.400.060A is not feasible in order to preserve the visibility of signs, then they will require a payment-in-lieu to the City. c. Sequencing A payment-in-lieu will not be approved unless the City finds that the applicant has demonstrated that the trees or planting spaces cannot be provided as specified in Section 60.400.060D and none of the modifications of boulevard tree planting and installation requirements listed in Subsections 1) through 6) below are practicable on the property. If the Parks and Recreation Director determines that more than one of the modifications listed below are practicable on the property, the modification Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 197 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping appearing first in the list shall be required (e.g., if both modifications 1) and 3) are practicable, the applicant shall be required to comply with modification 1) in lieu of submitting a payment-in-lieu). 1) Use of alternate canopy tree species; 2) The grouping of trees that may also include alternate tree species (this principle includes a reduction in the separation distance between trees acceptable to the Parks and Recreation Director); 3) Substituting understory for canopy trees; 4) Trimming of trees to provide business visibility; 5) Altering sign location, design, height, or sign type; and 6) Compliance with the “payment-in-lieu” requirements. d. Payment Payment shall be made prior to the recording of the Final Plat of the subdivision or issuance of a Zoning Certificate/building permit pursuant to a Development Plan or Conditional Use Permit approved by the City, or as agreed to in the development agreement. The calculation of the amount of the cash payment required shall be computed based solely on the number of boulevard trees reduced by the applicant for the purpose of sign visibility or infrastructure constrictions multiplied by the annual fee established by City Council. e. Funds Established All payments collected pursuant to this Section 60.400.060A.4 shall be placed in a neighborhood tree fund and shall be expended within one year of completing construction. The funds may only be disbursed for the establishment of boulevard trees on public rights of way. A fee for boulevard trees and installation shall be established on an annual basis by the City Council. f. Responsible Agency After consultation with the Parks and Recreation Director, the Community Development Director shall determine whether a payment-in-lieu will be accepted by the City. The payment shall be submitted to the Parks and Recreation Director. B. General Landscaping 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.060B is to improve Rochester’s vegetated environment and to foster aesthetically pleasing development that will protect and improve Rochester’s biodiversity and ecosystems. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 198 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping 2. Landscape Plan Required Any application for a Zoning Certificate or Conditional Use Permit involving the installation of required plantings shall be accompanied by a landscape plan that includes all required information. 3. Ownership of Landscape Area Landscape area ownership may take one of the following three forms. a. Private Ownership of Landscape Area Private landscape area is land located on the same zoning lot as the principal use under the control of the owners of the principal structure or use on the lot. b. Common Landscape Area Common landscape area is land within a development not individually owned or dedicated for public use that is designed and intended for the common use or enjoyment of the occupants of the development. c. Public Landscape Area Public landscaped area is a form of common landscaped area that has been dedicated in fee to the local governing body or one of its agencies. While maintained for the use and enjoyment of the general public, the area is designed primarily for the residents of the particular development where it has been used to meet the landscape area requirement. 4. Access Requirements When landscaped area is provided through either common or public means, the area must be accessible to all residents of the development. Such access may be provided either through adjacency of the private lots or buildings to the common space, the use of walkways or accessways leading to the common or public areas, or public rights-of-way that have frontage on the common or public open space for a distance of at least 40 feet. 5. Development of Private and Common Landscape Areas Private or common landscape areas shall be developed in a manner that serves one or more of the following purposes: a. To separate use areas on the development, such as circulation from recreation; b. To provide aesthetic benefits by providing a feeling of openness to the development when viewed from the adjacent right-of-way or adjacent residential properties; c. For passive or active recreational purposes; and/or d. To enhance the livability of interior building areas by providing open space adjacent to windows. 6. Permissible Types of Landscaped Areas Landscaped areas include: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 199 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping a. Required yards, courts, and bufferyards that are free of buildings, structures, and other substantial improvements (except structures or improvements qualifying as usable recreational area); b. Driveways that serve parking areas providing off-street parking for residential buildings with four or less units shall be permissible landscaped area; c. Ground surface areas located above underground facilities that meet the other requirements of this Section 60.400.060B; d. Pedestrian and bicycle paths; e. Plazas within a building that are directly oriented to the major pedestrian entrance of the building and are open to view and use by the public; and f. Areas developed for either passive of active recreation at ground level and natural areas such as lakes, ponds, wetlands, or grassed waterways. 7. Impermissible Types of Landscaped Areas The following are examples of what may not be counted as landscaped area: a. Public or private right-of-way for streets; b. Open parking areas or parking garages; c. Driveways that serve four or more parking spaces; except as provided for in Section 60.400.060B.6; d. Non-recreational buildings, including storage sheds and carports; and e. Balconies, screened porches, terraces, or similar passive recreation areas that are an integral part of the building. 8. Permitted Obstructions over Landscaped Areas The following shall not be considered obstructions when located over any landscaped area: a. Unenclosed terraces, fire escapes, planting boxes, or air conditioning units, provided no such items projects more than six feet into or over the landscaped area; b. Unenclosed balconies; and c. Eaves, gutters, or downspouts. 9. Landscaping in Public Rights-of-Way Landscape materials may be planted within the public right-of-way if permission is obtained from the Road Authority. Landscape area may be partially within a public right- of-way following approval of a revocable permit and as provided for in Section 60.500.070A. 10. Preservation of Common and Public Landscape Areas Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 200 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping Landscape areas shall be maintained so that use and enjoyment as open space is not diminished or destroyed. Common or public landscape area may be owned, preserved, and maintained by any of the following mechanisms: a. Ownership by the property owner subject to an agreement with the City obligating the property owner or an entity acceptable to the City to preserve and maintain the area; b. Through the use of condominium agreements in which all landscaped areas are identified as “common elements.” c. Dedication of open space to the City or an appropriate public agency, if either entity is willing to accept the dedication. d. Common ownership of the open space by a homeowner’s association that assumes full responsibility for its maintenance. e. Dedication of development rights of open space may be made to an appropriate public agency with ownership and maintenance responsibility remaining with the applicant or homeowner’s association. f. Deed-restricted private ownership that shall prevent development and/or subsequent subdivision of the open-space land and provide for maintenance responsibility. g. Land designated as the required landscape area for a development shall not be sold, subdivided, or developed unless adequate landscape area remains for the original development to meet ordinance requirements. Landscape area for one development may not be used to comply with the requirements for another development. 11. Planting Requirements The base planting requirements in this section are intended to enhance diversification of the landscaping, to include plantings beyond grass. a. Applicability 1) These requirements shall apply to all non-residential uses, and residential uses with four or more units, for front yards and, where applicable, street side yards. 2) These requirements do not apply in the MX-D and MX-T districts. 3) Minimum planting as described in Table 400.06-1 shall be located on the lot. 4) Plantings required by some other provision of this UDC, such as bufferyards, boulevards trees, etc. cannot be counted toward the minimum planting requirement. Table 400.06-1 Minimum Planting Requirements Zoning District MinimumPlanting Requirement R-2x and R3 1 understory tree; and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 201 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping Table 400.06-1 Minimum Planting Requirements Zoning District MinimumPlanting Requirement 3 deciduous or evergreen shrubs of minimum 3-foot-height for every 30 linear feet of lot frontage, planted at least 3 feet part on center \[1\] 2 canopy trees; and 2 understory trees, and R4 3 deciduous or evergreen shrubs of minimum 3-foot-height for every 30 linear feet of lot frontage, planted at least 3 feet part on center \[1\] 1 canopy tree, 1 Understory tree, and 6 deciduous or evergreen shrubs of minimum 3-foot-height for MX-N every 30 linear feet of lot frontage, planted at least 3 feet part on center \[1\] 1 canopy tree; and 3 deciduous or evergreen shrubs of minimum 3-foot-height for MX-S, MX-C, and MX-G every 30 linear feet of lot frontage, planted at least 3 feet part on center \[1\] 3 canopy trees; and 4 understory trees; and BP, LI, and SI 3 deciduous or evergreen shrubs of minimum 3-foot-height for every 30 linear feet of lot frontage, planted at least 3 feet part on center \[1\] Notes \[1\] Shrubs must meet the 3-foot minimum height requirement within two years of planting. b. Tree Placement and Clearances 1) Canopy trees shall be planted no closer than 12 feet from a building foundation, and understory trees shall be no closer than 10 feet from a building foundation. 2) No tree that has a mature height of 25 feet or greater shall be planted beneath an existing or proposed overhead utility line. Where canopy trees are required adjacent to or underneath overhead utility lines, understory trees shall be provided instead of the required canopy trees at a ratio of 2 understory trees per every 1 required canopy tree. 3) From time of planting through maturity, front and street side yard plantings shall not interfere with Visibility Triangle requirements, as described in 60.400.060B14. 4) Trees shall not be planted in utility easements. Other plantings, as described in 60.400.060B15, Planting in Easements, may be substituted with the approval of the Community Development Director. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 202 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping c. Site constraints Where lot size, topography, easements, or other constraints preclude complying with the requirements of this Section, the Community Development Director may authorize alternate plantings or planting locations. 12. Types of Plants Allowed a. All plant materials must meet specifications of the American Association of Nurseryman (AAN) for the number and grade. b. The Community Development Director may permit other types of plant materials, such as native grasses and forbs, if they are hardy to the Rochester area and not subject to blight or disease. c. Unless specifically indicated otherwise in this UDC, all plant materials shall meet minimum size standards in Table 400.06-2 Minimum Plant Size. Table 400.06-2 Minimum Plant Size Plant Material Type Minimum Size of Plantings Canopy Tree, Single Stem 2.5 inches caliper Canopy Tree, Multi-Stem Clump 6 feet height Understory Tree 4 feet height Evergreen Tree 6 feet height Shrub, Deciduous 15 inch height Shrub, Evergreen 3 feet height d. Existing, healthy plant material may be used to meet landscaping or bufferyard requirements provided they meet the minimum plant size specified in Table 400.06-2 Minimum Plant Size. 13. Installation a. Plantings required by this UDC shall be installed prior to final building inspection unless the Community Development Director modifies that to allow planting at a time of the year that will optimize the chances of success for growth of the plant materials. b. When the Community Development Director extends the time for required plantings to be installed, the applicant shall provide a letter of credit, a paid-in-full receipt from a reputable landscape firm, a performance bond or an escrow deposit to ensure that all plantings are installed. c. All financial guarantees shall be equal to the sum of 100 percent of the total cost, including materials and labor, of installation of the required plantings. d. The City shall be entitled to reimburse itself out of said funds for any cost and expense incurred by the city for completion of the work in case of default. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 203 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060B: General Landscaping e. Where financial guarantees are required for such improvements under other governmental authority, such as FHA Approval Requirements, and these conditions of approval meet or exceed the ordinance requirements, no additional guarantee is required. 14. Visibility Triangle In any zone district that requires a front or side street building setback, there shall be no landscaping (other than tree trunks) that extends into the vertical space between three feet and nine feet above curb grade. Vertical measurement shall be made from the top of the curb on the street adjacent to the nearest street of the triangle or, if no curb exists, from the edge of the nearest traveled way. Horizontal measurement shall be 30 feet along the property line from the intersection of two streets, or by joining points measured 10 feet back along a driveway and lot line from the point of intersection of the driveway and lot line. 15. Planting in Easements a. Vegetation located on utility easements shall be placed so that it does not interfere with the free movement of service vehicles, or placement and operation of utility facilities. b. Ground cover, grass, and native grasses, or hedges under three feet in heights may be installed in or permitted to remain in the public utility easement. c. Plantings in utility easements shall be placed at the risk of the property owner, and shall not interfere with reasonable access to the utility facility. Utility Companies will not replace plantings or landscaping removed or damaged during work within the easement area. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 204 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060C: Parking Lot Landscaping C. Parking Lot Landscaping 1. Applicability a. Landscaping is required for all primary use and accessory parking lots to reduce the visual impacts created by extensive parking areas and to reduce heat island impacts created by larger parking areas, unless exempted under Subsection b below. b. Parking lots that are located in a rear yard, contain 20 or fewer spaces, and are located behind or otherwise screened by a building from view from the public right-of- way shall be exempt from the landscape island requirements. 2. Parking Lot Screening Adjacent to a Residential Zoning District Off-street parking areas in Mixed Use and Non-Residential districts that are located adjacent to a Household Living use (other than a Multifamily Dwelling) located in a Residential district shall be screened according to the following standards: a. A landscape buffer a minimum of 10 feet in width, measured inward from the property line on all sides of the property abutting the applicable Household Living use; or b. A solid wall or fence no less than six feet in height installed on all sides of the property abutting the applicable Household Living use. 3. Parking Lot Landscape Islands Required Landscaped islands shall be included to break up parking rows and to allow for drainage. The interior area of parking lots shall be landscaped according to the following standards. a. Number of Landscape Islands Required A minimum of 12 percent of the internal parking lot area, exclusive of perimeter landscaping or bufferyard plantings, must consist of landscaped islands, unless permeable paving is used for all parking spaces, then the minimum landscaped islands percentage may be reduced to five percent. b. Landscape Island Size and Location Requirements 1) Landscape islands shall be a sufficient size to accommodate required landscaping. No landscaped island shall be less than eight feet in length or width and a minimum of 50 square feet. 2) Landscape islands shall be provided in parking areas along the ends of parking rows, adjacent to lot lines, and used to define the location and pattern of primary internal access drives. c. Landscape Island Planting and Tree Requirements 1) Exclusive of bufferyard landscaping and boulevard/street trees, landscape islands shall each contain a minimum of one tree and three shrubs per 400 square feet. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 205 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060D: Bufferyards 2) A minimum of 75 percent of the required parking area trees shall be deciduous canopy-type shade trees. D. Bufferyards 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.060D is to buffer existing development from abutting new development of different types, scales, or intensities by providing visual barriers between those land uses as well as providing more privacy and protecting abutting existing uses from potential wind, dust, noise, traffic, glare, visual disorder, and harmful or noxious effects of the new development. 2. Applicability New development, redevelopment, and changes of use in all zoning districts shall provide property edge buffering along shared property lines with abutting properties as indicated in Table 400.06-3, Required Bufferyard Type, regardless of whether the new development is larger or smaller or more or less intensive than the existing abutting use. Table 400.06-3 Required Bufferyard Level None = No Requirement; 1 = Level 1 Bufferyard; 2 = Level 2 Bufferyard; 3 = Level 3 Bufferyard; 4 = Level 4 Bufferyard Zone District and Applicant Zone District and Use Use of Abutting Non- Residential Property Residential Use in an Non-All Uses in a Use in an Residential Agricultural Residential Non- Agricultural Use in a Mixed and Use in a Mixed Residential and Use District Residential Use District District Residential District District Residential Use in an Agricultural None 2 2 3 4 and Residential District Non-Residential Use in an Agricultural and None 1 1 2 4 Residential District Residential Use in a Mixed Use None 1 None 1 4 District Non-Residential Use in a Mixed None None 1 None 2 Use District All Uses in a Non- Residential 1 1 1 1 None District NOTES Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 206 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060D: Bufferyards Table 400.06-3 Required Bufferyard Level None = No Requirement; 1 = Level 1 Bufferyard; 2 = Level 2 Bufferyard; 3 = Level 3 Bufferyard; 4 = Level 4 Bufferyard Zone District and Applicant Zone District and Use Use of Abutting Non- Residential Property Residential Use in an Non-All Uses in a Use in an Residential Agricultural Residential Non- Agricultural Use in a Mixed and Use in a Mixed Residential and Use District Residential Use District District Residential District District \[1\] When a residential use proposes 4 or more dwelling units, the required bufferyard is Level 2. 3. Bufferyard Requirements a. Table 400.06-4, Bufferyard Levels, describes two different bufferyard options in terms of their function, opacity, width, and planting requirements. Where a particular bufferyard level is required in Table 400.06-3, Required Bufferyard Level, the requirement may be met with the combination of minimum buffer width and minimum screening requirements specified under either Option 1 or Option 2. Where an option requiring a berm or fence is selected, the berm or fence shall comply with the standards of Section 60.400.060E, Fences, as appropriate. Table 400.06-4 Bufferyard Levels Minimum Bufferyard Requirements Per 100 Bufferyard Level Linear Feet and Description Configuration Option 1 Option 2 Level 1 Functions as a basic edge Minimum width of 10 Minimum width of 20 Bufferyard: Basic demarcating individual feet, 2 canopy feet, 2 understory properties with a slight plantings, 2 understory plantings, and 8 shrubs visual obstruction plantings, and 2 shrubs Level 2 Functions as an intermittent Bufferyard: visual obstruction and Minimum width of 15 Minimum width of 25 Aesthetic creates the impression of feet, 3 canopy feet, 2 canopy planting, spatial separation without plantings, 4 understory 3 understory plantings, eliminating visual contact plantings, and 8 shrubs and 6 shrubs between adjacent properties Level 3 Functions as a strong but Minimum width of 25 Minimum width of 35 Bufferyard: aesthetically pleasing buffer feet, 6 canopy feet, 4 canopy Strong to help mitigate the intensity plantings, 5 understory plantings, 7 understory challenges associated with plantings, and 20 plantings, and 15 non-residential uses shrubs shrubs Level 4 Minimum width of 25 Minimum width of 35 Functions as an opaque Bufferyard: feet, 6 canopy feet, 4 canopy screen that prevents visual Opaque plantings, 5 understory plantings, 7 understory contact between uses and plantings, 20 shrubs, plantings, 15 shrubs, creates a strong impression and a 6 foot tall and a 6 foot tall of total separation wooden fence or berm wooden fence or berm Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 207 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060D: Bufferyards b. Bufferyards may contain sidewalks, bikeways, multi-use trails, seating areas, stormwater facilities, or landscape features provided that the requirements in Table 400.06-4, Bufferyard Levels, are met. c. Where the bufferyard between a land use and vacant land turns out to be greater than the bufferyard that is required between the first use and the subsequently developed use, the existing use may expand its use into the original buffer area so long as the requirements of this Section 60.400.060D are met. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 208 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences Section 60.400.060E: Fences, Walls, and Hedges E. Fences, Walls, and Hedges All fences and walls except those installed to protect slopes from subsidence or erosion shall comply with the following standards. Fences and walls installed to protect slopes shall comply with the Building Code. 1. No fence, wall, or hedge may extend beyond or across a property line unless in joint agreement with the abutting property owner. 2. No fence, wall, or hedge shall be placed closer than 18 inches to any public sidewalk or within five feet of any alley right-of-way. 3. In all zoning districts, fences and walls located between the front of the primary building and the front lot line shall not exceed 36 inches in height. 4. In all zoning districts, fences and walls located between the front of the primary building and the front lot line shall not be completely opaque, and shall not be constructed of chain link. 5. Fences and walls that are not located between the front of the primary building and the front lot line shall not exceed six feet in height above the elevation of the surface of the ground at any point except: a. In instances where public safety or security necessitate, through a zoning certificate, the Community Development Director may authorize fences and walls to have a maximum height not to exceed 10 feet above the elevation of the surface of the ground at any point; or b. When the grade of buildings on abutting lots is greater than that of buildings on the applicant’s lot, the fence may exceed the height limitations, but shall not exceed the grade of the abutting building by more than five feet. 6. No fence, wall, or hedge shall be placed closer than 10 feet to the intersection of a driveway with any right-of-way used for vehicular or pedestrian traffic including alleys. 7. In any district that requires a front or side street building setback, there shall be no sight- obscuring or partly obscuring wall or fence higher than three feet above curb grade in any Visibility Triangle. Vertical measurement shall be made from the top of the curb on the street adjacent to the nearest street of the triangle or, if no curb exists, from the edge of the nearest traveled way. 8. Where a fence is installed on any property in a Mixed Use or Non-Residential zoning district along a property line with a lot containing a Household Living use in a Residential zoning district, the “finished” side of the fence (generally the side where structural supports and bracing are not visible) shall face the abutting Household Living use. 9. All fences, walls, and hedges shall meet all applicable clearance requirements of the National Electric Safety Code. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 209 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.060F: Alternative Equivalent Compliance F. Alternative Equivalent Compliance 1. Modifications of the required landscaping, bufferyard, and fencing requirements in this Section 60.400.060 may be approved by the Community Development Director when alternatives are justified by site or development conditions. Including but not limited to: a. Natural conditions, such as watercourses, natural rock formations, or topography; b. Unique lot size or configuration, particularly for infill and redevelopment projects; c. The location of existing utility or other easements; d. Potential risks to public safety; and/or e. Preservation or natural vegetation. 2. Alternatives from the requirements in this Section 60.400.060 may be approved by the Community Development Director if the Director determines that the proposed alternatives: a. Are consistent with the purposes of this Section 60.400.060; b. Do not include invasive vegetation included in an adopted city, county, or state list of prohibited or invasive species; c. Provide equal or superior buffering of adjacent properties from anticipated visual, noise, traffic, or activity impacts of the proposed development; and d. Provide equal or superior visual appearance of the property when viewed from public rights-of-way and adjacent public Parks or open spaces. Section 60.400.070 S ITE AND B UILDING D ESIGN A. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.070 is to establish site and building design standards that foster high-quality, attractive, and sustainable development. The standards are further intended to: 1. Protect and enhance the character and quality of Rochester’s neighborhoods; 2. Protect and enhance the long-term market value of property within Rochester; 3. Enhance the pedestrian scale of new developments and ensure compatibility between residential neighborhoods and adjacent non-residential uses; 4. Promote building designs and construction practices that are sustainable and adaptable to multiple uses for extended building lifecycles; 5. Minimize the negative impacts of on-site activities to adjacent uses; and 6. Balance the community’s economic and aesthetic concerns. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 210 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070B: Applicability B. Applicability This Section 60.400.070 shall apply to all site-specific development approvals in the City, subject to exceptions stated in this Section 60.400.070. C. Access and Connectivity All development subject to this Section 60.400.070 shall comply with applicable standards in Section 60.400.040, Access and Connectivity, as they relate to site design. D. Parking All development subject to this Section 60.400.070 shall comply with applicable standards in Section 60.400.080, Parking, Loading, and Stacking as they relate to site and building design. E. Site Design The following standards apply to all new developments and redevelopments in all districts except as specifically stated in this Section 60.400.070E. 1. Preservation of Natural Areas Site design shall maximize the use of already-disturbed land for roads, parking areas, or structures in order to preserve natural and undisturbed areas to the maximum extent practicable. 2. Hillside Development a. All slopes shall be stabilized, as required by the adopted Uniform Building Code. b. Revegetation or screening of permanent exposed slopes created by any new development shall be required to stabilize slopes or to enhance the character of development and provide visual and aesthetic benefit to the community. c. Where the use of seeding, sodding, or other ground cover treatment cannot be expected to produce a growth cover, the use of vines or other plant materials to screen the slope shall be required. 3. On-Site Utility Lines All on-site electric utility, cable television, communication lines, and other conduits connecting distributions lines to individual lots shall be placed and maintained underground unless this requirement is waived by the Community Development Director due to natural or human-made obstacles that make such placement impracticable. 4. Screening All Multifamily Dwellings, Group Living, Public, Institutional, Civic, Commercial, or Industrial uses (as listed in Table 300.01-1, Allowed Uses Table), shall comply with the following standards. Where a Residential Care Facility occupies a dwelling structure that would be exempt from these standards if occupied by Household Living uses, the Residential Care Facility is also exempt from these standards. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 211 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070E: Site Design a. Ground-Mounted Mechanical Equipment 1) Outdoor ground-mounted mechanical equipment (e.g., utility boxes, water backflow prevention, electrical boxes, subpanels, air conditioners, heating, cooling, and ventilating equipment, kitchen hoods and vents, swimming pool equipment, pumps and heaters, propane tanks, and all other mechanical equipment) shall be located where they are not visible from public open space, public trails, public streets, or from adjacent properties to the maximum extent practicable, and shall comply with all provisions of this UDC regarding location and screening. 2) In cases when ground-mounted mechanical equipment is visible from public open space, public trails, public streets, or from adjacent properties, the equipment shall be screened from view by a solid and permanent wall or fence or a vegetative screen that satisfies the following criteria: (a) The wall or fence shall be of a height equal to or greater than the height of the mechanical equipment being screened and shall use at least one of the predominant materials and colors on the nearest wall of the primary structures (excluding unfinished CMU block) or another type of permitted wall or fence installed on the site; or (b) The vegetative screen must comply with the standards for permitted landscaping materials and installation in Section 60.400.060B.11, 3) Commercial Wireless Telecommunication Service (CWTS), Ground-Mounted Solar Collectors, and other alternative energy systems shall be exempt from any screening requirements that would impair their ability to perform their intended functions. CWTS shall comply with all applicable provisions in Section 60.300.020F.1, Commercial Wireless Telecommunication Service. Ground- Mounted Solar Collectors shall comply with all applicable provisions in Section 60.300.020F.2, Solar Collector, Ground- or Building-Mounted. b. Loading, Service, and Refuse Areas 1) Outdoor loading, service, and refuse areas shall be integrated into the building design if possible or shall be located where they are not visible from public open space, public trails, public streets, or from abutting properties, to the maximum extent practicable. 2) In cases when loading, service, and refuse areas are visible from public open space, public trails, public streets, or from abutting properties, the loading, service, and refuse areas shall be screened from view by a solid wall or fence a minimum of eight feet in height that incorporates at least one of the primary materials and colors of the nearest wall of the primary building (excluding unfinished CMU block) or a vegetative screen planted along the full length of the area to be screened and a minimum of eight feet in height at the time of planting. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 212 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070E: Site Design 3) Individual waste and/or recycling receptacles for use by the public or by occupants of the facility are not subject to the location and screening requirements of subsections 1) and 2) above. 5. Traffic Calming, Circulation, and Trash Receptacles Developments over five acres in size and Site Development Plans for individual buildings containing more than 80,000 square feet of gross floor area shall comply with the following requirements. a. Traffic calming design and devices shall be incorporated into the site design. b. Pedestrian safety improvements shall be incorporated in areas with highest concentrations of pedestrian traffic (i.e., near building entrances). c. An outer drive aisle shall be used to divert vehicular traffic away from the area in front of stores and tenant spaces to the maximum extent practicable. d. Trash and recycling containers shall be provided near high pedestrian traffic areas. 6. Public Transit Stops Developments over one acre in size or Site Development Plans for individual buildings containing more than 20,000 square feet of gross floor area on an existing bus route shall be designed to accommodate a public transit stop. The transit stop must be located: a. In proximity to a primary building entrance along a walkway adjacent to the building; or b. Within 300 feet of a primary building entrance in an abutting parking area connected via a walkway to the building entrance. 7. Pedestrian Focal Points and Canopy Trees Developments over one acre in size or Site Development Plans for individual buildings containing more than 40,000 square feet of gross floor area shall include: a. Pedestrian focal points with enhanced pedestrian paving such as decorative scored concrete, stained concrete, exposed aggregate, integral colored, or textured concrete shall be provided; b. Canopy trees incorporated along pedestrian walkways at the rate of one canopy tree per 20 lineal feet of walkway. This requirement is in addition to the applicable requirements in Section 60.400.060, Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences, except that any canopy tree installed in a required bufferyard shall count towards the minimum planting requirement in that bufferyard; and c. Above-ground pedestrian amenities that do not require footings may be installed at the risk of the property owner, provided they do not interfere with reasonable access to the utility facility, upon obtaining a revocable permit. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 213 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070E: Site Design 8. Usable Recreation Area Each development containing Multifamily Dwelling uses, or containing a Residential Care Facility use with 7 or more residents that is subject to Multifamily Dwelling use standards, shall comply with the following standards. a. General Requirements 1) The usable recreation area provided shall be designed primarily for the use of the residents of the development providing the usable recreation land. 2) Usable recreation area may be developed for either active or passive recreation purposes, subject to the standards in this Section 60.400.070E.8. 3) Any application for construction or expansion of a Multifamily Dwelling use shall identify the boundaries of the areas and the types of improvements to be provided in the designated recreation areas. 4) Land designated as the required usable recreation area for a development shall not be sold, subdivided, or otherwise developed unless adequate recreation area remains to comply with the requirements of this UDC. 5) Usable recreation area required to comply with the requirements of this UDC for one development may not be used to comply with the requirements for another development. 6) The required square footage of usable recreation area shall equal the floor area of the Multifamily Dwelling multiplied by the applicable percentage in Table 400.07-1 Minimum Usable Recreation Area Required. Table 400.07-1 Minimum Usable Recreation Area Required Number of Units Minimum Area Required 18% of gross floor area of Multifamily Dwelling use, or 240 Four Units or Less square feet, whichever is greater 10% of gross floor area of Multifamily Dwelling use, or 240 Five Units or More square feet, whichever is greater 7) Usable recreation area that is landscaped in compliance with the standards in Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences may be used to meet landscaped area requirements. b. Permissible Improvements in Usable Recreation Areas 1) General Requirements (a) Usable recreation areas shall be improved so that they may be used for either passive or active recreation. (b) At a minimum, ground level outdoor entertainment or recreation areas shall be: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 214 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070E: Site Design (i) Improved with grass or other vegetation in compliance with Section 60.400.060 either through seeding or sodding, or left in its natural state. Areas of natural vegetation must: a. Provide pathways and/or sitting and observation areas developed to provide access to the natural area; and b. Provide ground cover to prohibit soil erosion; and c. Not include invasive species of vegetation. (ii) Improved for use as active recreation areas through the installation of play equipment such as swings, slides, sandboxes, basketball hoops, tennis courts, ballfields, swimming pools, and similar uses; or (iii) Paved or vegetated areas used for picnic tables, lawn furniture, barbecue stands, or similar amenities that do not involve active team sports. (c) The following types of spaces within a building may be counted towards the usable recreation area requirement. (i) Exterior balconies at least 70 square feet in size that are provided for individual dwelling units. (ii) Terrace areas that are open to the sky and accessible to all residents in a development. (iii) Separate, accessory recreational buildings at ground level may be counted as usable recreation area provided that the total impervious surfaces of such structures do not exceed 10 percent of the total required landscape area for the development. (d) Up to one-half of the required recreation area provided at ground level or in an adjacent public space may consist of water surfaces such as ponds, lakes, or streams. (e) Bikeways or Multi-Use Paths located in the interior of a block, surfaced in a dust-free manner, may be counted towards the usable recreation requirement if the Bikeway or Multi-Use Path is at least 10 feet in width and is part of an integrated system leading to principal destinations such as a park, school, or major recreation area. 2) Dimensions Ground level landscaped areas and adjacent public open space areas intended to meet the usable recreation area requirement shall meet the following dimensional requirements. (a) If the required recreation area is less than 10,000 square feet, all of it shall be located in a contiguous portion of the site or lot and no dimension shall be less than 30 feet, except that inner block play areas for small children that are Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 215 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design improved with play equipment shall have a minimum dimension of 20 feet and a minimum size of 1,000 square feet. If the required area is less than 900 square feet, the minimum dimension may be reduced to 15 feet. (b) For every 20,000 square feet of required usable recreation area, at least one area of not less than 10,000 square feet with a minimum dimension of 50 feet shall be provided. 3) Slope Ground level landscaped areas and adjacent public spaces intended to meet the usable recreation requirement shall meet the following requirements: (a) At least one-half of the required recreation area shall have a finished slope of less than 10 percent; and (b) The remainder of the area may have a slope of up to 25 percent if designated and improved for passive recreational use. 4) Location and Access (a) On developments containing five acres or more, usable recreation areas should be centrally located or distributed throughout the development to be readily accessible to the largest number of residents. (b) Access must be available to usable recreation areas using common landscaped area or adjacent public space either through the sharing of common lot lines, linkage by way of walkways or bikeways, or access by means of a public or private street right-of-way with a frontage of at least 20 feet on the usable recreation area. F. Building Design 1. General Requirements a. Applicability The following requirements apply to primary structures occupied by the primary uses listed below in the zoning districts listed below. All references to land uses or categories of land uses refer to those shown in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table. 1) Multifamily dwellings in all districts; 2) All Group Living uses except for Residential Care Facilities in structures that would be exempt from these standards if they were occupied by a Household Living use, as shown in Table 300.02-1); 3) Public, Institutional, and Civic uses in all districts except the SI district; 4) Commercial and Industrial uses in all districts except the SI district; and 5) Mixed use developments (i.e., those containing a mix of primary residential and non-residential uses) in all districts except the SI district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 216 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design b. 360-Degree Architecture All sides of each primary building façade shall be designed to provide architectural and visual interest and shall provide consistent architectural treatment on all building façades. A consistent architectural treatment is one where all building walls have defined levels of articulation and use different combinations of the same materials. c. Building Materials 1) Primary buildings shall be constructed of high quality, durable materials including but not limited to stone, brick, masonry, or wood. 2) The use of asphalt shingles, imitation stone, imitation brick, stucco, exterior insulation finish systems (EIFS), or vinyl siding is prohibited on any street- facing building façade. d. Transparency 1) Window glazing on the bottom two floors on street facing façades of a primary building shall not include reflective glass. 2) Window glazing on the bottom two floors on street facing façades of a primary building that do not provide visibility into residential dwelling units shall achieve a visible transmittance ration (VT) of at least 0.60. 3) In Residential districts, the glazed area of windows and doors shall occupy at least 30 percent of each street facing façade area between three and eight feet above grade. 4) In Mixed Use districts other than the MX-T and MX-D districts, the glazed area of windows and doors shall occupy at least 40 percent of each street facing façade area between three and eight feet above grade, and 30 percent of the non-street facing facades. (a) This transparency requirement may be reduced by a maximum of 5%, if the development provides architecturally significant window treatments that provide vertical articulation in addition to any articulation already required. 5) In the MX-T and MX-D districts, the glazed area of windows and doors: (a) In non-residential uses on the ground floor shall occupy at least 65 percent of each street facing façade area between three and eight feet above grade, and shall occupy at least 30 percent of each street facing façade area above the ground floor. (b) In residential uses on the ground floor shall occupy at least 30 percent of each street facing façade area between three and eight feet above grade, and shall occupy at least 30 percent of each street facing façade area above the ground floor. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 217 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design e. Roof-Mounted Equipment Screening 1) Roof-mounted mechanical equipment shall be: (a) Integrated into the design of the structure so that the equipment is not visible from ground level on any street-facing property boundary; or (b) Screened by a parapet wall or similar feature that is an integral part of the building’s architectural design, with a parapet wall height sufficient to screen the mechanical equipment from all sides when viewed from ground-level on each street-facing property boundary. (c) And; roof-mounted mechanical equipment shall be fully screened on all sides so that it is not visible from any residential use containing five or fewer units. 2) To reduce visual impacts on abutting properties, the color of roof-mounted equipment shall be the same color as the roof or the same color as an adjacent wall. 3) Commercial Wireless Telecommunication Service equipment, Building- Mounted Solar Collectors, and other alternative energy systems are exempt from any portion of these screening requirements that would impair their functions. f. Horizontal Articulation Primary buildings shall be designed to avoid blank wall planes by dividing façades into a series of smaller horizontal components that comply with the following standards. 1) In all districts , each façade, regardless of exterior wall plane setback, shall incorporate two or more of the following elements for every 60 horizontal feet: (a) Projections, recessions, or reveals such as, but not limited to, columns, pilasters, cornices, and bays, and having a change of wall plane that is a minimum of six inches in depth; (b) Change in texture and/or masonry patterns; and/or (c) Awnings or canopies extending at least four feet beyond the building face with a minimum vertical clearance of nine feet above the sidewalk. Glowing awnings (backlit, light showing through the material) are not permitted. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 218 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design 2) In the MX-T and MX-D districts, each street facing façade of each primary building shall comply with the following standards. (a) Access for Ground Level Units All ground level residential units along all street-facing sides of the building must provide direct access entries from the building exterior. The Community Development Director will waive this requirement for some or all of the units, upon determination that an alternative design will provide a better pedestrian orientated space along the frontage of the development. (b) Building Façades Less Than 150 Feet Long Each street facing façade with a horizontal length between 60 and 89 feet shall incorporate at least one of the following elements; street-facing façades with a horizontal length between 90 and 119 feet shall incorporate at least two of the following elements; and street-facing building façades with a horizontal length over 120 feet must incorporate at least three of the following elements for every 60 horizontal feet: (i) A change in a street facing parapet height of at least two vertical feet, extending at least 20 horizontal feet of parapet length; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 219 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design (ii) Horizontally oriented recesses at least eight inches into, or projections or cornices extending at least eight inches outward from, the building façade plane, at least eight inches tall, and extending at least 30 horizontal feet along the building façade (this element may be installed along the entire building façade, but if so installed shall only count as one of the required elements on any street-facing building façade longer than 60 feet); (iii) Vertically oriented recesses at least eight inches into, or projections at least eight inches outward from, the building façade plane, and at least eight inches wide, that have a height equal to at least 80 percent of the façade height; (iv) Ground level arcades or awnings extending for a horizontal distance of at least 20 feet in total (individual awnings may be shorter than 20 feet to fit appropriate building scale); and (v) Second (and upper) floor balconies on at least 50 percent of the residential dwelling units on a street facing building façade. (c) Buildings Façades 150 Feet or Longer In addition to incorporating at least three architectural elements from Subsection a above, each street facing façade of a primary building with a horizontal length over 150 feet (regardless of changes in façade alignment) shall incorporate at least one of the two design elements listed below. (i) Forecourt A wall plane recess creating a forecourt gathering space, which shall extend along at least 15 horizontal feet of the building façade, shall be a minimum of 10 feet in depth measured inward from the primary building wall plane, shall be open to the sky, and shall including windows or doors for accessing or viewing the building interior from the forecourt. The forecourt shall not be used for surface parking but may be used to satisfy the pedestrian oriented space requirement in Section 60.400.040D.11.d, Pedestrian Oriented Space. (ii) Top Floor Stepback A horizontal setback of the top floor of building façade at least six feet further from the street than the lower floor building façades, extending along the entire length of that building façade. The stepback may apply to more than the top floor of the building façade at the applicant’s option, but may not extend to ground level. 2. Additional Requirements in the MX-T District Each street facing façade of a primary building in the MX-T district shall comply with the following standards. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 220 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design a. Each primary structure shall have at least one pedestrian entrance on each street ndth facing façade. If the lot has frontage on Broadway, 2 St., 4 St./Collegeview Rd., thrd 12 St. or 3 Ave., the required entrance shall face those streets. If the lot does not have frontage facing a street, the pedestrian entrance shall face the front lot line. b. If there are multiple ground-floor commercial tenant spaces on the street facing façade, each ground floor tenant space with 25 feet or more of frontage shall have at least one pedestrian entrance facing that street. As an exception to this standard, a maximum of two abutting ground floor commercial tenants may share a single pedestrian entrance, with a common vestibule facing that public right-of-way. c. Each required pedestrian entrance shall open directly to the outside and have direct access to the adjacent sidewalk without requiring pedestrians to pass through a garage, parking lot, or a non-pedestrian area located between the pedestrian entrance and the street. 3. Additional Requirements in the MX-D District Each primary or accessory building within the MX-D district shall comply with the applicable DMC Design Guidelines to the maximum extent practicable, as determined by the Community Development Director. 4. Additional Requirements in the MX-D, MX-T, and MX-I Districts Each primary building in the MX-D, MX-T, and MX-I districts over 60 feet in height shall comply with the following standards: a. Minimum Floor-to-Floor Height The minimum floor-to-ceiling height of the ground floor of any principal use shall be 13 feet, and on upper floors shall be 12 feet. b. Vertical Articulation Each primary building that is more than ten stories in height shall be designed to include a clearly identifiable base, body, and top of the building. 1) Base (a) The base of a primary building shall not be more than three stories or 40 feet in height, whichever is less. (b) The base shall incorporate one or more of the following design techniques: (i) Incorporation of low planters and walls; (ii) Use of base architectural veneer banding or a wainscot treatment defined by different materials, textures, or colors; and/or (iii) Integrated covered walkways, trellises, or architectural awnings that provide deep shadow at ground level. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 221 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design Section 60.400.070F: Building Design 2) Body The body of a primary building shall include all floors of the building between the base of the building and the top of the building. Each façade of the building body shall comply with all of the following: (a) Incorporate at least a 20 percent reduction in floor area from the base of the building; (b) Be set back at least 10 feet from the edge of each street-facing base of the building; and (c) If the body of the building includes towers (i.e., two or more building floorplates rising from the base) each of the floorplates shall be separated from each other by at least 40 horizontal feet. 3) Top The top of the building shall include all portions of each building façade above the ceiling plate of the highest occupied floor of the building and may at the applicants’ option also include the façade of the highest occupied floor of the building. On each façade of the building top, no roofline shall exceed 50 feet in horizontal length without a visual variation that incorporates: (a) Projections, recessions, and/or dormers that alter the vertical or horizontal plan of the roof by at least two feet; (b) Change in roof height of at least two feet; and/or (c) Distinct parapet designs and cornice treatments. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 222 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080A: Purpose c. Additional Studies 1) For new developments over 100 feet in height, the City will require additional studies of wind, sunlight, and/or shadow impacts on surrounding properties and rights-of-way, bicycle, and/or pedestrian facilities, at the applicant’s expense, if the Community Development Director determines that the proposed height, bulk, length, location, or shape of the proposed development will create adverse wind, sunlight/shadow, or public safety impacts. 2) Based on the results of a required study, the Community Development Director may require that building design features be added, deleted, or changed to minimize or mitigate those impacts to the maximum extent practicable, provided that no required change shall have the effect of reducing the gross floor area of the building below the maximum permitted on that lot. 5. Iconic Building Alternatives On development sites larger than five acres, or for a primary structure containing a Public, Institutional, or Civic use, the Community Development Director will waive or adjust the building design standards in Subsections 1, 2, and 3 to approve an alternative design for a single primary structure if the Director determines that the following criteria are met. a. The primary structure is in a highly visible location, or will be highly visible due to its height or massing, or will contain a Public, Institutional, or Civic primary use; and b. The alternative design will create equal or better visual interest, or will enhance the image of the City or the neighborhood where it is located as well or better than, a building design that complied with all applicable standards in Subsections 1, 2, and 3 above; and c. Any adverse impacts on surrounding properties created by the waiver or adjustment of standards in Subsections 1, 2, and 3 above have been mitigated to the maximum extent practicable. Section 60.400.080 P ARKING, L OADING, AND S TACKING A. Purpose This Section 60.400.080F.4.c is intended to regulate the amount and design of off-street parking and loading for different areas of the City and to help protect the public health, safety, and general welfare by: 1. Avoiding and mitigating traffic congestion; 2. Providing necessary access for service and emergency vehicles; 3. Providing for safe and convenient interaction between motor vehicles, bicycles, and pedestrians; 4. Encouraging multi-modal transportation options and enhanced pedestrian safety; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 223 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080B: Applicability 5. Providing flexibility to respond to the transportation, access, and loading impacts of various land uses in different areas of the City; and 6. Avoiding and mitigating the adverse visual impact of large concentrations of exposed parking. B. Applicability 1. General Applicability Any building, improvement, or use of land approved or erected after January 1, 1992, shall comply with the requirements of this Section 60.400.080 unless specifically stated otherwise in this UDC. 2. Exceptions The requirements of this Section 60.400.080 do not apply to: a. The adaptive reuse of a building in any Mixed Use district that does not involve any expansion of the building’s existing square footage. Any square footage additions resulting in increased building square footage are subject to the parking requirement of this Section 60.400.080. b. A Fast Food Restaurant, Neighborhood Food and Service, Standard Restaurant, Business or Personal Service, Neighborhood Retail, or Small Retail use containing no more than 2,000 square feet of floor area, occupying a ground floor building space fronting a public sidewalk, and providing direct pedestrian access from the public sidewalk. c. Development in the Medical Campus District. C. Compliance with Other City Ordinances Residential uses shall comply with the parking requirements in Section 11-10 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances. D. Calculation of Parking and Loading Requirements 1. Area Measurements All square footage-based parking and loading requirements shall be computed based on the gross floor area of the applicable use or structure, as applicable. Parking Garages within a building containing other primary uses shall not be included in that computation. 2. Parking and Loading for Multiple Uses a. Lots containing more than one use shall provide parking and loading in an amount equal to the total of the requirements for all uses. b. The total number of spaces may be reduced in accordance with Section 60.400.080F. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 224 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080E: Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required 3. Parking and Loading for Unlisted Uses For uses not expressly listed in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, the Community Development Director shall determine minimum parking requirements based on: a. Apply the minimum vehicle parking requirement in Table 400.08-1 for the listed use that is deemed most similar to the proposed use (based on operating characteristics, the most similar related occupancy classification, or other factors determined by the Community Development Director); b. Establish the minimum vehicle parking requirement by reference to parking resources published by the Institute of Traffic Engineers (ITE) or other acceptable source of parking demand data; or c. Establish the minimum vehicle parking requirement based on a Travel Demand Management Plan in accordance with Section 60.400.080F.9. E. Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required Unless otherwise provided in this UDC, each development shall provide a number of off- street parking spaces that complies with the requirements of Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required. Table 400.08-1 Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required DU = Dwelling Unit; BR = Bedroom; Sq. ft. = square feet of enclosed gross floor area (unless stated otherwise); Blank Cell or Use Not Listed = No Requirement Use All Districts Except the MX-D District MX-D District Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Residential Uses Household Living Dwelling, Single-Family 1 per DU 1 per DU Detached Dwelling, Twin-Home 1 per DU 1 per DU Dwelling, Attached 1 per DU 1.5 per DU 1 per DU 1.5 per DU Dwelling, Duplex, Same Lot 1 per DU 1 per DU Dwelling, Triplex 1 per DU 1 per DU Dwelling, Fourplex 1 per DU 1 per DU Dwelling, Multifamily 1 per 1 BR unit; 1 per 2 BR unit; 1.5 0.5 per DU 1.5 per DU 0.5 per DU per 3 BR unit; 2 per 4 BR unit or more Dwelling, Live/Work 0.75 per DU Dwelling, Cottage 1 per DU 2 per DU 1 per DU 1.5 per DU Development Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 225 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080E: Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required Table 400.08-1 Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required DU = Dwelling Unit; BR = Bedroom; Sq. ft. = square feet of enclosed gross floor area (unless stated otherwise); Blank Cell or Use Not Listed = No Requirement Use All Districts Except the MX-D District MX-D District Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Manufactured Home Park 1 per DU 2 per DU 1 per DU Group Living Congregate Housing 1 per 2 beds 1 per bed 1 per 3 beds 1 per 2 beds Dormitory 1 per 2 beds 1 per 3 beds 1.5 per bed Medical Stay Dwelling Unit 1 per DU 2 per DU Nursing Home 1 per 3 beds 1 per 2 beds 1 per 4 beds 1 per 2 beds Offender Transitional 1 per 3 beds 1 per 4 beds Housing Residential Care Facility 1 per 3 beds 1 per 2 beds 1 per 4 beds 1 per 3 beds Public, Institutional, and Civic Uses Art Gallery, Museum, and 1 per 500 sq. ft. 1 per 700 sq. ft. 1 per 800 sq. ft. Library (TOD) Cemetery College or University TDM Plan Required TDM Plan Required Community Center 2 per 1,000 sq. ft. 4 per 1,000 sq. ft. 2 per 1,000 sq. ft. 3 per 1,000 sq. ft. Correctional Facility 2.5 per 1,000 sq. ft. 5 per 1,000 sq. ft. Day Care Facility 2 per 1,000 sq. ft. 4 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Emergency Service 2.5 per 1,000 sq. ft. 5 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Funeral Home 2 per 1,000 sq. ft. 4 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. 3 per 1,000 sq. ft. Medical Facility 2 per 1,000 sq. ft. 4 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 3 beds Place of Worship 1 per 5 seats 1 per 4 seats School 1 per 10 seats in the auditorium or main assembly room, or 1 per classroom, whichever is greater Social Services 2.5 per 1,000 sq. ft. Specialized Education 3 per 1,000 sq. ft. 5 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Commercial Uses Agricultural and Animal Uses Agriculture Production No requirement Agriculture Retail No requirement Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 226 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080E: Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required Table 400.08-1 Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required DU = Dwelling Unit; BR = Bedroom; Sq. ft. = square feet of enclosed gross floor area (unless stated otherwise); Blank Cell or Use Not Listed = No Requirement Use All Districts Except the MX-D District MX-D District Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Veterinary and Animal 1 per 500 sq. ft. in Services excess of 4,000 sq. 2 per 1,000 sq. ft. ft. (minimum of 4 spaces) Entertainment and Recreation Adult Entertainment 1 per 400 sq. ft. in 1 per 500 sq. ft. in 1 per 400 sq. ft. in excess of 1,000 sq. excess of 4,000 sq. MX-T ft. ft. Auditorium or Civic Center 1 per 4 seats in 1 per 6 seats 1 per 6 seats MX-T Campgrounds or RV Park 1 per overnight site Indoor Entertainment or 1 per 400 sq. ft. in 1 per 500 sq. ft. in 1 per 200 sq. ft. in Recreation excess of 1,000 sq. excess of 4,000 sq. MX-T ft. ft. Indoor Gun Range 1 per 3 persons based on maximum capacity Outdoor Entertainment or 1 per 4 persons Recreation based on max capacity Food, Beverage, and Lodging Bar or Tavern 1 per 400 sq. ft. 1 per 200 sq. ft. 1 per 400 sq. ft. 1 per 300 sq. ft. Bed and Breakfast 1 per each guest 1 per 2 guest rooms 1 per guest room room Fast Food Restaurant 1 per 200 sq. ft. 1 per 150 sq. ft. 1 per 250 sq. ft. Hotel or Motel 1 per guest room 1 per guest room 1 per 2 guest rooms Neighborhood Food and 1 per 300 sq. ft. Service Standard Restaurant 1 per 350 sq. ft. 1 per 250 sq. ft. 1 per 450 sq. ft. 1 per 250 sq. ft. Office, Business, and Professional Services Art Studio and Workshop 1 per 600 sq. ft. in 1 per 800 sq. ft. in excess of 1,000 sq excess of 4,000 sq. 1 per 500 sq. ft. ft. ft. Business or Personal 1 per 600 sq. ft. in 1 per 500 sq. ft. in Service excess of 1,000 sq. excess of 4,000 sq. 1 per 300 sq. ft. 1 per 100 sq. ft. ft. ft. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 227 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080E: Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required Table 400.08-1 Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required DU = Dwelling Unit; BR = Bedroom; Sq. ft. = square feet of enclosed gross floor area (unless stated otherwise); Blank Cell or Use Not Listed = No Requirement Use All Districts Except the MX-D District MX-D District Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Financial Institution 1 per 500 sq. ft. in 1 per 600 sq. ft. excess of 4,000 sq. ft. Office 1 per 500 sq. ft. in 1 per 500 sq. ft. 1 per 400 sq. ft. excess of 4,000 sq. 1 per 300 sq. ft. ft. Research and Testing 1 per 1,500 sq. ft. 1 per 400 sq. ft. 1 per 1,500 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Retail Sales Retail, Neighborhood 1 per 200 sq. ft. 1 per 300 sq. ft. 1 per 300 sq. ft. 1 per 200 sq. ft. Retail, Small 1 per 250 sq. ft. 1 per 400 sq. ft. 1 per 500 sq. ft. 1 per 300 sq. ft. Retail, Medium 1 per 300 sq. ft.; 1 per 500 sq. ft. in Except 1 per 600 1 per 300 sq. ft. excess of 4,000 sq. 1 per 300 sq. ft. sq. ft. in MX-T ft. Retail, Large 1 per 500 sq. ft. in 1 per 400 sq. ft. 1 per 300 sq. ft. excess of 4,000 sq. 1 per 300 sq. ft. ft. Vehicles and Transportation Automotive Center 2 per service bay 3 per service bay plus 1 per 500 sq. plus 1 per 200 sq. ft. of retail sales ft. of retail area area Automotive Repair 2 per service bay 2 per service bay Services, Major plus 1 per 600 sq. plus 1 per 300 sq. ft. of retail sales ft. of retail area area Fueling Station 1 per 250 sq. ft. of 1 per 400 sq. ft. of retail sales area retail sales area Motor Freight and Warehousing Motor Vehicle Sales, 1 per 500 sq. ft. of Leasing, or Storage indoor sales or leasing space (excluding areas used only for indoor vehicle storage) Public Transportation Dispatch Facility Manufacturing, Processing, and Commercial Services Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 228 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080E: Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required Table 400.08-1 Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required DU = Dwelling Unit; BR = Bedroom; Sq. ft. = square feet of enclosed gross floor area (unless stated otherwise); Blank Cell or Use Not Listed = No Requirement Use All Districts Except the MX-D District MX-D District Minimum Maximum Minimum Maximum Artisan Manufacturing 1 per 400 sq. ft. in 1 per 500 sq. ft. in excess of 1,000 sq. excess of 4,000 sq. 1 per 700 sq. ft. ft. ft. Heavy Commercial 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Services Heavy Industry 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Light Industry 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 1,200 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. Recycling Transfer Facility 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. 1 per 700 sq. ft. Repair and Maintenance 2 per repair bay 2 per repair bay Shop plus 1 per 600 sq. plus 1 per 1,000 sq. 1 per 1,000 sq. ft. ft. ft. Storage and, Distribution, and Wholesaling Junkyard Self Service Storage 1 per 10 indoor 1 per 10 indoor 1 per 5 indoor Facility storage units storage units storage units Wholesale Facility 1 per 1,200 sq. ft., 1 per 1,200 sq. ft., 1 per 700 sq. ft. plus plus 1 per vehicle plus 1 per vehicle 1 per vehicle normally stored on normally stored on normally stored or the site the site parked on site Resource and Extraction Landfill Quarry Sand or Gravel Excavation Accessory Uses and Structures Animal Husbandry 1 per 700 sq. ft. Drive-in Facility See Section 60.400.080L.3 Residential Management or 1 per 400 sq. ft. in 1 per 500 sq. ft. Sales Office MX-T Temporary Uses Carnival or Festival Determine on case-Determine on case- by-case basis at by-case basis at time of temporary time of temporary use permit use permit Contractor’s Office and 1 per 500 sq. ft. 1 per 700 sq. ft. Yard Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 229 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080F: Minimum Parking Adjustments F. Minimum Parking Adjustments 1. General a. Unless stated otherwise in this Section 60.400.080F, the required off-street parking spaces required by Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, shall be adjusted in accordance with this Section 60.400.080F. b. Regardless of which adjustments in this Section are applied, required off-street parking spaces for Residential uses, as shown in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table, shall not be reduced by more than 20 percent of the minimum amount required by Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required. c. Regardless of which adjustments in this Section are applied, required off-street parking spaces for any land uses not listed as residential land uses in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table shall not be reduced by more than 40 percent of the minimum amount required by Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required. d. All listed adjustments may be approved administratively, except for adjustments based on a TDM Plan, which shall be reviewed by, and may be approved by, the Planning Commission. 2. Minimum Parking Reduction for Uses Located in the MX-T The number of off-street parking spaces for all uses may be reduced up to 20% when located in the MX-T. 3. Shared Parking Where two or more uses listed in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table share a Parking Lot or Garage, the total off-street parking requirement for those uses shown in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, may be reduced by the factors shown in Table 400.08-2 Shared Parking Reduction below. If only two primary uses of land are sharing the parking, the total off-street parking required shall be the sum of the two parking requirements for the two uses divided by the factors for that combination of uses shown in Table 400.08-2 Shared Parking Reduction. If more than two uses share a parking lot or structure, the required parking shall be calculated by applying Table 400.08-2 Shared Parking Reduction below to the two uses with the largest parking requirements and then adding the required parking as shown in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, for the additional uses. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 230 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080F: Minimum Parking Adjustments Table 400.08-2 Shared Parking Reduction Add the requirements in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, and divide by the factors shown below. Food, Public, Beverage, Multifamily Other Property Use Institutional, Indoor Retail Dwellings Commercial or Civic Entertainment , or Lodging Multifamily Dwellings 1.0 Public, Institutional, or 1.1 1.0 Civic Food, Beverage, Indoor Entertainment, 1.1 1.2 1.0 or Lodging Retail 1.2 1.3 1.3 1.0 Other Commercial 1.3 1.5 1.7 1.2 1.0 4. Student Housing Reduction Dwelling units in a new residential development that are restricted solely to the residency and occupancy of students of an accredited educational facility with a physical campus within the municipal boundaries of the City are not required to provide off-street parking for dwelling units during the period of time the student residency restriction is in effect. For every 10 dwelling units that receive the exemption from providing off-street parking, at least one off-street parking space for the use of visitors to the dwelling units must be provided on site. 5. Public Parking Availability Reduction a. On-Street Parking Spaces Public, metered on-street parking spaces lying adjacent, in whole or in part, to the property line of the zoning lot for a new development with a non-residential land use that must provide off-street parking may count the adjacent metered on street spaces as all or part of the required off-street parking spaces. b. In a Garage The number of off-street accessory parking spaces for any non-residential use may be reduced by 10 percent if the new non-residential use is on a lot that lies within 500 feet of a publicly owned Parking Garage, as measured from the nearest point on the property line of the lot where the Parking Garage is located to the nearest point on the property line of the lot where the non-residential use requiring off-street parking is located. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 231 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080F: Minimum Parking Adjustments 6. Transit-Related Reductions a. Transit Proximity The number of required off-street parking spaces for residential uses may be reduced by 10 percent if the lot where the new residential development is located is within 660 feet of a signed bus stop or bus shelter serving a weekday bus route. b. Transit Improvement The number of required off-street parking spaces for non-residential uses may be reduced by ten percent if the Public Works Director determines that new development provides an adequately designed, sheltered transit stop within the development, in a location that will promote transit use in the City. This reduction shall not be awarded for that are detached from the principal structure on the site and located in the public right-of-way. 7. Shared Car Reduction A reduction in the number of required Residential off-street parking spaces may be granted if a shared or community vehicle is available for use by residents of a new residential development. Where one or more passenger vehicles are available on-site with an established procedure for private use by residents, the minimum parking requirement for a Residential use may be reduced by an additional 20 percent provided there are no more than 75 residential dwelling units per shared vehicle. 8. Ground Floor Retail Development Reduction New mixed use developments that include a ground-floor Retail Sales type use or a Fast Food Restaurant, Neighborhood Food and Service, or Standard Restaurant use may reduce their parking requirement by 10 percent. The use must front a public street and have pedestrian access from the street. 9. Travel Demand Management Plan a. Purpose A Travel Demand Management (TDM) Plan allows flexibility for uses that have widely varying parking and loading demand characteristics that make it difficult to specify a single off-street parking or loading standard. b. Applicability Applicants may submit a TDM Plan for any new development in any district. The City may require a TDM Plan for new developments with over 25,000 square feet gross floor area or as otherwise stated in this Section 60.400.080F.9. c. Standards The TDM Plan shall estimate parking demand for the proposed use based on the recommendations of the Institute of Traffic Engineers (ITE), Urban Land Institute, the International Council of Shopping Centers, the American Planning Association, or Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 232 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080G: Maximum Parking Adjustments other acceptable sources of parking demand data for uses and/or combinations of uses of comparable activities, scale, bulk, area, and location. d. Procedure The Planning Commission shall review each TDM Plan and may adjust the minimum and maximum parking standards in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, as adjusted by any other provisions of this UDC, based on information contained in the TDM Plan, subject to the limitation in Subsection 1.b above. G. Maximum Parking Adjustments 1. The provision of parking spaces beyond the maximum specified in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, may be allowed where public parking is proposed as a replacement for existing public parking removed as part of a redevelopment plan or where the City has by agreement secured spaces for public parking in a parking structure built as part of a new private development. 2. Uses in existence as of January 1, 2023 having more off-street parking spaces than the maximum number specified in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, are permitted to continue to legally use all available parking spaces and shall not be considered non-conforming because of the excess number of parking spaces. H. Visitor Parking 1. In all zoning districts except the R-2x, MX-T, and MX-D districts, new developments containing any combination of Single-Family Detached and Attached and/or Multifamily Dwellings, shall provide visitor parking in addition to the required off-street parking for each dwelling unit based on the requirements in Table 400.08-3 Visitor Parking Requirements. Required visitor parking may be provided on-street, off- street, in any type of permitted shared Parking Lot or Garage, or in parking bays designed as part of the original development. 2. All proposed subdivisions shall be reviewed for consistency with these requirements during the subdivision approval, and all other developments shall be reviewed during Site Development Plan approval. Table 400.08-3 Visitor Parking Requirements Residential Use Spillover Parking Spaces Required Single-Family Detached Dwelling 0.1 per dwelling unit Attached Dwelling 0.25 per dwelling unit Multifamily Dwelling 0.2 per dwelling unit 0-50 units 0.1 per dwelling unit 51+ units Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 233 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080I: Small Car Percentage I. Small Car Percentage In any Parking Lot or Garage providing over five spaces a percentage of the total spaces may be designed and marked for small cars according to Table 400.08-4 Small Car Percentage. Table 400.08-4 Small Car Percentage Maximum Percentage of Small Car Total Space Required Spaces 5-99 30% 100-149 40% 150 and more 50% J. Design and Location of Vehicle Parking 1. Accessible Parking The number and design of accessible parking spaces shall be pursuant to the International Building Code (IBC). 2. Dimensions of Parking Spaces and Drive Aisles All on-site parking and maneuvering areas shall be constructed according to the following dimensional standards. a. All parking aisles shall terminate with a bump-out for turnaround maneuverability. b. The length of a parking stall may be reduced allowing the front of vehicles to overhang the required parking space to the extent shown in Table 400.08-5, provided that: 1) Any raised curb in the overhang areas is no more than four inches in height; and 2) The front of the parking space is located adjacent to a landscaped area or sidewalk that is at least six feet in width. c. Parking space dimensions shall meet the requirements of Table 400.08 5 Parking Dimension Requirements unless specifically stated otherwise in this Section. Table 400.08-5 Parking Dimension Requirements (in feet) Two Rows of Two Rows of Parking Two-Way Parking One-Way Overhang Angle Stall Length Accessed Module Accessed Aisle Reduction from One-Width from Two- Way Aisle Way Aisle 30° 15 11 41 20 50 1.3 45° 17.6 12 47 20 55 1.9 Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 234 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080J: Design and Location of Vehicle Parking Two Rows of Two Rows of Parking Two-Way Parking One-Way Overhang Angle Stall Length Accessed Module Accessed Aisle Reduction from One-Width from Two- Way Aisle Way Aisle 60° 19 13.6 51.6 21 59 2.2 90° 18 20 56 23 59 2.6 3. Access a. A Parking Lot or Garage shall be designed to ensure safe and easy ingress, egress, and movement through the interior of the lot. b. Vehicular entrance drives shall be located and designed to minimize interference with pedestrians. 4. Location a. For Single-Family Detached and Same Lot Duplex Dwelling uses in all districts, off- street parking areas shall be located in a garage or on a driveway. Parking spaces that are located between the building façade and the front lot line, and that are not located in a permitted driveway parking area, are prohibited. b. For all other uses in an Agricultural and Residential and Mixed Use district, off-street parking areas shall not be located between the front building façade and the adjacent street frontage. c. Required off-street parking and loading shall be located on the same lot as the principal use except that: 1) In the MX-T and MX-D districts; (a) Parking for residents or employees may be provided within 600 feet of the site. (b) Parking for customers, visitors and patrons may be provided within; (i) 600 feet in the MX-T or; (ii) 1000 feet in the MX-D (c) Parking for employees of on-site businesses may be provided on-site or accommodated outside the MX-D or MX-T area at a remote park and ride facility where connecting service by public transit or private shuttle are arranged for use of on-site employees. 2) Up to 25 percent of required parking for a residential use in the MX-I, MX-T, or MX-D districts may be provided within 500 feet of the site containing the non- residential use. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 235 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080J: Design and Location of Vehicle Parking 3) Up to 50 percent of required off-street parking for any non-residential use in any district other than the MX-D district may be provided within 600 feet of the site containing the non-residential use. 4) Parking locations for the MX-D district shall comply with Section 60.400.080J.5, Location Requirements in the MX-D District. 5) As a condition of approval of off-site parking pursuant to Subsections 1 or 2 above, the applicant shall provide to the City evidence of the availability of the off-street parking for the exclusive use of the applicant’s residential or non- residential land use. d. To the maximum extent practicable, accessory parking shall be located at the rear of the principal building with access from an alley or if constructed as part of the principal building behind the front façade of the principal building. e. If is not feasible to locate the Parking Lot or Garage to the rear of the principal building, the parking may be located to one side of the principal building. A Parking Lot or Garage located to one side of a principal building shall be no more than 60 feet in width (not including any required landscape buffer areas) measured from the side wall of the principal building. f. If the principal building and Parking Lot or Garage is situated on a corner lot, the parking must be located to allow the principal building to be built to both the front and side-street property lines. A portion of the Parking Lot or Garage may front along the side-street lot line when situated behind the rear wall (or parallel extension thereof) of the principal building on the lot and subject to any other identified design features, setback, buffering, screening, and landscaping. g. Notwithstanding any MX-T district requirements, a new or expanded Parking Lot or Garage shall not abut any of the seven “active/pedestrian streets” shown on the Map below. A parking Lot or Garage is not considered to be abutting a street frontage if it is separated from the street property line by a principal building that is at least 15 feet in depth, one story above the sidewalk grade, and at least as wide as the parking facility on the lot. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 236 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080J: Design and Location of Vehicle Parking 5. Location Requirements in the MX-D District The following additional location requirements apply in the MX-D district. a. Parking for residents and short term, high turnover users such as visitors, guests, customers, or patrons may be provided off-site from the primary use. b. Parking for long-term, low turnover users such as employees of on-site businesses may be provided on-site or accommodated outside of the immediate area where the use is located at a remote park and ride facility where connecting service by public transit or private shuttle is arranged for use of on-site employees. c. Private parking facilities for off-site contract parking of employees of businesses or organizations in the MX-D district may not be constructed in the MX-D district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 237 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080J: Design and Location of Vehicle Parking 6. Additional Driveway Parking in Residential Districts a. In a side yard if the yard is at least eight feet in width and the parking area is paved. b. In the required front yard or side street side yard on an established driveway. All driveways must lead to a garage or to off-street parking spaces that meet the provision of this UDC. c. One additional space may be provided outside of the driveway if the following conditions are met: 1) The space is covered by pavement. Paving may include impervious surfaces (excluding gravel), concrete, bituminous, and Hollywood driveways (parallel paved tracks separated by a grass strip). 2) The space is not in that part of the required front yard or side street yard in front of the dwelling located upon the lot. 3) The parking space does not cover more than 20% of the front yard or side street side yard. 4) Access to the space is from the driveway and not the result of a separate or wider driveway approach. 5) The space is landscaped along the side away from the established driveway with a minimum of five shrubs meeting the requirements of this UDC. There must be adequate area between the driveway and the side lot line to allow room for the shrubs to grow on the property. 7. Stormwater Drainage a. Parking Lots shall be constructed such that all surface water is directed into a landscape bump out, island, or endcap. b. For all new Parking Lots containing 12 or more spaces, the following best management practices shall be used to improve stormwater infiltration and water quality: 1) Permeable pavement materials shall be installed. If such materials are the only practice employed from this list, then they shall cover at least 25 percent of the total Parking Lot area; 2) Treatments such as culvert outfalls, bioretention basins, or vegetated swales shall be installed; or 3) Other combinations of best management practices for stormwater infiltration and water quality subject to approval by the Community Development Director and Public Works Director. c. Water drainage from a Parking Lot shall not flow across a sidewalk. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 238 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080J: Design and Location of Vehicle Parking 8. Lighting a. The following requirements apply to Parking Lots, Parking Garages, and accessory parking facilities in the zoning districts and for the uses listed below. All references to land uses or categories of land uses refer to those shown in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table. 1) Multifamily Dwellings in all districts; 2) All Group Living uses except for Residential Care Facilities in structures that would be exempt from these standards if they were occupied by a Household Living use, as shown in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table; 3) Public, Institutional, and Civic uses in all districts except the SI district; 4) Commercial and Industrial uses in all districts except the SI district; and 5) Mixed use developments (i.e., those containing a mix of primary residential and non-residential uses) in all districts except the SI district b. Any exterior lighting provided for a Parking Lot or Garage shall use full-cutoff luminaires. If pole mounted, the maximum height of the luminaire shall be 18 feet with a maximum permitted illumination of one foot-candle at the property line. c. The light source of the luminaires used for interior lighting in a Parking Lot or Garage shall be completely shielded from view by persons standing anywhere within the adjacent street right-of-way. 9. Electric Vehicle Charging Parking areas with more than 50 parking spaces shall provide a minimum of one parking space dedicated to electric vehicles for every 25 parking spaces provided on site. The provision of three of fewer electric vehicle parking spaces shall not count toward the maximum allowed number of parking spaces. The provision of four or more electric vehicle parking spaces shall count toward the maximum allowed number of parking spaces. The electric vehicle parking space shall be: a. Located on the same lot as the principal use; b. Signed in a clear and conspicuous manner indicating exclusive availability to electric vehicles; and c. Outfitted with a standard “Level 2” electric vehicle charging station. 10. Parking Garage Design Requirements The following additional design standards apply to Parking Garages in all districts. a. Height and Depth Requirements In order to allow for possible future conversion to non-parking uses, street facing ground floor frontages of Parking Garages shall have a minimum height of 12 feet and shall be designed so that a minimum horizontal distance of 22 feet from each Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 239 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080K: Use of Vehicle Parking street-facing façade is not occupied by structural columns or driving aisles required to access parking spaces. b. Upper Floor Screening Street-facing façades above the ground floor of a Parking Garage shall screen vehicles by partial walls, windows, or other screening devices constructed of similar building materials as the primary structure and not less than three feet in height so that lower portions of vehicles are not visible from adjacent public streets. 11. Pedestrian Walkways Where a building façade providing customer or patron access is 400 feet in length or greater, walkways from building entrances or sidewalks adjacent to the building shall be extended into on-site parking areas at a rate of one per 250 feet of building façade and shall extend into the parking area a minimum of one-third of the depth of the parking lot area. 12. Parking Lot Landscaping Standards on Parking Lot landscaping can be found in Section 60.400.060, Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences. K. Use of Vehicle Parking 1. Off-street parking shall be improved and available for use at the time of final building inspection when a use or structure is first occupied, enlarged, or increased in capacity. When a change in use is proposed, the Community Development Director shall review the site layout in relation to the new use to ensure adequate off-street parking is available. 2. Off-street parking shall be permitted only in areas designed and maintained for such use consistent with the requirements of this Section 60.400.080. 3. Areas designated for off-street parking shall not be used for the open storage of goods or the commercial repair of vehicles. 4. Automotive vehicles or trailers without current legal license plates or that are inoperable shall not be stored or parked in any Parking Lot in any Agricultural or Residential District unless in a completely enclosed building. 5. Automotive vehicles or trailers without current legal license plates or that are inoperable shall not be stored or parked on any public right-of-way in any Agricultural or Residential District. 6. Excess, existing accessory off-street parking spaces no longer needed to comply with this Section 60.400.080, may not be converted to a commercial parking facility with more than four parking spaces, unless the conversion is approved as an interim use in accordance with Section 60.500.040NL, Interim Use Permit. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 240 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080L: Loading and Stacking Areas L. Loading and Stacking Areas 1. Number and Size of Loading Berths Required a. Loading berths shall meet the requirements of Table 400.08-6 Required Off-Street Loading Berths. b. The minimum turning radius for truck traffic areas to access a loading berth shall be 40 feet. c. A minimum stacking distance of 40 feet shall be provided at all ingress/egress access drives intersecting with a street. d. Variations from these standards may be approved by the Community Development Director based on information provided by the applicant demonstrating that the vehicle loading operations of the proposed use differ from the standards in Table 400.08-6 Required Off-Street Loading Berths or from those otherwise required by this Section 60.400.080. Table 400.08-6 Required Off-Street Loading Berths Number of Loading Berths Size of Each Loading Berth Gross Floor Area in Sq. Ft. Required Required N/A Less than 10,000 None 10 feet x 25 feet 10,000 -- 29,999 1 12 feet x 50 feet 30,000 -- 100,000 2 2, plus 1 additional loading berth for 14 feet wide x 50 feet long x 14 feet 100,000 and More every 100,000 sq. ft. beyond the first high 100,000 sq. ft. 2. Location of On-Site Loading Areas a. Required off-street loading spaces shall not be located in any front yard or in any required street side yard. b. Off-street loading spaces may occupy all or any part of a required rear yard where visibility from public streets and windows of neighboring buildings will be minimized. c. Loading berths and access routes to loading berths shall not interfere with Parking Lot or Parking Garage maneuvering areas or with designated on-site patron drop- off/pick-up locations. d. State and City streets or rights-of-way shall not be used for loading and unloading purposes without prior City approval of a revocable permit. 3. Vehicle Stacking Areas a. All uses with an entry gate, guard house, or drive-through shall provide the minimum number of on-site stacking spaces indicated in Table 400.08-7 Minimum Vehicle Stacking Space Required. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 241 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking Section 60.400.080M: Bicycle Parking Table 400.08-7 Minimum Vehicle Stacking Space Required All Other Areas Use MX-T and MX-D Districts Automotive Center 3 Spaces 5 Spaces Food, Beverage, and Lodging 3 Spaces 5 Spaces Uses Financial Institutions 2 Spaces 3 Spaces Other Uses 2 Spaces 3 Spaces b. Stacking spaces shall comply with Section 60.400.020F, Neighborhood Protection Standards, as applicable. c. Required parking spaces shall be designed and located to avoid interference with maneuvering into parking spaces or traffic flow in parking aisles, streets, bikeways, multi-use paths, sidewalks, or patron pick-up/drop-off areas. d. The site design for Outdoor Entertainment or Recreation uses such as stadiums with on-site parking shall provide stacking space for inbound vehicles equal to the area needed to handle three percent of the number of vehicles anticipated at full capacity of the seating area (assuming four persons per vehicle), unless the Road Authority has agreed that use of streets in the area for stacking is suitable. M. Bicycle Parking This Section 60.400.080M applies to developments over one acre in size or Site Development Plans for individual buildings containing more than 40,000 square feet. The Community Development Director will waive or adjust the requirements of this subsection if a particular use, project, district, or location does not warrant the bicycle parking in the amount specified below. 1. Minimum Amount Required a. Developments over one acre in size, new or expanded developments in the MX-D and MX-T districts, or Site Development Plans for individual buildings containing more than 40,000 square feet of gross floor area shall provide bicycle parking at a rate of one bicycle space per 10 vehicle spaces required for the proposed land use(s) as shown in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, without any reductions permitted or approved by Section 60.400.080F, Minimum Parking Adjustments, with a minimum of 10 bicycle parking spaces required. b. Developments over five acres in size, new or expanded developments in the MX-D and MX-T districts, or Site Development Plans for individual buildings containing more than 80,000 square feet of gross floor area shall provide bicycle parking at a rate of one bicycle space per 10 vehicle spaces required for the proposed land use(s) as shown in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, for the first 50 vehicle spaces, and then at a rate of one per 20 vehicle spaces thereafter. A minimum of 10 bicycle parking spaces are required, and no reductions are permitted based on any approval granted through Section 60.400.080F, Minimum Parking Adjustments. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 242 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.090 Exterior Storage Section 60.400.090A: Purpose c. When Subsections a or b require the provision of more than 20 bicycle parking spaces, at least 10 percent of the required bicycle parking spaces shall be long-term spaces. A long-term space is one that is located inside the primary structure containing the primary use for which the parking is provided, in an area of that building that is secured or generally accessible to tenants and occupants of the building and not to the general public, or is located outside that structure but in an enclosed container or structure protected from the weather in which the bicycle may be locked by the owner of the bicycle. 2. Bicycle Parking Location, Design, and Circulation a. Bicycle parking shall be located within 100 feet of a primary building entrance along a walkway adjacent to the building or within an abutting parking area where connected to a primary building entrance via a walkway. b. Bicycle parking facilities shall be designed to allow the bicycle frame and both wheels to be securely locked to the parking structure. The structure shall be of permanent construction such as heavy gauge tubular steel with angle bars permanently attached to the pavement. c. Bicycle parking areas shall be sized and designed so that locked bicycles do not encroach over sidewalks, walkways, required open space, required landscape areas, required usable recreation areas, private streets, or public rights-of-way. Section 60.400.090 E XTERIOR S TORAGE A. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.090 is to regulate the visual effect that uncontrolled storage of trash, merchandise, materials, or equipment can have when viewed from adjacent properties or adjacent public rights-of-way. B. Requirements in Agricultural and Residential Districts The following requirements apply to all Agricultural and Residential districts. 1. All waste, debris, or garbage shall be kept in an enclosed building or closed container designed for such purpose. 2. All materials, machinery, and equipment shall be stored within a building or be fully screened so as not to be visible from adjoining properties, except for the following when kept in good order: a. Laundry drying; b. Recreational equipment; c. Construction and landscaping materials and equipment currently being used on the premises; d. Agricultural materials and equipment, if intended for use on the property; e. Off-street parking of passenger vehicles and pickup trucks; and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 243 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.100 Exterior Lighting Section 60.400.090C: Requirements in Mixed Use and Non- Residential Districts f. The storage of firewood. C. Requirements in Mixed Use and Non-Residential Districts The following requirements apply to all Mixed Use and Non-Residential districts. 1. Trash storage shall be enclosed within a structure, or an adequate outside area shall be set aside for trash storage and shown on the Site Development Plan. 2. For non-residential uses in the MX-N zoning district trash shall be stored within an enclosed building. 3. All outdoor storage or containers shall be placed on a hard surface such as concrete and shall be aesthetically screened by a permanent fence, wall, or landscaping from adjacent properties and rights-of-way. 4. All outdoor storage and outdoor equipment, except for for-sale items, are prohibited when adjacent to or abutting a residential district. 5. Outdoor storage of items for sale are exempt from screening requirements, provided they do not face a Residential district or Residential use. This includes but is not limited to; firewood, lawn care products, propane, road salt, and sand. Section 60.400.100 E XTERIOR L IGHTING A. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.100 is to protect and promote the public health, safety, and welfare by permitting reasonable uses of exterior lighting. The standards are further intended to: 1. Reduce excessive and unnecessary use of lighting; 2. Minimize light pollution, glare, and light trespass; 3. Maintain nighttime safety, security, and enjoyment of property; 4. Curtail the degradation of nighttime visual environment; and 5. Minimize disturbance to sensitive plants and animals. B. Applicability 1. General Applicability All uses in all districts shall meet the requirements of this Section 60.400.100 unless specifically stated otherwise in this UDC. 2. Exceptions The requirements of this Section 60.400.100 do not apply to ball diamonds, playing fields, and tennis courts. Lighting for these uses shall be shielded to prevent light and glare from spilling over onto adjacent residential properties. The maximum permitted illumination at the property line shall not exceed one foot candle if the abutting property Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 244 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.100 Exterior Lighting Section 60.400.100C: Lighting for Parking Lots and Garages is located in a Residential district, and shall not exceed two foot candles if the abutting property is located in a Mixed Use or Non-Residential district. C. Lighting for Parking Lots and Garages Parking Lots and Garages shall comply with applicable standards in Section 60.400.080J.8, Lighting. D. Method of Measurement Lighting levels shall be measured in foot candles with a meter sensor mounted not more than six inches above ground level in a horizontal position at the property line. Readings shall be taken only after the cell has been exposed long enough to provide a constant reading. Measurements shall be made after dark with the light sources in question on, then with the same sources off. The difference between the two readings shall be compared to the maximum permitted illumination specified in this Section 60.400.100 for the type of luminaire used. E. General Requirements 1. Prohibited Lights a. Laser, strobe, flickering, or flashing lights is prohibited. b. Tower lighting is not unless required by the Federal Aviation Administration. c. Neon lighting and exposed strip lighting used to illuminate building facades, or used to outline or detail buildings, windows, or doors, or used to illuminate, outline, or detail service canopies is prohibited in or adjacent to any Residential district. d. When neon lighting or exposed strip lighting is used for any purpose, it must not be combined with or mounted near any reflective materials such as mirrors, shiny metals, highly glazed tiles, or other materials that would result in reflective glare. 2. Intensity a. The total light output must not exceed 50,000 lumens per acre as measured at the light source. b. The maximum intensity per light pole must not exceed 5,000 lumens as measured at the light source. c. The maximum illumination at any one location on the property must not exceed 15 foot candles. 3. Location Light sources or luminaires shall not be located within bufferyards except along Walkways, Sidewalks, Bikeways, or Multi-Use Trails. 4. Internal Lighting a. All internal luminaires that illuminate a window area that is viewable at the property line must be designed so that the light bulb, lamp, or light source is completely Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 245 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.100 Exterior Lighting Section 60.400.100F: Luminaire Mounting shielded from direct view of an observer standing at the property line measured at a point five feet above grade. b. Illumination for windows shall not exceed 2,000 lumens. c. On each property with a primary non-residential use, all internal luminaires that are viewable at the property line with a light intensity greater than 1,000 lumens, must be designed so that the light bulb, lamp, or light source is completely shielded from the direct view of an observer standing at the property line measured at a point five feet above grade. 5. Hours of Operation Exterior lighting shall observe the same hours of operation as the use itself as stated in Section 60.300.020, Use-Specific Standards, except that a minimum level of lighting for security purposes may be left on beyond the normal hours of operation. 6. Pedestrian-Oriented Lighting On-site or building-mounted pedestrian-oriented lighting providing at least four-foot candles at ground level with lighting level uniformity, average to minimum, shall be 2:1 or better. 7. Visibility Triangle In any district that requires a front or side street building setback, there shall be no sight- obscuring or partly obscuring lighting between three and six feet above curb grade in any Visibility Triangle. Vertical measurement shall be made from the top of the curb on the street adjacent to the nearest street of the triangle or, if no curb exists, from the edge of the nearest traveled way. F. Luminaire Mounting All wall, canopy, and pole-mounted luminaires must be installed at parallel to the ground (90 degrees from vertical). G. Maximum Permitted Illumination and Height 1. Exterior lighting shall meet the requirements of Table 400.10-1 Maximum Permitted Illumination and Height. Table 400.10-1 Maximum Permitted Illumination and Height Maximum Illumination Maximum Height Agricultural Agricultural Type of Cutoff on Non-Non- or Mixed Use or Mixed Use Luminaire Residential Residential Residential District Residential District District District District District 0.2 Not Not Not footcandles No cutoff \[1\] 10 feet Not permitted permitted permitted 3,000 Kelvin permitted Cutoff angle greater 0.2 Not Not Not Not 15 feet than 90 degrees \[1\] footcandles permitted permitted permitted permitted Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 246 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110A: Purpose Table 400.10-1 Maximum Permitted Illumination and Height Maximum Illumination Maximum Height Agricultural Agricultural Type of Cutoff on Non-Non- or Mixed Use or Mixed Use Luminaire Residential Residential Residential District Residential District District District District District 3,000 Kelvin 2.0 2.0 1.0 footcandle Cutoff angle less than footcandles footcandles 18 feet 30 feet 30 feet 90° \[2\] \[5\] 3,000 Kelvin 3,000 Kelvin 4,100 Kelvin NOTES \[1\] Luminaires with no cutoff and lights with a total cutoff angle of greater than 90 degrees are only allowed for single family or two-family dwellings, and shall not exceed 1,000 lumens. \[2\]Luminaires with a total cutoff of light of less than 90 degree shall be designed so that the bare light bulb, lamp, or source is completely shielded from the direct view of an observer standing at the property line at a point five feet above grade. 2. For all luminaires, the maximum luminous intensity (in candelas) at or above any angle of 90 degrees above vertical is zero, and the maximum luminous intensity (in candelas) at or above a vertical angle of 80 degrees above vertical must not exceed 10 percent of the luminous flux of the lamp or lamps in the luminaire. Section 60.400.110 S IGNS A. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.400.110 is to promote the public health, safety, and welfare of the City by establishing comprehensive standards, regulations, and procedures governing the erection, use, and display of devices serving as visual communications media. These standards are further intended to: 1. Promote and preserve aesthetics and to allow citizens to enjoy the natural scenic beauty of the City; 2. Minimize distractions and obstructions for drivers, bicyclists, and pedestrians; 3. Preserve property values and the neighborhood character within the City; 4. Balance the needs for signs and the impacts of signs by establishing minimum standards related to the use, location, and intensity of zoning districts and land uses; and 5. Comply with all applicable laws, statutes, regulations, and state and federal court decisions regarding free speech in the context of regulation of signs, and not to engage in any form of content-based regulation of sign messages prohibited by state or federal constitutions, statutes, or applicable court decisions. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 247 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110B: Applicability B. Applicability 1. This Section 60.400.110 shall govern all signs located in the City to the extent that they are not preempted by the requirements set forth in the Minnesota Outdoor Advertising Control Act, Minn. Stat. 173.01 et. Seq. and the Federal Highway Beautification Act, 23 U.S.C. 131 et. Seq. governing the control and regulation of signs along state and federal highways or exempted by Section 60.400.110C. 2. Required sign permits shall be approved pursuant to Section 60.500.060KK, Sign Permit. 3. In the event of a conflict between the standards in this Section 60.400.110 and the standards in the Destination Medical Center Design Guidelines, the Design Guidelines apply. C. Signs Not Requiring a Permit The following types of signs are exempt from the Sign Permit process. 1. Any sign erected, maintained, required, or posted by the City, state, or federal government when erected and maintained pursuant to law or in the public interest. 2. Any sign inside a building not attached to a window or door that is not legible from a distance of more than three feet beyond the lot line of where the sign is located. 3. Murals and up to two Banner signs that are in compliance with applicable standards in Section 60.400.110H and Section 60.400.110I. 4. Any non-lighted sign not exceeding three feet in height and not exceeding three square feet in area that is oriented, located, and designed to be viewed by occupants or users of the property while on the property, and not to be generally legible from abutting streets or properties. 5. One non-lighted sign at each entrance to, and one non-lighted sign at each exit from, any lot containing the drive-through lane of an allowed Drive-in Facility in any Mixed Use district, provided the sign does not exceed three feet in height and does not exceed three square feet in area. 6. Signs located on allowed primary or accessory athletic fields designed and used for competitive sports, that are oriented, located, and designed for viewing by participants in and spectators of those competitive sports, and that do not have any lighted surface facing and located within 200 feet of any residential primary use in a Residential district. 7. Any sign affixed to an athletic facility structure (excluding fencing) in the MX-I district that does not exceed 2,400 square feet in area and does not result in more than 10,000 square feet in total sign area of all such signs per use. 8. Sound trucks or other moving advertising media while operated on a public right-of-way. 9. Signs under 12 inches in height to enable emergency personnel to accurately identify structures or locations. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 248 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110D: Signs Requiring a Permit 10. Any temporary sign in compliance with Minn. Stat. Ch. 211B.045. 11. Any temporary sign erected during any period a property or a portion of a property is actively listed for sale or lease and that does not exceed 24 square feet in area or four feet in height. 12. One temporary sign, located at a construction site or on a construction barricade, beginning on the date a building permit is issued and ending on the date on which the last initial certificate of occupancy related to that building permit is granted. a. In Residential districts that contain Household Living uses other than Multifamily Dwellings, the sign shall not exceed 16 square feet in area and shall not exceed four feet above grade. b. In Residential districts for all uses other than those subject to Subsection a above, the sign shall not exceed 36 square feet in area and shall not exceed six feet above grade. c. In Mixed Use and Non-Residential districts, this sign shall not exceed 64 square feet in area and shall not exceed 10 feet above grade. D. Signs Requiring a Permit 1. All signs erected, altered, or replaced within the City that are not listed in Section 60.400.110C require a Sign Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060KK. 2. Any lighted sign requires a Sign Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060KK. 3. A new permit consistent with the standards in this Section 60.400.110D is required each time: a. A new primary building is constructed; b. The gross floor area of an existing primary building is expanded by more than 50 percent; c. An existing primary building is improved or redeveloped, and the value of that work exceeds 50% of the value of the existing primary building, as shown in applicable property tax records; E. Prohibited Signs The following types of signs are prohibited. 1. Billboards that contain stacked multiple display faces. 2. Flashing, moving, or intermittently lighted signs in: a. Any Agricultural and Residential district; b. The MX-D Medical subdistrict; and c. Any Mixed Use or Non-Residential lot abutting or directly across from an Agricultural and Residential district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 249 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110F: Sign Standards 3. Any sign that is constructed to resemble an official marker erected by the City, state, or any governmental agency or that by reason of positioning, shape, or color would conflict with the proper functioning of any traffic sign or signal or would impair or cause confusion of vehicular or pedestrian traffic. 4. Any sign that contains any obscene wording or images. F. Sign Standards The following standards apply to all signs, including billboards. In the event of a conflict between these standards and those in Section 60.400.110G Billboards, the billboard standards apply. 1. Design and Safety Requirements a. No sign shall be placed so as to obstruct or interfere with a window, doorway, or fire escape. b. Signs shall not extend into the vertical space between three feet and six feet above curb grade within any Visibility Triangle. Vertical measurement shall be made from the top of the curb on the street adjacent to the nearest street of the triangle or, if no curb exists, from the edge of the nearest traveled way. c. No sign that is permitted to extend over a public right-of-way may have a lower edge less than nine feet above the grade level of the right-of-way, unless approved by the City Engineer based on considerations of public and traffic safety. d. All permanent signs shall be constructed to meet Building Code standards for wind resistance and wind loads. Signs shall be rigidly suspended by means of fastening or support so as not to be free swinging nor a menace to persons or property. e. Signs illuminated by electricity or equipped in any way with electrical devices shall conform to the provisions of the electrical code. f. Adequate provisions shall be made for grounding metallic parts of roof signs exposed to lightning. g. The exposed uprights, superstructure, and/or backside of all signs shall be painted a neutral color such as light blue, gray, or white unless it can be demonstrated that such part of the sign designed or painted in another manner is integral to the overall design of the sign. h. No signs shall be painted on, attached to, or affixed to any trees, rocks, or similar organic or inorganic natural matter, or on any power line or telephone pole. i. No signs except those of a governmental entity shall be erected or allowed to extend over a public right-of-way, unless a revocable permit from the City is obtained prior to issuance of a sign permit. j. Each freestanding sign shall be set back from each lot line by at least two feet. Billboards shall also comply with Section 60.400.110G. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 250 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110F: Sign Standards 2. Lighting of Signs a. Internal lighting, back lighting, and spot lighting are permitted to illuminate signs as stated in Table 400.11-1 General Sign Standards. b. Each light source for internal lighting, back lighting, or spot lighting of a sign shall be shielded so that the source is not visible from any Agricultural and Residential district, any Residential Use in a Mixed Use district, and from any public right-of-way. c. Lighted signs adjacent to Residential districts and located within a zone that restricts hours of operation may only be lit during business hours. 3. Table of Sign Standards Table 400.11-1 General Sign Standards, states the general sign standards for all signs in all districts, unless stated otherwise in this Section 60.400.110. Table 400.11-1 General Sign Standards I = Internal B = Backlight S = Spotlight Non- Mixed Use Agricultural and Residential Residential Districts Districts Districts Type of Sign Non-MX-S, MX-G, Residential Residential MX-N MX-C, MX-D, BP, LI, SI Use Use MX-I MX-T Wall Signs 1 General: 1 Maximum Buildings over 5 stories: 1 additional \[1\] Number per Street Frontage 12 sq. ft. 24 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 250 sq. ft. 400 sq. ft. Maximum Area 8 feet Same as primary structure maximum height \[2\] Maximum Height Not Permitted B B, S \[9\] B, S I, B, S I, B, S Permitted Lighting \[3\] Freestanding Sign 1 1 \[4\] 1 \[5\] 1 \[5\] 1 1 Maximum Number per Street Frontage 12 sq. ft. 24 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 50 sq. ft. 64 sq. ft. 64 sq. ft. Maximum Area 6 feet 6 feet 6 feet \[8\] 15 feet 20 feet 15 feet Maximum Height Not Permitted B, S I, B \[9\] I, B, S I, B, S I, B, S Permitted Lighting Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 251 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110F: Sign Standards Table 400.11-1 General Sign Standards I = Internal B = Backlight S = Spotlight Non- Mixed Use Agricultural and Residential Residential Districts Districts Districts Type of Sign Non-MX-S, MX-G, Residential Residential MX-N MX-C, MX-D, BP, LI, SI Use Use MX-I MX-T Projecting Sign 1 1 1 1 1 Maximum Number 8 sq. ft. 12 sq. ft. 12 sq. ft. 16 sq. ft. 24 sq. ft. Maximum Area Not Permitted 12 feet 12 feet 12 feet 16 feet 18 feet Maximum Height I, B I, B I, B I, B I, B Permitted Lighting Roof Sign \[6\] 1 Maximum Number 150 sq. ft. 250 sq. ft. \[7\] Maximum Area \[7\] Not Not Not Not Permitted Permitted Permitted 10 feet 15 feet Permitted Maximum Height S, I, B S, I, B Permitted Lighting Business Center Signs Additional signs for business centers are permitted that comply with Section 60.400.110F.4 below. Residential Subdivision Signs One additional freestanding sign per entrance to a to a subdivision of lots for individual Household Living uses, and one per entrance to a development containing multiple buildings with Multifamily Dwelling uses, provided that the sign does not exceed 24 square feet in area and does not exceed four square feet above grade. NOTES \[1\] When more than one wall sign is permitted, the maximum area for the additional wall sign must be no more than 50% of the maximum wall sign area permitted for the property. \[2\] Must not extend above the top of the wall where it is attached. \[3\] Lighted wall signs are not permitted on secondary façades adjacent to a Residential district. \[4\] Signs must be located no closer than 50 feet from any shared lot line with a Residential district. \[5\] Signs must be located no closer than 25 feet from any shared lot line with a Residential district. \[6\] Roof signs are prohibited for lots that are adjacent to a Residential district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 252 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110F: Sign Standards Table 400.11-1 General Sign Standards I = Internal B = Backlight S = Spotlight Non- Mixed Use Agricultural and Residential Residential Districts Districts Districts Type of Sign Non-MX-S, MX-G, Residential Residential MX-N MX-C, MX-D, BP, LI, SI Use Use MX-I MX-T \[7\] If a roof sign is installed, the maximum permitted area for a wall sign(s) on the same property shall be reduced by the area of the roof sign. \[8\] Free Standings signs in the MX-N district shall be a Monument Sign. \[9\] In the MX-N district lighted signs shall not face any Agriculture or Residential district, or any Residential Use containing less than five units in a mixed use district. 4. Business Center Signs a. Each individual tenant within a business center is permitted one wall sign on the primary façade not to exceed 20 percent of the area of the façade, and that meets the applicable requirements of the district where it is located. One wall sign per secondary façade is permitted, not to exceed 20 percent of the area of the façade, and meeting the following requirements: 1) Wall signs are not permitted on secondary façades that face a Residential district unless separated by an existing expressway or freeway as stated in the Comprehensive Plan; 2) The wall sign must face and be visible from a collector or higher level street or the parking lot serving the business center; and 3) A total of two wall signs may be permitted per tenant within a business center. b. In addition, one freestanding sign per entrance of the business center is permitted. Each additional freestanding sign above the first is permitted at no more than 50 percent of the maximum freestanding sign area permitted for the property. 5. Marquees or Sun Canopies a. No sign affixed to or an integral part of a marquee shall be less than eight feet above any sidewalk level or its equivalent in the absence of a sidewalk. Marquees shall be permitted an area up to double that permitted for freestanding signs, provided that the increase in area above that allowed for freestanding signs is matched by a reduction in the area of other permitted primary signs. b. The sun canopy area shall count against the permitted wall sign area, but the sun canopy shall not count against the permitted number of primary signs. c. Lighting is prohibited on marquee signs or sun canopy signs on secondary facades when the secondary façade is adjacent to and facing a Residential district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 253 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110F: Sign Standards 6. Service Canopies a. Where a service canopy is permitted to protect outdoor customers from weather conditions, up to 50 percent of the vertical canopy façade area may be used for signage, and the permitted canopy signage shall be in addition to other sign allowances on the property. b. Lighted signs on any service canopy façade adjacent to and facing a Residential district are prohibited. c. Electronic message boards on service canopies are prohibited. 7. Electronic Message Boards a. Only freestanding signs and wall signs in Mixed Use and Non-Residential districts may include an electronic message board. b. Electronic message boards are prohibited in Agricultural, Residential, MX-N, and MX-S districts. c. Electronic message boards are prohibited on any Mixed Use or Non-Residential lots adjacent to an Agricultural or Residential district. d. Each permitted electronic message board shall be integrated into the overall sign face. e. The area of the electronic message board signage shall not exceed 50 percent of the total sign area of the wall or freestanding sign face where it is integrated, or 32 square feet, whichever is less. f. The top of any permitted electronic message board must not exceed 12 feet above grade. g. The electronic message display shall be programmed so it contains only static images, does not change more frequently than once every eight seconds, and transitions between images instantaneously or through dissolve or fade transitions, and without scrolling, flashing, fading, blinking, or other similar transitions. If dissolve or fade transitions are used, the time between messages shall not exceed one second of time. The electronic message board content may not move or create the appearance of movement, through varying light intensity or otherwise, on any part of board. h. Each electronic message board shall be provided with automatic dimming software or solar sensors to control brightness for nighttime viewing and varying daytime lighting conditions. i. No electronic message board may be illuminated at a level greater than 5,000 nits during daylight hours, or at a level greater than 500 nits during nighttime hours. j. In districts or when associated with allowed uses that have restricted hours of operation, electronic message boards may operate only during permitted business hours. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 254 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110G: Billboards G. Billboards 1. Spacing All billboards erected after December 22, 1992, shall comply with the following spacing standards: a. No billboard shall be located within 1,000 feet of another billboard located on the same side of the street. Distances between billboards shall be measured along the adjacent right-of-way line of the street or highway where the billboard is directed as shown in Figure 1a. b. No billboard shall be located within a 100 foot radius from the intersection of the rights-of-way of two or more streets or highways as shown in Figure 1b. c. No billboard shall be located within 200 feet of the intersection of a street and a railroad right-of-way. The distance shall be measured from the center point of the street-railroad intersection to the nearest edge of the billboard as shown in Figure 1c. d. No billboard shall be located within 300 feet of a Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility. This distance shall be measured from the nearest edge of the billboard to the Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility to the closest point on any boundary line of the Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility property as shown in Figure 1d. This restriction only applies to Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility properties that abut the same right-of-way where a billboard is oriented, regardless of whether the billboard is located on the same side or the opposite side of the right-of-way as the Place of Worship, School, or Medical Facility. e. No billboard shall be located within 250 feet of a boundary of an Agricultural and Residential district. This distance shall be measured from the nearest edge of the right-of-way to the closest point on any boundary of the Residential district as shown in Figure 1e. f. No billboard shall be located within 300 feet of and oriented toward the following portions of the following streets and highways within the City: 1) County State Aid Highway 22 from trunk Highway 52 at Apache Mall westerly th and northerly to Trunk Highway 52 at 55 Street NW, 2) County State Aid Highway 22 from Trunk Highway 14 at the University Center th northerly and westerly to Trunk Highway 63 at 37 Street NW; and th 3) 55 Street NW from Trunk Highway 52 easterly to County Road 133 (West River Road). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 255 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110G: Billboards Figure 1a Figure 1c Figure 1b Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 256 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110H: Temporary Signs Figure 1e Figure 1d H. Temporary Signs 1. Banners a. Each banner shall be installed or maintained parallel to a building façade or other vertical building surface. b. Each banner shall be mounted not more than 18 inches from the wall surface where it is attached. c. Banners in Agricultural and Residential districts shall be subject to the following limitations. 1) For non-residential uses, no more than one banner shall be permitted per use or per tenant. No banners are permitted on any wall abutting a residential use containing less than four dwelling units, or adjacent to an AG, R-1, R-2, or R-2x district. 2) For residential structures with four or more dwelling units, one banner per primary structure shall be permitted, provided the banner is oriented toward an abutting primary collector or higher order street or is adjacent to any district other than the AG, R-1, R-2, and R-2x districts. 3) No banners are permitted on any wall abutting a residential use containing fewer than four dwelling units or adjacent to a R-1, R-2, or R-2x district. 4) In all other circumstances, banners are prohibited in Residential districts. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 257 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110I: Murals and Other Displays 2. Portable Signs Freestanding portable signs are permitted in the MX-G, MX-D, LI, and SI districts after approval of a sign permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060.H, and shall comply with the following standards: a. No sign shall exceed 24 square feet in area or four feet in height. b. No sign shall be allowed for a period exceeding 14 days in any 12 month period. Each sign shall be removed within two days after the completion of the event that it relates. Once the sign permit expires, no additional permits for such signs shall be issued for the property during the 12 month period. c. Each sign shall meet all other applicable criteria listed in this Section 60.400.110. I. Murals and Other Displays 1. Applicability a. Except as stated in Subsection b below, this Section 60.400.110I applies to all displays on walls, or structures that: 1) Are not types of signs listed in Section 60.400.110C or Section 60.400.110E ; and 2) Exceed the permitted height, size, duration, or another applicable physical standard in this Section 60.400.110. b. This Section 60.400.110I does not apply to any City-sponsored signs, wall graphics, or displays that are located: 1) On City property; or 2) On public utility boxes, meters, or panels where such placement is allowed by a written contract between the City and any utility provider. 2. Special Review Required a. Applications for approval of a mural or other display under this Section 60.400.110I shall be reviewed by the Community Development Director pursuant to the review criteria in Subsection 3 below. b. A decision on the application shall be made within 45 days after the City’s receipt of a complete application. Any appeal of the decision shall be heard and resolved as set forth in Section 60.500.030F.2, Appeals. c. An approved application expands the number, size, and duration of signs otherwise permitted on the lot or development site. Any approval of a special display shall not affect the ability of the applicant to erect or maintain any other signs on the property permitted by this Section 60.400.110, and the approved display shall not be included in calculations to determine the total sign area or number of authorized signs. d. An approved application runs with the property unless otherwise specified by the Community Development Director in the record of approval, and all conditions and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 258 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.110 Signs Section 60.400.110J: Message Substitution limitations related to the approval shall be binding on future owners and users of the property. 3. Review Criteria The Community Development Director may approve an application for a mural or other display if it finds that the proposed mural or display: 1) Is a form of speech or expression protected by the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and/or the Minnesota Constitution; 2) Will be created, constructed, erected, or displayed in a way that is visually distinct from other permitted signs on the property; 3) Does not exceed the dimensions of any surface upon which it is mounted; 4) Will be treated to address vandalism and exposure to expected weather conditions; 5) Will not require extensive or repeated maintenance, unless the applicant has provided adequate assurance (including financial assurance) that maintenance and repairs will be timely performed; 6) Does not create a threat to public health or safety or to vehicular, bicycle, or pedestrian traffic safety; 7) Does not create noise, sound, light, reflection, glare, shading, flickering, vibration, or odor impacts on nearby properties; and 8) Does not impair the performance of required City functions on or around the property. J. Message Substitution 1. Any sign permitted pursuant to this Section 60.400.110 that contains a commercial message may be revised to contain a non-commercial message at any time, without the need to obtain a new Sign Permit. 2. Any sign permitted pursuant to this Section 60.400.110 that contains a non-commercial message may be revised to instead contain a commercial message at any time, without the need to obtain a new Sign Permit. 3. Changes in the message on a permitted sign shall not be considered alteration of the sign, as that term is used in this Section 60.400.110. K. Sign Measurements 1. Area of a Sign a. Sign area is calculated as the area within a continuous perimeter with up to eight straight sides that encloses the limits of text and graphics of a sign, together with any frame or other material or color forming an integral part of the display or used to differentiate the sign’s message from the background against which it is placed. The Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 259 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120A: Purpose area excludes the structure upon which the sign is placed (unless the structure is an integral part of the display or used to differentiate it), but includes any open space contained within the outer limits of the display face of a sign, or between any component, panel, strip, or figure of any kind composing the display face, whether this open space is enclosed by a frame or border or not. b. Support structures will not be counted against total sign if the Community Development Director determines that such elements are appropriately scaled to the size of the copy. 2. Measuring the Height of a Sign a. Sign height is measured as the vertical distance from the average elevation of the finish grade within a six-foot radius at the base of the sign to the top of the sign, including all backgrounds and support structures, exclusive of any filling, berming, mounding, or landscaping, solely done for the purpose of locating the sign. b. If natural grade at the base of a sign is lower than the grade of an adjacent road, the height of the sign may be measured from the top of curb elevation. c. For purposes of measuring the size of a billboard sign, only one side of a sign with two back-to-back parallel sign surfaces shall be the area of one of those surfaces. Section 60.400.120 I NCENTIVES A. Purpose This Section 60.400.120 establishes incentives to encourage public benefits in exchange for increased development density, size, or flexibility. These public benefits include the development of affordable housing for low-income households, infrastructure improvements, sustainable development practices, added public amenities, and heritage preservation. Incentives are only available for actions in each of these areas that are not otherwise required by this UDC, the Rochester Code of Ordinances, other City regulations, or state and federal law. These incentives are designed to further enhance the public health, safety, and welfare of the community. B. Combination of Bonuses More than one bonus in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives may be earned on a single property or development, but no combination of bonuses in Table 400.12-1 may result in the: 1. Maximum FAR on any lot or development site being increased by more than 25 percent above the maximum FAR that would otherwise apply under this UDC; or 2. Maximum gross floor area on any lot or development site being increased by more than 25 percent above the maximum gross floor area that would otherwise apply under this UDC; or Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 260 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120C: Timing of Incentive Application and Decision 3. Number of dwelling units on any lot or development site being increased by more than 25 percent above the maximum number of dwelling units that could be located on that lot or development site under this UDC. C. Timing of Incentive Application and Decision 1. Requests for approval of an incentive pursuant to this Section 60.400.120D shall be made at the time of pre-development review of a proposed application with City Staff. 2. The Community Development Director will waive the requirement in Subsection 1 above if the Director determines that acceptance of a later request for approval of a permitted incentive will not require City Staff to repeat earlier steps in the review process. 3. If a public meeting related to the application has already occurred, any waiver of Subsection 1 shall require that the public meeting be repeated and that information regarding the requested incentive be presented. 4. If the application requires a public hearing, no request for waiver of Subsection 1 may be approved after that public hearing has taken place. 5. If the application requires both a preliminary and a final approval, no request for waiver of Subsection 1 may be approved after preliminary approval of the application. D. Summary of Incentives 1. Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives lists the actions for which incentives are offered, the zoning districts where each incentive is available, and the different bonuses that are associated with each action. 2. No incentives may be awarded for any design feature, amenity, payment, or other action that would otherwise be required of the development under this UDC or other adopted City standards or regulations. Incentives are only awarded for actions that exceed those requirements and standards that would apply to the property if an incentive was not being requested. 3. No height bonus may result in a building located in a neighborhood protection area exceeding the maximum building height permitted in Section 60.400.020F, Neighborhood Protection Standards. 4. Compliance with the requirements of this Section 60.400.120, Incentives shall be confirmed by Staff review of the application. a. Where the underlying development application is subject to administrative approval, and the application complies with the applicable requirements of this Section 60.400.120, the approved incentive shall be included in the administrative approval of the application. b. Where Staff has confirmed compliance with the requirements for one or more incentives under this Section 60.400.120, but the underlying development application is subject to approval of the Heritage Preservation Commission, Planning Commission, or City Council, the decision-making body shall consider the application Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 261 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120D: Summary of Incentives pursuant to the applicable decision-making criteria in Chapter 60.500 Procedures and Administration assuming that all approved incentives will be constructed, and shall not condition its approval on removing or limiting an earned incentive. Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives No incentives are awarded for actions otherwise required by this UDC or adopted City regulations. No incentive may result in a building height exceeding the Neighborhood Protection Standards. Bonus Awarded Applicable Incentive Zoning Districts (Above Maximum Otherwise Permitted in the District) Affordable Housing AG, R-1, R-2, A 10% reduction in minimum lot size if at least 20 dwelling units and R-2x or 15% of dwelling units, whichever is larger, are income- restricted. R-3, MX-N, MX- A 20% increase in maximum FAR if at least 20 dwelling units or S, MX-C, MX-G, 15% of dwelling units, whichever is larger, are income-restricted. MX-I, and MX-T Housing for Low Income R-3, R-4MX-G, In addition to the FAR increase above, an additional 20 feet of Households MX-I, MX-C, and maximum building height if at least 20 dwelling units or 15% of MX-T dwelling units, whichever is larger, are income-restricted. A maximum of 4 additional stories of building height if at least 20 MX-D dwelling units or 15% of dwelling units, whichever is larger, are income-restricted. Additional Infrastructure A maximum of 2 additional stories of building height if on-site stormwater management features reduce the amount of MX-D stormwater that would otherwise be transmitted into the City’s piped storm drainage system by at least 10%. Stormwater In districts without maximum FAR limits, a 10% reduction in Management minimum lot area, and in districts with FAR limits a 10% increase in maximum FAR, if on-site stormwater management All other districts features reduce the amount of stormwater that would otherwise be transmitted into the City’s piped storm drainage system by at least 10%. 5 percent of additional building floor area for each 10 square Districts subject foot of new or replacement street construction, up to a 20% to FAR limits increase in maximum FAR. Street Improvements 5 percent of additional building floor area for each 10 square MX-D foot of new or replacement street construction, up to a maximum of 2 additional stories of building height. 5 percent of additional building floor area for each 10 linear foot Districts subject of new or replacement water, storm drainage, and/or electric for FAR limits lines, up to a 20% increase in maximum FAR. Utility Lines 5 percent of additional building floor area for each 10 square MX-D foot of new or replacement street construction, up to a maximum of 2 additional stories of building height. Sustainable Development Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 262 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120D: Summary of Incentives Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives No incentives are awarded for actions otherwise required by this UDC or adopted City regulations. No incentive may result in a building height exceeding the Neighborhood Protection Standards. Bonus Awarded Applicable Incentive Zoning Districts (Above Maximum Otherwise Permitted in the District) A 10% reduction in minimum lot size if levels of renewable R-1, R-2, and R- energy supply stated in Section 60.400.120E.3, Sustainable 2x Development are met. R-3, MX-N, MX- Renewable 20% increase in maximum FAR if levels of renewable energy S, MX-C, MX-G, Energy supply stated in Section 60.400.120E.3, Sustainable MX-I, MX-T, BP, Development are met. LI, and SI A maximum of 2 additional stories of building height if levels of R-4, MX-T, MX-D renewable energy supply stated in Section 60.400.120E.3, Sustainable Development are met. R-3, R-4, MX-N, MX-S, MX-C, 20% increase in maximum FAR if the green building standards MX-G, MX-I, MX- in Section 60.400.120E.3, Sustainable Development are met. T, MX-D, BP, LI, Green Buildings and SI A maximum of 2 additional stories of building height if the green MX-D building standards in Section 60.400.120E.3, Sustainable Development are met. Public Amenity MX-N, MX-S, 5% of additional building floor area for each 10 linear foot of Pedestrian MX-C, MX-G, pedestrian weather protection features, up to a 10% increase in Weather MX-I, MX-T, MX-maximum FAR, or in MX-D, up to one additional story in building Protection D, BP, LI, SI height. 5% of additional building floor area for each 1 square foot of Squares, MX-N, MX-S, improved and furnished square, plaza, or gathering space open Plazas, and MX-C, MX-G, to the public, visible from at least one public street, and located MX-I, MX-T, MX-at least partially within 100 feet of that public street, up to a Gathering D maximum 5% increase in building floor area, or in MX-D, up to Plazas an additional 2 stories in building height. A maximum of 2 additional stories of building height if public R-4, MX-T, MX-D land dedications related to the development exceed those otherwise required by the City by at least 25%. Dedication of In districts without maximum FAR limits, a 10% reduction in Public Land minimum lot area, and in districts with FAR limits a 10% All other districts increase in maximum FAR, if public land dedications related to the development exceed those otherwise required by the City by at least 25%. 5% additional building floor area in a new building constructed on a lot within 600 feet of, and in the same zone district as, the Historic MX-I, MX-T, and designated landmarked property (the “Receiving Lot”): Preservation MX-D 1. For each 5% of unused potential building floor area on a lot containing a designated landmarked property (the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 263 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120E: Incentive Requirements Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives No incentives are awarded for actions otherwise required by this UDC or adopted City regulations. No incentive may result in a building height exceeding the Neighborhood Protection Standards. Bonus Awarded Applicable Incentive Zoning Districts (Above Maximum Otherwise Permitted in the District) “Sending Lot”) that it is deed restricted to prevent future development on the Sending Lot; or 2. For each 5% of floor area in an existing designated landmarked property (the “Sending Lot”) renovated to meet applicable standards of the City’s Heritage Preservation Commission. Up to a maximum 20% increase in maximum FAR on the Receiving Lot. If the receiving lot is in the MX-D, additional building square footage up to a maximum of 2 additional stories in building height. E. Incentive Requirements Incentives listed in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives shall only be available to applicants that comply with all requirements for that bonus listed in this Section 60.400.120E. 1. Housing for Low Income Households In order to earn the incentive identified in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives, the affordable housing units shall meet one of the following two requirements, as determined by the Community Development Director. a. The units are restricted for occupancy for individuals whose income is 60 percent or less of the area median gross income for rental properties and less than 110 percent of the area median gross income for owner occupied properties for at least 30 years; or b. The project has been awarded Low Income Housing Tax Credits (LHTC). 2. Additional Infrastructure In order to earn the incentive identified in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives, the additional infrastructure provided shall meet one of the following three requirements. a. Stormwater Management The City Engineer shall determine whether the proposed improvements meet the following criteria. 1) For projects with a disturbance area of less than one acre, the applicant provides on-site water treatment for 100 percent of the water quality volume, regardless of the proposed disturbance area. This incentivizes on-site treatment of the water quality volume, as defined by the latest MS4 Permit. 2) For projects with a disturbance area of one acre or more, the applicant provides on-site water reduction of 100 percent of the water quality volume, as defined Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 264 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120E: Incentive Requirements by the latest MS4 permit. This incentivizes on-site stormwater reduction on a project that would otherwise have non-volume-reducing treatment options available such as filtration, detention, or constructing an off-site treatment. b. Street Improvements 1) Eligible improvements include but are not limited to the construction or payment for mobility improvements such as vehicle travel lanes, sidewalks, bikeways, or multi-use trails. 2) The street improvements are constructed, dedicated, and paid for by the applicant and provide additional benefits for the residents or occupants of the proposed development. 3) The street improvements are in a location where the proposed street improvements are needed by the City, of a type and design that are needed by the City, comply with applicable City construction standards, and are not required to be provided by the applicant to mitigate potential impacts of the proposed development by this UDC or other adopted City regulations, all as determined by the City Engineer. c. Utility Lines 1) Eligible improvements include but are not limited to the provision of a new link or connection to complete or improve the efficiency of an existing water, storm drainage, and/or electric line, the replacement of an existing water, storm drainage, and/or electric line to improve existing service, converting overhead electric lines to underground lines where that is not otherwise required, installing in-building transformer vaults in the MX-D district, and installing oversized water mains in residential developments. 2) The water, storm drainage, and/or electric lines are constructed, dedicated, and paid for by the applicant and provide additional benefits for the residents or occupants of the proposed development. 3) The water, storm drainage, and/or electric lines are in a location where the proposed lines are needed by the City, and of a type and design that are needed by the City, comply with applicable City construction standards, and are not required to be provided by the applicant to mitigate potential impacts of the proposed development by this UDC or other adopted City regulations, all as determined by the City Engineer. 3. Sustainable Development In order to earn the incentive identified in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives, the additional sustainable development infrastructure provided shall meet one of the following requirements. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 265 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120E: Incentive Requirements a. Renewable Energy The applicant shall submit written evidence acceptable to the City that one or more of the following types of renewable energy system(s) are being installed and that the installation of those devices will generate at least the minimum amounts of energy listed below: 1) On-site solar panels will generate at least 75 percent of estimated annual average electricity used in all primary buildings or solar panels will cover an area of the building or lot equal to at least 70 percent of the total roof area of all primary buildings; 2) On-site small-scale wind energy will generate at least 50 percent of estimated annual average electricity used in all primary buildings; 3) On-site geothermal technology will generate at least 50 percent of estimated annual average electricity used in all primary buildings; or 4) A combination of solar, wind, and geothermal energy systems installed on-site will generate at least the amount of energy that would have been generated through compliance with Subsections 1), 2), or 3) above. b. Green Building The applicant shall submit written evidence acceptable to the City showing compliance with either Subsection 1) or 2) below: 1) The project is designed to maintain an Energy Star score of 75 or higher for a period of at least five years and agrees to participate in the City benchmarking program; or 2) The project is being reviewed and expects to receive certification by one of the following verified third-party sustainability programs: (a) Silver Certification by the U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC) Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) rating system; (b) Silver Certification by the Home Innovation National Green Building Standard (NGBS) Green Certified rating system; (c) Petal Certification by the International Living Future Institute Living Building Challenge (LBC) rating system; (d) Three Green Globes Certification by the Green Building Initiative (GBI) Green Globes Certification rating system; or (e) Another verified third-party sustainability program producing equal or greater sustainability benefits to at least one of the programs listed in Subsections (a) through (d) above, as determined by the Community Development Director. 4. Public Amenity Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 266 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120E: Incentive Requirements In order to earn the incentive identified in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives, the additional public amenities provided shall meet one of the following three requirements. a. Pedestrian Weather Protection The applicant constructs and pays for one or more of the following features that provide protection to pedestrians from adverse climatic conditions. Development features eligible for this incentive include: 1) Fully enclosed and climate-controlled skyway or subway connections to adjacent buildings across a public right-of-way, in locations and using designs approved by the City Engineer and the Community Development Director; or 2) Fully enclosed and climate-controlled walkways between buildings, or between occupied buildings and Parking Garages, in locations approved by the City Engineer and the Community Development Director; b. Squares, Plazas, and Gathering Places The applicant shall construct, pay for, and submit evidence acceptable to the City ensuring long-term maintenance of, privately-owned spaces, including but not limited to plazas, squares, and other types of gathering spaces, that: 1) Are open to, visible to, and highly accessible to the public; 2) Incorporate seating areas or furniture and features to provide shade or weather protection to users of the amenity; 3) Are not required by any Section of this UDC or other adopted City regulation. c. Dedication of Public Land 1) The applicant shall dedicate additional land for public purpose in a location shown for that purpose on a City-approved plan and/or capital improvement program, and that are not otherwise required of the applicant by any Section of this UDC or other adopted City regulation. 2) Eligible facilities include but are not limited to playlots, neighborhood parks, community parks, special use parks, city squares or triangles, parkways, or trail systems providing access to major public facilities or along environmental corridors. 5. Historic Preservation In order to earn the incentive identified in Table 400.12-1 Summary of Incentives, the applicant shall either: a. Discourage demolition or replacement of an existing designated landmark by transferring the unused development potential or floor area from the lot containing the historic structure to another lot within 600 feet of the lot containing the historic structure, through a deed restriction on the lot containing the historic structure, and through development density transfer mechanisms acceptable to the City; or Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 267 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.120 Incentives Section 60.400.120F: Criteria for Incentives b. Pursuant to designs approved by the Heritage Preservation Commission, pay for restorations of or enhancements to a building designated as a historic landmark that is within 600 feet of the lot containing the historic structure. F. Criteria for Incentives The applicable decision-maker shall approve a requested incentive if it finds that the application complies with the following criteria. 1. If the application is eligible for Staff approval, the application shall be approved if the Community Development Director makes the following findings: a. The application and Site Development Plan comply with all applicable standards in this Section 60.400.120 Incentives. b. The existing or future planned public facilities in the area are adequate to serve the proposed development with the incentive; c. The application or Site Development Plan including the incentive are consistent with any Master Plan for that area that has been adopted by City Council as an element of the Comprehensive Plan; d. If the application proposes an “Additional Infrastructure” incentive, the proposed additional infrastructure capacity is needed in the area where the project is located; and e. If the application proposed a “Public Amenity” incentive, the proposed amenity is of a type that is not adequately provided in the area where the project is located. 2. If the application is subject to Heritage Preservation Commission, Planning Commission, or City Council approval, the application shall be approved if the decision-maker determines that the application, including all earned incentives, complies with the following criteria: a. The application meets all applicable criteria applicable to that type of application in Chapter 60.500, Procedures and Administration; b. The proposed development plan is compatible with the existing land uses in the area or the pattern of zoning within 1,000 feet of the property boundaries; c. The existing or future planned public facilities in the area are adequate to serve the proposed development with the incentive; and d. The application or Site Development Plan including the incentive are consistent with any Master Plan for that area that has been adopted by City Council as an element of the Comprehensive Plan. e. If the application proposes an “Additional Infrastructure” incentive, the Community Development Director has determined that the proposed additional infrastructure capacity is needed in the area where the project is located; and f. If the application proposed a “Public Amenity” incentive, the Community Development Director has determined that the proposed amenity is of a type that is not adequately provided in the area where the project is located. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 268 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.130 Maintenance and Operation Section 60.400.130A: Compliance with Other City, State, and Federal Requirements Section 60.400.130 M AINTENANCE AND O PERATION A. Compliance with Other City, State, and Federal Requirements 1. Compliance with Sections 9-4 and 9-17 and Title 17 of the Rochester Code of Ordinances is required. 2. The City shall have the authority to enforce applicable state and federal regulations concerning the following types of nuisance: a. Radioactivity, electrical disturbance, radiation; b. Odors resulting from liquid, air, or solid waste discharge; c. Liquid and solid waste discharges and disposal; d. Toxic matter discharge or disposal; e. Heat discharge and emission; f. Fire and explosion hazards; g. Emission of particulates; h. Blasting; and i. Burning of natural material. 3. In the case of more than one standard applying, the more stringent standard shall apply. B. Specialized Report The Community Development Director will require a specialized report detailing the potential impacts of a proposed development or use if the Community Development Director determines that the proposed use or development is likely to have difficulty complying with any of the standards of this Section 60.400.130, and/or failure to comply with these standards could cause a public health and safety concern. C. Point of Measurement Unless otherwise noted in this Section 60.400.130, the measurements necessary for enforcement of the standards in this Section shall be taken at the property line boundary of the use being considered for a Zoning Certificate or possible violation notice. D. Public Amenities Any public amenities required in this UDC including those constructed in return for a bonus in Section 60.400.120, Incentives shall be continuously maintained by the applicant unless dedicated to the City or otherwise agreed to in writing by the City. E. Landscaping and Usable Recreation Areas Failure to maintain all landscaping is a violation of this UDC. Developers and their successors in interest shall be responsible for the regular maintenance of all landscaping elements in perpetuity, specifically: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 269 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.130 Maintenance and Operation Section 60.400.130F: Exterior Storage 1. All plant material, including plant material on vegetated roofs, shall be maintained alive, healthy, and free from disease and pests; and 2. All landscape structures including, but not limited to, vegetated roof infrastructure, raised landscape planters, fences, and walls shall be repaired or replaced periodically to maintain a structurally sound and aesthetic condition. F. Exterior Storage 1. Each storage container must be painted and free of corrosion, rust, rot, holes, or leaks. 2. Each storage container must be kept free of graffiti, posters, bills, and signs, except that each sign no larger than two square feet in area shall be attached to the container identifying and providing emergency contact information for the owner of the container. 3. Graffiti and other vandalism of the storage container must be repaired within two weeks of the incident. A company identification sign no more than two square feet in area shall be attached to the storage container. G. Signs 1. All signs, together with their supports, braces, guys, and anchors shall be kept in repair and in proper state of preservation. 2. The display surfaces of all signs shall be kept neatly painted or posted at all times. 3. Every sign and the immediate surrounding premises shall be maintained by the owner, lessee, or manager of the property in a clean, sanitary, and inoffensive condition and free and clear of all obnoxious substances, rubbish, and weeds. 4. The repainting, changing of parts, and maintenance of signs shall not be deemed as alterations requiring a sign permit. 5. Signs that relate to activities on the lot that are no longer in operation shall be removed by the sign owner within 60 days from the date the use ceased operation, unless otherwise required by state or federal law. H. Odors 1. Unless state or federal regulations do not require a different result, no use shall emit any continuous odor or an odor causing detectable substances at or beyond the point of measurement. To be continuous, an odor must be present for more than 15 minutes in any one day and more than two days out of the month. 2. The existence of an odor shall be presumed when the concentration of the odor causing substance in the air at or beyond the point of measurement exceeds the lowest concentration listed for the substance in the most recent version of “The Air Pollution Abatement Manual,” Manufacturing Chemists’ Association. Substances that are not listed shall not be deemed to be odorous unless a chemist demonstrates that a discernible odor is being emitted. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 270 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.130 Maintenance and Operation Section 60.400.130I: Heat 3. Uses that are required by state or federal regulations to obtain state or federal level air quality permits are prohibited in any district other than the LI or SI districts except where authorized as part of a Distinctive Development. I. Heat Where federal and state regulations are not applicable, no continuous or repetitive discharge or emission of heat shall be allowed if it increases the ambient air or water temperature by one or more degree centigrade beyond the lot line. J. Fire and Explosion Hazards All activities involving, and all storage of, flammable and explosive materials shall be provided with adequate safety devices against the hazard of fire and explosion and with adequate firefighting and fire suppression equipment and devices standard in the industry. Burning of waste materials in open fires is prohibited. K. Glare 1. In the LI and SI districts, no direct or sky reflected glare, whether from flood lights or from high temperature processes, such as combustion or welding, shall cause illumination in excess of 0.5 foot candles at the point of measurement. 2. In all other districts, no operation or activity shall be conducted so that any glare, whether direct or reflected, is visible at the point of measurement. L. Smoke 1. Measurement of smoke shall be at the point of emission. 2. The Ringleman Smoke Chart published by the United States Bureau of Mines shall be used for the measurement of smoke. Table 400.13-1 Maximum Smoke Levels indicates for the various zoning districts the acceptable level of smoke emissions. These provisions, applicable to visible gray smoke, shall also apply to visible smoke of a different color but with an equivalent apparent opacity. Table 400.13-1 Maximum Smoke Levels District Type Maximum Level Exception of Emission Agricultural and Ringleman No. 0 None Residential Smoke of a shade equal to no. 2 on the chart may be emitted for a total of eight minutes during any Mixed Use Ringleman No. 1 one-hour period Smoke of a shade equal to no. 3 on the chart may Non-Residential Ringleman No. 2 be emitted for a total of eight minutes during any one-hour period Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 271 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.130 Maintenance and Operation Section 60.400.130M: Particulates M. Particulates 1. No solid or liquid particles shall be emitted at any point in concentrations to exceed 0.1 grains per cubic feet of conveying gas in any residential district and 0.3 grains per cubic feet of conveying gas in any other district. For measurement of the amount of particles in gases resulting from combustion, standard corrections shall be applied to a stack temperature of 500 degrees Fahrenheit and 50 percent excess air. 2. In addition to complying with those standards in Subsection 1, all uses shall comply with all applicable state and federal standards regarding particulate emissions, and in case of conflict the standards in Subsection 1, and applicable state or federal standards, the stricter standard shall apply unless the state or federal standards require a different result. N. Vibration 1. Vibration refers to ground transmitted oscillations. For the purposes of identifying and measuring different types of vibration: a. Amplitude shall mean the maximum displacement of the surface of the earth from its normal resting position. Amplitude is generally measured in inches or mils. b. Discrete Impulses shall mean a ground transmitted vibration stemming from a source where specific impulses do not exceed 60 per minute or one per second. c. Frequency shall mean the number of times that a displacement completely repeats itself in one second of time. Frequency shall be expressed in cycles per second (cps) or hertz (Hz). d. Impact shall mean an earthborn vibration generally produced by two or more objects striking each other so as to cause separate and distinct pulses. 2. Ground transmitted vibration shall be measured using a seismograph or complement of instruments capable of recording vibration displacement and frequency, particle velocity, or acceleration simultaneously in three mutually perpendicular directions. 3. Vibration shall not exceed the levels in Table 400.13-2 Vibration Levels. Table 400.13-2 Vibration Levels Maximum Peak Particle Velocity When the Lot is Adjacent to a: in Inches per Second 0.02 (7AM – 9PM) Residential District 0.01 (9PM – 7AM) 0.05 Mixed Use District 0.1 Non-Residential District 4. The maximum particle velocity shall be the maximum vector sum of three mutually perpendicular components recorded simultaneously. Particle velocity may also be expressed as 6.28 times the displacement in inches multiplied by frequency in cycles per Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 272 Chapter 60.400: Development Standards and Incentives Section 60.400.130 Maintenance and Operation Section 60.400.130O: Noise second. Steady state vibrations are ones that are continuous or in discrete impulses of more than 60 per minute. Discrete impulses that do not exceed 60 per minute shall be considered impact vibrations. Impact vibrations are limited to values that are no greater than twice those specified above. O. Noise 1. All activities shall comply with the Rochester Code of Ordinances Section 8-7-8 regarding permissible levels of noise and shall be conducted so as to avoid the creation of any noise that would create a public nuisance interfering with the use and enjoyment of adjacent properties. 2. Any amplified sound equipment shall be mounted so as to direct sound inward from property boundaries, rather than outward towards property boundaries. 3. Amplified sounds at a level higher than 65 decibels (the level of normal conversation) shall not be allowed to cross lot lines unless an approval has been issued for that purpose. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 273 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.010 Introduction and Summary Table of Procedures Section 60.500.010A: Purpose Chapter 60.500 Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.010 I NTRODUCTION AND S UMMARY T ABLE OF P ROCEDURES A. Purpose The propose of this section is to provide consistent, equitable procedures for the review of development proposals and to ensure that proposed development will be in accordance with the purposes and standards of this UDC. B. Summary Table of Review Procedures Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, lists the development applications authorized by this UDC, whether public notice is required, whether a pre-application meeting is required, and the role of City review and decision-making bodies. Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures Y = Yes R = Review D = Decision A = Appeal \[ \] = Public Hearing Public Pre- Review and Decision-Making Bodies Notice Submittal Procedure UDC Section Development - PublishedMailedPostedNeighborhood Information MeetingPreMeetingCommunity Development DirectorPlanning CommissionHeritage Preservation CommissionZoning Board of AppealsCity Council Major Decision by City Council Comprehensive Plan Section and/or Land Use Plan Y R \[R\] \[D\] 60.500.040A Adoption or Amendment Growth Management Map Section Y Y R \[R\] \[D\] Amendment 60.500.040B Annexation of Land Section 60.500.040B.4.Y Y R R \[D\] a UDC Text Amendment Section Y Y R \[R\] R\[1\] \[D\] 60.500.040D Rezoning (Official Zoning Section Y Y Y Y Y R \[R\]\[1\] R\[2\] \[D\] Map Amendment) 60.500.040E Designation or Removal Section of Landmark Property or Y Y Y Y Y R \[R\] \[D\] 60.500.040F Landmark District Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 274 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.010 Introduction and Summary Table of Procedures Section 60.500.010B: Summary Table of Review Procedures Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures Y = Yes R = Review D = Decision A = Appeal \[ \] = Public Hearing Public Pre- Review and Decision-Making Bodies Notice Submittal Procedure UDC Section Development - PublishedMailedPostedNeighborhood Information MeetingPreMeetingCommunity Development DirectorPlanning CommissionHeritage Preservation CommissionZoning Board of AppealsCity Council Major Land Subdivision Section Y Y Y Y Y R R \[D\] Permit 60.500.040G Final Plat Section Y R \[D\] 60.500.040H Official Map Adoption Section Y R R \[D\] 60.500.040I Public Street or Section Y R R \[D\] Easement Vacation 60.500.040J Distinctive Section Y Y Y Y Y R \[R\] \[D\] Development 60.500.040L Conditional Use Permit Y Y Y Y Y R R \[D\] Approved by City Council Interim Use Permit Section Y Y Y Y Y R R \[D\] 60.500.040N Decisions That May Require by a Designated Authority Conditional Use Permit Section Approved by Planning Y Y Y Y Y R \[D\] \[A\] 60.500.050A Commission Property Placement on Section D \[A\] Historic Inventory 60.200.04C Certificate of Section Appropriateness – Major R D\[3\] \[A\] 60.500.050B Alterations Shoreland Protection Section R \[D\] \[A\] Permit 60.500.050C Development Approvals by Community Development Director Zoning Certificate Section D \[A\] 60.500.060A General Development Section Y Y D \[A\] Plan 60.500.060B Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 275 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.010 Introduction and Summary Table of Procedures Section 60.500.010B: Summary Table of Review Procedures Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures Y = Yes R = Review D = Decision A = Appeal \[ \] = Public Hearing Public Pre- Review and Decision-Making Bodies Notice Submittal Procedure UDC Section Development - PublishedMailedPostedNeighborhood Information MeetingPreMeetingCommunity Development DirectorPlanning CommissionHeritage Preservation CommissionZoning Board of AppealsCity Council Site Development Plan Section Y\[4\] Y\[4\] D \[A\] 60.500.060C Certificate of Section Appropriateness – Minor D \[A\] \[A\] 60.500.060D Alterations Rental Housing Section D \[A\] Certificate 60.500.060E Temporary Permit Section D \[A\] 60.500.060F Minor Land Subdivision Section Y D \[A\] Permit 60.500.060G Floodplain Development Section \[5\] \[A\] Permit 60.500.060H Grading Permit Section \[5\] A 60.500.060I Lot Line Readjustment Section D \[A\] 60.500.060J Sign Permit Section D \[A\] 60.500.060K Flexibility and Relief Minor Modification Section D \[A\] 60.500.070A Major Modification Section R \[D\] \[A\] 60.500.070B Variance Section Y Y Y R \[D\] \[A\] 60.500.070C NOTES \[1\] UDC Text Amendments that involve the HPO or related procedures shall be reviewed by both the Planning Commission and the Heritage Preservation Commission. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 276 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.020 Review and Decision-making Bodies Section 60.500.020A: Purpose Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures Y = Yes R = Review D = Decision A = Appeal \[ \] = Public Hearing Public Pre- Review and Decision-Making Bodies Notice Submittal Procedure UDC Section Development - PublishedMailedPostedNeighborhood Information MeetingPreMeetingCommunity Development DirectorPlanning CommissionHeritage Preservation CommissionZoning Board of AppealsCity Council \[2\] Official Zoning Map Amendments that involve designation of HPO landmarks or landmark districts or removal of HPO landmark designations shall be reviewed by the Heritage Preservation Commission rather than the Planning Commission. \[3\] Public Meeting rather than Public Hearing is required. \[4\] A Site Development Plan proposing development of four or fewer residential units does not require a Pre-development Meeting or an information meeting. \[5\] Decision made by City Engineer. Section 60.500.020 R EVIEW AND D ECISION-MAKING B ODIES A. Purpose This Section describes the organization, powers, and duties of the offices and public bodies responsible for the administration of this UDC. B. Community Development Director 1. Creation There is hereby established the office of the Community Development Director. It shall be the duty of the Community Development Director or their authorized representative to enforce the UDC in accordance with its administrative provisions. 2. Powers and Duties Related the UDC a. The Community Development Director shall be generally responsible for organizing and overseeing the administration of this UDC, including but not limited to the performance of those duties indicated in Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures, unless this UDC or another City ordinance or regulation indicates that another City official or public body shall be responsible for performance of a specific action. b. All forms required in the administration of this UDC shall be maintained, issued, and made available through the Community Development Department, regardless of the agency or officer responsible for determining whether an application should be approved. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 277 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.020 Review and Decision-making Bodies Section 60.500.020C: Planning Commission c. The Community Development Director may make such rules and prescribe such forms, placards, or other material as may be necessary to perform their duties and responsibilities consistent with this UDC and other applicable codes, statutes, and regulations, which rules or forms shall be maintained separately as public records and available for public review in the Community Development Department. d. When a public hearing is required by this UDC, the Community Development Director shall: 1) Schedule the matter for review and hearing; 2) Give notice as required by this UDS, City Code or other law; 3) Maintain a record that includes relevant dates such as for notice, hearings, postponement and continuances, and a summary of action taken by the hearing body; 4) Except in the case of hearings before the City Council, prepare minutes of the hearing, which include the decision on the matter heard and the reasons for the decision; 5) Render the decisions of the hearing body within a reasonable time; and 6) Submit a copy of the decision to the applicant and other requesting parties e. The Community Development Director is responsible for making interpretations of the boundaries of the Official Zoning Map, and use interpretations, of this UDC, or any rule issued pursuant to it. An individual requesting an interpretation shall submit the request in writing to the Community Development Director. 1) Zoning district boundary interpretations shall be evaluated under to Section 60.200.020B, Boundary Interpretation. 2) Use interpretations shall be evaluated under Section 60.300.010C, Unlisted Uses and Structures. 3) The effect of an interpretation shall be to allow the requester to file the appropriate permit or certificate application which must be consistent with the interpretation received. 4) An interpretation shall be valid without limitation on the period of time except where the Council has amended this UDC to invalidate the interpretation. C. Planning Commission 1. Creation a. There shall be a Planning Commission consisting of nine members, established as organized under Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 2-9. b. All members shall be appointed by the Mayor with the approval of the City Council. c. Commission members shall serve without compensation. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 278 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.020 Review and Decision-making Bodies Section 60.500.020D: Heritage Preservation Commission d. Members shall serve a term of three years, and until a successor is appointed and qualifies. e. Each member of the commission, before entering upon their duties, shall take and subscribe an oath of office as prescribed by the City Charter. f. Vacancies occurring on the commission shall be filled for the unexpired term by an appointment by the Mayor with the approval of the City Council. g. The Mayor, with the advice and consent of the council, shall have the authority to remove any members of the commission whenever the best interests of the city shall be served thereby. h. The commission shall adopt a set of rules to govern its own meetings and procedures, which rules shall not be inconsistent with the provisions of the City Council, Charter and this UDC. 2. Powers and Duties Related to the UDC The Commission shall have advisory and decision-making powers relative to various administrative procedures as identified in this UDC, which shall include but not be limited to those shown in Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures. D. Heritage Preservation Commission 1. Creation a. The Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC) shall consist of nine voting members. b. In addition to the voting members, the Heritage Preservation Commission shall include, if available, a member of Olmsted County Historical Society, who shall be a non-voting member. This individual will be included in discussion and deliberation of ongoing business and be present for the purpose of building collaboration between the two organizations. c. All members shall be nominated by the Mayor and appointed by the City Council. Heritage Preservation Commission members must be persons with demonstrated interest and expertise in historic preservation and must reside within the City. Demonstrated interest and expertise may include experience and interest in a variety of avocations and fields engaged in historic preservation efforts and issues, including, without limitation, architecture, construction, legal, real estate, and economic development. d. Heritage Preservation Commission members shall serve staggered three-year terms. e. Each term of office shall expire on December 31 of the year the term is scheduled to expire. All subsequent appointments will be made for three-year terms. All members shall serve until their successors have been appointed and qualified. f. When a vacancy occurs, the Mayor shall nominate a successor for approval by the City Council to fill the unexpired term of the office. If a vacancy occurs in a term with less than 45 days remaining, the Mayor may allow the term to expire without nominating a successor. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 279 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.020 Review and Decision-making Bodies Section 60.500.020E: Zoning Board of Appeals g. Members will not receive a salary for their services, but may be compensated for any approved expenses incurred in the performance of their duties in accordance with guidelines established by the City Council. h. The Heritage Preservation Commission shall meet at least four times a year. i. The Heritage Preservation Commission shall elect from its members such officers as it may deem necessary. The Commission shall have the power to designate and appoint from its members various committees. j. The Heritage Preservation Commission shall follow adopted City policy for the conduct of its affairs and for the purpose of carrying out the intent of Section 60.200.040C HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay and related procedures in Chapter 60.500 Procedures and Administration. 2. Powers and Duties Related to the UDC The Commission shall have advisory and decision-making powers relative to various administrative procedures as identified in this UDC, which shall include but not be limited to those shown in Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures. E. Zoning Board of Appeals 1. Creation a. There shall be a Zoning Board of Appeals consisting of seven members, one of whom shall be a member of the Planning Commission. b. All members shall be appointed by the Mayor with the approval of the City Council. c. Members shall serve for a term of three years, except the Planning Commission representative, who shall serve for a term of one year. d. No member shall serve more than two consecutive terms. e. The Zoning Board of Appeals shall choose a chair from among its membership and determine its rules of proceeding, a copy of which shall be filed with the Community Development Director. 2. Powers and Duties Related to the UDC a. The Zoning Board of Appeals shall have advisory and decision-making powers relative to various administrative procedures as identified in the Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 20, which shall include but not be limited to those shown in Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures. b. Additional Zoning Board of Appeals duties related to the APO district are in Section 60.200.040B, APO -- Airport Protection Overlay. F. City Council 1. Powers and Duties Related to the UDC The City Council shall have all those powers and duties available to the governing body of a municipality in the state of Minnesota, including but not limited to those powers Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 280 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030A: General stated in Chapter V of the Charter of the City of Rochester, and the ordinances of the City of Rochester, which shall include but not be limited to those shown in Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures. Section 60.500.030 C OMMON P ROCEDURES A. General 1. The common review procedures in this Section 60.500.030 provide the foundation for specific review and approval procedures identified in Section 60.500.040J through Section 60.500.060K. 2. Not all common review procedures apply to every development application type. Section 60.500.040 through Section 60.500.060KJ identify how these common review procedures are applied to specific application types, and identify additional procedures and requirements beyond the common review procedures. B. Pre-Submittal Activities 1. Pre-Development Meeting a. Purpose The Pre-development Meeting is intended to provide an opportunity for the applicant to meet with Staff prior to submitting a formal application for development, to review property zoning and utility availability, identify required development review processes and public hearings, and determine public improvements and engineering studies that may be required. Staff can offer guidance and information that helps the applicant to better prepare the formal application. b. Applicability Pre-development Meetings are required as follows: 1) A Pre-development Meeting is required prior to the submission of certain application types, as shown in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures. 2) All applications that propose development of residential with five or more units, mixed use, commercial, or industrial development are required to participate in a Pre-development Meeting. 3) Pre-development Meetings are strongly encouraged for other development application types. 4) A Pre-development Meeting is valid for one year after the meeting date. c. Scheduling the Meeting 1) The Pre-development Meeting shall be scheduled on a first come, first served basis. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 281 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030B: Pre-Submittal Activities 2) A Pre-development Meeting is valid for one year after the meeting date; if an application related to the Pre-development Meeting is not filed within that one year period, a new meeting will be required. 2. Neighborhood Information Meeting a. Purpose The Neighborhood Information Meeting, held at the applicant’s expense, is intended to provide the residents of a neighborhood where development is proposed an opportunity to request information about the proposed development (if any) in their community, and provide feedback and input to the developers on their proposal. Applicants who are not required to hold a Neighborhood Information Meeting are nevertheless encouraged to hold a meeting in order to be aware of potential community concerns and reactions before substantial time and expense are invested in a specific project design. b. When Required 1) A Neighborhood Information Meeting is required prior to the submission of certain application types, as shown in Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures. 2) All applications that propose development of residential with five or more units, mixed use, commercial, or industrial development are required to administer a Neighborhood Information Meeting. A Neighborhood Information Meeting may be required if the Community Development Director determines that the project is likely to have material or unexpected impacts on the surrounding area. The Community Development Director will, within 15 days of receipt of an application, notify an applicant that such a determination has been made and that the application is incomplete until a Neighborhood Information Meeting has been held. Once the Neighborhood information Meeting has been held, the applicant will be allowed to re-submit the application but will not be required to pay an additional fee. 3) If the application is revised during the application process to include substantial changes from the project and plans shown at the initial Neighborhood Informational Meeting, the Community Development Director may require an additional Neighborhood Information Meeting. More detail about minor and major revisions to applications is included in Section 60.500.030D.5 Minor Revisions to Applications. c. Scheduling the Meeting 1) Where required by Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures, or upon notification that a hearing is required under Section 60.500.030B(2)(b)(2) or (3) above, the applicant shall request in writing that the Community Development Director schedule a Neighborhood Information Meeting. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 282 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030C: Public Hearings 2) The applicant shall complete and submit a Neighborhood Information Meeting request form at least five business days prior to the notification mailing. 3) The meeting must be held in an accessible facility, located in the same quadrant of the city, as described in Section 60.400.030M.5.e.2), in which the development is proposed. If the Community Development Director has concerns regarding the choice of meting facility, based on its design, accessibility, or proximity to residents who may be affected by the proposed development, the applicant may be required to select an alternate location. 4) The Community Development Director will provide a mailed postcard notice of the Neighborhood Information Meeting at least 10 calendar days prior to the meeting in accordance with Section 60.500.030C.1.b, Written Notice, and shall notify the Registered Neighborhood Association, if one exists, where the proposed development is located. 5) The Community Development Director shall also notify Registered Neighborhood Associations, if any exist, where the proposed development is located. 6) Neighborhood Information Meetings shall not be scheduled to conflict with regularly scheduled City Council meetings or on federal holidays, including Election Day. 7) Staff may attend but shall not present, evaluate, or approve development proposals at Neighborhood Information Meetings. 8) Multiple applications related to a single action or development or that are to be reviewed concurrently by City Council require a single Neighborhood Information Meeting. 9) An application for development shall include a written summary stating the time and location of the meeting, the number of attendees and the topics discussed. The summary shall list each concern raised at the meeting, and for each such concern, any changes made to the application in response to that concern or the reason why no change was made. 10) The application for development shall be submitted within 30 calendar days from the date of the Neighborhood Information Meeting. C. Public Hearings Where Table 500.01-1 Summary Table of Review Procedures, or State Law or City Code indicates that a public hearing is required, the hearing shall be scheduled, noticed, and conducted as follows. 1. Notice Requirements a. Notice of a Hearing Notice of a hearing shall contain the following information: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 283 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030C: Public Hearings 1) The date, time, and place of the hearing; 2) Where the hearing involves a development application for a specific parcel of land, a description reasonably calculated to inform a person of the location of the property for which the development permit or other action is pending, including the use of a map or postal address and a subdivision lot and block designation, a metes and bounds description, or the tax map designation assigned by the County Assessor; 3) The purpose of the hearing; 4) The interested parties may appear and be heard; 5) The sections of the UDC that are pertinent to the hearing procedure; and 6) Where information regarding the application may be examined and when and how verbal or written comments may be submitted. b. Written Notice 1) Notice Required Unless otherwise provided, addresses for a mailed notice required by this UDC shall be obtained from the County’s real property tax records and sources of property owner and tenant mailing addresses obtained no more than 60 days prior to mailing. Mailed notice shall be sent out by the Community Development Director at least 10 calendar days prior to the day of the hearing. Notice shall be provided to: (a) All owners and tenants of property affected by the application or owning or occupying property situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the property subject to the application, provided that no fewer than 50 distinct property owners and the tenants of those property owners shall be notified; (b) Any township included within or adjacent to the property subject to the application; (c) City Council; and (d) The Community Development Director will keep a list of all of the owners and addresses to which notice was sent. 2) Omissions and Effect of Omissions (a) Written notice is not required when a person’s name is not in the tax records at the time an application is filed, unless the address is on file with the Community Development Director. (b) The failure of a property owner to receive written notice or defects in the notice after a good faith attempt to comply with the notice requirements shall not invalidate the underlying action. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 284 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030C: Public Hearings (c) If any omission or defect in the written notice is brought to the attention of the hearing body, either at or prior to the hearing, the hearing body shall consider the defect prior to proceeding on the application. If it is found the omission or defect impaired a surrounding property owner’s ability to participate in a public hearing, and a delay will not prevent compliance with statutory or other time requirements, then the hearing body shall continue the hearing on the proposed application for at least 10 calendar days. c. Published Notice When published notice is required, it shall be published in the official newspaper of the City of Rochester, or in any other format authorized by Minnesota state law, at least 10 calendar days prior to the day of the hearing. d. On-Site Posted Notice 1) When Required On-site public notice signage shall be erected on the property where a development application is filed that requires City Council approval. 2) Sign Requirements (a) Posted Signs (i) Required sign(s) and content of the signs shall be provided by the Community Development Department. (ii) The applicant shall be responsible for posting the sign(s) at least 10 calendar days prior to the date of the first public hearing, and maintaining the sign(s) until the final public hearing body has taken final action upon the application. (iii) Posted sign(s) must be visible to the public, with an unobstructed view from the public right-of-way. At least one sign shall be placed for every 300 feet of linear frontage abutting a public right-of-way, not including alleys. Signs shall be posted on the subject property (not the public right- of-way), within five feet of the lot boundary. If the subject property does not have street frontage, at least one sign must be placed so that it is visible to the public. (b) Demonstration of Compliance (i) Prior to the first public hearing or public meeting date, the applicant shall submit evidence of compliance with these posting requirements between the date on which signs must be posted and the date of the first public hearing or public meeting. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 285 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030C: Public Hearings (ii) Failure to submit evidence shall be treated as failure to comply with the requirements of this Section 60.500.030C.1.d. If the applicant does not provide evidence that any failure to comply with these requirements has not impaired the public’s ability to participate in the public hearing, the hearing body may continue the hearing for at least 10 days provided that such delay will not prevent compliance with statutory or other time requirements imposed by law. (iii) If failure to comply with these requirements is not brought to the attention of the hearing body, the hearing body finds that failure to comply has not impaired the public’s ability to participate in the public hearing, or the hearing cannot be delayed due to statutory or other time requirements imposed by law, this failure shall not prevent the conduct of the public hearing or meeting or impair the validity of the proceedings on the application. (c) Removing Signs (i) The applicant shall remove all signs from the subject property within five days of the hearing body’s decision, or within five days of an application being withdrawn from consideration. (ii) Upon removal, all signs shall be returned the Community Development Department. e. Additional Notice Requirements for Shoreland Development 1) Copies of notices of any public hearings to consider variances, Shoreland Protection Permits, amendments, or conditional uses under local shoreland management controls must be sent to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources and postmarked at least 10 days before the hearing. 2) A copy of approved amendments and subdivisions/plats and final decisions granting variances or conditional uses under local shoreland management controls must be sent to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources and postmarked within 10 days of final action. 3) Copies of notices of public hearings related to properties located in the FPO district must be sent to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources so that the Commissioner receives the notice at least 10 days before the hearing. f. Additional Notice The City may provide additional notice to persons or entities not named in Subsections a through f above, or in forms not listed in 60.500.030C(1), including but not limited to electronic notification, but any errors in such notification will not impair the validity of the proceedings. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 286 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030D: Application Submittal and Processing g. Effect of Notice Except as provided in Section 60.500.030C(1)(b.2 and d.2)b above, if the applicant provides evidence that the required notices were timely published, mailed, posted, or otherwise provided as required by this Section 60.500.030C.1.c Published Notice, then the failure of an intended person or organization to receive actual notice due to changes of address since the latest update to the City real estate records, or due to changes of e-mail addresses since those were last provided to the City, or due to errors in postal delivery or newspaper publishing, or for other reasons, shall not be grounds for a delay of application review or a delay of public hearing(s), and shall not be grounds for appeal of the resulting decision. 2. Conduct of Public Hearing a. If the application is subject to a public hearing, the applicable review body shall hold a public hearing on the application in accordance with the applicable standards in this Section 60.500.030. b. Following a hearing, the hearing body shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application or, if the hearing is in the nature of an appeal, grant or deny the appeal. c. The deadline for the final decision may be extended only by written agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director. D. Application Submittal and Processing 1. Application Submittal Requirements The Community Development Director will provide all forms and information required for each type of application. The following additional information shall be submitted with an application, as applicable. a. Environmental Review 1) An Environmental Assessment Worksheet as required by Minnesota Rules Part 4410.4300 as amended; when required following a petition sent to the Environmental Quality Board; or if the Community Development Director determines that the project has the potential for significant environmental effects. 2) An environmental Impact Statement as required by Minnesota Rules Part 4410.4400 as amended. b. Traffic Impact Study 1) Applicability The following provisions apply in all zoning districts of the City except those portions of the MX-D zoning district that are not required to provide on-site off- street parking as described in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 287 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030D: Application Submittal and Processing (a) Rezoning Traffic Analysis, Traffic Impact Report, or Traffic Design Analysis (together the “Traffic Impact Study Requirements” and as further described below), is required for all applications subject to this Subsection b, that meet the criteria of those individual sections, and must be approved by the City as complete and containing all required information before the application is submitted. The adequacy of the analysis will be determined during review of the UDC application to which the analysis relates. (b) A scoping meeting with the City Engineer may be scheduled for applicants seeking a waiver of the requirements regarding a Rezoning Traffic Analysis, Traffic Impact Report, or Traffic Design Analysis. (c) Rezoning Traffic Analysis (i) A Rezoning Traffic Analysis is required for certain Rezoning and Land Use Plan Amendment requests. The purpose of the analysis is to evaluate whether adequate transportation capacity exists or will be available within a reasonable time period to safely and conveniently accommodate the proposed uses allowed by the requested land use or zoning classification. This requirement applies to: a. A proposed rezoning that could generate 100 or more directional trips during the peak hour or at least 1000 more trips per day than the most intensive use that could be developed under existing zoning; or b. A proposed rezoning on a site located along, or which has the potential to take access within 500 feet of a corridor identified as a freeway or expressway on the Thoroughfare Plan; or c. A proposed amendment to the Land Use Plan involving more than one acre which would permit uses generating higher traffic than the existing Land Use Plan designation; or d. Proposed development for a site of three-and-a-half acres or larger that is zoned MX-G, LI or SI. e. A proposed rezoning to the BP zoning district consisting of seven or more acres. (ii) The acceptability of the analysis shall be determined through the application review process. (d) Traffic Impact Report (i) A Traffic Impact Report shall be required for a Conditional Use Permit, Major or Minor Land Subdivision Permit, General Development Plan approval, Site Development Plan approval, Zoning District Amendment, or Land Use Plan Amendment, where the application involves any of the following, unless the application is required to complete a Rezoning Traffic Analysis pursuant to Subsection (a) above, or unless that requirement is waived or modified pursuant to this UDC: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 288 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030D: Application Submittal and Processing a. A land use type that has an average trip generation rate of 125 trips per acre per day or greater, according to most current versions of the ITE Trip Generation Informational Report or comparable research data published by a public agency or institution, and which will generate, based on the size of the development, 750 or more average daily trips; or b. A development that may concentrates 1,500 or more average daily trips through a single access point; or c. A development that uses an at-grade access opening onto an existing or proposed freeway or expressway as indicated on the adopted Thoroughfare Plan. d. A property zoned MX-G, LI, or SI consisting of 3.6 acres or more. e. A property zoned BP consisting of seven or more acres. (e) Traffic Design Analysis All Land Subdivisions and General Development Plans that do not require a Rezoning Traffic Analysis or Traffic Impact Report will be required to complete a Traffic Design Analysis, unless that requirement is waived or modified pursuant to this UDC. 2) Waivers The requirement to prepare a Rezoning Traffic Analysis, Traffic Impact Report, or Traffic Design Analysis may be waived by the City Engineer if the City Engineer determines that such report is not necessary to determine needed road improvements or that no unsafe or hazardous conditions will be created by the development as proposed. 3) Traffic Impact Study Requirements (a) The extent of the analysis or report shall be determined by standards and criteria, including but not limited to traffic level of service standards, appearing on the City’s website, and will depend on the location of the project, the amount of traffic generated from the development, and the existing conditions in the project area. (b) Studies completed at an early stage of development may need to be updated to include more detail as development plans become more specific or approval actions result in the reformulation of plans. As part of the review for determining whether a development application is complete, proposals for which an earlier traffic analysis study has been completed will be reviewed to ensure consistency with previous approvals or to identify the need for revision or refinement of previously completed studies. (c) An application required to submit a Rezoning Traffic Analysis, Traffic Impact Analysis, or Traffic Design Analysis that does not comply with this Section 60.500.030D.1.b and related requirements on the City’s website may be Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 289 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030D: Application Submittal and Processing denied, or the approval of the application conditioned upon compliance with those standards. 2. Authority to Submit an Application a. Unless expressly stated otherwise in this UDC, applications, permits, or processes under this UDC shall be submitted by the owner, contract purchaser, or any other person having a recognized property interest in the land on which development is proposed within the City; or by a person authorized to submit the application on behalf of the owner, contract purchaser, or other person having a recognized property interest in the land, as evidenced by a letter or document signed by the owner or contract purchaser; b. Where there are multiple owners of the property that is the subject of the application, the signature of a person authorized by Subsection a above must be obtained for each property owner, or if one or more such signatures cannot be obtained, the application shall document what efforts were made to obtain the missing signatures and the reason why the application may be processed without harm or liability to the interests of the missing signatories. c. For amendments to the Official Zoning Map, the application must include the signatures of the owners, or their representatives of at least 50 percent of the land involved. d. Notwithstanding Subsections 2.a, and 2.b, above, an application for designation of a landmark property or landmark district may be filed by the property owner, the Heritage Preservation Commission, the Mayor, or the City Council. e. No applicant may file an application under this UDC for a property that has received a notice of an outstanding violation of the UDC related to the same property, unless the Community Development Director determines that the application is for a project that, if approved, would cure or render moot the current violation. 3. Payment of Fees a. Staff shall maintain an official fee schedule on the City’s website for any application, permit, or process requiring a fee. The applicable charges or fees shall be set forth in the city’s schedule of charges and fees which will be adopted by resolution and modified from time to time. The official fee schedule shall be available to the public in the Community Development Department Office. b. Fees shall be paid at the Community Development Department office at the time of application submittal. When the Community Development Department has received a complete submittal, Staff shall calculate the total amount of the application fee and any other applicable fees. All payments shall be made to the City of Rochester. c. Until all applicable fees, charges, and expenses have been paid in full, no action shall be taken on any application, subdivision request, or permit. d. The Community Development Director may waive the application fee for any proposal that is actively being promoted by a unit of local government or quasi-public organization or that involves a local subsidy. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 290 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030D: Application Submittal and Processing e. No refunds shall be permitted after a Planning Commission or City Council hearing on the application has been held, regardless of whether or not the Planning Commission or City Council has taken action on the application. 4. Completeness of Application a. On receiving an application, Staff shall determine whether the application is complete and is consistent with conditions of previous approvals by an appointed or elected body applicable to the same property. A complete application is one that contains all information and materials required by the City website and this UDC for submittal of the particular application, and that has sufficient detail and readability to evaluate the application for compliance with applicable review standards of this UDC. b. No application shall be considered complete until all pre-submittal requirements as listed in Section 60.500.030B and D have been satisfied and all required fees have been paid. c. Upon determining that the application is incomplete, the Community Development Director shall notify the applicant of the submittal deficiencies. The applicant may correct the deficiencies and resubmit the application for a determination of completeness until Staff determines the application is complete. d. If the Community Development Director notifies an applicant of missing or deficient materials in an application under this UDC, and the applicant does not submit the missing materials or corrected materials within 30 days after the date on which the Director transmits the notice, the applicant will be considered inactive, and materials submitted to date will be returned to the applicant. Any application processing fees paid by the applicant in connection with an inactive application shall not be refunded. e. No application shall be reviewed for compliance with this UDC or scheduled for a public hearing by any review or advisory body until it is determined to be complete. f. The Community Development Director may determine that an application that is otherwise complete shall not be reviewed if existing violations of this UDC related to the subject property or the applicant exist, pursuant to Code of Ordinances Section 85.25. Upon determining that the application is complete, and that Subsection e above does not apply, Staff shall accept the application for review in accordance with the procedures and standards of this Chapter 60.500. g. Where a Rezoning Traffic Analysis, Traffic Impact Report, Traffic Design Analysis, or waiver of one or more of those documents is required, the application shall be considered complete after the City Engineer determines the Analysis is complete and satisfies the requirements of this ordinance. If the City Engineer determines the Analysis is not complete or does not satisfy the requirements of this ordinance, notice of such determination and the missing information must be provided to the applicant within 15 business days of the receipt of the Analysis. 5. Minor Revisions to Applications a. An applicant may revise an application after receiving notice of compliance deficiencies following Staff review, or upon requesting and receiving permission from an advisory or decision-making body after that body has reviewed, but not yet taken Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 291 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030D: Application Submittal and Processing action on, the application. Such revision must be accompanied by an acknowledgment that the revision amounts to a withdrawal of the prior application and submission of a new application for purpose of timelines under state law and this UDC. b. Revisions must be limited to changes that directly respond to specific requests or suggestions made by Staff, the advisory, or decision-making body, as long as they constitute only minor additions, deletions, or corrections and do not include significant substantive changes to the development proposed in the application. c. Minor changes to an application include only those types of changes that the Community Development Director has the authority to approve under Section 60.500.070A.41. If the Community Development Director determines that a Minor Change will increase the height of a structure above grade, reduce setbacks from abutting properties, or reduce the amount of open space on the site, or create additional impacts on abutting properties when compared with the application as submitted, the Director may require an additional Neighborhood Information Meeting pursuant to Section 60.500.030B.2.b. In such a case, the revised application will not be considered complete until after the Neighborhood Information Meeting has been held and the applicant has satisfied all other requirements of this UDC related to such meeting. d. All proposals for changes to an application that are not listed in Section 60.500.070A.41 Permitted Minor Modifications, shall require a new application, and may require an additional Neighborhood Information Meeting pursuant to Section 60.500.030B.2.b 6. Abandoned Applications If an accepted application has undergone the applicable review process and has not been resubmitted to address Staff-noted deficiencies within 30 days after notification of those deficiencies, the application shall be deemed abandoned and no application or processing fees related to the application shall be refunded to the applicant. Restarting an abandoned application shall require a Pre-development Meeting if the original application required a Pre-development Meeting, and may be subject to additional fees. 7. Withdrawal of an Application a. If a formal application is withdrawn before it is heard by the Planning Commission, the withdrawal shall be without prejudice and shall have no effect upon any subsequent application. b. If a formal application is withdrawn after it is heard by the Planning Commission, the withdrawal shall be with or without prejudice as the governing body shall decide. 8. Concurrent Review a. Two or more applications may be reviewed concurrently. The concurrent review of multiple applications shall be subject to the same criteria and findings that apply to each application individually as stated in this UDC. Each application requires a separate action by the designated hearing body. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 292 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030E: Review and Decision b. The following application types may be reviewed concurrently: 1) Amendment of Official Zoning Map; 2) General Development Plan; 3) Site Development Plan; 4) Questions of Land Use Plan conformance that are to be decided by the Council after review; 5) Major Land Subdivision Permit; 6) Conditional Use Permit; 7) Variance; and 8) Minor Modification. c. Where an application that may be approved by the Community Development Director pursuant to Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, is being reviewed concurrently with an application that requires approval by an appointed or elected body, the Director’s decision of whether to approve or deny shall accompany and be considered to be part of the application considered by the appointed or elected body, but the Director’s decision shall not become final unless and until the elected or designated authority acts to approve the application, approve it with conditions or deny the application, but the Director’s decision will stand unless the designated authority determines otherwise. E. Review and Decision 1. Staff Report a. For each application for which the Planning Commission or City Council serves as a hearing board or decision-maker, the Community Development Director shall prepare a Staff Report indicating whether the application complies with applicable provisions of this UDC and other adopted City, state, or federal regulations. b. The Staff Report shall recommend that the hearing board and/or decision-maker approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application based on its compliance with this UDC, including without limitation those criteria for approval for that type of application listed in this UDC. 2. Approval of Incentives a. Section 60.400.120, Incentives lists the review and decision procedure and criteria required for approval of an incentive. b. Decisions regarding applicable incentives are made by the Community Development Director, Heritage Preservation Commission, Planning Commission, or City Council as provided in Chapter 60.400.120F. c. If the Director approves any incentives requested in the application, any applicable review of the application by an appointed or elected body required by this UDC shall Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 293 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030E: Review and Decision be based on the application including all incentives approved by the Community Development Director. d. If the Director determines that approval of any incentive requested in the application will impose on the City obligations to finance operation or maintenance expenses related to the incentive, and that the City’s current budget or budgetary processes will not or may not be able to support those costs, the Director may deny the requested incentive, and any applicable review of the application by an appointed or elected body required by this UDC shall be based on the application not including those incentives denied by the Director. 3. Decision The application shall be subject to review, hearings, recommendations, and decisions as indicated in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures. a. Development Approvals by Community Development Director Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, indicates the applications for which the Community Development Director shall make the decision. Provided that no specific criteria for approval of that type of application are listed in Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director or another Section of this UDC, in which case the specific criteria listed in Section 60.500.060, the Director may approve an application, or approve it with conditions, pursuant to the following: if it complies with the following criteria: 1) Following acceptance of an application and a determination that the application is complete, the Community Development Director shall either issue or deny a permit or certificate within the following time frames: Table 500.03-1 Timeframe for Action on Complete Applications Maximum Number of Business Permit Type Days Zoning Certificate 10 days Rental Housing Certificate 5 days Sign Permits 10 days Other Applications Not Requiring 20 days Approvals by Department or Agencies Applications Requiring Approval or 7 days (following approval by others) Review by Departments or Agencies 2) The application must be consistent with any previous development approvals related to the property including but not limited to any approved General Development Plan, Distinctive Development, Major Land Subdivision Permit, or Minor Land Subdivision Permit. 3) The Community Development Director determines that the following criteria are met, based on the evidence submitted with the application, comments from Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 294 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030E: Review and Decision referral agencies, information on file with the Community Development Department, and any required approvals from other bodies: (a) The application complies with all applicable provisions of this UDC and other City regulations, as modified by any previously approved Minor Modifications, Major Modifications, or Variances; (b) The property is not subject to a pending notice of violation or legal action as a result of a violation of any federal, state, county, or city land use law or administrative rule, unless the proposed action would result in a correction of the violation or render the pending legal action moot; and (c) If subject to a development agreement, the property has performed all required actions within the timelines in that development agreement. 4) An applicant may revise a denied application and resubmit it, with payment of a new fee required pursuant to Section 60.500.030D.3. If a previously denied application is resubmitted within one year, the portions of the application that were approved need not be reconsidered unless Community Development Director determines that changed conditions or changes in the revised application require reconsideration. b. Decisions to be Made by a Designated Authority 1) If Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, or another provision of this UDC indicates that any designated authority shall make the decision on an application, the designated authority shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if it complies with the criteria applicable to approval of that type of application, using the process described for each application type. 2) If this UDC does not provide specific criteria for approval of an application to be decided by a designated authority, the designated authority shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions if it complies with the following criteria: (a) The application complies with all applicable provisions of this UDC and other adopted City regulations, as modified by any previously approved Minor Modification, Major Modification, or Variance; (b) The application is consistent with any previous development approvals related to the property including but not limited to any approved General Development Plan, Distinctive Development, Major Land Subdivision Permit, or Minor Land Subdivision Permit; and (c) The application will mitigate any negative impacts on surrounding properties to the maximum extent practicable. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 295 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030E: Review and Decision 3) Additional Provisions for Decisions to be Made by the Planning Commission If Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, indicates that the Planning Commission shall make the decision on an application, the following additional provisions shall apply: (a) Referral and Notice (i) Following acceptance of an application subject to Planning Commission approval, Staff shall, within three days, transmit one copy of the application, or appropriate parts of the application, to each referral agency for review and comment. If the referral agency does not comment within seven days, the referral agency shall be presumed to have no comment, unless an extension of up to seven days is requested by the agency and granted by the Community Development Director. (ii) The Community Development Director shall also mail a Notice of Proposed Action to all persons designated to receive notice as stated in Section 60.500.030C.1.b, Written Notice. The notice shall contain a synopsis of the development, and instructions on where to obtain additional information. (b) Preliminary Recommendation (i) The Community Development Director shall review any information received under Section 60.500.030D and make a preliminary recommendation of whether to grant the application, grant it with conditions, or deny the application. (c) Planning Commission Decision (i) Prior to the public hearing, in addition to the notice procedures outlined in Section 60.500.030C, notice shall be sent to all property owners who have land within 500 feet of, and to at least 50 property owners closet to, the parcel under consideration. (ii) If a preliminary decision of the Community Development Director is not scheduled for review, or following a scheduled review by the Planning Commission, the Community Development Director shall dispose of the development permit in the manner provided for by Section 60.500.030E.3 Decision. If there are any changes to the preliminary notice of action, the Community Development Director shall make such change or transmit a revised copy to the applicant. (iii) The Planning Commission shall take action by majority vote of its members present when the hearing was held, within 25 days of the close of the hearing, unless an extension is agreed to by the applicant. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 296 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030E: Review and Decision c. Decisions by City Council 1) If Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, indicates that the City Council shall make the decision on an application, City Council shall make the decision based on the criteria applicable to approval of that type of application listed in Section 60.500.040, Major Decisions by City Council. 2) If this UDC does not provide specific criteria for approval of an application to be decided by the City Council, the City Council shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions if it complies with the following criteria: (a) The application complies with all applicable provisions of this UDC and other adopted City regulations, as modified by any previously approved Minor Modification, Major Modification, or Variance; (b) The application is consistent with any previous development approvals related to the property including but not limited to any approved General Development Plan, Distinctive Development, Major Land Subdivision Permit, or Minor Land Subdivision Permit; (c) The application will mitigate any negative impacts on surrounding properties to the maximum extent practicable; and (d) The application is consistent with the Rochester Comprehensive Plan. 4. Timeframe for Decision a. Where Minnesota law requires that a decision included in this UDC be made within a designated number of days, the decision-maker shown in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, shall make a decision within that time period. b. Where an application requests approval of a use or activity involving freedom of expression or religion protected by the U.S. and Minnesota constitutions, including but not limited to applications for approval of an Adult Entertainment use or a Place of Worship, the decision-maker listed in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, shall make a decision on the application within 60 days, and if the decision is appealed to an appointed or elected body of the City as shown in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, the appeal shall be heard within 60 days of the notice of appeal. c. For purposes of this Subsection 4, a written request or application shall mean a complete application with all required supporting materials, as determined by the Community Development Director. d. The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. 5. Phased Development Where a development is to be constructed in phases, landscape area and usable recreation area shall be developed during the initial phases or during construction of Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 297 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030E: Review and Decision each phase in proportion to the number of dwelling units and non-residential floor area included in that phase relative to the total number of dwelling units and total non- residential floor area, unless the City has approved a development agreement authorizing alternative timing of those improvements. 6. Conditions of Approval As an alternative to denying an application that does not comply with this UDC and related provisions on the City website, the decision-making body for an application listed in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, may condition approval of the application as follows. a. All conditions of approval shall be reasonably related to the anticipated impacts of the proposed use or development or shall be based upon standards duly adopted by the City. Such conditions may include those necessary to carry out the purpose and intent of the Comprehensive Plan, other plans adopted by City Council, and this UDC. b. Any condition of approval that requires an applicant to dedicate land or pay money to a public entity in an amount that is not calculated according to a formula applicable to a broad class of applicants shall be roughly proportional both in nature and extent to the anticipated impacts of the proposed development, as shown through an individualized determination of impacts. c. During its consideration, the decision-making body may consider alternative potential conditions, and no discussion of potential conditions shall be deemed an attempt or intent to impose any condition that would violate the federal or state constitutions, statutes, or regulations. Discussions of potential conditions to mitigate impacts do not reflect actions by the decision-making body unless and until the decision-making body takes formal action to attach that condition to a development approval. 7. Financial Assurances a. Unless otherwise provided in this UDC or another City regulation, if the applicant is required by this UDC or other City regulation to complete or install any public and private improvements or amenities, or to comply with continuing obligations to mitigate impacts of activities approved under this UDC, including but not limited to those related to Sand or Gravel Excavation, Quarry, or Interim Use Permits related to land alterations, the applicant may be required to provide financial security to the City to ensure that the City will have adequate funds on hand to complete the required improvements or amenities or to bring the operations of the approved structure or activity into compliance with this UDC or any development permit or approval. b. Financial security will only be used by the City to complete required public and private improvements or amenities, or to bring properties into compliance if the applicant fails to provide those improvements in a timely manner as required by this UDC after written notice from the City and a reasonable opportunity to remedy the failure to construct or perform. c. Any required financial assurances will be released by the City, in whole or in part, only when the City has confirmed that the remaining financial security is adequate to Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 298 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations protect the City from damage or liability for any remaining obligations to construct or comply. 8. Development Agreements The City may require an applicant to execute, subject to City Council approval, one or more development agreements to address the phasing of development, to assign financial, operations, and management responsibilities over time through infrastructure or service agreements, to ensure the timely completion of any required on or off site infrastructure or amenities through financial guarantees or phasing agreements, to identify any public incentives or agreements between the City and the applicant, and to address any other items related to the design, execution, or potential impacts of an application under this Section 60.500.030E.8. 9. Findings and Order The hearing body shall prepare findings of fact and an order that includes: a. A statement of the applicable criteria and standards against which the proposal was reviewed; b. The reasons supporting a conclusion to approve or deny an application with or without conditions; and c. The decision to approve or deny the proposed application and any conditions of approval attached to the decision. 10. Record of Proceedings a. Minutes of the proceedings before the hearing body shall be prepared by the responsible party. b. Testimony shall be transcribed if required for judicial review or if ordered by the hearing body. c. The hearing body shall, where practical, retain as part of the hearing record each item of physical or documentary evidence presented and shall have the items marked to show the identity of the person offering the same and whether presented on behalf of a proponent or opponent. Exhibits received into the record shall be retained by the Community Development Director until after the applicable appeal period has expired, at which time, provided they are not required to be retained under the Records Retention Act (Minn. Stat. § 15.17) the exhibits may be released to the person identified thereon, or otherwise disposed. d. The findings and order shall be included in the record. e. An individual shall have access to the record of the proceedings at reasonable times, places, and circumstances. An individual shall be entitled to make copies of the record at the individual’s own expense. F. Post-Decision Actions and Limitations Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 299 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations 1. Notice of Action a. The Community Development Director shall notify the applicant in writing as to the final disposition of the application. b. The notice shall indicate the date when the decision will take effect and shall describe the right of appeal pursuant to Section 60.500.030F.2 Post-Decision Actions and Limitations. c. In the case of zoning certificates, rental housing permits, and sign permits, the application form may be used to transmit the notice of action. d. In the case of all other permits required by this UDC, the Community Development Director shall prepare a written Notice of Action containing findings of fact, and the conclusions based thereon, along with any conditions imposed upon the issuance of the permit, and shall send a copy of the notice to the applicant. 2. Appeals a. Availability and Effect of Appeals 1) Decisions made in the administration of this UDC may be appealed to a higher administrative body as stated in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures. 2) An appeal shall stay all proceedings in furtherance of the action appealed from, unless the Community Development Director certifies to the appeal body that by reasons stated in the zoning certificate, a stay would, in their opinion, cause imminent peril to life or property. In such case, proceedings shall not be stayed otherwise than by an order of the appeal body or by a restraining order issued by the District Court of Olmsted County, with notice to the Community Development Director and for due cause shown. 3) Following the close of the appellate public hearing, the reviewing body may affirm, reverse, or modify in whole or in part the determination, requirement, or decision that is under review. When the reviewing body modifies or renders a decision that reverses a decision of the Community Development Director or hearing body, the body must set forth its findings and state its reasons for its action. 4) The reviewing body must, within a reasonable time following the close of the appellate public hearing, adopt its findings of fact, and conclusions of law and order. The body must mail a copy of the findings to the applicant and appellant. b. Who May File an Appeal 1) An applicant aggrieved by a decision may file an appeal within 10 business days of a decision. 2) The basis for such an appeal may be any alleged error of an official or public body in making a decision, including failure to make a decision within the prescribed time limit. A decision means any decision, order, requirement, or Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 300 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations interpretation which the official or body has the power or duty to make under this UDC. c. Filing an Appeal 1) All appeals shall be in writing on forms available on the City website and accompanied with the applicable fees as shown on the City website. 2) All applications for an appeal shall contain: (a) An identification of the decision sought to be reviewed, including the date of the decision; (b) Identification of the status of the person seeking review in relation to the applicant (i.e., applicant, adjacent landowner, owner of record receiving notice, or basis for being aggrieved); and (c) The basis for the appeal including, as applicable, the state or federal law, or specific provisions of this UDC or the Rochester Code of Ordinances that was violated or not applied. d. Notice of Appeal Hearing 1) At least 10 days prior to the hearing, the Community Development Director, acting on behalf of the Appeal body, shall give notice of the time and place of the hearing to the appellant, and/or the official whose decision is being appealed; and by inter-office delivery to the following where they are not already an interested party: (a) The City Attorney; and (b) Other affected officers and agencies of the City government. 2) If the appeal will consider issuance of a permit, the Community Development Director shall within the same period of time by mail give notice to an owner of record for tax purposes or an occupant of each separately owned adjoining property. Such notices shall advise that an appeal from an administrative officer or public body is pending and direct further inquiry to the Community Development Director. 3) Required notices are for the convenience of adjoining property owners and any defect or omission therein shall not impair the validity of the public hearing with respect to any appeal. e. Conduct of Appeals 1) Appeals to the Zoning Board of Appeals (a) Types of Applications The Zoning Board of Appeals shall hear appeals on applications as specified in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 301 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations including appeals of interpretations of this UDC made by the Community Development Director. (b) Appeal Criteria and Findings (i) The Zoning Board of Appeals must make appeal decisions based on in its minutes with respect to the specific appeal, findings of fact, and conclusions of law, and upon substantial evidence or testimony which is competent, relevant, and material. (ii) Unless otherwise provided in this UDC, City Council review of the decision on appeal shall be based on the record of the proceedings before the original hearing body, but may be supplemented by additional documents or testimony related to those records. (iii) The Zoning Board of Appeals shall base its decision upon the appellate record. The appellate record shall include: a. A factual report prepared by the Community Development Director; b. The evidence submitted by the appellant and any other person to the Community Development Director and at the appellate public hearing; c. All exhibits, materials, pleadings, memoranda, stipulations, and motions submitted by the appellant and any other person to the Community Development Director and at the appellate public hearing; and (iv) Findings as to the existence or nonexistence of crucial facts shall be based upon evidence or testimony unless the party or parties before the Zoning Board of Appeals stipulate the facts or waive these requirements. (v) The record of every decision of the Zoning Board of Appeals shall also include the vote, abstention from voting, or absence of each member. (vi) The Zoning Board of Appeals may reverse or affirm, in whole or in part, or modify the order, requirement, decision, or determination appealed from and shall make any order, requirement, decision, or determination that in its opinion ought to be made under the circumstances. For this purpose, the Zoning Board of Appeals has all of the powers of the official from whom the appeal is taken. (vii) In rendering a decision with respect to an appeal from any order, decision, or determination, the Zoning Board of Appeals shall strictly interpret the language of the UDC in order to determine whether that the Community Development Director’s decision was correct or in error. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 302 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations (viii) The Zoning Board of Appeals shall not render any decision that confers rights or privileges on the appellant that are otherwise not permissible under the strict interpretation of the language of this UDC. 2) Appeals to the City Council (a) Types of Applications The City Council shall hear appeals on applications as specified in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures. (b) Appeal Criteria and Findings (i) Unless otherwise provided in this UDC, City Council review of the decision on appeal shall be based on the record of the proceedings before the original hearing body, but may be supplemented by additional documents or testimony related to those records. (ii) The City Council shall base its decision upon the appellate record. The appellate record shall include: a. A factual report prepared by the Community Development Director; b. The evidence submitted by the appellant and any other person at the previous and appellate public hearings; c. All exhibits, materials, pleadings, memoranda, stipulations, and motions submitted by the appellant and any other person at the previous and appellate public hearings; and d. The transcript of the previous hearing if available or a summary of the evidence. (iii) Notice of the public hearing shall be mailed to all property owners entitled to receive notice under the requirements applicable to the original permit application. 3) Appeals to District Court After all appeals have been exhausted, any person or persons aggrieved by a decision, has the right to appeal, within thirty (30) days of deliver of the decision to the appellant and applicant, to the District Court. 3. Validity of UDC Approvals a. A permit or license issued in conflict with the provision of this UDC shall be null and void and of no effect. Where a landowner has, in good faith and in reliance upon a permit issued in error, begun construction, the matter shall be referred to the City Council for disposition. b. Permits, certificates, and variances are valid only for the periods shown below. Use, development, recording, or other filing, as applicable must begin within the validity period unless otherwise noted: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 303 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations Table 500.03-2: Expiration of Approvals Type of Approval Length of Validity None Annexation of Land 1 year Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration 180 days Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration None Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment None Conditional Use Permit None Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District 2 years after approval, following Final Plat recording 1 year Floodplain Development Permit 2 years General Development Plan 2 years Grading Permit 1 year Interim Use Permit 180 days Lot Line Readjustment Final Plat must be submitted within 1 Major Land Subdivision Permit year after approval of Permit None Official Street Map Adoption None Public Street Vacation 2 years Rental Housing Certificate None Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) 2 years Sign Credit 180 days Sign Permit 1 year Site Development Plan 90 days Temporary Permit None UDC Text Amendment 1 year Distinctive Development None Variance 180 days Zoning Certificate NOTES \[1\] Construction or use pursuant to the approval must be initiated within this timeframe. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 304 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures Section 60.500.030F: Post-Decision Actions and Limitations c. The property owner or holder of a permit, certificate, approval or variance under this UDC that is listed in Table 500-03-1 above may apply for a one-time extension of the validity period listed in that table. If the Community Development Director determines that the property owner or holder of the permit or approval is moving diligently to initiate development under that permit or approval. The Director may approve a one- time extension of up to one-half the length of the initial validity period. d. An approved permit, certificate, or approval is assignable in writing to a purchaser, lessee, or tenant of the property, provided the assignee has agreed to the assignment in writing, but an assignment does not discharge any prior assignee from any obligation owed to any local governmental unit in connection with the development, unless the applicable unit of government consents to the discharge of the obligation. e. Amendments to the UDC that have been approved by City Council on first reading shall apply to pending applications, unless the amendment provides otherwise, or unless City Council determines that the amendment should not apply in a particular case in the interest of justice. f. If this UDC is amended to prohibit or change the standards applicable to a development authorized by a certificate or permit, the permit becomes void by operation of the law on the effective date of the amendment, unless the ordinance establishing the amendment provides otherwise or the applicant, in good faith and in reliance upon the permit, within 90 days, began construction subsequent to the issuance of the permit but before adoption of the amendment. 4. Amendments of UDC Approvals and Permits Following the approval or approval with conditions of an application under this UDC, the property owner may apply for amendment of the approval or approval with conditions. a. Minor Amendments – General Except as stated in Subsection b, c, or d below, the Community Development Director has the authority to approve any request for an amendment to an approved development application or permit that the Director had the authority to approve if it had been submitted as a request for a Minor Modification pursuant to Section 60.500.070A during the initial development or permit approval, except that: 1) The Community Development Director may not modify any condition on a development approval permit that was added by City Council, the Planning Commission, or the Heritage Preservation Commission; and 2) The Community Development Director may not modify the existing approval in any way that would result, when considered in combination with any approved Minor Modification included in the existing approval, in any UDC standard being modified to a greater degree than the Director could have initially approved as a Minor Amendment to the initial development or permit approval. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 305 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040A: Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment b. Minor Amendments – General Development Plans Modifications to a General Development Plan may be reviewed and approved as described in Section 60.500.060B.3.b. c. Minor Amendments – Conditional Use Permits Minor Amendments to Conditional Permit may be reviewed and approved as described in Section 60.500.050A.5.a. d. Minor Amendments – Subdivision Permits If the application is for a minor amendment to an approved Minor Land Subdivision, Major Land Subdivision Permit, the Community Development Director, in consultation with the City Engineer, will approve changes to be included in the Final Plat if they determine that the changes will not: 1) Materially alter the character of the approved permit; 2) Interfere with the intent and purposes of this UDC; or 3) Create undue burdens or impacts on adjacent properties. e. Major Amendments – General Except as stated in Subsection f below, any request for an amendment to an approved development application or permit under this UDC that may not be approved by the Community Development Director pursuant to Subsection a above may only be approved by the City official, designated authority, or City Council that approved the initial development application or permit, using the same procedure used by that official, designated authority, or City Council to review and approve the initial development application or permit. f. Major Amendments – Conditional Use Permits Minor Amendments to Conditional Permit may be reviewed and approved as described in Section 60.500.050A.5.b. Section 60.500.040 M AJOR D ECISIONS BY C ITY C OUNCIL A. Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.500.040A is to describe the process by which a new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan for the City can be adopted, which is also the way in which an adopted Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan for the City can be amended, in compliance with applicable Minnesota state law. 2. Applicability a. This process is applicable to all actions to adopt a new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan for the City of Rochester, as well as all actions to amend an existing Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 306 COMMUNITY APPROVALADOPTION OR AMENDMENT PLANCOMPREHENSIVE PLAN indicates public hearing DECISIONCITY COUNCIL RECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & COMMISSION PLANNING RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040A: Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment adopted Comprehensive Plan or the Land Use Plan element of the Comprehensive Plan. b. Where an application for a development approval or permit is under consideration, one criterion for approving that application requires consistency with the Comprehensive Plan and or Land Use Plan element, and the decision-maker decides that the application is not consistent with the Comprehensive Plan or the Land Use Plan element, the development application or permit may not be approved unless and until the Comprehensive Plan and/or the Land Use Plan is amended to make a finding of consistency possible. 3. Procedure for Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment The adoption of a new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan, or amendments to an existing adopted Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040AD.3. a. Application, Notice, and Hearing 1) The City Council, by resolution, or the Planning Commission on its own motion, or the Community Development Director, may propose a new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan for the City. 2) Any of the following may propose an amendment to the Comprehensive plan: (a) The City Council, by resolution, (b) The Planning Commission, on its own motion, (c) The Community Development Director, (d) Any property owner who has filed an application that has been determined to be inconsistent with the adopted Comprehensive Plan by application. 3) Any proposal for a Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan adoption or amendment shall be scheduled for public hearings before the Planning Commission and City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 307 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040A: Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment b. Planning Commission Hearing and Recommendation 1) The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the application for a Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan adoption or amendment pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that City Council approve, or deny the proposed comprehensive plan or comprehensive plan amendment based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. c. City Council Action 1) Upon recommendation of the Planning Commission, or after no less than sixty (60) days have passed since the Council proposed an amendment by resolution to the Planning Commission. The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the proposal for a Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan adoption or amendment pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, or deny the proposed adoption or amendment, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. 3) Unless the amendment is to permit an affordable housing development, it must be approved by 2/3 of the Council. In the event the amendment is to permit an affordable housing development, as defined in Minn. Stat. § 462.355, subd. 3, a simple majority of the Council must approval. 4) The City Council may extend the deadline for a final decision for a reasonable period of time by written agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. 4. Criteria for Comprehensive Plan and/or Land Use Plan Adoption or Amendment The Planning Commission shall recommend, and City Council may approve, the adoption of a new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan for the City, or an amendment to an existing adopted Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan for the City, if the City Council determines that the following criteria are met: a. The approval of the new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan, or any amendment to the Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan is in the best interests of the City, and will protect environment and the health, safety, and welfare of the citizens of the City, and particularly those of historically marginalized citizens and citizens experiencing disability. b. The approval of the new Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan, or any amendment to the Comprehensive Plan or Land Use Plan complies with all applicable requirements of Minnesota state law. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 308 COMMUNITY AMENDMENT OF GROWTH MANAGEMENT MAP indicates public hearing CITY COUNCIL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040B: Growth Management Map Major Amendment c. B. Growth Management Map Major Amendment 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.500.040B is to describe the process by which the adopted Growth Management Map may be amended from time to time in compliance with applicable Minnesota state law. 2. Applicability This process is applicable to all applications to amend the City’s Growth Management Map, and may be required to be completed before an application for an Official Zoning Map Amendment or another application under this UDC may be recommended for approval or approval with conditions. 3. Procedure for Major Amendment of Growth Management Map a. General A major growth management map amendment is any change to the growth management map that involves land area greater than 5 acres. A major growth management map amendment may be initiated by petition of the property owners or by agents of the property owners by written consent of the property owners. The City shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040B. b. Application, Notice, and Hearing 1) The City Council, the Planning Commission, or the Community Development Director may file an application to amend the Growth Management Map, and a property owner may file an application to amend the Growth Management Map as it relates to their property. 2) The application to amend the Growth Management Map shall be scheduled for public hearings before the Planning Commission and City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 309 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040B: Growth Management Map Major Amendment 3) Prior to application submittal, the applicant shall request a technical meeting with the Development Services team to review the development proposal. The Development Services team will review major amendments on a case-by-case basis. Following the technical meeting, a formal predevelopment meeting outlining the request is required. The amendment may be approved by the Development Services team provided the development will not adversely affect City infrastructure including but not limited to storm and sanitary sewer, drinking water, streets, parks, fire response times, etc. If the project receives formal Development Services approval, the project can proceed with application submission. c. Planning Commission Hearing and Recommendation 1) The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the application for an Annexation of Land pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that City Council approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. d. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for major amendment to the Growth Management Map pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, or deny the application, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. 3) A Major Growth Management Map Amendment must be approved by 2/3 of the City Council. 4) The City Council may extend the deadline for a final decision for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. 4. Criteria for Major Amendment of the Growth Management Map The Planning Commission shall recommend, and City Council may approve an amendment to the Growth Management Map, if the Council determines that the following criteria are met: a. The proposed GMMA will address a shortage of land designated and available for a proposed type of land use as evidenced by an objective market analysis with costs covered by the applicant. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 310 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040B: Growth Management Map Major Amendment b. A technical assessment of the sewage generation characteristics of proposed development in combination with assessment of remaining trunkline sewer capacity in the sanitary sewer subdistrict where the development is proposed should be completed to determine the availability of capacity and/or the potential scheduling of improvements to address this potential Adequate Public Facility deficiency. c. The impact of and cost to municipal utilities and infrastructure, including but not limited to road and transit infrastructure, sewer, water, and electric infrastructure, parks, etc. as a result of the proposed GMMA have been considered and the proposed project will not adversely effect these infrastructure systems. d. An assessment of natural features on the proposed site has found that the site is suitable for urban development. e. The proposed GMMA will not adversely affect the supply of land designated for the type of land use the area in question is currently planned for. f. The proposed Future Land Use Map amendment is consistent with and will help further the Vision, Principles and Goals of the P2S 2040 Comprehensive Plan and 1) Will not compromise the direction of the plan to create an integrated land use and transportation vision 2) Will not compromise the strategies identified in the plan to implement the Primary Transit Network or the anticipated phasing of the PTN identified in the plan 3) The development characteristics of uses in the proposed land use plan category as described in Tables 2-8 through 2-12 are compatible with surrounding land use classifications. 4) The locational characteristics and transportation features of the site are consistent with the locational and transportation factors described in Tables 2-8 through 2-12 for the proposed land use. g. The proposed amendment is consistent with community goals and policies as expressed in the City’s adopted Plans. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 311 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040C: Annexation of Land C. Annexation of Land 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.500.040B.4.a is to describe the process by which the City will consider petitions for annexation of land. 2. Applicability This process is applicable to petitions for annexation land submitted or signed by a majority of the landowners within such area. Procedure for Annexation of Land by Ordinance following receipt of a petition. 3. Procedure for Annexation of Land a. Amendments to the boundaries of corporate and extraterritorial limits shall be adopted as provided by Minnesota state statute, and approved annexations shall be entered on the zoning map in the same manner as amendments to the zoning district boundaries. b. The procedure to include new lands into the municipal boundaries of the City shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040B.4.a. c. Petition Submission, Notice, and Hearing 1) Property owners may submit a petition for an Annexation of Land by Ordinance as authorized by Minnesota state law. 2) The application for Annexation of Land shall be scheduled for public hearings before the Planning Commission and City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. Upon receipt of a petition, the Community Development Director will verify the following: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 312 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040C: Annexation of Land (a) That a majority of the property owners of such land proposed to be Annexed have signed the Petition; (b) That, within 10 days of submitting the petition to the City, the Petitioners have filed copies of the petition with the Chief Administrative Law Judge, the town board, the county board, and the municipal council of any other municipality which borders the land to be annexed; 3) If no objections to the Petition for Annexation of Land by Ordinance are received, the Petition for for Annexation of Land by Ordinance shall be scheduled for public hearings before the Planning Commission in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. 4) Following the Planning Commission hearing, the matter shall be scheduled for public hearings before the City Council for an annexation ordinance in accordance with Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures; except that at least 30 days’ written notice by certified mail will be provided to the town or towns affected by the proposed Annexation of Land By Ordinance and to all landowners within and contiguous to the area to be annexed. d. Planning Commission Hearing and Recommendation 1) The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the application for an Annexation of Land pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that City Council approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. e. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for an Annexation of Land pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. 3) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. 4. Criteria for Annexation of Land Approval The Planning Commission shall recommend, and City Council may approve an Annexation of Land, if it determines that the following criteria are met: a. The Annexation of Land is consistent with the adopted Comprehensive Plan regarding areas for future growth and development of the City; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 313 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT UDC TEXT AMENDMENT APPROVAL indicates public hearing CITY COUNCIL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040D: UDC Text Amendment b. The proposed Annexation of Land is able to be served by existing City infrastructure and services, or through future expansions of infrastructure and services included in approved City plans or policies, or the applicant has agreed to pay for required expansions of City infrastructure and services on terms acceptable to the City. c. The property proposed for the annexation is now or is about to become urban or suburban in character; and d. The Annexation of Land complies with all applicable provisions of Minnesota state law. D. UDC Text Amendment 1. Purpose The UDC text amendment process describes the review and approval procedures for amending the text of this UDC to respond to changed conditions or changes in public policy, or to advance the general welfare of the City. These amendments do not include rezoning. 2. Applicability The provisions of the UDC may periodically be amended or repealed. An amendment to the text of this UDC may only be initiated by the Community Development Director, Planning Commission, or City Council, or by a property owner if required by Minnesota law. 3. Procedure for UDC Text Amendment Approval Amendments shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040D.3. a. Initiation of Amendment Amendments to the UDC may be initiated by: 1) The Community Development Director, Planning Commission, or City Council; 2) If the City Council initiates the amendment, it shall instruct the City Attorney to prepare an ordinance for subsequent adoption by the City Council within 60 days of the final Planning Commission recommendation on the application. A request that the City Attorney prepare an Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 314 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040D: UDC Text Amendment ordinance shall not bind the City Council to subsequently approve any ordinance prepared relative to the zone change application. 3) Any individual suggesting to the City Council or the Planning Commission that it initiate the amendment on its own motion. Suggestions are entitled to consideration at the discretion of the City Council and/or Planning Commission. b. Notice and Hearing 1) For all application for or a proposal to consider for a UDC text amendment notice shall be provided by publication in a newspaper of general circulation at least 10 days before the date of the hearing scheduled by the Community Development Director. 2) In addition, written notice of any proposed amendment to the FPO district boundaries or the boundaries of Flood Fringe (FF), Floodway (FW), or Flood Prone (FP) subdistricts within the FPO district, together with the text of the proposed amendment and any supporting technical studies, shall be sent to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources so that the Commissioner receives notice at least 10 days before each public hearing. c. Planning Commission Hearing and Recommendation 1) The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the application for a UDC Text Amendment pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing to make a recommendation regarding whether the UDC should be amended. 2) Following the hearing, the Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that City Council approve, amend and approve, or deny the application, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. d. City Council Action 1) Upon recommendation of the Planning Commission, or after no less than sixty (60) days have passed since the Council proposed an amendment by resolution to the Planning Commission, the City Council shall follow the hearing requirements of the City Charter Section 6.06 act on the application for UDC Text Amendment pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) The City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, and based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below, amend the UDC as proposed, adopt a different amendment, or deny the application to amend. In the event of a denial, the Council will adopt written findings for decision not to adopt. 3) The Council may extend the deadline for a final decision for a reasonable period of time by written agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 315 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040D: UDC Text Amendment 4. Criteria for UDC Text Amendment Approval The Planning Commission shall recommend, and City Council may approve, an amendment to the text of this UDC if it determines that the following criteria are met: a. General 1) There is a public need for the amendment; 2) The amendment accomplishes one or more of the purposes of this UDC, the Comprehensive Plan, or other adopted City plans or policies; and 3) Adoption of the amendment will be lawful. b. Amendments to FPO District or Flood Protection Regulations In addition, if the application includes changes to the FPO District or any standard, criteria, or other regulation of this UDC related to the protection of the public from flood risks, the following criteria shall apply: 1) The proposed change complies with the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) Technical Conditions and Criteria and has been approved in writing by FEMA; and 2) The proposed change has been submitted to and approved by the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 316 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040E: Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) E. Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) 1. Purpose The Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) procedure is intended to provide a mechanism for the City to consider an application for the rezoning of real property within the jurisdictional area of the City and to ensure that the statutory requirements established in Minnesota law for the zoning of real property are met. 2. Applicability a. The City Council may amend the boundaries of zoning districts established on the Official Zoning Map, except for the HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay district, as stated in this Section 60.500.040E b. The City Council may amend the boundaries of the HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay as stated in Section 60.500.040FE Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District. c. Zoning of land in the process of annexation may be done in conjunction with the Annexation of Land proceedings, but shall be subject to the procedure and notice requirements of this Section 60.500.040E. The proposed zoning ordinance shall not be passed on final reading prior to the date when the annexation ordinance is passed on final reading but the ordinance annexing the property can also zone the property. 1) If the City initiates the Annexation of Land and the land use plan shows that the future use of the property is low density residential and other provisions of this Section do not require another designation, the land will be zoned R-2. 2) If the City initiates the Annexation of Land and the future land use plan shows that the future use of the property is something other than low density residential, the land will be zoned H with a hearing to be held within 60 days after annexation. 3) If the landowner initiates the Annexation of Land, the landowner shall identify the zoning district for the property at the time of annexation. For any lands designated as low density residential on the future land use map, the landowner shall request R-2 zoning. d. Property designated on the adopted Flood Insurance Rate Maps for Olmsted County, Minnesota and Incorporated Areas effective April 19, 2017, and any amendments thereto. e. Within 30 days after the effective date of an Annexation of Land that was adopted without designating a zoning district, or within six months after the passage of a joint resolution designating an area in need of orderly annexation, the Community Development Director shall prepare a report for the Planning Commission examining the existing pattern of development in the area, the character of the property, and the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 317 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT (OFFICIAL ZONING MAP AMENDMENT) APPROVAL REZONING indicates public hearing CITY COUNCIL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040E: Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) land use plan recommendation for the area, and shall include a recommendation on suitable zoning designation for the property. If the City Council finds it is important to the protection or implementation of City policies, interim regulations may be applied to the annexed area until more permanent action can be taken. 3. Procedure for Rezoning Applications for amendments to the Official Zoning Map Amendments shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040E.3. If a General Development Plan is required pursuant to Section 60.500.060B, the General Development Plan shall have been approved by City Council prior to or concurrently with action on the application for Rezoning. a. Initiation of Amendment Amendments to the Official Zoning Map may be initiated by: 1) The Community Development Director, Planning Commission, or City Council; 2) If the City Council initiates the amendment, it shall instruct the City Attorney to prepare an ordinance for subsequent adoption by the City Council within 60 days of the final Planning Commission recommendation on the application. A request that the City Attorney prepare an ordinance shall not bind the City Council to subsequently approve any ordinance prepared relative to the zone change application. 3) Any property owner formally requesting City Council to grant an amendment to the Official Zoning Map for land for which they are the property owner; or 4) Any individual suggesting to the City Council or the Planning Commission that it initiate an amendment on its own motion. Suggestions are entitled to consideration at the discretion of the City Council and/or Planning Commission. b. Notice and Hearing 1) For all Official Zoning Map amendments, notice shall be provided by publication in a newspaper of general circulation at least 10 days before the date of the hearing scheduled by the Community Development Director. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 318 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040E: Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) 2) In addition, for any amendment to the Official Zoning Map mailed notice shall be sent to all owners of land situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the outer perimeter of the subject property. Where the Official Zoning Map is to be changed or amended incidental or as part of a general revision to this UDC, whether such revision is made by repeal of the existing UDC and enactment of a new ordinance, or otherwise, notice of mail shall not be required. 3) In addition, written notice of any proposed amendment to the FPO district boundaries or the boundaries of Flood Fringe (FF), Floodway (FW), or Flood Prone (FP) subdistricts within the FPO district, together with the text of the proposed amendment and any supporting technical studies, shall be sent to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources so that the Commissioner receives notice at least 10 days before each public hearing. c. Planning Commission Hearing and Recommendation 1) The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing on the application for Rezoning pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council approve or deny the application, the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. d. City Council Action 1) Upon recommendation of the Planning Commission, or after no less than sixty (60) days have passed since the Council proposed an amendment by resolution to the Planning Commission, the City Council shall follow the requirements of the City Charter Section 6.06 on the application for rezoning pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing(s), the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC and based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below, amend the ordinance or findings for decision not to rezone. 3) Any determination by the City Council shall be supported by findings based on the criteria in Section 60.500.040E.4 and these findings shall be reflected in the minutes of the City Council proceedings. 4) In the event the rezoning is from residential to non-residential or central development core, the amendment must be approved by 2/3 of the Council. 5) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 319 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040E: Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) 4. Criteria for Rezoning Approval a. General If the application is for any amendment to the zoning map other than an amendment of FPO district boundaries or the boundaries of Flood Fringe (FF), Floodway (FW), or Flood Prone (FP) subdistricts within the FPO district, the Planning Commission shall recommend for approval, and the City Council may approve a rezoning request if determines that the following criteria are met: 1) The amendment must satisfy all of the following criteria: (a) The permitted uses allowed within the proposed zoning district will be appropriate on the subject property and compatible with adjacent properties and the neighborhood; and (b) The proposed amendment does not involve spot zoning. 2) In addition to the requirements in Section 60.500.040E.4.a.1), the amendment must satisfy at least one of the following criteria: (a) The area, as presently zoned, is inconsistent with the policies and goals of the Comprehensive Plan; (b) The area was originally zoned erroneously due to a technical or administrative error; (c) While both the present and proposed zoning districts are consistent with the Comprehensive Plan, the proposed district better aligns with the policies and goals of the Comprehensive Plan or other adopted City plans or policies, as determined by City Council; (d) The area has changed or is changing to such a degree that it is in the public interest to rezone to encourage development or redevelopment of the area consistent with the policies and goals of the Comprehensive Plan; or (e) The area includes lands identified as Decorah Edge and the amendment would provide for beneficial development that maintains typical urban density while preserving habitat and protecting processes that maintain groundwater quality and quantity. (f) The area includes lands identified on adopted City plans as an important natural or historic resource, and the amendment would provide for beneficial development that would protect those resources. b. Amendment of FPO District Boundaries or Internal Designations If the application is for an amendment of FPO district boundaries or the boundaries of Flood Fringe (FF), Floodway (FW), or Flood Prone (FP) subdistricts within the FPO district, the following criteria shall apply instead of those in Subsection a above. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 320 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040E: Rezoning (Official Zoning Map Amendment) The floodplain designation shall not be revised or removed from floodplain areas unless: 1) The proposed change complies with the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s (FEMA) Technical Conditions and Criteria and has been approved in writing by FEMA; and 2) The proposed change has been submitted to and approved by the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources; and 3) The applicant demonstrates that: (a) The designation is in error; or (b) The area has been filled to or above the elevation of the regional flood and is contiguous to lands outside the floodplain; or (c) The Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources has approved in writing a special exception to Subsections 2(a) and 2(b) based on the Commissioner’s determination that the lands are adequately protected for the intended use through other measures. 4) All amendments to the floodplain provisions of this zoning code, including amendments to the official zoning map, must be submitted to and approved by the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources prior to adoption. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 321 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROPERTY OR LANDMARK DISTRICT DESIGNATION OR REMOVAL OF LANDMARK indicates public hearing CITY COUNCIL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONCOMMISSION REVIEW & HERITAGE PRESERVATION RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040F: Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District F. Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District 1. Purpose This process is intended to implement the provisions of Section 60.200.040C HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay by enabling the City to designate historic landmark structures and districts. 2. Applicability This Section 60.500.040F applies to all applications to designate a landmark property or district in the City. 3. Procedure for Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District Applications for Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040FE. a. Initiation of Amendment 1) The property owner, the Commission, the Mayor, or the City Council, may initiate a landmark designation. 2) An application for a landmark property or landmark district designation shall be submitted to the state historic preservation office of the Minnesota Historical Society for a 60-day review period. The state historic preservation office’s nonbinding comments shall be sent to the commission for its review. b. Notice and Hearing The application shall be scheduled for public hearings before the Heritage Preservation Commission and City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 322 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040F: Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District c. Heritage Preservation Commission Hearing and Recommendation 1) The Heritage Preservation Commission shall hold a public hearing on the application pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the Heritage Preservation Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council approve or deny the application, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. d. City Council Hearing and Decision 1) Upon recommendation of the Heritage Preservation Commission, the City Council shall follow the requirements of the City Charter Section 6.06 on the application to section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing(s), the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC and based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below, amend the ordinance or deny the application. In the event of a denial, the Council will adopt written findings for decision not to Rezone. 3) Any determination by the City Council shall be supported by findings based on the criteria in Section 60.500.040F.4 and these findings shall be reflected in the minutes of the City Council proceedings. 4) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. e. Post-Approval Actions 1) Properties designated as landmarks shall be added to the official list and shown on a map as landmarks in the HPO overlay district. This designation shall not change or modify the underlying zone classification. 2) The City Clerk shall record with real estate records of the county a certified copy of the ordinance designating the property including its legal description. 4. Criteria for Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District a. Criteria for Designation If the application is for designation of a landmark property or landmark district, the Heritage Preservation Commission shall make its recommendation, and the City Council shall make its decision, pursuant to the criteria in Section 60.200.040C.5 Evaluation Criteria for Landmark Designation. b. Criteria for Removal If the application is for removal of a landmark property or landmark district designation, the Heritage Preservation Commission shall make its recommendation, and the City Council shall make its decision, pursuant to the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 323 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040F: Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District following standards. Landmark designation may be removed from a property based on reconsideration of historic significance, historic integrity, or economic hardship. 1) Reconsideration of Historic Significance (a) Removal of a landmark property designation shall be approved if an application demonstrates that the property no longer meets any of the criteria stated in Section 60.200.040C.5, Evaluation Criteria for Landmark Designation. (b) Removal of a landmark district designation from all or part of a landmark district shall be approved if an application demonstrates that the property or properties proposed for removal. (i) No longer meets any of the criteria in Section 60.200.040C.5, Evaluation Criteria for Landmark Designation; or (ii) The properties are no longer united or linked by their interrelationship, by plan or physical development, aesthetically or through past events; or (iii) The majority of the properties in the area proposed for removal no longer possess a concentration of identified historically significant resources. 2) Reconsideration of Historic Integrity Removal of a landmark property or part or all of a landmark district designation shall be approved if the application demonstrates that the historic integrity of the properties proposed for removal is no longer intact or sufficient to warrant designation, based on their location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association. 3) Economic Hardship Removal of a landmark property or part or all of a landmark district designation shall be approved if an application demonstrates that the property or properties proposed for removal are burdened by an economic hardship and cannot earn a reasonable economic return, as evidenced by the following information: (a) Current level of economic return, including: (i) Amount paid for the property, date of purchase, party from whom purchased, and any relationship between the owner of record, the applicant, and person from whom the property was purchased; (ii) Amount owed on the property and annual debt services payments; (iii) Current value of the property, as evidenced by the current assessed value of the property for tax purposes, value from any appraisal performed within the previous two years, and documentation of any local, state, and federal taxes paid upon the property or value assigned to the property for purposes of tax deductions, tax credits, or depreciation over the previous four years; and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 324 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040F: Designation or Removal of Landmark Property or Landmark District (iv) Annual gross and net income from the property and for the previous three years, itemized operating and maintenance expenses for the previous three years, and depreciation deduction and annual cash flow before and after debt service, if any, during the same period. (b) Current use of the property and feasibility of alternative uses for the property that could earn a reasonable economic return. Assessment of feasibility shall be based on: (i) Report from a qualified architect or structural engineer as to the structural soundness of any building on the property and its suitability for rehabilitation. (ii) Cost estimates for the proposed construction, alteration, demolition, or removal, and an estimate of any additional costs that would be incurred to comply with the requirements for rehabilitation. (iii) Expert testimony or opinion on the feasibility of rehabilitation or reuse of the existing structure by an architect who meets professional qualifications established by the standards. (c) Estimated market value of the property in each of the following conditions, as evidence by any appraisal performed in the last two years; any listing of all or a portion of the property for sale, lease, rental, or occupancy during the last two years; or other relevant reports or information: (i) In its current condition; (ii) After completion of the proposed alteration or demolition; and (iii) After renovation of the existing property for continued use. (d) Any additional data that supports the claim of economic hardship. (e) A determination of economic hardship will not be granted to a property owner who has engaged in demolition by neglect. A property owner shall provide proof of having conducted routine maintenance and any necessary major repairs on a designated property to support its continued preservation, and demonstrate that demolition by neglect is not the cause the economic hardship request. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 325 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040G: Major Land Subdivision Permit G. Major Land Subdivision Permit 1. Purpose a. The Major Land Subdivision Permit process is intended to ensure that the creation of new developable lots within the City comply with all applicable requirements of state law, this UDC, and all applicable City and other government regulations related to transportation, utilities, protection of sensitive lands, and the provision of public services, and are consistent with the adopted Rochester Comprehensive Plan. b. A Major Land Subdivision Permit is the initial document authorizing the creation of a major subdivision of land and is recognized as the preliminary subdivision plat under Minnesota state law. A Final Plat approval pursuant to Section 60.500.040H will also be required before land subdivision activity can proceed. 2. Applicability a. This Section 60.500.040G applies to all activities that will create five or more new developable lots or parcels which are 2 ½ acres or less in size, or that creates a new vertical subdivision, or that is otherwise defined as a Subdivision of Land by the state of Minnesota or City ordinance, except for: 1) Those activities exempt from regulation by Minnesota Statute Chapter 462; 2) Those activities exempt from these regulations by the Community Development Director because all of the proposed lots front on a platted or dedicated street right-of-way and for which no major changes to the right-of-way are proposed. 3) Those activities related to land or lots that are eligible for approval as a Lot Line Readjustment pursuant to Section 60.500.060J; and 4) Those divisions of land that are eligible for approval as a Minor Land Subdivision Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060GF. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 326 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PERMIT APPROVALMAJOR LAND SUBDIVISION indicates public hearing CITY COUNCIL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040G: Major Land Subdivision Permit 3. Procedure for Major Land Subdivision Permit Approval Applications for a Major Land Subdivision Permit shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040G. If a General Development Plan is required pursuant to Section 60.500.060B, the General Development Plan shall have been approved by City Council prior to or concurrently with action on the application for Major Land Subdivision Permit. a. Notice and Hearing The application for a Major Land Subdivision Permit shall be scheduled for a public hearing before City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. b. Planning Commission Recommendation The Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. c. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for a Major Land Subdivision Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application based on the criteria in Subsection d below. 3) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. d. Final Plat and Grading Permit Required 1) After approval of a Major Land Subdivision Permit, an approved Grading Permit, as described in Section 60.500.060I shall accompany the submittal of the Final Plat for the property. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 327 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040G: Major Land Subdivision Permit 2) No land development activity other than grading may take place on the property prior to Final Plat approval pursuant to Section 60.500.040H. e. Approval of Construction Plans After approval of a Major Land Subdivision Permit, the applicant shall have prepared, by a professional engineer, registered in the state of Minnesota, construction plans, consisting of complete construction drawings and specifications of all easements, streets, traffic control devices, sanitary sewers, storm water facilities, water system facilities, sidewalks and other improvements required by this UDC. Construction plans shall be submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval, and must be consistent with the engineering standards adopted by Public Works in conjunction with the development of subdivisions. f. Phased Development 1) An approved Major Land Subdivision Permit shall enable a landowner to proceed to a Final Plat any time within a two-year period. The Council may approve a phasing plan, extending the effective period of the land subdivision permit up to 10 years, in situations where the landowner intends to develop discrete portions of the site successively, rather than the whole site at one time. Phased development proposals require the landowner to enter into a development agreement with the City. 2) If a development agreement does not extend the two year period, if more than two years have passed since approval of a Major Land Subdivision Permit, changes to the Final Plat may be required where a change in the comprehensive plan or this UDC or related regulations have occurred that affect the compliance of the approved Permit with such documents. The applicant may make the necessary changes and proceed to Final Plat, or may choose to resubmit the Major Land Subdivision Permit application for review pursuant to this Section 60.500.040G. 4. Criteria for Major Land Subdivision Permit Approval The Planning Commission shall recommend, and City Council shall approve, a Major Land Subdivision Permit, if it determines that the following criteria are met: a. The proposed land subdivision is consistent with the adopted Comprehensive Plan. b. The proposed land subdivision conforms to all standards in this UDC, unless a Minor Modification, Major Modification, or Variance for any deviation from the standards in this UDC has been approved pursuant to this UDC. c. The proposed land subdivision permit is consistent with any approved and applicable General Development Plan, Conditional Use Permit, and/or Traffic Impact Study. d. The proposed land subdivision will not result in a violation of federal or state law or city or county ordinance. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 328 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040G: Major Land Subdivision Permit e. The proposed water system and sanitary sewer system are adequate to serve the normal and fire protection demands of proposed development and to provide for the efficient and timely extension to serve future development. f. The plan for soil erosion and stormwater management meets the adopted standards of the City of Rochester and is consistent with the adopted Stormwater Management Plan or adopted drainage or stormwater policies. g. The vehicular, pedestrian, transit and non-motorized system is consistent with adopted transportation plans and is consistent with the street layout standards listed in Section 60.400.040C Subdivision Level Connectivity and Circulation and applicable traffic service standards. h. The soils, topography and water tables have been adequately studied to ensure that all lots are developable for their designated purposes. i. The proposed subdivision will not have off-site impacts on the street, drainage, water, or wastewater systems that exceed adopted standards. j. The lot and block layout provide for safe and convenient pedestrian, non-motorized vehicle, transit, vehicular, service and emergency access, efficient utility service connections, and adequate buildable area in each lot for planned uses. k. The proposed subdivision has taken into account the current six-year and other Long-Range Capital Improvements Programs and the elements listed in those programs in the design of the subdivision. l. The proposed subdivision will not have adverse impacts on the safety or viability of permitted uses on, or the efficient continued development of, adjacent properties. m. Rights-of-way and easements of adequate size and dimension are provided for the purpose of constructing the street, utility, and drainage facilities needed to serve the development. n. The proposed parks, trail thoroughfares, and open space dedications are consistent with adopted plans, policies, and regulations. o. If located in a residential zoning district, the subdivision addresses the need to avoid spillover parking from subdivision residents into surrounding residential districts. p. For any land located within the Special Flood Hazard Area of the FPO – Floodplain Overlay: 1) The proposed subdivision adequately mitigates the risks of flooding, inadequate drainage, soil and rock formations with severe limitations for development, severe erosion potential, or any other floodplain related risks to the health, safety, or welfare of the future residents of the proposed subdivision in a manner consistent with this ordinance; 2) Each lot contains a potential building site located outside of the Floodway District at or above the regulatory flood protection elevation; 3) Adequate drainage is provided to reduce exposure of flood hazard; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 329 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040G: Major Land Subdivision Permit 4) For all subdivisions containing land within the Floodway and/or Flood Fringe District boundaries, the regulatory flood protection elevation and the required elevation of all access roads are clearly labeled on all required subdivision drawings and platting documents; 5) The subdivision provides road access both to the subdivision and to the individual building sites no lower than two feet below the regulatory flood protection elevation; and 6) All public utilities and facilities, such as sewer, gas, electrical, and water systems, are located and constructed to minimize or eliminate flood damage. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 330 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040H: Final Plat H. Final Plat 1. Purpose The Final Plat process is intended to ensure that all aspects of a Major Land Subdivision Permit approved or approved with conditions pursuant to this UDC is accurately documented and recorded in the public land records through the preparation of a subdivision plat meeting the requirements of Minnesota law. 2. Applicability The Final Plat process applies to all lands that are the subject of a Major or Minor Land Subdivision Permit that has been approved or approved with conditions, and must be completed before a Zoning Certificate for any activity on the lots shown in those Permits may occur. 3. Procedure for Final Plat Approval a. Applications for a Final Plat shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040HG. b. The Community Development Director shall approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application for a Final Plat approval based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. c. Phased Development Where a final plat for phased development is subject to a development agreement with the City, phasing will be allowed up to six years for two phases, eight years for three phases and ten years for four phases. 4. Criteria for Final Plat Approval The application shall be approved or approved with conditions, and the applicant authorized to record the Final Plat, if the Community Development Director determines that the plat complies with all applicable provisions of this UDC and Minnesota law and accurately reflects all changes required by the City during the Major Land Subdivision Permit process. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 331 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040I: Official Map Adoption I. Official Map Adoption This Section 60.500.040I implements Minnesota Statute 462.359. In case of conflict between the provisions of this Section and the statute, the statute will apply. 1. Purpose The Official Map Adoption process is intended to clarify how the map designating the locations, names, and details of public streets in the City may be adopted, in conformance with Minnesota state law. 2. Applicability This Section 60.500.040I shall apply whenever the City Council determines that any aspect of the Official Map should be updated, and whenever an update of that map is required by Minnesota Law. 3. Procedure for Official Map Adoption Applications for adoption or OFFICIAL MAP APPROVAL amendment of the Official Map shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040I. a. Application, Notice, and Hearing 1) An application for adoption or amendment of the Official Map may be filed by the Community Development Director, City Engineer, Planning Commission, or City Council. 2) The application for adoption or amendment of the Official Map shall be scheduled for public hearings before the Planning Commission and City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. b. Planning Commission Recommendation The Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council amend the official map, or deny the application, based on the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 332 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040I: Official Map Adoption c. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for adoption of amendment of the Official Street Map pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC and based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below, amend the official map or deny the application to amend. In the event of a denial, the Council will adopt written findings for decision not to adopt. 3) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by written agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter 4. Criteria for Official Map Adoption Approval The Planning Commission shall recommend, and the City Council shall approve, the application for adoption of an Official Map if it determines that the following criteria are met: a. The lands designated on the Map are needed for future street and highway purposes; and b. The Map meets all applicable requirements of Minnesota state law. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 333 PUBLIC STREET OR EASEMENT VACATION APPROVAL Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040J: Public Street or Easement Vacation J. Public Street or Easement Vacation 1. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.500.040JI is to clarify the process for vacating dedicated public right-of-way. 2. Applicability This process applies to all applications to vacate a public street or easement or right-of- way. If does not apply to requests to vacate private easements within or outside of a public street or public right-of-way that do not affect the designation or City or public ownership of the surface of the street or right-of-way or its use for public travel, circulation, or mobility. 3. Procedure for Public Street or Easement Vacation Adoption Applications to vacate a public street or easement shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040JI. a. Application, Notice, and Hearing 1) An application for a Public Street or easement Vacation may be filed by the Community Development Director, City Engineer, Planning Commission, City Council or by petition by owners of at least 50% of the land abutting the public street or easement. 2) The application for Public Street or easement Vacation shall be scheduled for a public hearing before City Council in accordance with Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures. b. Planning Commission Recommendation The Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. c. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for Public Street Vacation pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 334 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040K: Criteria for Public Street Vacation Approval 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, by at least 5 votes of the Council, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application based on the criteria in Subsection d below. 3) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. K. Criteria for Public Street Vacation Approval 1. The Planning Commission shall recommend, and the City Council shall approve, or approve with conditions, the Public Street Vacation if it determines that the application complies with the following criteria: a. The vacation of the public street is in the public interest and will confer a public benefit on the City; b. The vacation of the public street will not deny legally required public access to any lot or parcel. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 335 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040L: Distinctive Development L. Distinctive Development 1. Purpose The purpose of the Distinctive Development procedure is to allow landowners to propose certain types of development that cannot be accomplished through other zoning districts and procedures in this UDC provided that those developments provide to the City benefits equal to or greater than what the City would achieve if the Distinctive Development procedure were not used. The Distinctive Development procedure may not be used simply to obtain relief from otherwise applicable standards in Section 60.300.020, Use-Specific Standards, or to obtain relief from otherwise applicable standards in Chapter 60.400, Development Standards, and Incentives that could have been granted pursuant to Section 60.400.120. 2. Applicability The City may accept an application for Distinctive Development approval if the proposed development cannot be accomplished through any combination of the base and overlay zoning districts in this UDC with any adjustments to UDC standards permitted pursuant to Section 60.500.070, Flexibility and Relief, or by providing the benefits required for certain types of flexibility pursuant to Section 60.400.120 Incentives. Prior to submittal of a Distinctive Development application, a zone change to the most applicable zoning district shall be reviewed and approved by City Council. 3. Procedure for Distinctive Development Approval Applications for Distinctive Development shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040LJ. a. Application 1) The application may include any use or combination of uses listed in Table Section 60.300.010B Allowed Uses Table, but may not include any uses not listed in that Table. 2) The application shall list each standard in Section 60.300.020, Use-Specific Standards, and in Chapter 60.400, Development Standards, applicable to similar types and density/intensity of land, land use, or development that is to be modified or that shall not apply in the Distinctive Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 336 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040L: Distinctive Development Development. Unless identified for modification in the application and approved pursuant to this Section 60.500.040LJ, the applicable standards in Section 60.300.020, Use-Specific Standards, and in Chapter 60.400, Development Standards, shall apply. 3) The Community Development Director may require that an application for approval of a Distinctive Development include a General Development Plan based on the size, complexity, or anticipated impacts of the proposed Distinctive Development. b. Notice and Hearing 1) Notice of the public hearing on a Distinctive Development application shall be provided by publication in a newspaper of general circulation at least 10 days before the date of the hearing. 2) In addition, for any Distinctive Development application, mailed notice shall be sent to all owners of land situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the outer perimeter of the subject property. c. Planning Commission Recommendation The Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. d. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for a Distinctive Development approval pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing or hearings, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. 3) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by written agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. e. Site Plan(s) Required 1) Following approval of the Distinctive Development application the applicant shall prepare and submit a Site Plan(s) for each portion of the property pursuant to Section 60.500.060B that incorporates any changes or conditions imposed by the City Council as part of its decision. 2) The Community Development Director shall review and approve the final Site Development Plan(s) for the Distinctive Development pursuant to Section 60.500.060C. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 337 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040L: Distinctive Development 3) A Land Subdivision Permit for lot consolidation shall be required prior to development approval when a development is proposed across multiple lots. This includes but is not limited to primary structures, accessory structures, off- street parking, bufferyards/landscaping, recreation areas, exterior storage, and signage. 4. Criteria for Approval of Distinctive Development The Planning Commission shall recommend for approval, and the City Council may approve, an application for approval of a Distinctive Development if it complies with the following criteria: a. Meets Applicability Requirements The application as recommended for action still complies with the Purpose statement in Subsection 1 above and the Applicability provisions in Subsection 2 above. b. Exceeds Minimum Design Standards If a Distinctive Development application includes multifamily, mixed use, or industrial structures, these structures shall provide a greater level of design quality than would be required for buildings of a similar type and density/intensity in Section 60.400.070F, Building Design. c. Capacity of Public Facilities The existing or future planned public facilities in the area are adequate to serve the proposed development. d. Geologic Hazards Areas of natural or geologic hazard, such as unstable slopes, sinkholes, and floodplains, have been identified and avoided or the impacts of the Distinctive Development on those areas will be addressed and mitigated in the required Site Development Plan(s). e. Natural Features For developments involving new construction, the arrangement of buildings, paved areas and open space has preserved the existing topography and the existing desirable vegetation on the site to the maximum extent practicable. f. Traffic Impacts The Distinctive Development will not cause the level of service on surrounding streets to be reduced below applicable City standards, and, if located in a Residential zoning district: 1) Will not cause traffic volumes to exceed planned capacities on local residential streets; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 338 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT CITY COUNCIL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONREVIEW & PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040M: See Section 60.500.050A Conditional Use Permit for criteria. 2) Will not generate frequent truck traffic on local residential streets; and 3) Will not create additional traffic during evening and nighttime hours on local residential streets. g. Height Impacts For developments involving new construction, the heights and placement of proposed structures will not create material negative impacts on surrounding Residential zoning district(s). Material negative impacts include but are not limited to block sunlight from reaching adjacent properties during a majority of the day for over four months out of the year. h. Parking Impacts The proposed development will provide adequate motor vehicle parking to avoid overflow parking into surrounding Residential zoning districts. i. Pedestrian and Bicycle Access and Circulation The proposed development will provide pedestrian and bicycle access and circulation better than that required for developments with buildings of a similar type and density/intensity by Section 60.400.040 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT Access and Connectivity. Conditional Use Permit APPROVAL BY CITY COUNCIL Approved by City Council M. See Section 60.500.050A Conditional Use Permit for criteria. indicates public hearing Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 339 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council 0: N. Interim Use Permit 1. Purpose The Interim Use Permit process is intended to allow property in Mixed Use and Non- Residential zoning districts to be used for purposes that may not be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan under conditions that ensure its long-term use will be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. 2. Applicability This Interim Use Permit process applies to: a. All proposed uses of property in the Mixed Use or Non-Residential zoning districts for any use that is not permitted in that zoning district for a period longer than 12 months. b. All land disturbing activities that the City Engineer determines, pursuant to Section 60.500.060I.4.f, Grading Permit, require an application for an Interim Use Permit before a Grading Permit may be approved. 3. Procedure for Interim Use Permit Approval a. Notice and Hearing 1) Notice of the public hearing on an Interim Use application shall be provided by publication in a newspaper of general circulation at least 10 days before the date of the hearing. 2) In addition, for any Interim Use application, mailed notice shall be sent to all owners of land situated wholly or partly within 350 feet of the outer perimeter of the subject property. 3) A Land Subdivision Permit for lot consolidation shall be required prior to development approval when a development is proposed across multiple lots. This includes but is not limited to primary structures, accessory structures, off-street parking, bufferyards/landscaping, recreation areas, exterior storage, and signage. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 340 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.040 Major Decisions by City Council Section 60.500.040N: Interim Use Permit b. Planning Commission Recommendation The Planning Commission shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, recommend that the City Council approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application, based on the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. c. City Council Action 1) The City Council shall hold a public hearing on the application for an Interim Use pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.2, Conduct of Public Hearing. 2) Following the hearing, the City Council shall, within the time limits imposed by this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application based on the criteria in Subsection d below. 3) The final decision may be extended for a reasonable period of time by agreement between the applicant and the Community Development Director, but not to exceed six months from the date of the first hearing on the matter. 4. Criteria for Interim Use Permit Approval The Planning Commission shall recommend approval, and the City Council shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if it complies the following criteria: a. The application complies with all applicable provisions of Chapter 7-5, Rental Unit Registration, of the Rochester Code of Ordinances and the criteria in Section 60.500.030E.3.a.3), except that the interim use of the property need not be a Permitted or Conditional Use of the property allowed in the zoning district where the property is located; b. The proposed use complies with all applicable standards for that use listed in Section 60.300.020, Use-Specific Standards, in the zoning district most similar to that in which the interim use is located, as determined by the Community Development Director; c. The application does not involve or require the construction of any permanent structure with a useful economic life longer than the term of the Interim Use Permit; d. Pursuant to Section 60.500.030E.7 Financial Assurances, the applicant has provided financial assurance adequate if the Community Development Director determines that such assurance are necessary to ensure that the Interim Use will be terminated and any structures related to the interim use be removed (unless the City consents to the continued existence of those structures) at the end of the interim use period; and e. If the application related to land disturbing activities that the City Engineer determines, pursuant to Section 60.500.060I.2.c, require an application for an Interim Use Permit, the applicant has given the City adequate assurances (which may include financial assurances) that the activity will not create substantial adverse impacts on surrounding properties during the Interim Use period or allow the land to be used for purposes inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan after the Interim Use Permit period. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 341 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPROVAL BY PLANNING COMMISSION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050A: Conditional Use Permit f. The date or event that will terminate the use can be identified with certainty. Section 60.500.050 D ECISIONS T HAT R EQUIRE A H EARING BY A D ESIGNATED A UTHORITY A. Conditional Use Permit This process applies to both Conditional Use Permits that may be approved by Planning Commission and those that may only be approved by City Council, as indicated in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table. 1. Purpose The Conditional Use Permit procedure provides a mechanism for the City to evaluate proposed land uses that are generally characterized by infrequency of use, high degree of traffic generation, and/or requirement of a large land area. This procedure is intended to ensure compatibility of such uses with surrounding areas and that adequate mitigation is provided for anticipated impacts. 2. Applicability A Conditional Use Permit shall be required for the establishment of land uses identified as requiring Planning Commission approval or City Council approval in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table. Approval of a new Conditional Use Permit is also required for modification or expansion of an existing conditional use. 3. Procedure for Conditional Use Permit Approval a. An application for approval of a Conditional Use Permit shall be reviewed and a decision made pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, including but not limited to Section 60.500.030E.3.a.3). b. If Table 300.02-1 indicates the use is approved by Planning Commission, the provisions of Section 60.500.030E.3.b Decisions to be Made by Authority shall also apply, and the decision shall be based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. c. If Table 300.02-1 indicates the use may only be approved by City Council, the provisions of Section 60.500.030E.3.c Decisions by City Council shall also apply. In this case, the Planning Commission shall make a recommendation, and the City Council shall make a decision, based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. d. Before approving or approving with conditions a Conditional Use Permit in the FPO – Floodplain District Overlay, the Community Development Director shall confirm that Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 342 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050A: Conditional Use Permit the applicant has obtained all required state and federal permits related to floodproofing and flood protection measures. e. A copy of each decision approving or approving with conditions a Conditional Use Permit in the FPO – Floodplain District Overlay shall be sent by mail to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources within 10 days after the decision. f. A Land Subdivision Permit for lot consolidation shall be required prior to development approval when a development is proposed across multiple lots. This includes but is not limited to primary structures, accessory structures, off-street parking, bufferyards/landscaping, recreation areas, exterior storage, and signage. 4. Criteria for Conditional Use Permit Approval a. General The Planning Commission or the City Council, as indicated in Table 300.02-1, shall approve a Conditional Use Permit if it determines that the proposed use will not create any of the following negative impacts. 1) Vehicular loading, unloading, parking, and vehicular or pedestrian circulation on the site will create hazards to safety or will impose a significant burden upon public facilities; 2) The Site Development Plan does not provide pedestrian access to any customer/tenant ingress/egress of the building, including from a public right-of- way and off-street parking area that serves the use while minimizing non- vehicular/vehicular conflicts; 3) The operation of the use will create significant negative impacts on the surrounding area or will impose undue burdens on the sewers, sanitary and storm drains, water, or similar public facilities; 4) The application will create significant negative environmental impacts on the surrounding area. 5) The application or related Site Development Plan fails to comply with one or more previous use or development approvals for the property, including without limitation any Distinctive Development approval or General Development Plan applicable to the property; and/or 6) The application or related Site Development Plan fails to comply with all applicable UDC regulations or other City adopted regulations applicable the use or zone district in which the property is located, including but not limited to any Use-Specific Standard applicable to the proposed use in Section 60.300.020, unless a Minor Modification, Major Modification, or Variance permitting that deviation has been approved by the City. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 343 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050A: Conditional Use Permit b. Additional Criteria for Approval in FPO – Floodplain District Overlay If the application relates to property in the FPO – Floodplain Overlay, the Planning Commission or the City Council, as indicated in Table 300.01-1, shall approve a Conditional Use Permit if it determines that the following additional criteria have been met. 1) The application may only be approved or approved with conditions if the applicant has obtained all required local, state, and federal government permits related to floor protection and floodproofing. 2) The following factors shall be considered in addition to those in Section 60.500.050A.4: (a) The danger to life and property due to increased flood heights or velocities caused by encroachments; (b) The danger that materials may be swept onto other lands or downstream to the injury of others; (c) The proposed water supply and sanitation systems and the ability of these systems to prevent disease, contamination, and unsanitary condition; (d) The susceptibility of the proposed facility and its contents to flood damage and the effect of such damage on the individual owner; (e) The importance of the services provided by the proposed facility to the community; (f) The need for a waterfront location for the facility; (g) The availability of alternative locations not subject to flooding for the proposed use; (h) The compatibility of the proposed use with existing development and development anticipated in the foreseeable future; (i) The relationship of the proposed use to the comprehensive floodplain plan and management program for the area; (j) The safety of access to the property in times of flood for ordinary and emergency vehicles; and (k) The expected heights, velocity, duration, rate of rise, and sediment transport of the flood waters expected at the site. c. Additional Criteria for Approval in SDO -- Shoreland District Overlay If the application relates to property in SDO – Shoreland District Overlay, the Planning Commission or the City Council, as indicated in Table 300.01-1, shall approve a Conditional Use Permit if it determines that the following additional criteria have been met: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 344 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050A: Conditional Use Permit 1) A thorough evaluation of the waterbody and topographic, vegetation, and soil conditions on the site to ensure: (a) The prevention of soil erosion or other possible pollution of public waters, both during and after construction; (b) The visibility of structures and other facilities as viewed from public waters is limited; (c) The site is adequate for water supply and on-site sewage treatment; and (d) The types, uses, and numbers of watercraft that the project will generate are compatible in relation to the suitability of public waters to safely accommodate watercraft; 2) Setbacks from the Ordinary High Water Level; 3) A wetland delineation is required for all development that has Decorah Edge soils or groundwater supported wetlands on the Decorah Edge overlay Map and or Hydric Soils based on the USDA Soil Survey as they are administered by the City’s 6-3 Wetland Conservation Ordinance; and 4) Special provisions for the location, design, and use of structures, sewage treatment systems, watercraft launching and docking areas, and vehicle parking areas. 5. Modifications to Approved Conditional Use Permits a. Minor Modifications 1) Subject to the restrictions listed below, the Community Development Director is authorized to make changes to approved Conditional Use Permits if necessitated by engineering factors or other circumstances unforeseen at the time the permit was approved. 2) Minor modifications include but are not limited to modification in building locations; height; maximum lot coverage; maximum or minimum floor area; exterior facades; landscaping materials and placement; design of public facilities; and the addition, deletion, or change of accessory structures or uses; but do not include any modification of required public infrastructure addressed in a development agreement and do not include any of the following: (a) In the case of residential development, an increase or decrease in the number of approved dwelling units by more than 10 percent; (b) An increase or decrease in the floor area ratio resulting in more than ten percent change in building coverage on the lot; (c) Changes in site design that may create problems or conflicts associated with vehicular traffic, transit vehicle or patron, non-motorized vehicle or pedestrian circulation on-site and at access points; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 345 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050A: Conditional Use Permit (d) Inadequate public facilities; (e) A reduction in off-street parking and loading spaces, unless the reduction in parking does not result in non-conformance with the requirements of this UDC; (f) A significant change in the character of the project as originally approved including: (i) Elimination of one of the major approved elements of the project such as the approved use; (ii) Reduction of transparency at the ground level, by more than 10 percent either through elimination of glass, or obstruction of more than 10 percent of glassing that reduces the visibility in and out of the structure; and (iii) Significant change in either the durability or quality of building materials or landscaping. b. Major Modifications Modifications to approved Conditional Use Permits that are not listed in Subsection a.2) above may only be approved through the same process used to approve the Conditional Use Permit being amended. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 346 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050B: Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration B. Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration 1. Purpose The Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration process is intended to ensure that any proposed major alterations to a designated landmark property, including contributing properties within a landmark district, comply with all applicable provisions of the HPO – Historic Preservation Overlay in Section 60.200.040C and with all other provisions of this UDC and City regulations designed protect properties historically significant to the community. 2. Applicability A Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration is required for all alterations to a designated landmark property or to a contributing property in landmark district, except for those that qualify for approval as a Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration pursuant to Section 60.500.060D Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration and those activities that are exempt from the requirement to obtain a Certificate of Appropriateness pursuant to Section 60.500.060D.2.b, Exemptions. 3. Procedure for Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration a. An application for approval of a Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration shall be reviewed and a decision made pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, including but not limited to Section 60.500.030E.3.b, Decisions to be Made by , unless modified by this Section 60.500.050B. b. If Table 500.01-1 indicates the use is subject to Heritage Preservation Commission approval, the provisions of Section 60.500.030E.3.b, Decisions to be Made by Designated Authority, shall also apply, except that a public meeting that allows for public comment rather than a public hearing shall be required, and the decision shall be based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. 4. Criteria for Certificate of Appropriateness – Major Alteration Approval The Heritage Preservation Commission shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if it complies with the applicable Secretary of the Interior Standards, as described in Section 60.200.040C.8. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 347 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050C: Shoreland Protection Permit C. Shoreland Protection Permit 1. Purpose The Shoreland Protection Permit process is intended to allow for new projects on undeveloped land, redevelopment of previously built sites, or conversions of existing buildings and land in the SDO – Shoreland District Overlay in a way that complies with all applicable provisions in Section 60.200.040F, and protects and enhances the natural scenic qualities and environmental benefits of the Shoreland District Overlay both during and after development. 2. Applicability This Section 60.500.050C applies to all land in the SDO – Shoreland District Overlay, and requires that a Shoreland Protection Permit be obtained before conducting any of the following activities on such land, in addition to any other development applications required by other sections of this ordinance: a. Industrial uses; b. Residential development containing five or more dwelling units with densities exceeding four units per suitable acre, as described in Section 60.200.040F.3.c; c. Subdivisions of five or more dwelling units with densities exceeding the minimum lot width density standards in Section 60.200.040F.4.b. d. Accessory Agricultural uses; e. Any structure, with the exception of a water-oriented accessory structure, or grading in the Shoreland Impact Zone; 3. Procedure for Shoreland Protection Permit Approval a. The Community Development Director shall review any information received under Section 60.500.030D and make a determination of whether the applicant is entitled it issuance of the permit by a fair preponderance of the evidence. Following the preliminary decision on the application, the Community Development Director shall prepare a notice of action as required by Section 60.500.030F.1 and shall transmit a copy to the Planning Commission at their next regularly scheduled meeting. b. An application for approval of a Shoreland Protection Permit shall be reviewed and a decision made by the Planning Commission pursuant to Section 60.500.030, Common Procedures, pursuant to the criteria in Subsection 4. below. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 348 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050C: Shoreland Protection Permit c. The Planning Commission shall conduct a public hearing, as required by Section 60.500.030, to consider upholding or reversing the preliminary decision of the Community Development Director. d. Following approval or approval with conditions of a Shoreland Protection Permit, the applicant must obtain all other applicable approvals, as required by this ordinance, prior to beginning development activities. 4. Criteria for Shoreland Protection Permit Approval The Planning Commission shall approve a Shoreland Protection Permit authorizing a conditional use in the Shoreland District Overlay, unless the Planning Commission makes one or more of the following findings with respect to the proposed development: a. The intensity, location, operation, and dimensions of the proposed structure will be detrimental to the shoreland environment, and will impose undue burdens on existing natural drainage ways, sensitive lands and soils, and public waterways. b. The provisions for on-site bufferyards and landscaping do not provide adequate protection of adjacent public waterways and do not maintain the natural vegetation of the site. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 349 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.050 Decisions That Require a Hearing by a Designated Authority Section 60.500.050C: Shoreland Protection Permit 1) For residential developments consisting of buildings containing five or more units, or industrial developments, the following vegetation management standards shall apply. (a) The riparian edge of the lot within the Shore Impact Zone must be preserved in its natural or existing state, for a minimum of 80 percent. Where the existing or natural state of the riparian edge has been previously cleared or lacks deep-rooted, woody vegetation, the shore impact zone shall be restored consistent with the Standards in Section 60.200.040F.11.a.3. (b) These protections shall be preserved in perpetuity and maintained by use of deed restrictions, covenants, permanent easements, public dedication, or other equally effective and permanent means. (c) The city shall monitor compliance under Section 60.300.040F.11.a.3 to ensure permanent protection. 2) For residential subdivisions containing buildings with four or fewer dwelling units, the following vegetation management standards shall apply, which are alternative to those detailed in Section 60.200.040F.11.a.2.c&d. (a) 100% of the Shore Impact Zone must be preserved in its natural or existing state. Where the existing or natural state of the riparian edge has been previously cleared or lacks deep-rooted, woody vegetation, the entirety of the shore impact zone shall be restored consistent with the Standards in Section 60.200.040F.11.a.3. (b) These protections of the shore impact zone shall be preserved in perpetuity and by use of shared ownership, HOA covenants, or public dedication. The city shall monitor compliance under Section 60.300.040F.11.a.3 to ensure permanent protection. (c) The city shall monitor compliance under Section 60.300.040F.11.a.3 to ensure permanent protection. c. The project plans fail to provide adequate protection against soil erosion and/or stormwater management problems that may be created by the development. d. The proposed development does not comply with all applicable standards of the SDO – Shoreland District Overlay, the standards of the underlying zoning district, or the standards specifically applicable to the proposed use, and a variance or modification to allow such deviation has not been secured by the applicant. e. The proposed development will increase flood heights and/or flood duration, will increase the rate of rise, will modify the extents of the floodplain, will increase sediment transport, and/or will increase flow velocities of the flood waters expected at the site. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 350 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALS APPEAL TO ZONING ZONING CERTIFICATE APPROVAL DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060A: Zoning Certificate f. The development poses a danger that materials may be swept onto other lands or downstream to the injury of others or damage to property. Section 60.500.060 D EVELOPMENT A PPROVALS BY C OMMUNITY D EVELOPMENT D IRECTOR A. Zoning Certificate 1. Purpose Zoning Certificates are issued by the Community Development Director to authorize a development to proceed based on information included on the application evidencing compliance with UDC requirements. 2. Applicability a. A zoning certificate shall be required before: 1) Any new use may be established involving a change in the use or appearance of exterior of a building or involving the erection, construction, reconstruction or alteration of a building or structure; 2) An existing use is changed or modified so as to alter the character of its occupancy; 3) The re-establishment of a previous use involving the erection, reconstruction, construction or alteration of a building or structure; or 4) The issuance of a temporary permit. 5) The amplification of sound pursuant to Chapter 117 of the Rochester Municipal Code, in which case the Community Development Director’s signature on an application for a Sound Amplification Permit shall constitute a zoning certificate for that activity. 3. Procedure for Zoning Certificate Approval An application for approval of Zoning Certificate shall be reviewed and a decision made pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Subsection 4 below. 4. Criteria for Zoning Certificate Approval a. The Community Development Director shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if it complies with the criteria in Section 60.500.030E.3.a.3). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 351 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060A: Zoning Certificate b. No use or development authorized by a Conditional Use Permit, or requiring a Minor Modification, Major Modification, or Variance shall be issued until a Zoning Certificate confirming compliance with any conditions attached to those prior approvals has been approved. c. The Community Development Director will approve a conditional certificate of zoning occupancy where conditions beyond the control of the applicant exist which will not permit total completion of the development for a specified period of time. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 352 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060B: General Development Plan B. General Development Plan 1. Purpose The purpose of the General Development Plan requirement is to ensure that a landowner investigates the broad effects development will have not only on the site itself, but on adjacent properties and the on and off-site public infrastructure system. 2. Applicability a. Approval of a General Development Plan is required prior to or simultaneously with City Council action on any of the following types of applications under this UDC: 1) Each Comprehensive Plan Amendment that is not initiated by the City; 2) Each Rezoning involving more than five acres of land that is not initiated by the City; 3) Each Major Land Subdivision Permit; 4) A Distinctive Development, if required by the Community Development Director pursuant to Section 60.500.040L.3.a.3). b. City Council may initiate a General Development Plan in connection with applications under this UDC other than those listed in Subsection 2.a above if Council determines that the application may have significant negative impacts on the surrounding area or on the City’s ability to provide adequate infrastructure or public services to the proposed development or other areas of the City. c. The owner of property that is not the subject of an application listed in Subsection 2.a above may file an application to approve a General Development Plan. In this case, the application shall include the signatures of each property owner included in the proposed boundaries of the GDP or a statement as to why there are any non- signatories, if applicable. d. Notwithstanding the provisions of Subsection 2.a above, approval of a General Development Plan is not required in connection with the types of applications listed in Subsections 2.a.1), 2), or 3) for: 1) Any proposed development for which no new connections to a public street are required, and for which this UDC does not require the preparation of a Traffic Impact Report. 2) Any proposed development for which the applicant is required to receive approval of a Conditional Use Permit or Site Development Plan for a project that will be approved under the provisions of a Registered Land Survey rather than a final subdivision plat. 3) Except within the Wetland Conservation and the DEO - Decorah Edge Overlay, any proposed development for which: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 353 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALS APPEAL TO ZONING GENERAL DEVELOPMEN PLAN DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060B: General Development Plan (a) An active General Development Plan has previously been approved by City Council; (b) The Community Development Director determines that new proposed streets need not continue beyond the land to be subdivided in order to complete an appropriate street system or to provide access to adjacent property. (c) The Community Development Director has determined that any application for re-zoning is consistent with the land use designation in the adopted Rochester Comprehensive Plan and for which no new right-of-way, street or utility easement is needed to accommodate the orderly development of the subject parcel and abutting property. 3. Procedure for General Development Plan Approval Applications for a General Development Plan approval shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.040E.3. a. Criteria for General Development Plan Approval The Community Development Director shall approve a General Development Plan if the following are satisfied: 1) All applicable standards in this UDC are met including the proposed land uses for the underlying zoning district as stated in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table, and standards in Section 60.400.030, Subdivision Standards, and Section 60.400.040, Access and Connectivity; 2) The mix of housing is consistent with adopted the Comprehensive Plan. 3) The proposed plan makes provisions for planned improvements and streets reflected in the City’s adopted Capital Improvements Program; 4) Utilities are available to directly serve the area of the proposed land use, or the City is planning for the extension of utilities to serve the area of the proposed development and such utilities are in the first three years of the City’s current 6- Year Capital Improvements Program, or that other arrangements have been made pursuant to Section 60.500.030E.7 Financial Assurances to ensure that adequate utilities will be available concurrently with development; 5) Provisions for wetlands areas and DEO zoning district Edge Support comply with applicable standards in this UDC and will maintain the quality and quantity Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 354 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060B: General Development Plan of groundwater recharging lower aquifers and to protect discharge, interflow, infiltration, and recharge processes. If the eventual platting of the area will require approval of a Major Land Subdivision Permit, the proposed development must satisfy one of the following categories of development: (a) A development bounded on all sides by arterial or higher-level streets, streams, or other topographic constraints, existing development, land already included in an approved General Development Plan, or permanent open space that limits the inclusion of other abutting lands; (b) A development with adequate public facilities and constituting the entire remaining service area of a major public facility improvement (such as a trunk sewer or water tower) that has been identified as a project in the Capital Improvement Program; (c) A development that consists of at least 80 acres in land area regardless of ownership or interest, and consists of all lands for which the applicant has ownership or interest; or (d) A development for which a development agreement has been executed by the owner and the city for the entire property included in the proposed General Development Plan. The development agreement must have been drafted based on the development of the property occurring as proposed in the General Development Plan. b. Modifications to a General Development Plan The Community Development Director will approve amendments to an approved General Development Plan if the Director determines that they comply with the criteria in Subsection a above, and will waive any application submittal requirements not required to evaluate the impacts of the proposed modification. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 355 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALS APPEAL TO ZONING SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN APPROVAL DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060C: Site Development Plan C. Site Development Plan 1. Purpose a. The Site Development Plan review process is intended to promote the safe, functional, and aesthetic development of property and to ensure that new structures, utilities, streets, parking, circulation systems, yards, and open spaces are developed in conformance with the standards of this UDC. b. The Site Development Plan review shall consider the siting of structures and related site improvements so as to promote harmonious relationships with adjacent development, promote use of non-motorized transportation and transit, enhance the pedestrian environment, and minimize bicycle, pedestrian, and motorized vehicle conflicts. 2. Applicability a. Site Development Plan review is required for: 1) All site development in the City that requires a development permit except a detached single-family dwelling, twin-home dwelling, or duplex dwelling; 2) All construction or modification of structures, parking lots and the creation of impervious surfaces; 3) All changes of use on a site, as determined by the Community Development Director. b. Site Development Plan approval shall occur prior to the issuance of a building permit. c. When a Site Development Plan application is reviewed, or when the Final Plan for a Planned Development is reviewed, the Site Development Plan review is included as part of those reviews. 3. Procedure for Site Development Plan Approval a. An application for approval of a Site Development Plan shall be reviewed and a decision made pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Section 4 below b. Development pursuant to an approved Site Development Plan must begin within one year after approval, unless otherwise approved by the Community Development Director, or the approval becomes null and void. c. A Land Subdivision Permit for lot consolidation shall be required prior to site development approval when a Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 356 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060C: Site Development Plan development is proposed proposed across multiple lots. This includes but is not limited to primary structures, accessory structures, off-street parking, bufferyards/landscaping, recreation areas, exterior storage, and signage. 4. Criteria for Site Development Plan Approval The Community Development Director shall approve a Site Development Plan if it satisfies all of the following. a. The proposed development is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. b. The proposed development complies with all applicable laws and ordinances. c. The Site Development Plan layout satisfies the purpose and all development standards of the underlying zoning district unless a variance is approved. d. The proposed development, wherever practical, indicates all utility service transmission systems (including, but not limited to, water, sewer, natural gas, electrical, and telephone lines) are placed underground. e. The proposed development will occur in a manner that will not impede the normal and orderly development or improvement of surrounding property for uses permitted by applicable laws and ordinances. f. The proposed development is consistent with adopted policies and standards for access, grading, drainage, erosion control, and stormwater management. g. The proposed development is consistent with any approved General Development Plan, Conditional Use Permit, and Traffic Impact Study approved for the property. h. There has been complete compliance with all issues addressed in any applicable development agreement. i. The proposed development provides convenient access for pedestrians and transit patrons to the building entrance(s), bicycle access to designated bicycle parking and motor scooter parking, unless determined by the Community Development Director to be unnecessary due to the context or programmed improvements. j. The proposed development, including its size and density is compatible with the existing and planned development of adjacent property. k. On-site access and circulation design for pedestrians, bicyclists, transit vehicles, and patrons and private vehicles and integration of these facilities with adjacent properties will support the safe travel of persons of all ages and abilities by minimizing vehicular, pedestrian, and bicycle conflicts through the use of appropriate traffic calming, pedestrian safety, and other design features appropriate to the context. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 357 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060D: Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration D. Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration 1. Purpose The Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration process is intended to ensure that any proposed minor alterations to a designated landmark property, including those properties within a landmark district, comply with all applicable provisions in Section 60.200.040E and with all other provisions of this UDC and City regulations designed protect properties historically significant to the community. 2. Applicability a. When Required A Certificate of Appropriateness –Minor Alteration is required for: 1) Replacement or alteration of signs and awnings. 2) Replacement or alterations of features that are not character defining. 3) Alterations not visible from public land or the right-of-way. 4) Alterations to non-contributing properties in any historic district. b. Exemptions The following activities may be performed without the requirement to obtain a Certificate of Appropriateness. 1) Maintenance and repair that does not affect the external appearance of the property; 2) Interior remodeling and modifications that do not affect the external appearance; 3) Exterior repainting (color selection), or re-plastering similar to the existing finish; 4) Routine repair or maintenance such as caulking, replacement of fasteners, repair of window glazing or other such minimally intrusive work; and 5) Upgrading of mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems and other code- required work to make properties functional, when it has no visual impact to the property as seen from off-site. 6) If there is a question as to whether an activity qualifies as exempt from the requirement for a Certificate of Appropriateness, the Heritage Preservation Commission shall make the determination regarding exemption status of the proposed activity. 7) In an emergency situation where immediate repair is needed to protect the safety of a building or structure and its inhabitants, the Community Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 358 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing COMMISSIONPRESERVATION HERITAGE APPEAL TO MINOR ALTERATION –CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060D: Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration Development Director and Building Official may approve the alteration without prior Heritage Preservation Commission action. 3. Procedure for Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration An application for approval of Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alterations shall be reviewed and a decision made by the Community Development Director pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Section 4 below. 4. Criteria for Certificate of Appropriateness – Minor Alteration Approval The Community Development Director shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if it complies with the applicable Secretary of the Interior Standards, as described in Section 60.200.040C.8.d. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 359 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALSZONING APPEAL TO APPROVALRENTAL HOUSING CERTIFICATE DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060E: Rental Housing Certificate E. Rental Housing Certificate 1. Purpose The Rental Housing Certificate process is intended to ensure that each rental unit in the city meets all applicable requirements of this UDC and applicable City regulations. 2. Applicability A valid Rental Housing Certificate shall be required for each habitable dwelling unit in the City before the Building and Safety Department may approve a registration certificate allowing an owner or operator to rent any dwelling unit for occupancy by another individual. 3. Procedure for Rental Housing Certificate Approval An application for approval of Rental Housing Certificate shall be reviewed and a decision made by the Community Development Director pursuant to Section 38.05 of the Rochester Municipal Code and Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Section 4 below. 4. Criteria for Rental Housing Certificate Approval The Community Development Director shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if it complies with all applicable provisions of Section 38.05 of the Rochester Municipal Code and the criteria in Section 60.500.030E.3.a.3). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 360 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALSZONING TO APPEAL TEMPORARY PERMIT APPROVAL DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060F: Temporary Permit F. Temporary Permit 1. Purpose The Temporary Permit process is intended to allow the short-term use of property (not to exceed a maximum of 12 calendar months) for purposes permitted in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table under conditions that minimize potential negative impacts on surrounding properties. 2. Applicability A Temporary Permit is required for each use listed as a Temporary in Table 300.01-1 Allowed Uses Table. 3. Procedure for Temporary Permit Approval a. An application for approval of Temporary Permit shall be reviewed and a decision made by the Community Development Director pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Section 4 below. b. In addition to those conditions listed in Section 60.300.020H1, the Community Development Director may attach such conditions as the Director determines necessary to protect the public health and safety during the temporary permit. c. Approval of a Temporary Permit shall be in the form of a revocable permit for a period effective for not more than 12 calendar months. d. A Temporary Permit may not be extended beyond 12 calendar months. Any continuation of the approved activity requires the application for and approval of a new Temporary Permit. 4. Criteria for Temporary Permit Approval The Community Development Director shall approve the application, or approve it with conditions, if: a. It complies with all applicable use-specific standards in Section 60.300.020H Temporary Permits; and b. It complies with the criteria in Section 60.500.030E.3.a.3). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 361 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060G: Minor Land Subdivision Permit G. Minor Land Subdivision Permit 1. Purpose a. The Minor Land Subdivision Permit process is intended to ensure that the creation of small numbers of new developable lots within the City comply with all applicable requirements of state law, this UDC, and all applicable City and other government regulations related to transportation, utilities, protection of sensitive lands, and the provision of public services, and are consistent with the adopted Rochester Comprehensive Plan. b. A Minor Land Subdivision Permit is the initial document authorizing the creation of a minor subdivision of land and is recognized as the preliminary plan under Minnesota state law. 2. Applicability a. This Section 60.500.060G applies to all activities that will create no more than four new developable lots, including vertical as defined in Minnesota state law that will create no more than four new lots, or that is otherwise defined as a Subdivision of Land that creates no more than four new developable parcels by the state of Minnesota or City ordinance, all of the proposed lots front on a platted or dedicated street right-of-way and for which no major changes to the right-of-way are proposed; except for: 1) Those activities exempt from regulation by Minnesota Statute Chapter 462; 2) Those activities related to land or lots that are eligible for approval as a Lot Line Readjustment pursuant to Section 60.500.060J; 3) Those divisions of land that are required to complete a Major Land Subdivision Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.040G; and 4) Activities that are the subject of a Grading Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060H.4.f, unless the activity will involve the construction of structures or improvements that will continue to exist following the completion of the Grading Permit. b. If the Community Development Director determines that the Minor Land Subdivision Permit process is being used repeatedly or on related parcels of land to avoid the Major Land Subdivision Permit process in Section 60.500.040G, or that the use of the Minor Land Subdivision Permit process by the same owner or by owners acting in concert and that the impacts of the series of applications creates impacts on the land, surrounding properties, or City services and infrastructure similar to those created by a Major Land Subdivision, the Director will require that the applicant complete the Major Land Subdivision Permit process. c. A Minor Land Subdivision Permit shall be required prior to site development approval when a development is proposed on more than one lot; and/or a development is proposed across multiple lots. This includes but is not limited to primary structures, Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 362 APPEAL TO MINOR LAND SUBDIVISION APPROVAL indicates public hearing RECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ZONING APPEALSBOARD OF Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060G: Minor Land Subdivision Permit accessory structures, off-street parking, bufferyards/landscaping, recreation areas, exterior storage, and signage. 3. Procedure for Minor Land Subdivision Permit Approval a. An application for approval of a Minor Land Subdivision Permit shall be reviewed and a decision made by the Community Development Director pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Section 4 below. b. No grading of the property included in the Minor Land Subdivision Permit may occur until a Grading Permit pursuant to Section 60.500.060H.4.f, as applicable, has been obtained. c. After approval of a Minor Land Subdivision Permit, the applicant shall have prepared, by a professional engineer, registered in the state of Minnesota, construction plans, consisting of complete construction drawings and specifications of all easements, streets, traffic control devices, sanitary sewers, storm water facilities, water system facilities, sidewalks and other improvements required by this UDC. Construction plans shall be submitted to the City Engineer for review and approval. 4. Criteria for Minor Land Subdivision Permit Approval The Community Development Director shall approve a Minor Land Subdivision Permit, if it determines that the following criteria are met: a. The proposed land subdivision is consistent with the Rochester Comprehensive Plan. b. The proposed land subdivision conforms to all standards in this UDC, unless a Minor Modification, Major Modification, or Variance for any deviation from the standards in this UDC has been approved pursuant to this UDC. c. The proposed land subdivision permit is consistent with any approved and applicable General Development Plan, Conditional Use Permit, and/or Traffic Impact Study. d. The proposed land subdivision will not result in a violation of federal or state law or city or county ordinance. e. The proposed water system and sanitary sewer system are adequate to serve the normal and fire protection demands of proposed development and to provide for the efficient and timely extension to serve future development. f. The plan for soil erosion and stormwater management meets the adopted standards of the City of Rochester and is consistent with the adopted Stormwater Management Plan or adopted drainage or stormwater policies. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 363 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060H: Floodplain Development Permit g. The lot layout provides for safe and convenient pedestrian, non-motorized vehicle, transit, vehicular, service and emergency access, efficient utility service connections, and adequate buildable area in each lot for planned uses. h. The proposed subdivision will not have adverse impacts on the safety or viability of permitted uses on, or the efficient continued development of, adjacent properties. H. Floodplain Development Permit 1. Purpose The Floodplain Development Permit process is intended to ensure that all development in the FPO – Floodplain Overlay complies with all applicable provisions in Section 60.200.040E and with all other provisions of this UDC and City regulations designed to reduce the risk of damage due to flooding. 2. Applicability This Section 60.500.060H applies to all land in the FPO – Floodplain Overlay district, and requires that a Floodplain Development Permit be obtained before conducting any of the following activities on such land: a. The erection, addition, modification, rehabilitation, or alteration of any building or structure. Normal maintenance and repair requires a permit if, separately or in conjunction with other planned work, it constitutes substantial improvement; b. The use or change of use of a building, structure, or land; c. The construction of a dam, on-site septic system, or fence, except for a farm fence; d. The change or extension of a nonconforming use; e. The repair of a structure that has been damaged by flood, fire, tornado, or any other source; f. The placement of fill, excavation of materials, or the storage of materials or equipment; g. Relocation or alteration of a watercourse (including new or replacement culverts and bridges), unless a public waters work permit has been applied for; h. All new construction and substantial improvements; i. All placement of manufactured homes; and j. Any other type of development. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 364 CITY ENGINEER DECISION indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALSZONING TO APPEAL PERMIT APPROVALFLOODPLAIN DEVELOPMENT Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060H: Floodplain Development Permit 3. Procedure for a Floodplain Development Permit a. An application for approval of Floodplain Development Permit shall be reviewed and a decision made by the City Engineer pursuant to Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures, pursuant to the Criteria in Section 4 below. b. Before authorizing any alteration or relocation of a river or stream, the Community Development Director must notify adjacent communities. Applying for a permit to work in public waters pursuant to Minn. Stat. Sec. 103G.245 suffices as adequate notice. A copy of the notification must also be submitted to the Chicago Regional Office of the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). c. Following the approval or approval with conditions of a Floodplain Development Permit, the applicant must obtain a Zoning Certificate before beginning any of the activities listed in Subsection 2 above. d. Following completion of the activities authorized by a Floodplain Development Permit and Zoning Certificate, the applicant shall submit certification by a registered professional engineer, registered architect, or registered land surveyor that the finished fill and building elevations were accomplished in compliance with the provisions of this UDC. Where applicable, the applicant shall submit analysis of no- rise for projects in the Floodway. A registered professional engineer or architect shall certify that the flood-proofing methods are adequate to withstand the flood depth, pressures, velocities, impact, and uplift forces. Where a nonconforming structure is extended or substantially altered the certificate of zoning compliance shall specifically state the manner in which the nonconforming use or structure differs from the flood protection standards and criteria in this UDC. e. Accessory structures designed in accordance with Section 6.212 are exempt from certification required by Subsection d above, provided sufficient documentation is provided. f. The Community Development Director shall maintain a record of the elevation of the lowest floor (including basement) of all new structures and alterations or additions to existing structures in the FPO district, as well as the elevation to which structures and alterations or additions to structures are floodproofed. g. As soon as is practicable, but not later than six months after the date such supporting information becomes available, the Community Development Director must notify the Chicago Regional Office of FEMA of any physical changes that increase or decrease Base Flood Elevations by submitting a copy of the relevant technical or scientific data. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 365 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060H: Floodplain Development Permit 4. Criteria for Floodplain Development Permit Approval The application may be approved or approved with conditions a Floodplain Development Permit if the Community Development Director determines that If a proposed building site is in the FPO – Floodplain Overlay, all construction and substantial improvements including the placement of manufactured homes must be: a. Designed (or modified) and adequately anchored to prevent floatation, collapse, or lateral movement of the structure resulting from hydrodynamic and hydrostatic loads, including the effects of buoyancy; b. Constructed with materials and utility equipment resistant to flood damage; c. Constructed by methods and practices that minimize flood damage; d. Constructed with electrical, heating, ventilation, plumbing, and air conditioning equipment and other service facilities that are designed and/or located so as to prevent water from entering or accumulating within the components during conditions of flooding at least as high as the regulatory Flood Protection Elevation; e. Designed to provide adequate drainage to reduce exposure to flood hazards; and f. Designed in a way that is not detrimental to uses in adjoining areas. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 366 CITY ENGINEER DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060I: Grading Permit I. Grading Permit 1. Purpose The City shall review any development project involving significant changes in land form to review impacts on drainage patterns, protect ground water supplies, to minimize risks from shifting or settling soils or rock formations, and to mitigate the visual impact of grading Activities. 2. Applicability a. Except as listed in Subsection 2.b below, a Grading Permit shall be required for any non-agricultural project involving the movement of 50 cubic yards of earth material. b. The following activities are exempt from the requirement to obtain a Grading Permit: 1) Agricultural operations involved in crop production; 2) Activity necessary as an emergency measure for the safety or protection of life or property; and 3) Activities exempted under the applicable provisions of the Minnesota State Building Code. 4) Excavation of a basement for which a building permit has been issued 5) Installation of utilities not involving other surface grading c. If the City Engineer determines that the activity proposed in an application for a Grading Permit may have substantial impacts on surrounding properties, or will result in structures that will remain on the land following the proposed grading activities, or may allow or prepare the land for uses inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan, the Engineer can require that the applicant obtain an Interim Use Permit for the land disturbance activity from City Council before approving the Grading Permit. 3. Procedure for Grading Permit Approval a. Applications for a Grading Permit shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this APPEAL TO ZONING Section 60.500.060H.4.f. BOARD OF APPEALS b. The City Engineer shall approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application for a Grading Permit based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 367 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060I: Grading Permit 4. Criteria for Grading Permit Approval The application shall be approved or approved with conditions if the City Engineer determines that the application complies with this UDC and all applicable City, state, and federal regulations and has minimized any negative impacts on surrounding properties related to. a. Restoration and stabilization of cut and fill areas; b. Drainage patterns; c. Water quality and quantity; d. Permanent and interim erosion and sediment control plans; and e. The amount and type of material being moved to or from the site. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 368 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing BOARD OF APPEALSZONING TO EALAPP LOT LINE READJUSTMENT APPROVAL DIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.060 Development Approvals by Community Development Director Section 60.500.060J: Lot Line Readjustment J. Lot Line Readjustment 1. Purpose The Lot Line Readjustment process is intended to allow minor adjustments between the boundaries of already platted lots or unplatted parcels that create no more than one additional developable lots and do not require the dedication of additional right-of-way. 2. Applicability The Lot Line Readjustment process applies in the following situations: a. The rearrangement of existing lot lines for either part of a platted lot or an unplatted parcel, when no additional lots or parcels are created and no parcels are removed; and b. A single re-subdivision and rearrangement of a single parcel or group of parcels in an R-1 or R-2 district that creates no more than one additional lot or parcel, and that does not remove any existing parcels, where the dedication of a street or easement to provide additional access is not required. This process may be used only once for each parcel of land. c. All parcels associated with the application must be within the same recorded subdivision. If any parcels are located in a different subdivision, the application must follow the Minor Land Subdivision process as described in Section 60.500.060GF. d. Following the approval of the lot line readjustment, a Lot Combination through the County Recorder’s office is required. 3. Procedure for Lot Line Readjustment Approval a. Applications for a Lot Line Readjustment Permit shall comply with all applicable requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.060J. b. The Community Development Director shall approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application for a Lot Line Readjustment based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. 4. Criteria for Lot Line Readjustment Approval The application may be approved or approved with conditions if the Community Development Director determines that it complies with the following criteria: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 369 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.060K: Sign Permit a. Each of the resulting lots will meet the minimum dimensional requirements for the zoning district in which it is located, as shown in Section 60.400.020 Dimensional Standards, b. No additional general utility easements, drainage easements, access easements or street easements or rights-of way shall be required to provide access or adequate utility services to any of the resulting lots. c. No lot or parcel included in the application has been the subject of or included in a previous Lot Line Readjustment application or decision. The re-subdivision of any lot or parcel that was subdivided or modified through a Lot Line Readjustment (formerly known as a Type I Land Subdivision) after January 1, 1992, shall be subject to review and approval as a Minor Land Subdivision Permit, as described in Section 60.500.060G. K. Sign Permit The City reviews any applications to erect or modify a sign through the Building Permit process. See Rochester Code of Ordinances, Chapter 4.1, Building Code. Section 60.500.070 F LEXIBILITY AND R ELIEF A. Minor Modification 1. Purpose The Minor Modification procedure is intended to allow relatively small modifications of dimensional, numeric, and certain other standards of this UDC where the need for the adjustment is due to unusual site conditions and the approved modification will not have a material negative impact on surrounding properties. 2. Applicability a. The ability to request a Minor Modification is available to all applications for an approval under this UDC except an application for another form of flexibility or relief pursuant to this Section 60.500.070A. b. No request for a Minor Modification may include any type or level of relief for which a Major Modification pursuant to Section 60.500.070B or a Variance pursuant to Section 60.500.070C is required. c. A Minor Modification request may be used to amend the standards of a restricted development approved under prior versions of this ordinance. d. A Minor Modification shall not be granted to allow any modification of any dimensional standard listed in Section 60.400.020G, Exceptions to the Dimensional Standards by an amount larger than is permitted by that Section. e. A request for a Minor Modification may only be submitted for a single platted lot, or for up to three contiguous lots under common or related ownership. Individual or related or repeated requests for Minor Modifications may not be used to modify UDC standards for a multi-lot development, or for part or all of a subdivision plat or phase of development involving more than three contiguous lots. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 370 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT MINOR MODIFICATION APPROVAL RELATED APPLICATIONDIRECTOR DECISION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070A: Minor Modification f. If the Community Development Director determines that the number or combination of Minor Modifications included in a single application may result in impacts on the surrounding properties similar to those that would require approval as a Major Modification, the Director may require that the applicant instead apply for a Major Modification pursuant to Section 60.500.070B. 3. Procedure for a Minor Modification Approval a. Review of a request for a Minor Modification is not a separate procedure under this UDC. Instead, a request for a Minor Modification shall be included in the application for other types of APPEAL TO ZONING permits or approvals under this BOARD OF APPEALS UDC. The request(s) shall be submitted in writing, for indicates public hearing consideration in conjunction with the primary application type. The written request shall include citation of the standard(s) of this UDC from which modification is sought. b. The Community Development Director shall make a decision as to whether an application for a Minor Modification meets the criteria in this Section 60.500.070A. c. When the application that contains a request for Minor Modification is to be decided by an appointed body or City Council pursuant to Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, the decision of the Community Development Director shall be incorporated as part of the application, and the decision of the appointed body or City Council shall be made on the application as a whole, and shall not reconsider the Minor Modification decision separately. d. The Community Development Director’s decision on a requested Minor Modification may not be appealed separately from the decision on the application to which it is attached. An individual or organization authorized to file an appeal of the Director’s decision may list a violation of this Section 60.500.070A as grounds for appealing the decision on the permit, approval, or authorization that includes the Minor Modification after a final decision on that permit, approval, or authorization has been made pursuant to this UDC. 4. Permitted Minor Modifications A request for a Minor Modification may be submitted only for the types of adjustments listed in this Section 60.500.070A.4, and the Community Development Director may approve only those Minor Modifications listed in this Section. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 371 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070A: Minor Modification Table 500.07-1 Standards Subject to Minor Modification Code Standard Potential Maximum Modification Site Standards Lot area (minimum) Lots larger than 3,000 sq. ft. 15% Lots of 3,000 sq. ft. or smaller 25% Lot width (minimum) Lots larger than 3,000 sq. ft. 15% Lots of 3,000 sq. ft. or smaller 25% Lot Dimensional Standards Front setback (minimum or maximum) 15% Side setback (for primary or accessory structures) 20% Minimum sum of side yards 20% Rear setback (for primary or accessory structures) 15% Building Standards Building height (minimum or maximum) Residential 5 ft. All other 10 ft. Building length (maximum) 10% Development Standards Landscape area reduction \[1\] 20% Bufferyards (minimum width) 10% Usable recreation area reduction 20% Sign area 10% Sign height 2 ft. Building Design To the extent determined necessary by the Community Development Director to facilitate infill, redevelopment, or Building design development of comparable quality to standard requirements of Section 60.400.070F Reasonable Accommodation under federal Fair Housing Act All requests See Section 60.500.070A.4.a Relief under Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act All requests See Section 60.500.070A.4.b NOTES Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 372 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070A: Minor Modification \[1\] Requests for more other variations from landscape requirements may use the Alternative Equivalent Compliance option described in Section 60.400.060F. a. Reasonable Accommodations Under the Federal Fair Housing Amendments Act 1) In response to a written application identifying the type of housing being provided and the portions of the Federal Fair Housing Act that require that reasonable accommodations be made for such housing, the Community Development Director is authorized to take any of the following actions in order to provide reasonable accommodations without the need for a Major Modification or a Variance: (a) Modify any facility spacing, building setback, height, lot coverage, or landscaping requirement by no more than ten percent; or (b) Reduce any off-street parking requirement by no more than one space. 2) The Community Development Director may approve a type of reasonable accommodation different from that requested by the applicant if the Director concludes that a different form of accommodation would satisfy the requirements of the Federal Fair Housing Act with fewer impacts on adjacent areas. The decision of the Community Development Director shall be accompanied by written findings of fact as to the applicability of the Fair Housing Act, the need for reasonable accommodations, and the authority for any reasonable accommodations approved. b. Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLIUPA) The Community Development Director may grant minor modifications in order to eliminate substantial burdens on religious exercise as guaranteed by the Federal Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act of 2000, as amended. In no circumstance shall the Community Development Director approve a modification that allows a religious assembly use, or any uses, structures, or activities accessory to it, in a zoning district where this UDC prohibits such use or accessory use, structure, or activity unless the UDC permits secular assembly under similar terms in that zoning district. 5. Criteria for Approval A requested Minor Modification may be approved or approved with conditions if the Community Development Director finds that the modification: a. Addresses an unusual site constraint or unusual requirement of the proposed use or building that is not common to other lots, uses, or buildings in the surrounding area or is generally consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; b. Will have no material adverse impact on any abutting lots, or any material adverse impact will be mitigated by conditions attached to the approval of the modification; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 373 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070A: Minor Modification c. Does not violate any conditions of approval that may have previously been applied to development of the property by the Planning Commission or the City Council; and d. Does not result in: 1) A change in Permitted or Conditional Uses, or the allowed mix of uses, or the Use-Specific Standards in Section 60.300.020 applicable to any use in the zoning district where the property is located, unless required for compliance with the federal Fair Housing Amendments Act or the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act; 2) A deviation from building or fire codes; 3) A deviation from adopted engineering standards; 4) Requirements for public roadways, utilities, or other public infrastructure or facilities; 5) A change to a development standard that has already been modified through an incentive as described in Section 60.400.120 or through any other procedure described in this UDC. 6) A change to any standard or criteria in Section 60.200.040C HPO- Heritage Preservation Overlay, Section 60.200.040E. FPO-Floodplain Overlay, or Section 60.200.040F SDO-Shoreland District Overlay, or any requirement of state or federal law. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 374 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070B: Major Modification B. Major Modification 1. Purpose The Major Modification procedure is intended to allow for adjustments or deviations from dimensional, numeric, and certain other standards of this UDC that are greater than, or different in kind than, the extent of variation allowed by a Minor Modification as described in Section 60.500.070A. Major Modifications are intended to provide greater flexibility to adjust UDC standards (other than permitted or conditional uses), without requiring the level of practical difficulties required for a Variance under Minnesota law. 2. Applicability a. The ability to request a Major Modification is available to all applications for an approval under this UDC except an application for another form of flexibility or relief pursuant to this Section 60.500.070. b. No request for a Major Modification may include any type or level of relief for which the Community Development Director determines that a Variance pursuant to Section 60.500.070C is required. c. A Major Modification request may be used to amend the standards of a restricted development approved under prior versions of this ordinance, or to expand an existing nonconforming use. d. A request for a Major Modification may include related requests that could have been reviewed as Minor Modifications if they were requested separately, but in that case the combined requests shall be treated as a request for a Major Modification. e. A request for a Major Modification may only be submitted for a single platted lot, or for up to three contiguous lots under common or related ownership. Individual or related or repeated requests for Major Modifications may not be used to modify UDC standards for a multi-lot development, or for part or all of a subdivision plat or phase of development involving more than three contiguous lots. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 375 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT JOR MODIFICATION APPROVALMA indicates public hearing APPLICATIONDECISION ON RELATED DECISION INCLUDED IN PLANNING COMMISSION RELATED APPLICATION Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070B: Major Modification 3. Procedure for Major Modification Approval a. Review of a request for a Major Modification is not a separate procedure under this UDC. Instead, a request for a Major Modification shall be included in the application for other types of permits or approvals under this UDC. The request(s) shall be submitted in writing, for consideration in conjunction with the primary application type. The written request shall include APPEAL TO CITY COUNCIL citation of the standard(s) of this UDC from which modification is sought. b. A Major Modification request associated with an application type that receives Staff-level approval, as described in Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, shall cause that application to be elevated for review and approval by the Planning Commission. c. Requests for a Major Modification shall require notice pursuant to Section 60.500.030C.1.b Written Notice, and shall comply with other requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures. d. The Planning Commission shall approve all Major Modification requests that comply with the approval criteria described in 0 below. e. When the application that contains a request for Major Modification is to be decided by City Council pursuant to Table 500.01-1, Summary Table of Review Procedures, the decision of the Planning Commission shall be incorporated as part of the application, and the decision of City Council shall be made on the application as a whole, and shall not reconsider the Major Modification decision separately. f. The Community Development Director’s decision on a requested Major Modification may not be appealed separately from the decision on the application to which it is attached. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 376 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070B: Major Modification Table 500.07-2 Standards Subject to Major Modification Potential Maximum Code Standard Modification Site Standards Lot area (minimum) Lots larger than 3,000 sq. ft. 25% Lots of 3,000 sq. ft. or smaller 35% Lot width (minimum) Lots larger than 3,000 sq. ft. 25% Lots of 3,000 sq. ft. or smaller 35% Lot Dimensional Standards Front setback (minimum or maximum) 35% Side setback (for primary or accessory structures) 25% Minimum sum of side yards 25% Rear setback (for primary or accessory structures) 25% Building Standards Building height (minimum maximum) Residential 10 ft. All other 15 ft. Building length (maximum) 20% Development Standards To the extent determined necessary by the Community Development Director to facilitate infill, Neighborhood Protection Standards redevelopment, or development of comparable quality to standard requirements of Section 60.400.020F. Landscape area reduction \[1\] 35% Bufferyards (minimum width) 20% Usable recreation area reduction 35% Sign area 15% Sign height 5 ft. NOTES Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 377 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070B: Major Modification \[1\] Requests for more other variations from landscape requirements may use the Alternative Equivalent Compliance option described in Section 60.400.060F. 4. Permitted Major Modifications A request for a Major Modification may be submitted only for the types of adjustments listed in this 0, and the Planning Commission may approve only those Major Modifications listed in this Section. Potential modification of standards not allowed through Major Modification are described in Section 60.400.080F, Minimum Parking Adjustments, Section 60.400.080G, Maximum Parking Adjustments, and Section 60.400.120, Incentives. 5. Criteria for Major Modification Approval A requested Major Modification may be approved or approved with conditions if the Planning Commission finds that the modification: a. Addresses an unusual site constraint or unusual requirement of the proposed use or building that is not common to other lots, uses, or buildings in the surrounding area or is generally consistent with the Comprehensive Plan; b. Will have no material adverse impact on any abutting lots, or any material adverse impact will be mitigated by conditions attached to the approval of the modification; c. Does not violate any conditions of approval previously applied to development of the property by the Planning Commission or the City Council; and d. Meets at least one of the following criteria: 1) The modification will provide options for a more connected neighborhood layout or, for an adjustment for a residential subdivision, the adjustment will result in a neighborhood layout and level of multi-modal connectivity equal or better than would have been required without the adjustment; or 2) The modification will result in equal or better screening and buffering of adjacent properties and ground and roof mounted equipment than would have been required without the adjustment; or 3) The modification will not result in a material increase in on-street parking or traffic congestion on any local street in any Residential zone district within 200 feet of the applicant’s site; and e. Does not result in: 1) A change in Permitted or Conditional Uses, or the allowed mix of uses, or the Use-Specific Standards in Section 60.300.020 applicable to any use in the zoning district where the property is located. 2) A deviation from building or fire codes; 3) A deviation from adopted engineering standards; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 378 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070C: Variance 4) Requirements for public roadways, utilities, or other public infrastructure or facilities; 5) A further change to a development standard that has already been modified through an incentive as described in Section 60.400.120 or through any other procedure described in this UDC; or 6) A change to any standard or criteria in Section 60.200.040C HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay, Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, or Section 60.200.040F SDO – Shoreland District Overlay, or any requirement of state or federal law. C. Variance 1. Purpose The Variance procedure is intended to allow property owners with unusual lot or site conditions to request the opportunity to vary standards and criteria in this UDC that cannot be modified through the Minor Modification or Major Modification procedures, in order to avoid practical difficulties that would otherwise be created by the strict adherence to the provisions of this Code, as required in Chapter 462.357 (sub. 6) of the Laws of Minnesota. 2. Applicability a. The City shall accept an application for a Variance if the Community Development Director has determined that neither a Minor Modification nor a Major Modification, nor any other form of flexibility and/or relief authorized in this UDC is sufficient to mitigate practical difficulties that would be claimed by the applicant by the strict application of the standards and criteria in this UDC. The Variance shall be the minimum necessary to afford relief. b. The Community Development Director’s determination as to the applicability of the Variance process may not be appealed separately from an appeal of the decision on the Variance or other form of relief that the Director determines is applicable. 3. Procedure for Variance Approval a. Applications for a Variance shall comply with all requirements of Section 60.500.030 Common Procedures applicable to decisions that require a public hearing before a designated authority, unless modified or supplemented by this Section 60.500.070CA. b. Any approved Variance is only valid for the proposal outlined in the Variance application. c. For any Variance application that does not involve the standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, the Zoning Board of Appeals shall, within the time limits stated in this UDC, approve, approve with conditions, or deny an application for a Variance of any standard or criteria based on the criteria in Subsection 4 below. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 379 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070C: Variance d. Upon filing of an application for a variance to standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, the Community Development Director shall notify the applicant in writing that construction below the flood protection elevation increases risks to life and property, and that the issuance of a Variance to construct a structure below the flood protection elevation will result in increased premium rates for flood insurance up to amounts as high as $25 for $100 of insurance coverage, and the Director shall maintain a record of each such notification: e. Upon filing of an application for a variance to standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay the Community Development Director shall notify the Commissioner of Natural Resources of the time, place, and subject matter of the hearing no less than ten days prior to a hearing. Such notice shall be accompanied by such supporting information as is necessary to indicate the nature and effect of the proposed use. f. Following approval or approval with conditions of a Variance of the standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, the Community Development Director shall: 1) Maintain a record of the Variance action, including the justification for its issuance, and report such Variances issued in the annual report to the Administrator of the National Flood Insurance Program, when requested by the Federal Emergency Management Agency; and 2) Submit a copy of the decision and its justification for issuance to the Minnesota Commissioner of Natural Resources within 10 days of such action. g. A decision by the Zoning Board of Appeals to approve, approve with conditions, or deny a Variance may only be appealed to District Court. h. A Variance and any conditions and safeguards that are made a part of the terms under which the Variance was granted are binding upon the applicant and any subsequent purchaser, heir, or assign of the property, and any violation of a variance or its conditions and safeguards shall be a violation of this UDC. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 380 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT indicates public hearing CITY COUNCILAPPEAL TO VARIANCE APPROVAL DECISIONRECOMMENDATIONDIRECTOR REVIEW & Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.070 Flexibility and Relief Section 60.500.070C: Variance 4. Findings Required for Variance Approval An application for a Variance shall be approved or approved with conditions if the Zoning Board of Appeals makes findings that the following criteria have been met: a. The Variance is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and in harmony with the general purposes and intent of this UDC. b. The applicant proposes to use the property in a reasonable manner but there are practical difficulties in achieving that proposed use while complying with this UDC. c. The practical difficulties are unique to the property, are not solely economic considerations, and have not been created by the landowner. Examples of practical difficulties that are unique to the property include but are not limited to irregularity, narrowness, or shallowness of the lot, exceptional topographical or physical conditions, or inadequate access to direct sunlight for solar energy systems, that are peculiar to the property that do not apply to other lands within the neighborhood or the same class of zoning district. d. If the requested Variance is for earth sheltered construction, the application complies with Minnesota Stat. 216C.06, Subd. 14. e. The Variance will not alter the essential character of the surrounding area, will not be materially injurious to other property in the area, and will not be materially detrimental to public health of welfare. f. The development of the parcel in question cannot be integrated with development of adjacent lots or parcels under the same or related ownership that would allow reasonable economic use of the total site consistent with the provisions of this UDC. g. The Variance will not allow a use otherwise not permitted within the zoning district: h. The Variance does not involve a change to or exception from a numerical standard that is included in the definition of a use (such as the maximum number of square feet in a Neighborhood Retail establishment). i. For any Variance application that involve the standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, the following additional criteria shall apply: 1) No Variance that would increase in flood levels during the base flood discharge in any designated regulatory floodway may be approved. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 381 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080A: Purpose 2) No Variance shall have the effect of allowing in any use prohibited in that district, permit a lower degree of flood protection than the Regulatory Flood Protection Elevation for the area, or permit standards lower than those required by State law. 3) No Variance shall result in additional threats to public safety, extraordinary public expense, create nuisances, cause fraud on or victimization of the public, or conflict with existing local laws or ordinances. 4) The failure to grant the Variance would result in undue hardship to the applicant, and strict conformity with the standards would be unreasonable, impractical, and not feasible under the circumstances. 5) The variance is consistent with the general purpose of the flood control standards and the intent of the state and national laws and programs. 6) The Variance shall be the minimum necessary, considering the flood hazard, to afford relief. j. The Board may grant a Variance to the standards in this UDC if it finds that: 1) There has been substantial and detrimental reliance in good faith by an applicant who has received a permit or certificate issued in error by the administrative official charged with enforcement of this ordinance, and 2) The mistaken issuance of the certificate or permit is not the result of an action on the part of the applicant, the property owner, or any other person or party who has had control of the property, to provide misleading or incorrect information, or to knowingly withhold information necessary for the administrative official to accurately review the permit or certificate request. k. In granting a Variance, the Board may impose such reasonable and appropriate conditions and safeguards as may be necessary to accomplish the purposes of the regulations that are to be modified and to reduce or minimize potentially injurious effects of the Variance upon adjoining properties, the character of the neighborhood, and the health, safety, or general welfare of the community, provided that any such conditions are directly related to and roughly proportional to the impact of the Variance. Section 60.500.080 N ONCONFORMITIES A. Purpose The purpose of this Section 60.500.080 is to regulate land uses, buildings, structures, lots, site features, and signs that were legally established but that do not conform to the requirements of this UDC as of its effective date or due to later amendments, or have otherwise been rendered nonconforming due to circumstances that were not self-created. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 382 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080B: General Authority to Continue These regulations specify the circumstances and conditions under which such nonconformities shall be permitted to continue or expand. B. General Authority to Continue 1. Nonconformities will be allowed to continue and may be allowed to expand based on the regulations of this section, unless an additional limit on the continuation or expansion of the use is stated in another Section of this UDC or unless the nonconforming aspect of the property or its use or occupancy is discontinued for a period of a year or more. In determining whether discontinuance has occurred, the City may consider utility bills, sales or other tax receipts, evidence of listings for sale or lease, or other factors indicative of active use, occupancy, and/or operation of the nonconforming aspect of the property occurring during that period, C. Bringing a Nonconformity into Compliance The owner of a property containing a nonconformity that was not legally established may bring it into compliance with this UDC by securing all permits and approvals that would have been required for the initial development of the property. If such permits and approvals are obtained, the applicant may be required to submit to the City corrected documentation of the property and improvements “as-built.” D. Conditions on Nonconformities The City may attach reasonable conditions on the expansion, reconstruction, replacement, or improvement of a nonconformity pursuant to Section 60.500.030E.6 Conditions of Approval, subject to any limitations imposed by Minnesota state law, including but not limited to those changes to applicable setbacks required by Minnesota state law. E. Nonconforming Use 1. Authority to Continue a. Unless specified otherwise in this Section 60.500.080 or elsewhere in this UDC, the legally established nonconforming use of land or a structure shall be allowed to continue regardless of any change in ownership or occupancy of the use, until that use is discontinued or another provision of this UDC requires the termination of the use. The use may not be enlarged or expanded to occupy a larger area than legally established, except as specified in Subsection 5 below. b. Without limiting the generality of Subsection a, any use or occupation of land approved prior to the Effective Date as a Conditional Use or as a Planned Unit Development shall be permitted to continue as a lawful use or occupancy. The approved site plan and all terms, covenants and conditions shall remain in effect and shall continue to control the use or occupation of such land. Changes or modifications to the use, occupancy, site design, or interpretations necessary to clarify detail not addressed in the approved plan, shall be made in accordance with the standards and procedures of this UDC. Where a Conditional Use or Planned Unit Development has been approved for a site but the development has not been constructed, the approved plans remain in effect and may be used to guide the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 383 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080E: Nonconforming Use development of the site unless a revised plan is submitted and approved under this UDC. 2. Repair and Maintenance Unless limited by Section 60.500.080F Nonconforming Structure, the structure in which a nonconforming use is located may be maintained, repaired, restored, improved, or altered subject to the same requirements for permits and approvals applicable to maintenance and repair of conforming structures. 3. Change of Nonconforming Use The Community Development Director has the authority to approve a Zoning Certificate to permit a nonconforming use of land or structure to be changed to a conforming use, or changed to another nonconforming use, provided the new nonconforming use is of equal or lesser intensity, and that there are no additional negative impacts to surrounding properties that result from the new nonconforming use. The Community Development Director’s determination of possible adverse impacts on surrounding properties shall be based on: a. Any estimated change in noise, vibration, dust, odor, fumes, glare, or smoke detectable at the property line; b. Any estimated change in numbers and kinds of motor vehicle trips to the site; c. Any change in the amount and nature of outside storage, loading, and parking; d. Any change in the visual appearance of the site and structures; and e. Any change in hours of operation. 4. Addition of Parking to a Nonconforming Use The Community Development Director may approve the addition to or expansion of nonstructural off-street parking facilities to relieve on-street parking or loading pressures caused by the nonconforming use, provided that no such additional or expanded parking for a non-residential nonconforming use is located in a Residential zoning district and a Site Development Plan for the revised site and parking is approved pursuant to Section 60.500.060B. 5. Expansion of Nonconforming Use a. The Community Development Director will approve the expansion of a nonconforming use within an existing conforming or nonconforming structure, provided that: 1) The expansion does not increase the degree of nonconformity or include the addition of a secondary structure; 2) All other applicable standards including but not limited to required parking and landscaping, are met; and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 384 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080E: Nonconforming Use 3) The Community Development Director determines that there will not be additional adverse impacts to surrounding properties, based on the factors listed in Subsection 3 above. 4) In the MX-T district the gross floor area (for indoor uses) or the gross site area (for outdoor uses) occupied by a nonconforming use may not be expanded by more than 25 percent 5) In all other districts the gross floor area (for indoor uses) or the gross site area (for outdoor uses) occupied by a nonconforming use may not be expanded by more than 15 percent. b. Any proposed expansion of a nonconforming use that requires enlarging an existing building or adding a secondary structure will be reviewed as a request for a Major Modification, as described in Section 60.500.070B. c. The continued excavation of a site for which all required permits and approvals have been granted, after adoption of an ordinance making that use nonconforming, shall not be considered an expansion of a nonconforming use. 6. Discontinuance of Nonconforming Use a. For all properties other than those listed in Subsection b below, any nonconforming use that is discontinued for a period of one year (or three years if the nonconforming use is located in a building originally designed as a civic or institutional structure) shall lose its legal nonconforming status, and any subsequent land use or occupancy shall conform to all provisions of this UDC, unless within less than one year of the discontinuance, the Community Development Director approves a substitute use pursuant to Subsection 3 above or the Planning Commission approves the re- establishment of the use after a public hearing based on a determination that there will not be additional negative impacts to surrounding properties, based on the factors listed in Subsection 3 above. If the Planning Commission makes such a decision, it can also permit the re-establishment of the nonconforming use without the correction of existing building or property nonconformities. b. If the Director determines that a nonconforming use has been discontinued, the burden shall be on the applicant to show that it has not been discontinued through the use of sales tax, business tax, business licenses, property appearance factors, third party testimony, or other factors. 7. Damage to Nonconforming Structure A nonconforming use that does not have a primary structure, or that occupies a conforming structure that has not been damaged as described in this Section, but that has been damaged by fire or other natural cause may be repaired, restored, or replaced to the same condition it occupied prior to the disaster or other damaging event, subject to the following limitations: a. If the use has been damaged to the extent of greater than 50 percent of its estimated market value, as indicated in the records of the Olmsted County Assessor, the owner must apply for Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 385 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080F: Nonconforming Structure any required permits or approvals necessary to continue the use or to reconstructed accessory structures within six months of when the property was damaged. b. The repaired use may not have a ground floor footprint or a total gross floor area that is larger, or a height that is taller than it was before the damaging event occurred unless all nonconformities have been eliminated. 8. Nonconforming Use Created by Flood District Regulations a. Where a nonconforming use is created by the standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, and the use is located in a conforming structure, no request for modification, expansion, or reconstruction of the nonconforming use may increase the flood damage potential of the use or structure and, if located in a floodway, may not increase the degree of obstruction to the flood flow, unless otherwise specified in federal rules and regulations. b. Where a nonconforming use is created by the standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, and the use is discontinued for more than one year, the use of the property must thereafter comply with the provision of this UDC. F. Nonconforming Structure 1. Authority to Continue Unless specified otherwise in this Section 60.500.080 or elsewhere in this UDC, a legally existing nonconforming structure shall be allowed to continue to be occupied for any use that is permitted in the zoning district where the structure is located, or that is allowed to continue as a nonconforming use or land without a primary structure pursuant to Section 60.500.080E Nonconforming Use regardless, of any change in ownership or occupancy of the structure, until another provision of this Section requires the termination of the occupancy of the structure. 2. Repair and Maintenance A nonconforming structure containing a confirming or allowed nonconforming use may be maintained, repaired, restored, improved, or altered subject to the same requirements for permits and approvals applicable to maintenance and repair of conforming structures. But no maintenance, repair, or alteration may increase the extent of the nonconformity. 3. Expansion of Nonconforming Structure a. A nonconforming structure may be expanded in size, provided that the expansion will not increase an existing nonconformity or create a new nonconformity. b. A nonconforming structure located in the MX-T district may be expanded in size up to 50 percent without complying with the otherwise applicable minimum height standard, provided it does not increase any other existing nonconformity or create any other new nonconformity. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 386 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080G: Nonconforming Structure Created by Flood District Regulations 4. Relocation of Nonconforming Structure A nonconforming structure may be moved in whole or in part to another location on the lot, provided that the relocation lessens the extent of the nonconformity of the structure. 5. Damage to Nonconforming Structure A nonconforming structure that has been damaged by fire or other natural cause may be repaired or restored to the same condition it occupied prior to the disaster or other damaging event, subject to the following limitations: a. If the structure has been damaged to the extent of greater than 50 percent of its estimated market value, as indicated in the records of the Olmsted County Assessor, the owner must apply for a building permit within six months of when the property was damaged. b. The repaired structure may not have a ground floor footprint or a total gross floor area that is larger, or a height that is taller than it was before the damaging event occurred unless all nonconformities have been eliminated. 6. Elimination of a Nonconforming Structure When a nonconforming structure has been eliminated or removed from a lot, legal nonconforming status for the structure is terminated, and may not be carried over to any new structure on the lot. Any proposed new structure shall be required to comply with all applicable terms of this UDC. G. Nonconforming Structure Created by Flood District Regulations A lawful nonconforming structure by the standards or criteria in Section 60.200.040E FPO – Floodplain Overlay, may continue, subject to the following additional standards. 1. A nonconforming structure must not be expanded, changed, enlarged, or altered in a way that increases its nonconformity. Expansion or enlargement of nonconforming structures within the Floodway District is prohibited. 2. Any structural alteration or addition to a nonconforming structure that would result in increasing the flood damage potential of that structure or use must be protected to the regulatory flood protection elevation in accordance with any of the elevation on fill or floodproofing techniques (i.e., FP-1 thru FP-4 floodproofing classifications) allowable in the State Building Code, except as further restricted in provisions 3. and 4. below. 3. Whenever any alteration, addition or repair to a nonconforming structure exceeds 50 percent of its current market value as determined from the records of the Olmsted County Assessor, the entire structure shall be made to conform to all applicable floodplain regulations. This requirement shall also apply at such time the cumulative effect of all additions, alterations, or major repairs since the date the structure became nonconforming exceed 50 percent of the current market value. 4. The alteration, addition, or repair to a nonconforming structure, when the value of such work does not exceed 50 percent of its current market value as determined from the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 387 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080H: Nonconforming Lot records of the Olmsted County Assessor, shall not increase the flood damage potential of the structure. Repair of a nonconforming structure, if located in the floodway, shall not increase the degree of obstruction to the flood flow. 5. If active use or occupancy of a nonconforming structure is discontinued for more than one year, the use of the structure must thereafter conform to the floodplain provisions of this UDC. 6. If any nonconforming structure is substantial damage, it may not be reconstructed except in conformity with the provisions of this UDC. The applicable provisions for establishing new uses or new structures will apply depending upon whether the use or structure is in the Floodway, Flood Fringe or Flood Prone Districts, respectively. 7. If any nonconforming structure experiences a repetitive loss, it must not be reconstructed except in conformity with the provisions of this UDC. 8. Any substantial improvement to a nonconforming structure requires that the existing structure and any additions must meet the requirements of this UDC for new structures. 9. Where a nonconforming structure located in the FPO – Floodplain District Overlay is extended or substantially altered, the as-built documentation required shall specifically state the manner in which the nonconforming structure differs from the flood protection standards and criteria in this UDC. H. Nonconforming Lot 1. A nonconforming lot of record may be used for any land use permitted in the zoning district in which the lot is located, provided that all other requirements of this UDC are met. 2. A conforming structure on a nonconforming lot may be enlarged or expanded provided it meets all of the applicable UDC standards for the zoning district in which the property is located. 3. Construction on Nonconforming Lots within SDO – Shoreland District Overlay a. Lots of record in the office of the County Recorder on February 22, 1995, that are located in the SDO – Shoreland District Overlay and that do not meet the minimum lot area and width standards of the underlying zoning district may be allowed as buildable lots, provided that 1) The use is permitted in the zoning district; 2) The lot has been in separate ownership from abutting lands at all times since it became substandard; 3) The lot was created in compliance with official controls in effect at the time; 4) All structure and septic system setback distances are met; 5) A Type 1 sewage treatment system consistent with Minnesota Rules, Chapter 7080 can be installed or the lot is connected to a public sewer; and Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 388 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080I: Nonconforming Site Feature 6) The impervious surface coverage does not exceed 25 percent of the lot. b. A Variance from setback requirements pursuant to Section 60.500.070C must be obtained before any use, sewage treatment system, or building permit is issued for a lot. In evaluating the Variance, the Board of Adjustment shall consider sewage treatment and water supply capabilities or constraints of the lot and shall deny the variance if adequate facilities cannot be provided. c. In a group of two or more contiguous lots of record under a common ownership, an individual lot must be considered as a separate parcel of land for the purpose of sale or development if it meets the following requirements: 1) The lot must be at least 66 percent of the minimum dimensional standard for lot width and lot size for the shoreland classification consistent with Minnesota Rules, Chapter 6120; 2) The lot must be connected to a public sewer, if available, or must be suitable for the installation of a Type 1 sewage treatment system consistent with Minnesota Rules, Chapter 7080, and applicable City sewer treatment standards; 3) Impervious surface coverage must not exceed 25 percent of each lot; and 4) Development of the lot must be consistent with an adopted comprehensive plan. d. A lot subject to Subsection c above that does not meet the requirements of Subsection c must be combined with the one or more contiguous lots so they equal one or more conforming lots to the maximum extent practicable. e. Notwithstanding Subsection c, contiguous nonconforming lots of record in shoreland areas under a common ownership must be able to be sold or purchased individually if each lot contained a habitable residential dwelling at the time the lots came under common ownership and the lots are suitable for, or served by, a sewage treatment system consistent with the requirements of Minnesota Statutes 115.55 and Minnesota Rules, Chapter 7080, or connected to a public sewer. f. In evaluating all Variances, Zoning and Building Permit applications, or Conditional Use Permit requests, the decision-making body shall require the property owner to address, when appropriate, storm water runoff management, reducing impervious surfaces, increasing setback, restoration of wetlands, vegetative buffers, sewage treatment and water supply capabilities, and other conservation-designed actions. g. A portion of a conforming lot may be separated from an existing parcel as long as the remainder of the existing parcel meets the lot size and sewage treatment requirements of the zoning district for a new lot and the newly created parcel is combined with an adjacent parcel. I. Nonconforming Site Feature For purposes of this Section 60.500.080I, nonconforming site features include any failure to comply with the standards of Section 60.400.060 Landscaping, Bufferyards, and Fences; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 389 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080I: Nonconforming Site Feature Section 60.400.070 Site and Building Design; Section 60.400.080 Parking, Loading, and Stacking; or Section 60.400.100 Exterior Lighting. 1. Authority to Continue Unless specified otherwise in this Section 60.500.080 or elsewhere in this UDC, a lot or parcel with a legally established nonconforming site feature shall be allowed to continue to be occupied for any use that is permitted in the zoning district where the structure is located, regardless of any change in ownership or occupancy of the structure, until another provision of this Section requires the remediation of the nonconforming site feature. 2. Repair and Maintenance Upon issuance of a zoning certificate by the Community Development Director, a nonconforming site feature may be maintained, repaired, or altered. However, changes to the property described in Sections 60.500.080.G.3, 4, and 5 may require termination of the nonconforming site feature, and its replacement with features that conform to the regulations of this UDC. 3. Expansion of Nonconforming Site Features Nonconforming site features shall not be expanded in any way that would increase the degree of nonconformity, but the addition of nuisance abatement measures such as fences, screening, landscaping, drainage controls, the permanent all weather surfacing of yards or parking areas, and the addition of security features such as lighting and temporary buildings that would reduce security risks in the area is permitted subject to the same permits and approvals applicable to changes to conforming site features. 4. Required Degree of Conformance During Changes to Uses or Structures When permitted changes to or expansions of nonconforming uses or nonconforming structures pursuant to Section 60.500.080E, Section 60.500.080F, or Section 60.500.080G are made, nonconforming site features shall be brought into or closer to compliance with this UDC as follows: a. Nonconforming Parking 1) Any request to increase the gross floor area of the primary structure on the site that would require an increase in parking of less than 50 percent of the total number of parking spaces normally required, as described in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, shall be required to provide additional parking only for the new portion of the development. 2) Any request to increase the gross floor area of the primary structure on the site that would require an increase in parking of more than 50 percent or more of the total number of parking spaces normally required, as described in Table 400.08-1, Minimum and Maximum Vehicle Parking Required, shall be required to provide all required parking, thus bringing the site into conformity with the provisions of this UDC. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 390 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.080 Nonconformities Section 60.500.080J: Nonconforming Signs b. Other Nonconforming Site Features Nonconforming site features other than parking shall be brought into or closer to compliance with this UDC to the same degree required for similar changes or expansions to conforming uses and structures. J. Nonconforming Signs 1. Authority to Continue a. Legally constructed billboards and other signs are nonconforming signs and may continue, subject to the regulations of this Section 60.500.080J. b. Any billboard or sign in an annexed area that had been legally established at the time of Annexation of Land shall be permitted to continue, and shall be treated as a legal nonconforming sign. c. Any billboards or signs in annexed areas that were not legally established are not authorized to continue. Such billboards and signs are illegal and must be removed immediately upon notice to the sign owner. d. When the use of any nonconforming sign has been discontinued for a period of one year, regardless of any intent to resume or not to abandon such use, that sign shall be presumed to be abandoned and shall not thereafter be reestablished except in full compliance with this Section 60.500.080J. 2. Repair and Maintenance The maintenance and minor repair of a nonconforming billboard or sign is permitted. 3. Modification of Nonconforming Sign a. No nonconforming billboard or sign may be moved in whole or in part to any other location where it would remain nonconforming. b. A new nonconforming billboard shall only be erected in compliance with the City’s Sign Credit program. 1) Erection of a new billboard requires the removal of an equivalent amount of sign area from an existing billboard. In the case of a billboard with two faces, only the area removed from one face of the sign shall count towards the area permitted on a new billboard. 2) Removal of sign area generates a sign credit, valid for two years from date of issuance. 3) Expired sign credits shall not be restored. 4) A sign permit for the new billboard using the sign credit must be submitted for review by the Community Development Director prior to the expiration of the sign credits. 5) A sign credit may only be used in a location that meets all standards of this UDC, including but not limited to Section 60.400.110 Signs. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 391 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.090 Violations, Enforcement, and Penalties Section 60.500.090A: Responsibility 6) Credits may be transferred between parties. 4. Removal of Nonconforming Signs by Public Entity a. If a nonconforming billboard is removed as a result of condemnation initiated by the City, the sign owner shall be entitled to financial compensation or a sign credit, but not both. b. The City retains the right to determine whether the sign owner shall be offered choice between a sign credit and financial compensation, or only be offered financial compensation. c. If a nonconforming billboard is removed by a public entity other than the City, the sign owner will not be entitled to a sign credit. 5. Damage to Nonconforming Sign a. Any nonconforming billboard that requires maintenance or repair equal to or greater than 50 percent of the market value of the sign shall obtain a permit for repair within six months of when the damage occurs, or the sign shall be required to be removed or brought into compliance with the requirements of Section 60.400.110 Signs. b. A damaged sign that has not obtained a permit for repair within the specified timeframe must be removed within 60 days of the date of receipt of removal notice from the Community Development Director. 6. Termination by Abandonment When the use of a billboard has been discontinued for one year, it shall be presumed to be abandoned. If a determination of abandonment is made by the Community Development Director, the owner of the sign may appeal the finding to the Zoning Board of Appeals by submitting evidence that the sign is still in use, legal, and conforming to the standards in this UDC. Following a determination of abandonment by the Director or the failure of an appeal to the Zoning Board of Adjustment, an abandoned billboard may not be re-established, and shall be removed within 90 days after written notice from the City to do so. Section 60.500.090 V IOLATIONS, E NFORCEMENT, AND P ENALTIES A. Responsibility Each property owner is responsible to ensure that all persons using the property, whether tenants, lessors, sublessors, occupants, operators, or others, comply with all applicable standards of this UDC. B. City Policy on Compliance It is the policy of the City that this Section will normally be served best if the Community Development Director first seeks to have a violation brought into compliance. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 392 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.090 Violations, Enforcement, and Penalties Section 60.500.090C: Types of Violation C. Types of Violation 1. Failure to comply with any standard, regulation, of requirement of this UDC or any regulation adopted by a City department or agency under authority granted by this UDC. 2. Failure to comply with any condition attached to a permit or approval by the City under this UDC. 3. Engaging in the division of land for sale or development in any way that does not comply with the standards, criteria, and procedures for approval of a Minor or Major Land Subdivision Permit or a Final Plat under this UDC. 4. Transferring title to any lot, tract, or parcel of land before any subdivision plat required for this UDC has been approved and the approved plat has been filed with the Olmsted County land records for the county or counties in which the property is located. 5. Submitting for recording in the Olmsted County land records any subdivision plat that has not been approved under this UDC. 6. Obtaining a permit or approval under this UDC through submittal of inaccurate or misleading information, or through making inaccurate or misleading statements at a public hearing, regarding the proposed development, the conditions of the land on which the proposed development is located, or conditions on adjacent parcels. 7. Obstructing or removing any notice required to be posted or otherwise given under this UDC. 8. Failure to complete required improvements. D. Notification Whenever a violation of this UDC is known or suspected to exist or expected to be committed, any person may notify the Community Development Director of the violation. All officers and agencies of the City shall notify the Community Development Director of any information that suggests that a violation exists or is expected to be committed. E. Investigation of Violations 1. Upon receiving any information that suggests a violation, the Community Development Director shall conduct an investigation to determine whether a violation exists or is reasonably expected to be committed. 2. The Community Development Director is hereby empowered to cause any building, structure, or tract of land to be inspected and examined. 3. Where necessary, the Community Development Director may call upon the Chief of Police for assistance. 4. If the Community Development Director determines that it is necessary for the City to employ the services of any qualified expert to advise in establishing whether or not a violation has occurred, the expert’s fee shall be paid by the violator if said violation is established, otherwise it shall be paid by the City. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 393 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.090 Violations, Enforcement, and Penalties Section 60.500.090F: Notice of Violation F. Notice of Violation 1. The Community Development Director shall, upon a determination that a violation exists or is reasonably expected to be committed, promptly give notice of violation by regular mail, or by personal service to the owners of record for tax purposes of the property involved. 2. The notice of violation shall indicate the location and nature of the violation, the provision(s) or of the UDC that have been or are expected to be violated, and whether immediate enforcement will be sought or up to 30 days allowed to correct or remove the violation. 3. A defect in the notice of violation with respect to any such matters shall not prevent the enforcement of this UDC. G. Discontinuance of Work Once the notice of violation has been served, no work shall proceed on any development covered by such orders, except in a manner consistent with those orders and this UDC. It shall be a separate misdemeanor violation for any person to continue any development in a manner inconsistent with the orders or this UDC. H. Enforcement After Expiration of Time Period 1. If the time period provided in the notice of violation has elapsed and the alleged violation has not been corrected or brought into compliance, the Community Development Director shall consult with the City Attorney, and the City Attorney shall initiate any legal or equitable action deemed appropriate. 2. The City Attorney shall not initiate any legal or equitable action if: a. An appeal of the notification of violation has been filed with the Community Development Department, or b. The City Council or court of competent jurisdiction has stayed enforcement pending the outcome of a proceeding before it concerning the violation. 3. The Community Development Director shall act as a complaining witness when necessary to initiate a criminal action against a violation. 4. If a Development Agreement has been executed and security has been posted and required public improvements are not installed pursuant to the terms of the Agreement, the City may: a. Declare the Agreement to be in default and require that all public improvements be installed regardless of the extent of completion of the development at the time the agreement is declared to be in default; b. Obtain funds pursuant to the surety and complete the public improvements by itself or through a third party; c. Assign its right to receive funds pursuant to the surety in whole or in part to any third party, including a subsequent owner of the subdivision or addition for whom the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 394 Chapter 60.500: Procedures and Administration Section 60.500.090 Violations, Enforcement, and Penalties Section 60.500.090I: Penalties public improvements were not constructed, in exchange for the subsequent owner's Agreement to complete the required public improvements; and/or d. Exercise any other rights available under the law. I. Penalties Any person, firm, or corporation violating any of the provisions of this UDC is guilty of a misdemeanor. Each and every day during which such violation continues shall be deemed to be a separate offense. Fines and imprisonment are appropriate as a penalty for violations and a deterrent against future violations. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 395 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.010 Rules of Construction Section 60.600.010A: Purpose Chapter 60.600 Definitions Section 60.600.010 R ULES OF C ONSTRUCTION A. Purpose The provisions of this Section 60.600.010 are intended to establish guidelines to follow in clarifying ambiguities that may arise regarding the meaning of text in the UDC, the interpretation of the zoning map it incorporates, or the application of rules and regulations adopted pursuant to the UDC. B. Rules of Construction All words and terms used in this UDC have their commonly accepted dictionary meaning unless they are specifically defined in this UDC or the context in which they are used clearly indicates to the contrary. The following rules of construction apply: 1. All words used in the present tense include the future tense. 2. All words used in the singular number include the plural, and words in the plural number include the singular. 3. The masculine gender shall include the female and neutral. 4. The word “shall” is mandatory, and not discretionary, and the word “may” is permissive. 5. The word “building” shall include the word “structures.” 6. The phrase “used for” includes the phrases “arranged for,” “designed for,” “intended for,” “maintained for,” and “occupied for.” 7. The words “land,” “property”, “parcel,” “premise,” and “tract” are all interchangeable unless the context clearly indicates to the contrary. 8. The word “individual” includes a “firm,” “association,” “organization,” “partnership,” “trust,” “company,” or “corporation” as well as a single individual. 9. When the UDC states that an act may be performed by an employee holding a certain position within the City, that act may be performed by that employee’s designated agent or assistant. Section 60.600.020 R ULES OF M EASUREMENT A. Rounding of Numeral Requirements The application of UDC standards resulting in fractional requirements shall be treated in the following way: 1. Off-Street Parking Spaces The requirement for a fractional space shall be rounded up to the next whole number, resulting in the provision of one full space. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 396 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.020 Rules of Measurement Section 60.600.020B: Parking Space Calculation 2. Setbacks a. No rounding of fractional requirements shall occur. When checking actual on-site measurements, the Community Development Director shall recognize the inherent difficulty in providing for an exact building location and shall permit minor deviations to occur as long as the spirit and intent of the UDC is met. b. Setbacks shall be measured from the wall of a structure. 3. Density or Floor Area Calculations resulting in a fractional unit may be rounded up to the next whole number. 4. Height No rounding of fractional requirements shall occur. When checking actual on-site measurements, the Community Development Director shall recognize the inherent difficulties in establishing final grade lines during construction and shall permit minor deviations to occur as long as the spirit and intent of the UDC is met. 5. Plant Materials Calculations resulting in provision of a fractional plant unit shall be rounded up to the next whole number. B. Parking Space Calculation The following shall be used in determining the number of off-street parking spaces required. 1. Floor Area In the case of office, merchandising and business and personal service uses, “floor area” shall mean the gross floor area used or intended to be used by tenants for their primary business activity or for service to the public as customers, patrons, clients, or patients, including areas occupied by offices, public areas, or the display of merchandise. It shall not include areas used principally for non-public purposes, such as storage, the incidental repair, processing, or packaging of merchandise, for show windows, for restrooms, areas devoted to mechanical equipment, or for dressing rooms. 2. Places of Public Assembly In places of public assembly where patrons occupy benches, pews, or other similar seating facilities, each 20 inches of seating shall be counted as one seat for the purpose of determining the requirements of off-street parking. 3. Employee(s) Reference to “employees on the largest work shift” means the maximum number of employees employed at the facility regardless of whether such person is a full time employee. The largest work shift may be a particular day of the week, daily work shift, or peak period such as the lunch or dinner period in the case of a restaurant. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 397 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.020 Rules of Measurement Section 60.600.020C: Computation of Time 4. Capacity The maximum number of persons that may be accommodated by the use as defined by building or fire code requirements. C. Computation of Time For purposes of calculating required public notice periods or time periods related to the filing or processing of applications under the UDC, unless this UDC specifically states that the measurement is based on “calendar days”, shall be computed so as to exclude the first and include the last day of the prescribed or fixed period or duration of time. When the last day of a period falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, that day shall be omitted from the computation. D. Rules of Measurement Separation Requirements Where this UDC requires separation between uses, such distance will be measured from the property line of the existing use to the boundary line of the proposed use. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 398 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions Section 60.600.030 D EFINITIONS ABUT To share a common lot line for a distance greater than a point. ABUTTING Lots, buildings, uses, or other features regulated by this UDC share a common lot line for a distance greater than a point. Lots that are separated by a street, right-of-way, platted alley, trail, or railroad track are not abutting. ACCESS A way or means of approach to provide physical vehicular entrance to a property. ACCESS ROADWAY A roadway, privately owned and maintained and established on an easement or common area, providing joint right of access for more than four lots. ACCESSORY BUILDING, STRUCTURE OR USE A building, structure or use located or conducted upon the same lot (or on a contiguous lot in the same ownership) as the primary building, structure or use to which it is related, that is 1) clearly incidental to, and customarily found in connection with, such primary building or use and 2) is operated and maintained for the benefit or convenience of the owners, occupants, employees, customers, or visitors of the lot. ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT, ATTACHED A subordinate dwelling unit added to or created within a primary structure that provides basic requirements for living, sleeping, cooking, and sanitation. ACCESSORY DWELLING UNIT, DETACHED A subordinate dwelling unit detached from a primary structure, but located on the same lot or parcel, that provides basic requirements for living, sleeping, cooking, and sanitation. A recreational vehicle, travel trailer, camper, or similar vehicle shall not be used as a detached accessory dwelling unit. ADEQUATE BUILDABLE AREA An area that can accommodate a typical building anticipated for development on the lot after considering building setbacks, building envelopes, required parking areas and landscaping requirements. ADJACENT Lots, buildings, uses, or other features regulated by this UDC that would be bordering or touching except for an intervening street, right-of-way, platted alley, trail, or railroad track, if the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 399 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions lot lines for the properties containing the building, use, or other feature in question were extended across the intervening street, right-of-way, platted alley, trail, or railroad track, until they intersected, unless otherwise stated in this UDC. ADULT BODY PAINTING STUDIO An establishment or business that provides the service of applying paint or other substance whether transparent or nontransparent to or on the body of a patron when such body is wholly or partially nude in terms of “specified anatomical areas.” ADULT BOOKSTORE A business engaging in the barter, rental, or sale of items consisting of printed matter, pictures, slides, records, audiotapes, videotapes or motion picture film, if such shop is not open to the public generally but only to one or more classes of the public, excluding any minor by reason of age, or if a substantial or significant portion of such items are distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on the depiction or description of “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas”. The phrase “substantial or significant portion of such items” as used in the definition of an adult bookstore means at least 25 percent of the inventory, stock and trade, or publicly displayed merchandise, or at least 25 percent of the floor area of the business (not including storerooms, stock areas, bathrooms, basement or any portion of the business not open to the public). ADULT CABARET An establishment that provides dancing or other live entertainment, if such establishment excludes minors by virtue of age (except any business licensed under Rochester Code of Ordinance Chapter 125A) or if such dancing or other live entertainment is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on the performance, dedication, or description of “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas.” ADULT COMPANIONSHIP ESTABLISHMENT A companionship establishment as defined in Rochester Code of Ordinances Section 105-01 that excludes minors by reason of age, or provides the service of engaging in or listening to conversation, talk or discussion between an employee of the characterized by an emphasis on “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas”. ADULT ENTERTAINMENT Adult bookstores, adult motion pictures theaters, adult mini-motion picture theaters, adult massage parlors, adult saunas, adult companionship establishments, adult health clubs, adult cabarets, adult novelty businesses, adult motion picture arcades, adult modeling studios, adult hotels or motels, adult body painting studios, and other adult establishments. ADULT ESTABLISHMENT A business that is conducted exclusively for the patronage of adults and specifically excludes minors from patronage either by law or by the operators of such business and offers its patrons Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 400 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions services or entertainment characterized by an emphasis on matter depicting, exposing, describing, discussing, or relating to specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas. ADULT HOTEL A hotel that specifically excludes minors from patronage and wherein material is presented that is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on matter depicting, describing, or relating to specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas. ADULT MASSAGE PARLOR, HEALTH CLUB A massage parlor as required to be licensed by Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 115 or a health club that restricts minors by reason of age, and provides the services of massage, if such service is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas”. ADULT MINI-MOTION PICTURE THEATER A business premises within an enclosed building with a capacity for less than 50 persons used for presenting visual media material if such business as a prevailing practice excludes minors by virtue of age, or if said material is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on the depiction or description of “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas” for observation by patrons therein. ADULT MODELING STUDIO An establishment whose major business is the provision, to customers, of figure models who are so provided with the intent of providing sexual stimulation or sexual gratification to such customers and who engage in specified sexual activities or display specified anatomical area while being observed, painted, painted upon, sketched, drawn, sculptured, photographed, or otherwise depicted by such customers. ADULT MOTION PICTURE ARCADE Any place to which the public is permitted or invited wherein coin or slug-operated or electronically or mechanically controlled still or motor picture machines, projectors, or other image-producing devices are maintained to show images to five or fewer persons per machine at any one time, and where the images so displayed are distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on depicting or describing specified sexual activities or specified anatomical areas. ADULT MOTION PICTURE THEATER A business premises within an enclosed building with a capacity of 50 or more persons used for presenting visual media material if said business as a prevailing practice excludes minors by virtue of age, or if said material is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on the depiction or description of “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas” for observation by patrons in the establishment. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 401 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions ADULT NOVELTY BUSINESS A business that has as a primary activity the sale of devices that simulate human genitals or devices that are designed for sexual stimulation. ADULT SAUNA A sauna as defined in Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 115, that excludes minors by reason of age, or provides a steam bath or heat bathing room used for the purpose of bathing, relaxation, or reducing, using steam or hot air as a cleaning, relaxing or reducing agent, if the service provided by the sauna is distinguished or characterized by an emphasis on “specified sexual activities” or “specified anatomical areas”. AFFECTED PARTY For purposes of this UDC, the phrase includes The Zoning Administrator, any applicant, the owner or occupant of the property under consideration if different from the applicant, and any owners of adjacent properties who are entitled to receive a notice of public hearing or a notice of action for the application involved. An individual may qualify as an affected party upon showing that he owns, controls, leases, or otherwise has an interest in property that will be substantially and directly affected by a proposal and that is located within 350 feet of the boundary of the property involved in the proposal. AGRICULTURE PRODUCTION Establishments engaged in the production of crops, plants, or vines, including forestry, and the incidental sale of produce raised on the premises to individuals, or establishments in existence on January 1, 1992 that are engaged in the keeping, grazing, or feeding of livestock for sale, value increase, or livestock increase. This use also includes establishments that provide support to the agricultural community including but not limited to those engaged in elevators, soil preparation services, crop services, farm management services, breeding services, experimental farms for research or educational services, and small scale farm product processing such as cider mills, dairies, poultry, or meat processing, and commercial stable operations, including riding stables, but not including any use meeting the definition of Agricultural Retail. AGRICULTURE RETAIL Establishments and related land areas that are primarily engaged in providing services related to or conducting the sale at retail of farm equipment sales and repair, farm produce sales and supply, horticulture and floriculture products, including nurseries, greenhouses, and other places used to raise flowers, shrubs, and plants for later retail or wholesale; lawn and garden services; ornamental shrub and tree services. These enterprises typically produce their own stock, unlike a garden center that imports from other establishments the products it sells at retail. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 402 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions AISLE As used in regulations related to parking, a traveled way in a parking lot by which cars enter and depart parking spaces. ALCOHOLIC BEVERAGE Any beverage containing more than one-half of one percent alcohol by volume. ALLEY A public or private street primarily designed to serve as secondary access to the site or rear of those properties whose primary frontage is on some other street. ALTERATION (OF A BUILDING) See Structural Alteration (of a Building). ANIMAL FEEDLOTS A lot or building or combination of lots and buildings intended for the confined feeding, breeding, raising, or holding of animals exceeding 10 animal units and specifically designated as a confinement area where manure may accumulate, or where the concentration of animals is such that a vegetative cover cannot be maintained within the enclosure. A pasture shall not be considered an animal feedlot. ANIMAL HUSBANDRY The keeping of domestic animals, such as horses, dogs, cats, bees, not primarily for produce or value increase but rather for show, sport, or as pets. ANIMAL UNIT A unit of measure used to compare differences in the production of animal manure that employs as a standard the amount of manure produced on a regular basis by different types of animals. For purposes of this UDC, the animal unit or animal unit calculation measure shall be the same unit of measure currently used by the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency in Chapter 7020 of the Minnesota Rules relating to animal feedlots and storage, transportation, and use of animal manure. ANNEXATION (OF LAND) The addition of a land area into the City under the process outlined in Minnesota Statute Section 414 with a resulting change in the boundaries of the City. ARCADE A covered passageway, typically found at street level and often comprised of a series of arches supported by columns, which is accessible and open to the public. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 403 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions ARCHERY RANGE An area or facility designated or operated primarily for the use of an archer, bow and arrow, long bow, recurve bow, compound bow, or crossbow. ART GALLERY, MUSEUM, AND LIBRARY A facility or area that is open to the public and is intended for the acquisition, preservation, study, and exhibition of works of artistic, historical, or scientific value. ART STUDIO AND WORKSHOP A facility that includes work or teaching space for one or more artists, artisans, or musicians. ARTISAN MANUFACTURING Application, teaching, making, or fabrication of crafts or products by an artist, artisan, or craftsperson either by hand or with minimal automation and may include direct sales to consumers, in a facility not exceeding 10,000 square feet in gross floor area. This definition includes uses such as small-scale fabrication, manufacturing, and other industrial uses and processes typically not permitted in non-industrial zoning districts such as welding and sculpting. AUDITORIUM OR CIVIC CENTER A hall or seating area, generally enclosed, where an audience views a musical or theatrical performance, concert, sporting, or other entertainment event. AUTOMOTIVE CENTER An establishment that is engaged in both the retail sales of a limited or full range of vehicle parts and fuels and the repair and maintenance of automobiles and light trucks. Self-service, automated, or full service car washes as a primary use of property are included in this. AUTOMOTIVE DEALERSHIP An establishment engaged in the retail sale, leasing, repair and servicing of automobiles and light trucks, where vehicles for sale are on display in a showroom or on a lot for the traveling public. AUTOMOTIVE REPAIR SERVICES, MAJOR Establishments involved in the major repair of automobiles and light trucks, where the service is non-routine in nature, affecting major structural or mechanical components of the vehicles, that may involve storage of the vehicle for multiple days on the site. The repair of all other classes of trucks and motor homes is included. AWNING A fixed or retractable shelter projecting from and supported by the exterior wall of a building constructed of non-rigid materials on a supporting framework, often made of wood, cloth, vinyl, or other flexible material. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 404 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions BALCONY A porch or other partially enclosed exterior platform designed for outdoor use attached to the upper floors of a building. BAR OR TAVERN An establishment primarily engaged in the selling of drinks for consumption on the premises, where entertainment and the incidental sale of prepared food for consumption on the premises are permitted accessory uses. These establishments may charge a fee or admission charge for the entertainment provided. Included in this category are bars, beer gardens, discotheques, night clubs, taverns, hookah bars, and dance halls. BASEMENT Any area of a structure, including crawl spaces, having its floor or base subgrade (below ground level) on all four sides, regardless of the depth of excavation below ground level. BED AND BREAKFAST The commercial rental of bedrooms within a private residence, providing temporary accommodations, and typically including a morning meal to overnight guests. BEDROOM In a multifamily or attached dwelling, a private room planned and intended for sleeping, separated from other rooms by a door, and accessible to a bathroom without crossing another bedroom or other living area. BIKEWAY A Bikeway shall mean either of the following: Bicycle Lane A portion of the roadway designated for bicycles by striping, signage, and/or pavement markings for preferential or exclusive use of bicycles. Bike lanes must be located on both sides of the road to accommodate bicyclists traveling in the same direction as the adjacent vehicular lane. Bicycle Path A facility physically separated from the roadway and intended for bicycle use. A bicycle path is designed for the use of two lane, two-way bicycle traffic. Paths may be located within open space through a development, along an abandoned rail line or adjacent to an existing road. BLANK WALL A wall (including building façades and retaining walls) if it meets any of the following: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 405 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions 1. A wall or portion of a wall with a surface area of at least 400 square feet having both a length and a width of at least 10 feet without a transparent window or door, building modulation at least one foot in depth, or other architectural feature; 2. Any portion of a wall between three and 13 feet above ground level with a horizontal dimension longer than 15 feet without a window, door, building modulation at least one foot in depth, or other architectural feature including art work (such as mosaic, mural, sculpture, or relief), or qualifying landscaping. Qualifying landscaping includes a landscape planting bed at least five feet wide or a raised planter bed at least two feet high and three feet wide in front of the wall with planting materials that are sufficient to obscure or screen at least 35 percent of the wall’s surface within three years. BLOCK A parcel or group of parcels forming a unit of land bounded on all sides by a street or other transportation routes or by physical barriers such as water, or public open space. BLUFF A topographic feature such as a hill, cliff, or embankment having the following characteristics (an area with an average slope of less than 18 percent over a distance for 50 feet or more shall not be considered part of the bluff): 1. Part or all of the feature is located in a shoreland area; 2. The slope rises at least 25 feet above the ordinary high water level of the waterbody; 3. The grade or slope from the toe of the bluff to a point 25 feet or more above the ordinary high water level averages 30 percent or greater; and 4. The slope must drain toward the waterbody. BLUFF, TOE OF THE The lower point of a 50-foot segment with an average slope exceeding 18 percent. BLUFF, TOP OF The higher point of a 50-foot segment with an average slope exceeding 18 percent. BOARD OF APPEALS The Zoning Board of Appeals of the City of Rochester, Minnesota. BOULEVARD That portion of the right-of-way outside the vehicle travel lanes that may contain sidewalks, landscaped area, infrastructure, or amenities. BOULEVARD TREEGREEN FACILITIES AGREEMENT An agreement between an applicant and the City to ensure the timely installation of required boulevard trees, which may include but is not limited to terms addressing the latest date by Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 406 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions which boulevard trees must be installed, requirement(s) to submit a cash escrow, surety bond, or letter of credit, and terms upon which the City will release such required financial security. BUFFERYARD A unit of yard together with the plantings required thereon designed to mitigate nuisance between abutting land uses or between a land use and a public street. BUILD-TO LINE The line at which construction of a building, excluding porches, bay windows, covered porches, decks, and patios, is to occur on a lot. A build-to line typically runs parallel to the front property line and is established to create an even building façade line on a street. BUILDABLE AREA The area of a lot remaining after the minimum yard or setback requirements of this UDC have been met. BUILDING Any structure used or intended for supporting or sheltering any occupancy. Where roofed structures are separated from each other by party walls having no openings for passage, each portion so separated shall be deemed a separate building. BUILDING CODE Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapter 50. BUILDING CODE, STATE The Minnesota State Building Code, setting forth standards for the construction, addition, modification, and repair of buildings and other structures for the purpose of protecting the health, safety, and general welfare of the public, that has been adopted by the City of Rochester. BUILDING FRONT The wall of a building that faces the front lot line of a lot. BUILDING LINE A line parallel to the front lot line at a distance equal to the minimum depth of the front yard required for the zoning district where the lot is located. BUILDING PERIMETER The horizontal distance measured along those walls from which, when viewed from above, lines drawn perpendicular to the wall will intersect a lot line without intersecting another wall of the building. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 407 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions BUILDING, PRIMARY A building in which is conducted, or that is intended to be conducted, the primary use of the lot on which it is located. BUILDING, TEMPORARY See Structure, Temporary BUSINESS OR PERSONAL SERVICE An establishments primarily engaged in providing services involving the care of a person or his or her apparel or rendering services to business establishments on a fee or contract basis, such as barber shops, clothing rental, tattoo or piercing parlor, photographic studios, cleaning and garment services (but not including power laundries or dry cleaning plants), coin operated laundries, advertising and mailing, building maintenance, office equipment rental and leasing, photo finishing, business supply services computer programming/data processing services, locksmiths, and repair of business or household goods and equipment generally weighing less than 25 pounds. BUSINESS CENTER A building or group of buildings planned, constructed, and managed as a single entity, and generally with common on-site parking for a group of commercial, office, or service establishments. BUSINESS PARK A development planned as a total entity for a group of commercial, light industrial, office or service establishments with coordinated standards for lighting, sign, grading, landscaping, and storage and with development-level controls on trip generation. CALIPER A nursery stock measurement in inches of tree trunk diameter used to standardize plant size. Trunk caliper for trees up to four inches is to be measured six inches above the soil line and trees greater than four inches in caliper are measured 12 inches above the soil line. CAMPGROUND OR RV PARK An establishment engaged in providing overnight or short-term sites for the placement of recreational vehicles or temporary housing, with or without facilities such as water and electricity. This does not include long-term storage or Recreational Vehicles. CANOPY PLANTING OR TREE Trees and plantings consisting of a single stem or multi-stem trunk, that is characterized by an oval, round, or umbrella-shaped overhead crown that provides significant shade as the tree or planting reaches maturity. At maturity a canopy planting or tree will normally be a minimum of 35 feet in height. Not all canopy plantings or trees can be expected to reach that height in an Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 408 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions urban setting, however, the normal height as depicted by the University of Minnesota or the Minnesota Department of Transportation is acceptable. CAPACITY The maximum number of persons that may be accommodated by a development as determined by building code or fire code requirements. CARNIVAL OR FESTIVAL A temporary festival typically offering amusement rides, variety shows, or other entertainment. CARPORT A shelter for one or more automotive vehicles that is open on at least two sides, formed by a roof projecting from the side of a building or a detached structure of the same type. CEMETERY Land used or intended to be used for the burial of the dead, including animals, and dedicated for cemetery purposes. Permitted uses include a columbarium, mausoleum, or crematorium. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS A permit issued by the Heritage Preservation Commission granting an applicant approval for the alteration, change, demolition, relocation, excavation, or new construction of a structure within a local historic or conservation district. CHAIN-LINK FENCE A fence of steel or aluminum posts and wires woven into a diamond pattern that may have a galvanized, painted or vinyl coated exterior finish. CHANGE OF USE A use that differs from the previous use of a building or land in terms of major retail product mix, services offered, production methods, type, or intensity of residential use. CHILD An individual who has not reached 18 years of age. CITY The incorporated City of Rochester, Olmsted County, state of Minnesota. CITY ENGINEER The individual designated as the city engineer by the Public Works Director. CLERICAL ERROR An unintentional mistake in preparing, reviewing, or revising a document. Clerical errors include, but are not limited to: (a) scrivener’s errors; (b) misspellings; (c) omitting, transposing, or mis- Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 409 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions entering a word, number or symbol; (d) references to an incorrect provision in the UDC or in a federal or state law or regulation. CLINIC An establishment engaged in the care, diagnosis, and treatment of sick, ailing, infirm and injured persons, and those in need of medical, dental, vision, and/or surgical attention, but who are not provided with board or room, nor kept overnight on the premises. COLLEGE OR UNIVERSITY An institution other than a trade school that provides full-time or part-time education beyond high school. COMMISSION “Commission” means either the Planning Commission, or the Heritage Preservation Commission (HPC) of the City of Rochester, Minnesota. Reference by default is to the Planning Commission. When Heritage Preservation Commission is intended, the reference is spelled out, indicated by “HPC” acronym, or indicated by context. COMMISSIONER Unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, “Commissioner” means the Commissioner of the Department of Natural Resources State of Minnesota. COMMON DRIVEWAY A driveway shared and used jointly to provide access to two or more residential or Non- Residential properties. COMMUNICATIONS TOWER A tower structure and related equipment enabling the transmission of electronic signals via wired and wireless means, but not including any use meeting the definition of a Commercial Wireless Telecommunications Service. COMMUNITY CENTER A building or portion of a building used for nonprofit, cultural, educational, recreational, religious, or social activities that is open to the public or a designated part of the public, usually owned and operated by a public or nonprofit group or agency. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR The Community Development Director as provided for in the Rochester Code of Ordinances Section 20-16, or his or her authorized representative. COMMUNITY GARDEN The cultivation of food and/or horticultural crops, composting, aquaponics, aquaculture and/or hydroponics including but not limited to gardens, container gardens, edible landscapes, residential greenhouses, herb gardens, rooftop gardens, berry patches, vegetable gardens. All Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 410 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions of which may include the production and sale of food products from food grown on the premises. Community Garden may be divided into separate plots for cultivation by one or more individuals or may be farmed collectively by members of the group and may include common areas maintained and used by group members. COMPREHENSIVE PLAN The adopted goals, policy statements, standards, programs, and maps for guiding the physical, social, and economic development, both public and private, of the City and its environs, including. any unit or part of such plan separately adopted, and as amended by City Council. CONGREGATE HOUSING A dwelling providing shelter and services that may include meals, housekeeping, personal care assistance and minor medical services, but not intermediate, long term or extended nursing care for residents. Congregate housing does not fall within the Fair Housing Amendments Act (FHAA), nor does it meet the definition of any other group living use. CONSTRUCTION OFFICE The permanent location of a room or group of rooms used for managing the affairs of a construction or contracting company. A construction office may allow outdoor storage, but its location is fixed, and not related to on-site management or operation of a given construction project. CONTIGUOUS Next to, abutting, or touching and having a boundary, or portion thereof, that is coterminous. CONTRACTOR’S OFFICE AND YARD A temporary building or structure used as a construction office or outdoor storage area for equipment and materials for a project located on the same site during its construction. CORNICE A horizontal decorative projection located at the top of a building near the roof line, which may include a roof overhang. CORRECTIONAL FACILITY A building along with associated lot area designed for the confinement of individuals for the purpose of discipline or punishment or incarceration of convicted criminals. COUNCIL The City Council of the City of Rochester, Minnesota. COUNTY The County of Olmsted, Minnesota. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 411 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions CRAWL SPACE A low space below the first story of a building, where there has not been excavation deep enough for a basement, but where there is space for installation of and service to pipes, ducts, and utilities. CURB A stone, asphalt, or concrete boundary marking the edge of a roadway or paved area. DAY CARE FACILITY A licensed private or public establishment that for gain or otherwise, regularly provides one or more dependents with care, training, supervision, rehabilitation, or developmental guidance on a regular basis, for periods of less than 24 hours a day, in a place other than the dependent's home. DECIBEL (dB) A unit of sound pressure level, abbreviated as dB. DECK A structure open to the sky that is attached to or abuts the wall of a dwelling and is afforded access to the interior of the dwelling through one or more doors. Structures 30 inches or more above grade are considered accessory structures, while structures lower to the ground are considered permitted projections into required yards. DECORAH EDGE-RELATED DEFINITIONS When used in the context of regulating the Decorah Edge area, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. DECORAH EDGE The Decorah Edge is a geologic feature within the states of Minnesota, Iowa, and Wisconsin. It is a layer of Impermeable shale that perches ground water and causes the ground water to flow horizontally until it seeps out on eroded slopes or through the shallow soils. The soils and plants treat the ground water by utilizing the nitrate that we used in fertilizing our crops and gardens along with our septic effluent. In the treatment process it flows into wetlands and fens or just being infiltrated into the ground as aquifer recharge. This cleansing effect helps keep our ground water cleaner than with just collection and infiltration. This is why the city has put so much effort into protecting this resource. Decorah Edge shall include the area: 1. Where the Decorah, Platteville, or Glenwood formation is the first-encountered bedrock according to the "Bedrock Geology: Steele, Dodge, Olmsted and Winona Counties" data plat produced by the Minnesota Geological Survey—University of Minnesota in 2004, as modified by field investigation, reliable well logs or more precise mapping; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 412 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions 2. Having a depth to bedrock of less than 25 feet according to the "Depth to Bedrock: Steele, Dodge, Olmsted and Winona Counties" data plat produced by the Minnesota Geological Survey—University of Minnesota in 2004, as modified by field investigation, reliable well logs or more precise mapping; and 3. Where there are contiguous adjacent areas with the Cummingsville or higher (Stewartville or Prosser) formations as the first-encountered bedrock. An area for which the first-encountered bedrock is the Decorah Shale, Platteville Limestone, or Glenwood Shale, that is separated from the Cummingsville or higher formations by a topographic saddle and is at a higher elevation than the saddle, is excluded from the Decorah Edge. For purposes of the DEO district, the term "saddle" means a ridge between two peaks or summits EDGE SUPPORT AREA Edge Support Area includes non-wetland areas with features associated with perched groundwater tables, groundwater discharges, or Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands located in the Decorah Edge, including: 1. Haverhill (474B), Root (471) and Palms (528B) soils; 2. Areas where the seasonal groundwater table is within five feet of the surface and slopes are under 18 percent, including Shullsburg (312B or 312C), Littleton (477B), and similar soils; 3. Areas with slopes over 18 percent within 50 feet of Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands or Haverhill (474B), Palms (528B), Shullsburg (312B or 312C), Littleton (477B) or similar soils; 4. Areas within 50 feet of springs; 5. Areas within 50 feet of seeps; 6. Areas of hydric soils in and adjacent to drainageways draining Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands; 7. Areas within 50 feet of a perennial or ephemeral stream in the Decorah Edge; and 8. Areas of hydric soils buried by sedimentation adjacent to Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands or in proximity to and at the same approximate elevation as Groundwater Supported Slope Wetlands. GROUNDWATER SUPPORTED SLOPE WETLAND A wetland area that is saturated predominately by groundwater, including wetlands in the vicinity of springs or seeps. Such wetlands may be associated with highly organic peat-like soils such as Haverhill (474B) and Palms (528B) soils. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 413 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions MINOR WATERSHED AREA A minor watershed, as defined and mapped by the state department of natural resources division of waters in 1999, as revised, and distributed by the land management information center. DEDICATION The transfer of property interests from private to public ownership for a public purpose. DEMOLITION PERMIT A building permit that authorizes the demolition or removal of an existing building or structure from a site. DEPENDENT An individual with a mental or physical disability. DEVELOPMENT Any man-made change to improved or unimproved real estate, including a change in use or the creation of a subdivision. DEVELOPMENT SITE A plot of land that is intended or suitable for a proposed servicing of unimproved land or the improvement of previously developed land and for which there is the proposed construction of any improvement, new buildings or renovation, or significant change of existing buildings to accommodate a new land use or increased density of a land use and for which City approvals are required. DORMITORY A multifamily dwelling designed primarily as housing for, or likely to be occupied by, undergraduate or post-graduate students. DRAINAGEWAY A above-ground channel that provides for the collection and conveyance of stormwater runoff from a watershed area of over 1,200 acres in size, that is not part of a designated floodplain. The area of the drainageway shall be calculated as that area needed to convey the water of a 100 year rainfall within the watershed. DRIVE-IN FACILITY An accessory use that by design, physical facilities, service, or by packaging procedures encourages or permits customers to receive services or obtain goods while remaining in their motor vehicles, but not including any use meeting the definition of Outdoor Entertainment or Recreation. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 414 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions DRIVEWAY A private minor vehicular access between a street or roadway and a designated off-street parking area. DRIVEWAY APPROACH The portion of a driveway located between a property line and the edge of the street pavement. Driveway approach width is measured per the Engineering Standards. DWELLING, ATTACHED A building containing three or more dwelling units arranged side by side, separated from each other by a firewall and having separate direct means of egress and ingress to each unit from the outside. DWELLING, COTTAGE DEVELOPMENT A shared-interest low-density residential community in which multiple small individual dwellings are served by shared private ways or infrastructure, and in which the development intensity may be measured by the amount of gross floor area in residential dwelling units rather than the number of residential dwelling units. A cottage development may include a combination of dwelling units with shared facilities including but not limited to open space, parking lots or carports, gardens, recreation areas, community building(s) with facilities such as a kitchen and dining area, and meeting and activity spaces. DWELLING, DUPLEX A building on a single lot containing two dwelling units. DWELLING, FOURPLEX A single building on a single lot containing four dwelling units under one roof, each of which is occupied by one family. DWELLING, LIVE/WORK A dwelling unit containing an integrated living and working space in different areas of the unit, and in which the dwelling areas are located above or behind the working space, in order to allow the ground floor working space at the front of the building to serve patrons or customers. DWELLING, MULTIFAMILY A building containing five or more dwelling units on a single lot, including but not limited to apartments, cooperative apartments, and condominiums. Regardless of how rental units are equipped, any multifamily dwelling in which units are available for rental periods of one week or less shall be considered a hotel or motel. DWELLING UNIT A single unit providing complete, independent living facilities for one or more persons, including permanent provisions for living, sleeping, eating, cooking, and sanitation. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 415 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions DWELLING, SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED A detached building containing one dwelling unit located on a single lot, including both those constructed on site and those constructed partially or entirely off-site, that meet adopted building codes or U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development manufactured housing codes for long-term occupancy. The building must be anchored and attached to a permanent frost-depth foundation or foundation system constructed in conformance with the adopted building code. DWELLING, TRIPLEX A single building on a single lot containing three principal dwelling units under one roof, each of which is occupied by one family. DWELLING, TWIN-HOME A building containing one dwelling unit attached to one other building containing only one dwelling, with each building on a separate lot. EARTH BERMED Buildings constructed so that there is earth covering on above grade portion of building walls and no earth covering on the roof. The total amount of the earth covering is less than 50 percent of the walls and roof surface area. EARTH SHELTERED Buildings constructed so that more than 50 percent of the exterior surface area of the building, excluding garages and other accessory buildings, is covered with earth and the building code standards promulgated pursuant to Minn. Stat. Ch. 16.85 are satisfied. Partially completed buildings shall not be considered earth sheltered. EASEMENT A grant of one or more of the property rights by the property owner to and for use by the public, a corporation, or another individual or entity. EASEMENT, DRAINAGE An easement required for the installation of stormwater sewers or surface drainage channels, or the preservation or maintenance of a natural stream or watercourse. EASEMENT, UTILITY An easement required for the installation of overhead or underground utilities, including but not limited to sanitary sewer, water, electric, gas, and audio or visual communication lines. ELECTRIC VEHICLE CHARGING STATION A facility or area where electric-powered or hybrid-powered motor vehicles can obtain electrical current to recharge batteries and that is accessory to a primary use of the property. This use can be incidental to any allowable use in any zone district. There are currently three types of electric vehicle charging stations: Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 416 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions 1. A Level 1 station uses 110 volt current and generally provides approximately one to two miles of additional vehicle range from one hour of charging time. 2. A Level 2 station uses at least 220 volt current and generally provides approximately 10- 20 miles of additional vehicle range from one hour of charging time. 3. A Level 3 station uses a current significantly higher than 220 volts and generally provides 60-80 miles of additional vehicle range from 20 minutes of charging time. EMERGENCY SERVICE An establishment engaged in providing police, fire, ambulance services or related emergency first aid services. ESTABLISHMENT An economic unit, generally at a single physical location, where business is conducted, services provided, or industrial operations performed. EXCAVATION The artificial removal of earth material. EXCAVATION ACTIVITIES Activities involving Substantial Land Alteration, Quarry, or Sand or Gravel Excavation. EXTERIOR LIGHTING DEFINITIONS CUTOFF The point at which all light rays emitted by a lamp, light source, or luminaire are completely eliminated (cutoff) at a specific angle above the ground. CUTOFF ANGLE The maximum angle formed by a line drawn in the direction of emitted light rays at the light source and a line perpendicular to the ground from the light source. CUTOFF-TYPE LUMINAIRE A luminaire with elements such as shields, reflector, or refractor panels that direct and cut off the light at a cutoff angle that is less than 90 degrees. FOOT CANDLE A unit of illumination produced on a surface, all points of which are one foot from a uniform point source of one candle. GLARE The brightness of light source that causes eye discomfort. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 417 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions LUMINAIRE A complete lighting unit consisting of a light source and all necessary mechanical, electrical and decorative parts. EXTERIOR WOOD The heartwood from species of wood having natural resistance to decay, including redwood, cedars, and black locust; grades of lumber that contain sapwood from species of wood having a natural resistance to decay, including redwood and cedars; or treated wood. EXPANSION Any Increase in a dimension such as number of units, size, area, volume or height of an existing structure or facility. FAÇADE The exterior walls of a building exposed to public view from a public street. The wall visible from a public street or parking lot and used for the main public access or that has distinguishing architectural features will be considered the primary façade. A wall that is visible from a public street or parking lot serving the business center but not the main access to the building is considered the secondary façade. FAMILY Family is defined as a group of individuals persons living together as a relatively stable and permanent with a bona fide single housekeeping unit that is unlikely to have any significant negative impact on the residential character of the neighborhood including such characteristics as a family-like structure of authority, an integrated economic unit, or evidence of a domestic bond between members. FAST FOOD RESTAURANT An establishment whose primary business is the sale of food and/or beverages in a ready to consume state for consumption within the restaurant building, within a motor vehicle parked on the premises, or off the premises as a carry out order, and whose principal method of operation involves serving food and/or beverages in edible containers or in paper, plastic, or other disposable containers. FENCE An artificially constructed barrier of any material or combination of materials erected to enclose or screen areas of land. FILL A deposit of earth material placed by artificial means. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 418 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions FINANCIAL INSTITUTION A facility that provides financial and banking services to individuals and businesses. These services may include deposit banking and closely related functions such as making loans, investments, check cashing, and fiduciary activities. Accessory uses may include automatic teller machines and offices. FIREARM A gun including but not limited to pistols, revolvers, rifles, muzzleloaders, and shotguns that discharges shot or a projectile by means of an explosive, a gas, or compressed air. FITNESS CENTER An Indoor Entertainment or Recreation use consisting of a building or portion of a building designed and equipped for the conduct of exercise in a place with facilities and equipment for people to maintain or improve their physical fitness, operated for profit or not-for-profit, and that can be open only to bona fide members and guests of the organization, or open to the public for a fee with limited hours. FLAG LOT A lot that has only sufficient frontage on a street to comply with the required access width requirements of this UDC, shaped in such a manner that the portion of the lot closest to the street can only be used for access purposes and not as yard or buildable area, and whose width some distance back from the right-of-way is sufficient to provide adequate space to meet yard or setback requirements. Only that portion of the lot of adequate width to meet lot width requirements or allow for provision of adequate yards or setback shall be counted as part of the lot area. FLOOD PROTECTION-RELATED DEFINITIONS When used in the context of regulating flood protection, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. AO ZONE An area of shallow flooding shown on the City’s Flood Insurance Rate Map (FIRM) with base flood depths from one to three feet where a clearly defined channel does not exist, where the path of flooding is unpredictable and undetermined, and where low velocity flow may be evident. CRITICAL FACILITIES Facilities necessary to a community’s public health and safety, those that store or produce highly volatile, toxic or water-reactive materials, and those that house occupants that may be insufficiently mobile to avoid loss of life or injury. Examples of critical facilities include hospitals, correctional facilities, schools, daycare facilities, nursing homes, fire and police stations, wastewater treatment facilities, public electric utilities, water plants, fuel storage facilities, and waste handling and storage facilities. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 419 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions EQUAL DEGREE OF ENCROACHMENT A method of determining the location of floodway boundaries so that floodplain lands on both sides of a stream are capable of conveying a proportionate share of flood flows. FARM FENCE An open type of fence of posts and horizontally run wire, further defined by Minnesota Statutes, Section 344.02, Subd. 1(a-d), that is not considered to be a structure for purposes of floodplain regulation. Fences that have the potential to obstruct flood flows, such as chain link fences and rigid walls, are regulated as structures for purposes of floodplain regulation. FLOOD FRINGE That portion of the floodplain outside of the floodway. Flood fringe is synonymous with the term "floodway fringe" used in the Flood Insurance Study. FLOOD INSURANCE RATE MAP An official map on which the Federal Insurance Administrator has delineated both the special hazard areas and the risk premium zones applicable to the community. A FIRM that has been made available digitally is called a Digital Flood Insurance Rate Map (DFIRM). FLOOD INSURANCE STUDY The attached material includes the Flood Insurance Study for Olmsted County, Minnesota, and Incorporated Areas, dated ____, which includes an examination, evaluation and determination of flood hazards, and if appropriate, corresponding surface elevations, or an examination, evaluation, and determination of mudslide (i.e. mudflow) and/or flood-related erosion hazards, upon which the incorporated floodplain maps are based. FLOODPLAIN The land adjacent to a body of water that has been or may be hereafter covered by flood water including that land covered by the regional flood. FLOOD PROOFING Any combination of structural and nonstructural additions, changes or adjustments to structures and properties that reduce or eliminate flood damage to real estate, water and sanitary facilities, structures, and their contents. FLOOD PROTECTION ELEVATION The flood protection elevation is an elevation no lower than one foot above the elevation of the regional flood plus any increases in flood elevation caused by encroachments on the floodplain that result from designation of a floodway. In Zone AO, the flood protection elevation is established by adding one foot above the depth number specified in feet on the FIRM to the highest adjacent grade at the structure’s proposed location on the ground. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 420 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions FLOOD, REGIONAL A flood that is representative of large floods known to have occurred generally in Minnesota and reasonably characteristic of what can be expected to occur on an average frequency in the magnitude of the 100-year recurrence interval. Regional flood is synonymous with the term "base flood" used in the Flood Insurance Study. FLOOD, STANDARD PROJECT A hypothetical flood estimated and mapped by the U.S. Corps of Engineers, representing the critical flood runoff volume and peak discharge that may be expected from the most severe combination of meteorological and hydrologic conditions that are considered reasonable characteristic of the Rochester region, excluding rare combinations. FLOODWAY The minimum channel of a watercourse and those portions of the floodplain adjoining the channel, that are reasonably required to carry or store the regional flood discharge. FP-1, FP-2, FP-3, FP-4, FP-5 Different classifications of flood proofing measures as defined by the state building code. FREEBOARD A factor of safety usually expressed in feet above a design flood level for flood protective or control works. (Freeboard is intended to compensate for the many unknown factors that could contribute to flood heights greater than the height calculated for a selected flood or floodway condition such as wave action, bridge opening and floodway obstructions resulting from debris or ice, and the hydrologic effects of urbanization of the watershed). LETTER OF MAP AMENDMENT (LOMA) A document issued by the Federal Emergency Management Agency providing documentation for findings that have been made showing that single a lot or single structure is not located in a Special Flood Hazard Area as defined in 44 CFR 59. LOWEST FLOOR The lowest floor of the lowest enclosed area (including basement). An unfinished or flood resistant enclosure, used solely for parking of vehicles, building access, or storage in an area other than a basement area, is not considered a building’s lowest floor; provided, that such enclosure is not built so as to render the structure in violation of the applicable non- elevation design requirements of 44 Code of Federal Regulations, Part 60.3. OBSTRUCTION Any dam, wall, wharf, embankment, levee, dike, pile, abutment, projection, excavation, channel modification, culvert, building, wire, fence, stockpile, refuse, fill, structure, or matter in, along, across, or projecting into any channel, watercourse, or regulatory floodplain that Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 421 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions may impede, retard, or change the direction of the flow of water, either in itself or by catching or collecting debris carried by such water. ORDINARY HIGH WATER LEVEL See definition in general definition list. SUBSTANTIAL DAMAGE For purposes of floodplain regulation, damage of any origin sustained by a structure where the cost of restoring the structure to its before damaged condition would equal or exceed 50 percent of the market value of the structure before the damage occurred. SUBSTANTIAL IMPROVEMENT For purposes of floodplain regulation, within any consecutive 365-day period, any reconstruction, rehabilitation (including normal maintenance and repair), repair after damage, addition, or other improvement of a structure, the cost of which equals or exceeds 50 percent of the market value of the structure before the “start of construction” of the improvement. This term includes structures that have incurred “substantial damage,” regardless of the actual repair work performed. The term does not include either: 1. Any project for improvement of a structure to correct existing violations of state or local health, sanitary, or safety code specifications that have been identified by the local code enforcement official and that are the minimum necessary to assure safe living conditions; or 2. Any alteration of a “historic structure,” provided that the alteration will not preclude the structure’s continued designation as a “historic structure.” For the purpose of the floodplain regulations in this UDC, “historic structure” is as defined in 44 Code of Federal Regulations, Part 59.1. FLOOR AREA (OF A BUILDING) The sum of the gross horizontal area of the several floors of a building measured from the outside faces of walls or the centerline of party walls separating two buildings, but not including any interior parking spaces, loading spaces, any space where the floor to ceiling height is less than six feet, any space devoted to mechanical equipment, terraces, breezeways or screened porches, or basement or other subterranean area not intended for human habitation or service to the public. The floor area for enclosed space having a floor to ceiling height in excess of 20 feet shall be computed on the basis that each 15 feet of height shall be equal to one floor. FLOOR AREA RATIO Establishes the maximum ratio of floor area to net buildable area on a zoning lot FOUNDATION OR, FOUNDATION SYSTEM A permanent foundation that provides adequate support of the building’s vertical and horizontal loads and transfers these and other imposed forces, without failure, from the building to the Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 422 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions undisturbed ground below the frost line and constructed in accordance with the state building code as adopted by the City. FUELING STATION A facility where fuels like diesel, gasoline, ethanol, natural gas, electricity, and hydrogen; related supplies for motorists; and convenience foods and goods are sold. All services included in Automotive Center are excluded. FUEL TANK A safe container for flammable fluids. FUNERAL HOME An establishment providing services such as preparing the human or animal dead for burial, cremating human remains, and arranging and managing funerals, and for which permitted accessory uses include a crematorium. FRONTAGE The distance that a lot line coincides with the right-of-way line of a public street or the boundary of a private street. GARAGE A detached accessory building or a portion of a primary building used for the parking and storage of vehicles, merchandise, or equipment, and that is not a separate commercial establishment open to the general public. When associated with a residential use in a residential district, it shall be limited to use for parking and storage of vehicles, noncommercial trailers, and household equipment. GARAGE SALE The sale of used household belongings at a residential dwelling or residential neighborhood including but not limited to “home sale,” “estate sale,” “attic sale,” and “basement sale” and any other type of residential sale of tangible personal property. GARDEN CENTER A retail business for the display and sale of products either inside or outside of a building or structure. The products for retail sale that may be displayed and stored in a greenhouse or outdoors include those products related to gardening and landscaping including, but not limited to, outdoor live plants; landscaping materials such as lawn ornaments, pavers, and landscape walls; bulk materials such as mulch, topsoil, rock, and gravel; gardening supplies such as fertilizer, pesticides, and small hand tools. Related retails sales may also be part of a garden center including cut flowers, indoor live plants, Christmas trees and related retail products. Landscaping services may be a part of the garden center. Greenhouses or retail buildings and offices may be part of a permanent garden center. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 423 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions GEOTHERMAL ENERGY SYSTEM Land area and equipment for the conversion of natural geothermal energy into energy for beneficial use. GRADE The lowest point of elevation of the finished surface of the ground, paving or sidewalk within the area between the building and the property line, or between the building and a stabilization structure such as a retaining wall, or, where the property line or structure is more than five feet from the building, between the building and a line five feet from the building. GRADING Any excavation or fill combination of those activities. GRADING PLAN An integrated set of documents that addresses how a proposed development will comply with the requirements of part 50.01 (2) of the Building Code. GREENHOUSE A building whose roof and sides are made largely of glass or other transparent or translucent material and in which the temperature and humidity can be regulated for the cultivation of delicate or out-of-season plants for subsequent sale, for personal enjoyment, or for the temporary storage or display of plant material. GROSS LEASABLE AREA The total floor area designed for the occupancy and exclusive use of a tenant. GROUP LIVING USE Those residential uses listed in Tables 330.02-1 400.08-1 as Group Living Uses HABITABLE ROOM A room used or intended to be used for sleeping, cooking, living, or eating purposes, excluding such enclosed spaces as closets, pantries, bath or toilet facilities, service rooms, corridors, laundries, unfinished attics, foyers, storage space, utility rooms or similar spaces. HABITABLE UNIT A habitable room, singularly or in combination with other rooms, that provides sleeping facilities alone or in combination with required cooking, eating, or living facilities. HEAVY COMMERCIAL SERVICES An establishment that has an industrial character even though it is not involved in the manufacturing or processing of products including but not limited to a composting facility, contractor’s office or yard, lumber yards, utility yards, public maintenance shops, carpet and rug cleaning, printing and publishing services, power laundries, and dry cleaning plants, that may Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 424 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions generate negative impacts largely through their need for outside storage of equipment and materials, the large expanse of land needed for this storage, and the creation of dirt, dust, and noise, along with intermittent truck traffic. HEIGHT (OF A BUILDING) The vertical distance above grade along the building front measured to the highest point of the coping of a flat roof, or to the deck line of a mansard roof, or to the average height between the eave and ridge of a gable, hip, or gambrel roof. Maximum height establishes the maximum height in feet above grade, allowed for structures within a given zoning district. HERITAGE PRESERVATION DEFINITIONS When used in the context of regulating heritage preservation, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. ALTER OR ALTERATION A change to the exterior of an existing building, structure, site, or feature that materially modifies its appearance or construction. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS A permit issued granting an applicant approval for the alteration, change, demolition, relocation, excavation, or new construction of a designated property or within a designated historic district. CONTRIBUTING PROPERTY A building, site, structure, or object that adds to the historic architectural qualities or archaeological values for which a property or landmark district is considered significant. DEMOLITION Any act or process that destroys in part or in whole a historic resource. This includes the removal of any material constituting part of a structure that affects the exterior appearance of the structure, other than for purposes of ordinary maintenance or repair, as well as inadequate maintenance or any other action that reduces the stability or longevity of a structure or impairs its historic or architectural integrity. DEMOLITION BY NEGLECT The long-term neglect of a historic structure that contributes to a level of dilapidation so severe that rehabilitation of the structure no longer serves as a viable option and demolition must be considered on account of the public health, safety, and welfare. DESIGNATED PROPERTY A property designated by the City Council as a landmark property, a landmark district, or contributing to a landmark district. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 425 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions DESIGNATION The formal process described in Section 60.500.040F, Designation of Landmark Property or Landmark District, to recognize a property as historically significant and eligible for benefits, subject to the terms of this UDC. EMERGENCY REPAIR Work necessary to prevent destruction or dilapidation to real property or structural appurtenances thereto immediately threatened or damaged by fire, flood, tornado, or other disaster HERITAGE PRESERVATION DESIGN GUIDELINES A locally specific document providing additional information for the review of proposed alterations or additions to designated landmarks or landmark districts. HERITAGE PRESERVATION PROGRAM A plan established by the city that contemplates a vision for the city's historic preservation program, setting near-term and long-term priorities for the program, and identifies proactive and innovative strategies for achieving the identified goals and objectives. HERITAGE PRESERVATION PROPERTY A property listed on the City’s inventory and located within the Heritage Preservation Overlay district. HISTORIC INTEGRITY The ability of a property to convey its significance relative to the aspects of location, setting, design, materials, workmanship, and association. HISTORIC RESOURCE Properties including objects, buildings, structures, sites, landscapes, and districts subject to the provisions of Section 60.200.040C HPO – Heritage Preservation Overlay or related procedures in Chapter 60.500 Procedures and Administration. HISTORIC SIGNIFICANCE The documented importance of a property or feature for its contribution to or representation of broad patterns of national, regional, or local history, architecture, engineering, archaeology, and culture. HISTORIC SITE The location of a significant event, a prehistoric or historic occupation or activity or a building or structure, whether standing, ruined, or vanished, where the location itself possesses historic, cultural, or archaeological value regardless of the value of any existing structure. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 426 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions INVENTORY A list of properties identified by the Heritage Preservation Commission that may be evaluated for historic significance and designation as a landmark at a future time and that has interim protection if an application for a Demolition Permit is submitted. LANDMARK A district, site, building, structure, object, or other property of historic significance designated locally pursuant to Section 60.500.040F. LANDMARK OBJECT A construction other than a building or structure that is small in scale and simply constructed or primarily artistic in nature. It may be movable by nature or by design, but is associated with a specific setting and environment. PRESERVATION Active maintenance and repair of existing historic materials and retention of a property's form as it has evolved over time, which is one of four approaches to the Secretary of Interior Standards. RECONSTRUCTION The act or process of depicting, by means of new construction, the form, features, and detailing of a non-surviving site, landscape, building, structure, or object for the purpose of replicating its appearance at a specific period of time, which is one of four approaches to the Secretary of Interior Standards. REHABILITATION Altering a property to meet continuing or changing uses while retaining the property's historic character-defining features, which is one of four approaches to the Secretary of Interior Standards. RELOCATION Moving a building or structure from its original historically significant or existing location to another location. REPAIR The limited replacement in kind, or with compatible substitute material, of extensively deteriorated or missing parts of features. RESTORATION Alteration of a property to depict the property at a particular period of time in its history, while removing evidence of other periods, which is one of four approaches to the Secretary of Interior Standards. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 427 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions RESTORE The act or process of accurately depicting the form, features, and character of a property as it appeared at a particular period of time by means of the removal of features from other periods in its history and reconstruction of missing features from the restoration period. SECRETARY OF THE INTERIOR’S STANDARDS (FOR TREATMENT OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES) A series of concepts published by the National Park Service about maintaining, repairing, and replacing historic materials, as well as designing new additions or making alterations to historic properties and includes Approaches for Preservation, Rehabilitation, Restoration and Reconstruction. HOME OCCUPATION Any gainful occupation or profession engaged in by the occupant of a dwelling unit at or from the dwelling unit. HOTEL OR MOTEL A building or series of buildings operated as an establishment providing accommodations in habitable units by prior arrangements, for compensation, without restriction on the time period involved. Regardless of how rental units are equipped, any Multifamily Dwelling in which units are available for rental periods of one week or less shall be considered a hotel or motel. HOUSEHOLD LIVING USE Those residential uses listed in Tables 300.02-1 400.08-1 as Household Living Uses HOUSING CODE Rochester Code of Ordinances Chapters 32 through 38. IMPERVIOUS SURFACE A constructed hard surface that prevents or retards entry of water into the soi land causes water to run off the surface in greater quantities and at an increased rate of flow than prior to development, including rooftops; decks; sidewalks; patios; swimming pools; parking lots; concrete, asphalt, gravel driveways, or permeable pavers; and other similar surfaces. INDOOR ENTERTAINMENT OR RECREATION A commercial recreation facility that provides completely enclosed or indoor entertainment or recreation space, such as racquet clubs, indoor skating rinks or swimming pools, bowling alleys, billiard, pool, or bingo parlors, amusement arcades, indoor archery ranges, indoor live or motion picture theaters, and fitness centers or gymnasiums, and where food or beverages may be served as an accessory use, but does not include any use meeting the definition of Adult Entertainment, Auditorium or Civic Center, or Indoor Gun Range. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 428 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions INDOOR GUN RANGE An indoor area or facility designated or operated primarily for the use of firearms. INDUSTRY, HEAVY An establishment involved in the manufacture, fabrication, processing, compounding, or assembling of materials from raw material or previously processed material, and that have severe potential for adversely affecting surrounding land uses due to potential environmental impacts related to noise, smoke/particulate emissions, vibration, noxious gases, odors, glare/heat, fire/explosion hazards and waste disposal including above ground storage of flammable, hazardous or poisonous gases, liquids, or materials. In addition, these uses may generate large amounts of vehicle traffic, may involve the use of large unenclosed production areas, or may require large, tall structures that are unsightly. Heavy industrial uses typically involve primary production processes in the area of paper products (pulp mills), food processing (slaughterhouse, meat packing plant), chemicals (manufacture of inorganic chemicals, resins, plastics, paints, fertilizers, explosives, ink), petroleum products (refineries, bulk storage), primary metals (blasting, smelting, rolling), machinery and equipment manufacturer (vehicle assembly, engines, construction equipment), leather (storing, curing, tanning), gravel based products (manufacture of bricks, concrete, abrasives), lumber products (saw mills), solid waste disposal facility, and waste transfer facility. INDUSTRY, LIGHT An establishment involved in the processing, fabrication, assembly, or compounding of products where the process involved is relatively clean and nuisance-free, usually completely enclosed, and without adverse environmental effects, that can generally be made compatible with surrounding areas through buffering and through separation required by yard and height limitations. Typically, these uses result in the creation of finished products for sale on a wholesale basis to retailers or directly on a retail basis, and include uses in the following areas: lumber products (millwork, cabinet-making) textiles, printing and publishing services, bottling works, carpet and rug cleaning, furniture manufacture, paper (final processing from purchased bulk stock), rubber and plastics (compounding processed resins, molding plastics), gravel based products (pottery, cutting, finishing granite, firing and decorating clay products), and ice manufacturing. INSTITUTIONAL PROPERTY Land used by a nonprofit, religious or educational organization, such as a place of worship, library, public or private school, hospital, or airport. Government owned or operated building, structure or land used for a public purpose shall not be considered institutional property. INTENSIVE VEGETATION CLEARING The complete removal of trees or shrubs in a contiguous patch, strip, row, or block. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 429 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions INTERIM USE A use approved by City Council for a specific period of time in anticipation of a different long- term use of the property being proposed or approved during that time. INTERNAL PARKING LOT LANDSCAPE AREAS Landscaped areas within a parking lot that are surrounded on at least three sides by paved areas that are used for parking and traffic circulation. INTERSECTION A place where two or more public or private streets cross at the same grade. JUNKYARD All or part of a lot, parcel or land, building, or structure used for the storage, processing, or abandonment of wastepaper, rags, scrap metal, or other scrap of discarded goods, materials, or machinery, or two or more unregistered, inoperable motor vehicles. LAND USE PLAN The Land Use Plan portion of the Comprehensive Plan for the Rochester Urban Service Area. LANDFILL A permanent facility either publicly or privately owned and operated for the purpose of disposing solid waste. LANDSCAPE AREA Land set apart for the plantings of grass, shrubs, trees or similar living plants, or other ground surface treatment such as decorative rock, bark, or stone. LANDSCAPE PLAN An integrated set of documents that may consist of both drawn and written materials describing bufferyards, landscaping, and screening to be installed on a lot or parcel. LANDSCAPED ISLAND (IN A RIGHT-OF-WAY) A grassed or landscaped area located within the limits of the roadway portion of a local street or access roadway, serving both traffic control and aesthetic purpose. LIMITED ACCESS ROADWAY A roadway, privately owned and maintained and established on an easement, providing joint right of access for up to four lots. LOADING AREA An off-street space or berth on the same lot with a building or contiguous to a group of buildings, for the temporary parking of a commercial vehicle while loading or unloading merchandise or materials, and that abuts or is connected by means of a driveway to a street or alley. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 430 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions LONG RANGE TRANSPORTATION PLAN The most recent version of the Long Range Transportation Plan for the City and the Townships of Cascade, Marion, Rochester, and Haverhill and a portion of High Forest. LOT The smallest unit of land division defined by plat or by metes and bounds description, that is not divided by a lot line, right-of-way, or other publicly owned land, and that does not include the right-of-way of any street upon which the lot abuts, even if ownership to such right-of-way lies with the owner of the lot. LOT AREA The area contained within the lot lines of a lot, excluding any right-of-way or private street. LOT, CORNER A lot abutting two or more streets at their intersection, or upon two parts of the same street forming an interior angle less than 135 degrees. LOT DEPTH The average horizontal distance between the front lot line and the rear lot line of a lot. LOT LINE A line of record bounding a lot that divides one lot from another lot or from a public or private street or any other public space. Where any portion of a lot extends onto a public right-of-way, the lot line shall be deemed to be the boundary of said right-of-way. LOT, THROUGH A lot that fronts upon two parallel or approximately parallel streets. LOT WIDTH A horizontal distance measured between the side lot lines. LOT LINE, FRONT A lot line separating a lot from the predominant public or private street or roadway right-of-way abutting the property, as determined by the City. LOT LINE, INTERIOR SIDE A side lot line that separates a lot from another lot. LOT LINE, REAR On a rectangular lot other than a corner lot, the lot line opposite and most distant from the front lot line; on a corner lot, an interior lot line that is designated at the time of development. Triangular shaped lots whose lot width narrows when moving away from the front lot line have no rear lot line. The rear lot line(s) on irregular shaped lots with more than four lot lines are Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 431 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions those interior lot lines that, when the endpoints of the line(s) are connected, create a line exceeding the width at the building line. LOT LINE, SIDE Any lot line other than a front or rear lot line. LOT LINE, SIDE STREET A side lot line separating a lot from a secondary public or private street or roadway right-of-way abutting the property, as determined by the City LOT OF RECORD Any validly recorded lot that, at the time of its recording, complied with all applicable laws, ordinances, and regulations. LOT SIZE The minimum size lot, in square feet, for certain types of residential development, measured on a horizontal plane. See also Site Area. LOW DENSITY (RESIDENTIAL) DISTRICTS The R-1, R-2, and R-2x zoning districts. LUMBER YARD An establishment engaged in the retail sale of building supplies and household equipment that is characterized by the presence of an outdoor storage area used for the keeping of building supplies such as lumber or masonry products. MANUFACTURED HOME A building, fabricated in an off-site facility for installation or assembly at the building site, transportable in one or more sections, that, in the traveling mode, is eight feet or more in width or 40 feet or more in length, or when erected is 320 or more square feet in size, and is built on a permanent chassis and designed to be used as a dwelling for one family, with or without permanent foundation, when connected to the required utilities, and includes the plumbing, heating, air conditioning, and electrical system contained in the building, and that is certified as constructed in compliance with the “manufactured home building code” as established under Minn. Stat. Ch. 327. MANUFACTURED HOME PARK A residential development on a site that consists of two or more spaces for the placement of manufactured homes for dwelling or sleeping purposes, regardless of whether or not a fee is charged for the use of such space. This development is typified by a land-lease arrangement between the residents of the manufactured homes in the community and a single ownership entity or common owner(s) in a cooperative arrangement as opposed to a development that consists of individually owned lots subdivided for the placement of manufactured homes. A Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 432 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions manufactured home park does not include real property used for the display and sale of manufactured homes, unless the manufactured homes for display or sale are permanently sited in conformance with the UDC as model homes in the park, nor does it include a Campground or Recreational Vehicle Park in which spaces are not intended for long-term occupancy. MANUFACTURED HOME PARK LOT A parcel of land in a manufactured home park used for the placement of a single manufactured home for the exclusive use of the residents of the manufactured home. The area of the lot for rezoning purposes shall not include any common or community open space or required perimeter bufferyard area. The area of the lot shall not include any land devoted to the development of streets (public or private) including the required boulevard and any land used for common sidewalk or walkway area located parallel and adjacent to a private street lying adjacent to the lot. MANUFACTURED HOME SUBDIVISION A development that consists of individually owned lots created for the placement of manufactured homes that complies with this jurisdiction's regulations for subdivision. All uses, buildings, and structures within the approved subdivision must obtain Zoning Certificate approval prior to their placement or construction. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 433 Support Campus Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions MEDICAL CAMPUS DISTRICT Medical Institutional Subdistrict Two defined areas of the City, known as Medical Institutional Subdistrict, and the Support Campus (shown in the maps below), the boundaries of which may be amended from time to time pursuant to applicable law. The Medical Institutional Subdistrict is subject to the following Ordinances: #2726, #3669, and #4052; while the Support Campus is subject to Ordinance #3534. Any construction or development that occurs within the boundaries of the Medical Institutional Subdistrict and/or Support Campus, and which is stated or referenced in the Mayo Clinic’s 5-year Plan Update, shall be subject to the respective ordinances governing the Medical Institutional Subdistrict and Support Campus (collectively, the “Mayo Special District Ordinances”), at the time the 5-year Plan Update is submitted, and no provisions of the UDC shall be construed to impose greater restrictions thereon. In the event the Mayo Special District Ordinances address a specific requirement, the Mayo Special District Ordinances requirements shall prevail. Conversely, should the Mayo Special District Ordinances be silent on a requirement, then the UDC requirements shall apply. MEDICAL FACILITY An establishment engaged in providing diagnostic services, extensive medical treatment (including surgical services) and other hospital services, as well as continuous nursing service, including general medical and surgical hospitals, specialty hospitals, medical laboratories, bio medical research and development, outpatient care facilities, medical schools and associated dormitories, medical appliance sales, and similar uses, but not including a Clinic or Veterinary and Animal Services. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 434 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions MEDICAL STAY DWELLING UNIT A dwelling unit that has been issued a lodging license from the state or from Olmstead County and in which accommodations are furnished exclusively to medical patients, their families, and caregivers while the patient is receiving or waiting to receive health care treatments or procedures for a period of one week or more, and where no supportive services, health supervision, or home care services are provided. MINIMUM PERCENTAGE OF USABLE RECREATION AREA The minimum amount of usable recreation space that shall be provided for certain types of residential development. MINIMUM WIDTH AT BUILDING LINE A numerical standard, in feet, for minimum lot width for certain types of development. This width shall be measured between non-intersecting lot lines. On lots with curvilinear front lot line, the width shall be measured as the length of the tangent to the front yard line. MIXED BUILDING TYPE DEVELOPMENT A development that complies with this jurisdiction's regulations for subdivisions, consisting of three or more individually owned lots for either the placement of manufactured homes, subject to the design criteria contained herein, or for the placement of other dwelling types consistent with the standards of the underlying zoning district. MOBILE HOME A non-HUD compliant structure built prior to June 15, 1976, on a permanent chassis, capable of being transported in one or more sections and designed to be used with or without a permanent foundation as a dwelling when connected to on-site utilities, but not including manufactured homes or recreational vehicles. Mobile homes are not permitted in the City. MODULATION (OF A BUILDING FAÇADE) A stepping back or projecting forward of portions of a building face within specified intervals of building width and depth, as a means of breaking up the apparent bulk of a structure’s continuous exterior walls. MONUMENT SIGN A ground-related, freestanding sign which is attached to the ground or to its base on grade by a solid sign structure and which structure extends from the ground or base to the sign face at the same or greater width as the sign face. MOTOR FREIGHT AND WAREHOUSING An establishment engaged primarily in either the storage or shipment of goods and materials, including terminal facilities for handling freight, and maintenance facilities in which the truck (including tractor trailer units) involved with the operation of the business are stored, parked, and serviced. Materials within a warehouse or terminal facility may be combined, broken down, Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 435 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions or aggregated for transshipment or storage purposes where the original material is not chemically or physically changed. Above ground storage of flammable, hazardous or poisonous gases, liquids, or materials is not included in this definition (see Heavy Industry). MOTOR VEHICLE SALES, LEASING OR STORAGE An establishment engaged in the display for sale or lease of automobiles, trucks, farm machinery, recreational vehicles, and manufactured homes, including vehicle dealerships or the commercial storage of privately owned trailers, boats, campers, or similar vehicle. MULTI-USE TRAIL A path physically separated from motor vehicle traffic, located either within a street right-of-way or a separate right-of-way or easement, and intended for use by some combination of bicyclists, pedestrians, equestrians, and other non-motor vehicle traffic. MUNTIN A bar or rigid supporting strip between adjacent panes of glass. NEIGHBORHOOD FOOD AND SERVICE An establishment containing not more than 2,000 square feet of gross floor area, and intended to serve the local neighborhood, whose primary business is the sale of food and/or non- alcoholic beverages including a standard restaurant, bakery, coffee house, ice cream parlor, deli, grocery, or similar use. NEIGHBORHOOD PARK A public recreation facility designed to give residents of one or more neighborhoods the opportunity for the enjoyment of open space, and that may also provide for the use of the residents’ playground equipment, picnic areas, and areas suitable for use as ball fields, tennis, and basketball courts, and skating rinks. Trail corridors providing access from residential areas to neighborhood park facilities may be considered part of the neighborhood park. NONCONFORMING APPEARANCE Any conforming use located on a lot that is zoned Non-Residential, abuts a lot in a residential district, in existence at the time this UDC was adopted, and that does not meet the appearance control standards of this UDC. NONCONFORMING LOT OF RECORD Any validly recorded lot existing at the time this UDC was adopted that does not comply with the minimum lot area or frontage requirements of the district where it is located. NONCONFORMING PARKING Any development that does not provide the number of off-street parking spaces that would be required by this UDC for a new development of the same type. The existence of parking spaces located outside of an approved driveway in the front or street side yard on a property in a Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 436 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions residential district that were not approved through a lot and site development approval procedure do not constitute legal, nonconforming parking. NONCONFORMING SIGN Any sign that would not be permitted in the zone where it is located by the regulations of this UDC. NONCONFORMING STRUCTURE A structure that does not comply with the height, setback, density, or floor area ratio requirements of the district where it is located including structures that do not comply with the flood proofing and elevation regulations of the floodplain overlay districts. NONCONFORMING USE An activity using land or structures that would not be permitted to be established as a new use in the zone where it is located by the regulations of this UDC. NURSERY Land or greenhouses used to raise flowers, shrubs and plants for later retail or wholesale sales. NURSING HOME An establishment primarily engaged in providing intermediate or long-term nursing and health related care to individuals. OCCUPANCY The residing of an individual overnight in a habitable unit, or the installation, storage or use of equipment, merchandise, or machinery in any institutional, commercial, or industrial building. OFFENDER TRANSITIONAL HOUSING A dwelling unit or one or more habitable units in a house or hotel designed, intended, or used principally to provide short-term housing to offenders on supervised release or conditional release who are receiving housing assistance from the Minnesota Department of Corrections or Olmsted County Community Corrections and/or who are required to live in the housing as a condition of their release. “Offender Transitional Housing” does not include housing declared by state law to be a permitted single-family residential use. The term “short-term” shall mean a period of time not exceeding one year. A dwelling or lodging facility owned by the offender or a member of the offender’s immediate family shall not be considered Offender Transitional Housing. OFFICE A room or group of rooms used for managing the affairs of an establishment or for the non- retail, non-production conduct of affairs of a service, professional institutional, or business nature including medical offices or clinics, studios for those involved in art, sculpture, and music including organizations operating on a membership basis for the promotion of the interests of Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 437 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions the membership, including trade associations, business associations, professional membership organizations, labor unions, or civic or fraternal organizations, but not including place of worship, hospitals, golf and country clubs, or credit unions. ON-SITE OR OFF-SITE PUBLIC OR PRIVATE FACILITY IMPROVEMENT The sizing, grading, location or improvement of lots, structures, areas accessible to the general public, streets, roads, trails, walkways, curbs and gutters, water, sewers, storm drainage, lighting, sewers, electricity, gas and other utilities, and the protection and conservation of floodplains, shore lands, soils, water, vegetation, energy, air quality, and geologic and ecologic features, and similar on-site or off-site public or private utilities and improvements that are reasonably related to the proposed subdivision and that are needed so that the facilities can adequately handle the needs created by the proposed subdivision. The term includes “required improvements,” “on-site and off-site public improvements,” “development improvements,” “off- site improvements” and “public improvements.” OPEN SPACE An area identified by easement or other mechanism that guarantees that the area will not be intentionally disturbed and that provides, at a minimum, for access by a public agency or a qualified land trust for purposes of monitoring the condition and maintaining the site. OPERATIONS PLAN (FOR EXCAVATION ACTIVITIES) A plan, including a Site Development Plan and Report, required to be submitted by applicants for Conditional Use Permit approval of excavation activities that describes the area to be disturbed, required bufferyards and additional information necessary to ensure the excavation activity is safe on the site and is compatible with surrounding development and land uses. ORDINARY HIGH WATER LEVEL For purposes of floodplain and shoreland regulations, the boundary of public waters and wetlands and shall be an elevation delineating the highest water level that has been maintained for a sufficient period of time to leave evidence upon the landscape, commonly that point where the natural vegetation changes from predominantly aquatic to predominantly terrestrial. For watercourses, the ordinary high water level is the elevation of the top of the bank of the channel. For reservoirs and flowages, the ordinary high water level is the operating elevation of the normal summer pool. OUTDOOR EATING AREA Any group of tables, chairs, or other seating fixtures and appurtenances intended for the outdoor consumption of food or beverage by patrons, employees, or tenants, when located adjacent to an establishment having the same operator. OUTDOOR ENTERTAINMENT OR RECREATION A commercial recreation facility that is primarily an open-air facility, such as baseball fields, swimming pools, skating rinks, golf driving ranges, miniature golf facilities, drive-in theaters, Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 438 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions amphitheaters, outdoor concert halls, racetracks, ranges (skeet, rifle, or archery), bowling alleys, and amusement parks. OUTDOOR STORAGE The keeping, in an unroofed area or structure open to view on its sides, of any goods, junk, material or merchandise in the same place for more than 24 hours and including adjacent land area improved and necessary to provide access to such goods. PARAPET An extension of the main walls of a building above the roof line. PARK Public parks operated by the City or by the City’s Board of Park Commissioners, including all park buildings, trails, parkways, and related facilities. A Community Center use within a public park is considered part of a Park. PARK SYSTEM PLAN The system-wide comprehensive plan adopted by the Rochester Park and Recreation Board for the acquisition, development, or redevelopment of parks, playgrounds, recreational facilities, wetlands, trails, or open space areas. PARKING BAY A portion of a site improved for the off-street parking of vehicles, where individual parking spaces are accessed directly from the street. Parking space shall not be from within the right-of- way. PARKING LOT A surface area whose purpose is to provide accessory or primary use parking spaces for motor vehicles, this category also includes community lots that are established to meet the parking needs in a residential area. PARKING GARAGE An above ground and/or belowground structure, or a part of a primary structure, designed for parking automobiles and light trucks and van, in which at least one level of parking is located above or below another level of parking in the same structure. This use does not include parking and storage facilities for recreational vehicles, boats, and trucks seven feet in height or greater. PARKING STRUCTURE Any aboveground or belowground structure, either freestanding or constructed as part of a building with a non-parking primary use, whose purpose is to provide accessory or primary use parking spaces for motor vehicles. In the MX-T district a permitted Parking Lot or Garage associated with a City designated park and ride may provide automobile maintenance services, such as oil changes and car washes, as an accessory use. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 439 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions PASTURE An area where grass or other growing plants are used for grazing and where the concentration of animals is such that a vegetative cover is maintained during the growing season, except in the immediate vicinity of temporary supplemental feeding or watering devices. PAVEMENT A hard, smooth surface of a parking lot, driveway or drive aisle that is made from concrete, asphalt or a paving brick, or similar durable permanent permeable pavement. PEDESTRIAN A person moving about by foot or using a wheelchair or other mobility aid other than a motor vehicle. PEDESTRIAN-ORIENTED SPACE An area located outside of the right-of-way between a building and a street or along a pedestrian facility that promotes visual and pedestrian access onto the site and provides pedestrian-oriented amenities and landscaping to enhance the patron’s or public’s use of the space for passive activities such as resting, reading, and/or picnicking. PERIMETER The boundaries or borders of a lot, tract, or parcel of land, or the total combined length of all those boundaries or borders PHASE I SURVEY Sometimes called a “recognizance level survey”, the process used to identify historic properties to be placed on an inventory, pursuant to Section 60.200.040C4. Typical methods include archival research, informant interviews, field survey and professional analysis along with identification of the criteria from Section 60.200.040C5 for which the property is under consideration, documented in a standard format. PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICE A system of components that generates electricity from incident sunlight by means of the photovoltaic effect, whether or not the device is able to store the energy produced for later use. PILASTER A rectangular, non-bearing column attached to a building façade as an ornamental design feature PLAT, FINAL The final map on which an applicant's plan for the division of land for purposes of development is presented to the City for approval and that, if approved, will be submitted to the County Recorder. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 440 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions PLAT, PRELIMINARY Also known as a Major Land Subdivision. A draft map on which an applicant’s plan for the division of land for purposes of development is presented to the City for review and comment regarding compliance with this UDC and other standards and regulations adopted by the City, prior to submittal of a Final Plat for approval. PLACE OF WORSHIP A building or structure, or groups of buildings or structures, that by design and construction are primarily intended for the conducting of organized religious services and associated accessory uses. PLANNED UNIT DEVELOPMENT Unique and separate zoning districts established by action of the Rochester Common Council on specific parcels of land according to the provision of the previous Rochester Zoning Code Ordinance No. 1659 as amended, which is no longer in effect. PLAYGROUND All play areas designed primarily for children including, but not limited to, an outdoor area set aside for recreation and play containing playground equipment, such as climbing toys, seesaws, and swings. PROPERTY OWNER The fee owner of land, or the beneficial owner of land whose interest is primarily one of possession and enjoyment in contemplation of ultimate ownership. The term includes but is not limited to venders under a contract for deed. PROTECTED LOT See Section 60.400.020F.2.a, Protected Lots for the definition of Protected Lot. PUBLIC PARKING LOT A public or private land area designed for the off-street parking of motor vehicles that is not associated with any primary use or building on the same lot. Public parking lots typically charge a fee (hourly, weekly, monthly) or other consideration for the time a vehicle is parked on the lot. PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION DISPATCH FACILITY An establishment primarily engaged in furnishing local and suburban passenger transportation, including taxi cabs, passenger charter services, school buses, and terminals (including service facilities) for motor vehicle passenger transportation. PUBLIC UTILITY Any corporation or government entity supplying natural gas, electric, transportation, water, sewer, or communication service to the general public. For the purposes of this UDC, wireless telecommunication utilities shall not be considered a Public Utility and are defined separately. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 441 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions PUBLIC WATERS Those waters defined by Minn. Stat. Ch. 103G.005.Subd.15.15a QUARRY A land disturbance or development activity that meets or exceeds any of the following thresholds and exceeds practices allowed through a Grading Permit: 1. Activities principally designed to mine, extract, or remove bedrock materials for commercial purposes; 2. An exposed bedrock slope steeper than 3:1 that is over 25 feet in height occurring at any time during or following excavation; 3. The temporary or permanent exposure of rock face made as part of or following excavation in excess of 25 feet in height. The measurement of height of the exposed rock face shall be the vertical measurement from the lowest elevation of the excavation to the top of the exposed face. Multiple faces shall be added together to determine height; 4. Removal from a site of more than 20,000 cubic yards of earth material per acre of land being excavated or 100,000 cubic yards of earth for the entire site; 5. Activities that deposit soil, bedrock, or other earthen material on site; 6. An excavation activity using a crusher; or 7. A Substantial Land Alteration meeting any of the above characteristics. RAILROAD TRANSPORTATION Establishments engaged in domestic freight and passenger transportation by rail including railroad yards, freight stations and switching yards. REACH A hydraulic engineering term to describe a longitudinal segment of a stream or river influenced by a natural or man-made obstruction. In an urban area, the segment of a stream or river between two consecutive bridge crossings is typically constitute a reach. RECLAMATION PLAN A plan, including a Final Site Development Plan and Report, required to be submitted by applicants for Conditional Use Permit approval of excavation activities that describes how the site will be reclaimed for subsequent use after conclusion of the excavation activity. RECREATIONAL EQUIPMENT Craft designed for use on water or snow, as well as motorized vehicles designed for use on surfaces other than public roadways, and including trailers used to transport such craft or vehicles. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 442 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions RECREATIONAL VEHICLE A temporary structure, less than 40 feet in length, that can be towed, hauled, or driven and is primarily designed as temporary housing accommodations for recreational, camping or travel use including but not limited to travel trailers, truck campers, camping trailers and self-propelled motor homes. RECREATIONAL VEHICLE PARKING Storage of recreational vehicles at a residence as an accessory to the primary use of the property. RECYCLING DROP BOX A small collection facility typically treated as an accessory to another primary use where recyclable materials are accepted from the public. RECYCLING TRANSFER FACILITY A primary use of a lot or parcel of land for the separation and temporary storage of recycled or used materials before they are sent to a processing facility. Recycling Transfer Facility includes the operation of and expansion of any waste-to-energy facility in existence on the effective date of this UDC and the establishment of new facilities in support of waste-to-energy operations after the effective date of this UDC. REFERENCE LINE The reference line of any public or private street is whichever of the following two lines that is closer to the existing right-of- way line: 1) a line within the right-of-way that is parallel to and five feet inside of the right-of- way line; or 2) the line created by the existing curb location parallel to the right-of way line. REGISTERED LAND SURVEY (RLS) The drawing or map of a subdivision prepared for filing of record pursuant to Minn. Stat. Ch. 508. Registered Land Survey must go through appropriate application process to become Registered Land or Torrens property. REGULATED LOT See Section 60.400.020F.2.b, Regulated Lots for the definition of Regulated Lot. RELATED SERVICE FACILITY A type of accessory use designed primarily to serve the occupants or patrons of another primary use in the same building or development including but not limited to snack bars, restaurants, cafeterias, and other eating establishments; barbershops, beauty shops, gift shops, newsstands, office supply sales, duplicating services, and similar retail stores and services; swimming pools, tennis courts, playgrounds, playfields, meeting rooms, exercise rooms, saunas, gymnasiums, and similar recreational facilities; dispensaries and similar health care facilities; and self-service laundry and dry cleaning drop off facilities, but not including adult Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 443 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions entertainment or any use that is already listed as permitted or conditional use in the same zone district. The Related Service facility shall be accessory to a primary use that provides living facilities, employment, or overnight accommodations for a significant number of persons, such as a multifamily dwelling, office or institutional building, manufacturing plant or research facility, or hotel. REPAIR AND MAINTENANCE SHOP An establishment engaged in miscellaneous repair services, primarily of products generally weighing more than 25 pounds such as televisions, washers and dryers, furniture (including re- upholstery), small engines, or other equipment, and not meeting the definition of a Business or Professional Service, Automotive Center, or Automotive Repair Services, Major. RESEARCH AND TESTING An establishment or other facility for carrying on investigation in the natural or physical sciences, or engineering and development as an extension of investigation with the objective of creating end products, on a contract or fee basis, and including pilot plant operation. RESIDENCE FOR CARETAKER OR SECURITY GUARD One accessory dwelling unit or manufactured home for a caretaker, owner, operator, manager, or Security Guard and their related family that is located on the premises of another primary use for the occupancy of a caretaker, security guard, or other person charged with oversight or protection of the primary use. RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILITY A public or private establishment licensed by the state of Minnesota, that for gain or otherwise, regularly provides one or more children, or one or more adults meeting the definition of “adult” in Minn. Stat §245A.02, Subd. 2 with 24 hour care, food, lodging, training, education, supervision, rehabilitation, or treatment, and including all facilities providing lodging to persons whose right to live together as a household is protected by the Federal Fair Housing Act or the Federal Fair Housing Amendments Act as amended and interpreted by the courts. RESIDENTIAL FLOOR A story within a building in which over 50 percent of the floor area is devoted to dwelling units. RESIDENTIAL MANAGEMENT OR SALES OFFICE A facility in a residential development that serves as a headquarters for sales and management of dwelling units within the development. RETAIL ESTABLISHMENT An establishment engaged in selling goods or merchandise to the general public for personal or household consumption and rendering services incidental to the sale of such goods, including furniture and appliance sales and business centers. These establishments are characterized by the following: 1) They buy and receive as well as sell merchandise; 2) They may process some Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 444 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions products, but such processing is incidental or subordinate to the selling activities; and 3) They predominantly sell to customers for their own personal or household use. RETAIL, NEIGHBORHOOD A retail establishment that is under 3,000 square feet gross floor area. RETAIL, SMALL A retail establishment that is under 10,000 square feet gross floor area. RETAIL, MEDIUM A retail establishment that is under 25,000 square feet gross floor area. RETAIL, LARGE A retail establishment that is over 25,000 square feet gross floor area. RIGHT OF ACCESS The legal authority providing for the right of ingress to or egress from a public street. RIGHT-OF-WAY A strip of land acquired by dedication, reservation, prescription, or condemnation occupied or intended to be occupied by a road, crosswalk, utility line, railroad, electric transmission line, streetscape improvements, street furniture, or other similar use. RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE The lines that form the boundaries of a right-of-way. ROAD AUTHORITY The unit of government having control of the right of access to a right-of-way. ROADWAY That portion of a street, common area or easement area improved for use by motor vehicles, including travel lanes and parking lanes, but not including driveways. SAND OR GRAVEL EXCAVATION An excavation or unconsolidated sediments including gravel, sand, or peat that meets or exceeds any of the following thresholds and exceeds practices allowed through a Grading Permit: 1. Activities principally designed to mine, extract, or remove unconsolidated sediments for commercial purposes; 2. Removal from the site of more than 20,000 cubic yards of unconsolidated sediments per acre of land being excavated or more than 100,000 cubic yards from a single site; or 3. A substantial land alteration (see definition in this Chapter) designed to occur for more than 48 months. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 445 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions SCHOOL A public school as defined in Minn. Stat. Ch. 120.05, or a nonpublic school as defined in Minn. Stat. Ch. 123.932. SEASONAL SALES A building or structure used for the retail sales of Christmas trees, holiday décor and seasonal gifts, fresh fruits, vegetables, flowers, herbs, or plants. Such use may also involve the accessory sales of other unprocessed foodstuffs, home processed food products such as jams, jellies, pickles, sauces or baked goods, and homemade handicrafts. No commercially packaged handicrafts or commercially processed or packaged foodstuffs shall be sold. Such uses also include “pick your own” establishments where customers gather their own produce from the fields for purchase and off-site consumption. SEDIMENTATION Sedimentation shall mean the settling out of soil particles that have been transported by water or wind. (Sedimentation occurs when the velocity of water or wind in which soil particles are suspended is slowed to a sufficient degree and for a sufficient period of time to allow the particles to settle out of suspension or when the degree of slope is lessened to achieve the same result). SELF SERVICE STORAGE FACILITY An establishment designed and used for the purpose of renting or leasing individual storage spaces to tenants who have sole private access to such space for storing personal property. SEMIPUBLIC USE The use of land by a private, nonprofit organization to provide a public service that is ordinarily open to some persons outside the regular constituency of the organization. SENSITIVE LANDS Land that features significant and/or fragile environmental qualities like wetlands, threatened or endangered species, wildlife habitat, unstable or potentially unstable slopes, expansive soils, stands of mature trees, other significant natural features, as well as properties that are subject to periodic inundation, subsidence of the earth’s surface, high water table, or have difficult topography, unstable soils, wetlands, or other natural or human-created hazards to life or property, as determined by the City Engineer. SENSITIVE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT The preservation and management of areas unsuitable for development in their natural state due to constraints such as shallow soils over groundwater or bedrock, highly erosive or expansive soils, steep slopes, susceptibility to flooding, or occurrence of flora or fauna in need of special protection. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 446 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions SETBACK The separation in linear feet, measured on a horizontal plane, required between the wall of a building and each of its lot lines at a given height. SETBACK PLANE A theoretical plane extending over the lot and inclined upward from the horizontal by a designated number of degrees and intersecting with the ground at the lot line. SHELTER, STORM A structure or portion of a structure intended to provide protection to human life during periods of danger to human life from nuclear fallout, blasts, air raids, storms, or other emergencies. SHOOTING RANGE OR GUN RANGE An area or facility designated or operated primarily for the use of firearms. SHORELAND-RELATED DEFINITIONS BLUFF IMPACT ZONE A bluff and land located within 20 feet from the top of a bluff. SHORELAND IMPACT ZONE Land located between the ordinary high water level of a public water and a line parallel to it at a setback of 50 percent of the building setback. SHORELAND Land located within 300 feet from a river or stream, or the landward extent of a floodplain designated by ordinance on a river or stream, whichever is greater. SHRUBS Typically are multi-stemmed woody plants that at maturity are normally less than 15 feet in height. Shrubs are typically low growing plants that can be used for creating hedges, screening, and for windbreaks. SIDEWALK A hard-surface or raise pathway located within or outside the street right-of-way that is designated for the exclusive use of pedestrian traffic. SIGN-RELATED DEFINITIONS When used in the context of regulating signs, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. BACK LIGHTING The sign message is raised off of the sign's background and illuminated by a light source located behind the message that illuminates the background. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 447 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions BANNER A strip of cloth-like, vinyl, lightweight or other woven material on which a sign appears. BILLBOARD A sign that directs attention to any person, product, event, service, or other matter that is not related to or on the premises where the sign is located. SIGN, BUSINESS CENTER An identification sign for a commercial site with multiple tenants, displaying the names of each tenant on the site. CANOPY, SERVICE A roof-like structure attached to or detached from the principal building that provides only overhead protection to outside customer service areas. CANOPY, SUN An awning made of cloth or permanent construction, attached to the wall of a building, for the purpose of shielding windows or doorways from the elements. ELECTRONIC MESSAGE BOARD A sign or component of a sign that uses changing lights to form a message or series of messages that are electronically programmed or modified by electronic processes. MARQUEE A structure attached to and projecting from a wall of a building, located above an entrance. MURAL A painting or similar work of art on the side, ground, or ceiling of a building, wall, or structure. INTERNAL LIGHTING The sign is illuminated by a light source located inside of the sign structure including neon lighting, illuminated channel letters, and lightboxes. SIGN Any object, device, display, structure, or part thereof, situated outdoors or indoors, that is displayed to attract the attention of the public while on public streets, highways, or walkways by any means, including words, letters figures, designs, symbols, fixtures, colors, illumination, or projected images. Signs do not include merchandise or other objects visible in a window display, and do not include signs located more than 18 inches inside the outer walls of a building and not intended to be viewed by persons outside the building. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 448 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions SIGN, FREESTANDING A self-supporting sign resting on or supported by means of poles, standards of any other type of base anchored to the ground. SIGN, NOVELTY A portable sign with a structure designed, in whole, to resemble an animal or other character figure and that includes a changeable message sign, either as an integral part of the structure or attached to the structure in some manner, and usually transported on a trailer. SIGN, PORTABLE Any sign not permanently attached to the ground or other permanent structure, or a sign designed to be transported, including but not limited to: signs designed to be transported by means of wheels; signs converted to A- or T-frames; menu and sandwich board signs; balloons used as signs; movable flags (excluding banners); umbrellas; and signs attached to or painted on vehicles parked and visible from the public right-of-way, unless the vehicle is used for normal day-today operations of the occupant of the lot or property. SIGN, PROJECTING A sign, other than a wall sign, that attaches to and projects from a structure or building façade. SIGN, ROOF A sign mounted on the roof of a building or that depends upon a parapet wall for support. SIGN, STACKED MULTIPLE DISPLAY FACES A sign structure containing signs that are placed in a vertical or horizontal row and that contain more than one sign designed to provide information to the public. SIGN, WALL A sign mounted parallel to or an integral part of a building façade or other vertical building surface. Signs in shop windows are included. SIGN CREDIT A benefit granting the holder of the credit the right to erect a new billboard that conforms with all applicable laws upon the furnishing of proof to the Community Development Director that an existing legal nonconforming billboard and its supporting structure have been removed. SPOT LIGHTING The sign is illuminated by spotlights directed specifically at the sign area. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 449 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions SITE Any lot or parcel or combination of lots or parcels assembled for the purpose of development. SITE AREA The minimum size of parcel or tract, in square feet, on which the development of a particular use may occur, measured on a horizontal plane. See also Lot Size. SITE DEVELOPMENT PLAN An integral set of documents that may consist of both drawn and written materials whose purpose is to provide the necessary information needed for an approving authority to decide whether the proposed development will comply with the UDC standards. SLOPE An incline from the horizontal expressed in an arithmetic ratio of horizontal magnitude to vertical magnitude. 3:1 slope = 3:1 = 3 feet horizontal to 1 foot vertical SOCIAL SERVICES An establishment that provides social or welfare services to those in need, for no fee or compensation, or at a fee recognized as being significantly less than charged by profit-making organizations. Services may include but are not limited to information and referral services; counselling; skill development; aid through the provision of food, clothing, daytime or overnight sheltering; life skill and personal development programs; alcohol, drug, or substance abuse counselling centers; and drop-in or activity space. SOIL EROSION The removal and/or loss of soil by the action or water, ice, gravity, or wind, including both the detachment and transport of soil particles. SOLAR COLLECTOR, GROUND- OR BUILDING-MOUNTED A photovoltaic (PV) panel, array of panels or other solar energy device, the primary purpose of which is to provide for the collection, inversion, storage, and distribution of solar energy for electricity generation, space heating, space cooling, or water heating. Ground-Mounted Solar Collector may be a principal or accessory use. Building-Mounted Solar Collector is an accessory use. Building-Mounted Solar Collector includes agrivoltaic systems and parking canopy solar systems. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 450 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions SPECIALIZED EDUCATION An establishment engaged in furnishing specialized academic or technical courses, normally on a fee basis, including but not limited to vocational or distance-learning schools; cosmetology schools; computer, networking, and technology schools; and paralegal or medical assistant programs; along with non-degree granting schools, establishments providing art or physical education instruction, or any other instructional establishment that does not meet the definition of a College or University or School. SPECIFIED ANATOMICAL AREAS Anatomical areas consisting of: 1. Less than completely and opaquely covered human genitals, pubic region, buttock, anus, or female breast(s) below a point immediately above the top of the areola; and 2. Human male genitals in a discernibly turgid state, even if completely and opaquely covered. SPECIFIED SEXUAL ACTIVITIES Activities consisting of the following: 1. Actual or simulated sexual intercourse, oral copulation, anal intercourse, oral anal copulation, bestiality, direct physical stimulation of unclothed genitals, flagellation, or torture in the context of a sexual relationship, or the use of excretory functions in the context of a sexual relationship, and any of the following sexually oriented acts or conduct: anilingus, anal sex, coprophagy, coprophilia, cunnilingus, fellatio, necrophilia, pederasty, pedophilia, piquerism, zooerasty; or 2. Clearly depicted human genitals in the state of sexual stimulation, arousal, or tumescence; or 3. Use of human or animal ejaculation, sodomy, oral copulation, coitus, or masturbation; or 4. Fondling or touching of nude human genitals, pubic region, buttocks, or female breasts; or 5. Situations involving a person or persons, any of whom are nude, clad in undergarments or in sexually revealing costumes, and who are engaged in activities involving the flagellation, torture, fettering, binding or other physical restraint of any such persons; or 6. Erotic or lewd touching, fondling, or other sexually oriented contact with an animal by a human being; or 7. Human excretion, urination, menstruation, vaginal or anal irrigation. STAFF The Community Development Director and all employees of the Community Development Department of the City under the supervision of and subject to the authority of the Community Development Director. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 451 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions STANDARD RESTAURANT An establishment whose primary business is the sale of food and/or beverage to customers in a ready to consume state, and whose principal method of operation includes two or more of the following characteristics: 1. Customers may be seated by a restaurant employee and place their order to the restaurant employee from menus at the table; and/or 2. Customers, are served their food and beverage by restaurant employees at the same table or counter where the food and/or beverage are consumed; and/or 3. A cafeteria type operation where food and beverage generally are consumed within the restaurant building. 4. Food is served on ceramic, porcelain, glass or similar table ware. STEEP SLOPE Lands having average slopes over 12 percent over horizontal distances of 50 feet or more that are not bluffs. STREET NAMING RELATED DEFINITIONS When used in the context of designating public or private roadways, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. AVENUE A roadway aligned in a north and south direction, conforming to the appropriate address grid line, and generally designated by a number. BOULEVARD A roadway divided by a landscaped center island and generally designated by a name. CIRCLE A roadway containing a closed loop that is not interrupted by a through roadway and generally designated by a name. COURT A roadway having a horseshoe shape and whose terminus point begins and ends at the same roadway and generally designated by one name throughout its entire length. DRIVE A curvilinear roadway of more than 1,000 feet in length and generally designated by a name. LANE A roadway ending in a cul-de-sac that is not interrupted by a through roadway and generally designated by a name. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 452 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions PARKWAY A special scenic route or park drive generally designated by a name. PLACE A short curvilinear or diagonal roadway less than 1,000 feet in length generally designated by a name. PRIVATE ROADWAY A roadway constructed on private land and not maintained by a city, township, or Olmsted County. ROAD A diagonal or curvilinear roadway more than 1,000 feet in length and generally designated by a name. STREET A roadway aligned in an east-west direction, conforming to the appropriate address grid line, and generally designated by a number. STORAGE CONTAINER A fully enclosed structure made of metal or other construction materials, that is not part of a primary building and is intended to be used for storage purposes. Storage containers are individual units that are periodically removed from a property by truck and are considered a structure without any attached foundation or footings. A storage container may be a self- contained unit that includes wheels and is licensed as a vehicle or a unit that must be trucked to a site and removed from the trailer used for transport. This definition excludes warming sheds at city parks and schools, prefabricated sheds typically used for household, garden, or hobby storage, dumpsters, or roll off containers that are used for the collection of solid waste. Storage containers are also referred to as cargo containers, temporary storage containers, portable storage containers, containerized storage devices, semi-trailers, or truck-trailers. STORMWATER MANAGEMENT PLAN An engineering analysis that describes the effect of development on an existing landscape and the mitigation necessary to meet applicable ordinances, regulations, and standards related to water quality, conveyance, and flooding. The stormwater management plan also presents the engineering process and calculations performed to design a development in compliance with applicable regulations and standards. STORY (OF A BUILDING) That portion of a building included between the upper surface of any floor and the upper surface of the floor next above, except that the topmost story shall be that portion of a building included between the upper surface of the topmost floor and the ceiling or roof above. If the finished floor level directly above a usable or unused under floor space is more than six feet above grade for Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 453 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions more than 50 of the total perimeter or is more than 12 feet above grade at any point, such usable or unused under floor space shall be considered as a story. STORY, FIRST (OF A BUILDING) The lowest story in a building that qualifies as a story, as defined herein, except that a floor level in a building having only one floor level shall be classified as a first story, provided such floor level is not more than four feet below grade for more than 50 percent of the total perimeter, or not more than 8 feet below grade at any point. STREET A strip of land used or intended to be used for the passage or travel of motor vehicles, non- motorized vehicles, and pedestrians, including roadway, boulevard, medians, islands, paths, sidewalks, and related facilities. STREET, PRIVATE A street owned and maintained by one or more private property owners. STREET, PUBLIC A street established on a right-of-way that has been dedicated for public use. STRUCTURAL ALTERATION (OF A BUILDING) Any change in the supporting members of a building, such as the bearing walls, beams or girders, or any change in the dimension or configuration of the roof or exterior walls. STRUCTURE A combination of materials to form construction for use, occupancy, or ornamentation, whether installed on, above or below the surface of land or water. STRUCTURE, TEMPORARY A building or structure without foundation or footings that is designed to be transportable and that is not designed for attachment to the ground, to another structure, or to any utility system on the same premises for an undetermined length of time. SUBDIVISION The separation of an area, parcel, or tract of land into two or more parcels, tracts, lots, or into long term leasehold interests where the creation of the leasehold interests necessitates the creation of streets, roads, or alleys, for residential, commercial, industrial or any other use or any combination thereof, except for those subdivisions exempted by Minn. Stat. Ch. 462.352 (sub. 12). SUBDIVIONS, SIMPLE VERTICAL A subdivision where the platted area is vertically separated by simple planes across the entire extent of the lot. The vertical subdivision is intended to allow each vertical component Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 454 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions of the lot to be located within a separate legal parcel, and not to subdivide individual tenant spaces and/or residential units. SUBDIVISION, COMPLEX VERTICAL A subdivision where the platted area is separated by anything other than simple planes across the entire breadth of the lot. SUBSTANTIAL LAND ALTERATION A development activity that meets or exceeds any of the following thresholds and exceeds practices allowed through a Grading Permit: 1. Grading activities designed to occur for more than 24 months and less than 48 months; 2. The removal from a site of more than 10,000 gross cubic yards of earth material per acre and less than 20,000 gross cubic yards of earth material per acre; 3. An exposed bedrock slope steeper than 3:1 that is over ten feet and less than 25 feet in height occurring at any time during or following excavation; 4. A movement of 500 cubic yards or more of earth that involves a change in natural or pre- existing grades of ten or more vertical feet for any portion of a parcel; or 5. Any movement of earth on the entire parcel in excess of 100,000 cubic yards. SWIMMING POOL A private recreational pool, pond, lake, or open tank not located within a completely enclosed building and capable of containing water to a depth at any point greater than 24 inches. SWIMMING POOL, ABOVE GROUND A swimming pool whose exposed sides have a height of four feet or greater above the natural ground located adjacent to said swimming pool. SWIMMING POOL, IN-GROUND A swimming pool whose sides are not exposed and are below the natural ground located adjacent to said swimming pool. SWIMMING POOL, SURFACE A swimming pool whose exposed sides have a height of more than 24 inches, but less than four feet above the natural ground located adjacent to said swimming pool. TATTOO OR PIERCING PARLOR An establishment whose primary business activity is the practice of one or more of the following: 1. The placement of designs, letters, figures, symbols, or other marks upon or under the skin of any person, using ink or other substances that result in the permanent coloration of the skin; Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 455 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions 2. Creation of an opening in the body of a person for the purpose of inserting jewelry or other decoration. TELECOMMUNICATIONS-RELATED DEFINITIONS When used in the context of regulating telecommunications, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. COMMERCIAL WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS SERVICE (CWTS) A facility that transmits and/or receives signals or waves radiated or captured by a wireless telecommunications antenna. It may include: antennas of all kinds including microwave dishes, horns, and other types of equipment for the transmission or reception of such signals, telecommunications tower or similar structures supporting said equipment, equipment buildings or cabinets, parking area, and/or other accessory development in order to provide telecommunication services including cellular, personal communication services (PCS), specialized mobilized radio (SMR), enhanced specialized mobilized radio (ESMR), paging and similar services that are marketed to the general public. Non-commercial or broadcasting antennas are not considered to be wireless telecommunications utilities. CWTS, CO-LOCATED ON EXISTING STRUCTURE A CWTS located on the same structure as other CWTS, including a public utility structure, for mounting wireless telecommunications antennas by more than one provider of wireless telecommunications services. CWTS, FREESTANDING A CWTS that consists of a standalone support structure, antennas, and associated equipment. The support structure may be a wooden pole, steel monopole, lattice tower, or similar structure. CWTS, STEALTH ON EXISTING STRUCTURE A CWTS that is aesthetically integrated or otherwise consistent with surrounding existing buildings, structures, and landscaping, including height, color, style, massing, placement, design, and shape, and that does not visually stand out as a CWTS. EQUIPMENT STRUCTURE OR CABINET A cabinet, structure or building that houses telecommunications and related electrical equipment used by wireless telecommunications services. FALL ZONE A graphically represented, geographically identified boundary that encompasses the predicted area of land identified by a registered engineer that will completely contain all the pieces of a collapsed monopole tower as a result of a structural failure. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 456 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions SMALL-CELL CWTS A CWTS that is designed to act as a booster site that provides increased localized network capacity. A small-cell CWTS has three or fewer antennas, no greater than four feet long each, and does not exceed 35 feet in height for a freestanding small-cell CWTS, and includes associated equipment cabinet(s). TOWER Any ground or roof mounted pole, spire, structure, or combination thereof taller than 15 feet, including supporting lines, cables, wires, braces, and masts, intended primarily for the purpose of mounting an antenna, meteorological device, wind energy conversion system, or similar apparatus above grade. TOWER-GUYED A tower that is supported, in whole or in part, by guy wires and ground anchors used to mount an antenna. TOWER-LATTICE A guyed or self-supporting three or four sided, open, steel frame tower used to mount an antenna. TOWER-MONOPOLE A tower consisting of a single, enclosed pole, constructed without guy wires and ground anchors used to mount an antenna. WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS ANTENNA A component of a CWTS. Any exterior transmitting or receiving device that may be mounted on a tower, building, or structure and used in communications that radiates or captures electromagnetic waves, digital signals, analog signals, radio frequencies (excluding radar signals), or other commercial signals. It includes, but is not limited to, directional antennas (such as panels, microwave dishes, and satellite dishes) and omni- directional antennas (such as whips), but not including a communications tower. WIRELESS TELECOMMUNICATIONS TOWER A component of a CWTS. A structure intended to support wireless telecommunications antennas. Examples of such structures include, but are not limited to, freestanding poles (such as monopoles, masts, poles, or guyed towers) and lattice construction steel towers. TEMPORARY HOUSING Any tent, recreational vehicle or other temporary structure used for human shelter that is designed to be transportable and that is not attached to the ground, to another structure, or to any utility system on the same premises for the purpose of occupancy for more than 30 consecutive days. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 457 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions TEMPORARY PERMIT A permit that allows property to be used in a manner that does not conform to the regulations of the applicable zoning district established for a fixed period of time with intent to discontinue such use upon the expiration of such time. A temporary permit shall not involve the construction or alteration of any permanent building or structure. TENANT For the purposes of public notice, any leaseholder, resident, or occupant at an address who is not the owner of that property. TENNIS COURT An indoor or outdoor facility designed with courts specifically for the recreational use of tennis, squash, handball, and/or other similar court games. TRAFFIC ENGINEER The traffic engineer for the applicable Road Authority of a public street. TRANSPARENCY The ability to see through with clarity. An opening in the building wall allowing light and views between interior and exterior. Measured as glass area for buildings, glass or screen area for porches and as open area for parking structures. TRANSPORTATION SERVICES An establishment furnishing services related to the arrangement of persons and goods movements, such as freight forwarding, parking services, or the rental/leasing of automobiles or two axle trucks. TURNOUT An area at the end of a dead-end parking lot designed to allow for the backing of vehicles at the end of the parking lot. UNDERSTORY PLANTING OR TREE Plantings or trees that consist of single or multi-stem trunks that, at maturity, will normally be between 15 and 30 feet in height. These small to medium-sized trees or plantings often prefer shade and grow naturally under the canopy of larger trees, where they are used for variety and aesthetic purposes in plantings. UNDISTURBED, AREA OF An area of special site preservation to qualify for floor area or density bonus, in which the natural ground cover and plant or woodland growth shall not be removed except through actions: 1. Necessary to limit the spread of disease and noxious weeds, 2. To trim or remove dead trees or parts of dead trees that are a hazard, or Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 458 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions 3. To control the erosion of soil from the site. UPZONING A change in zoning allowing more intensive development. More intensive development is indicated by an increase in density, a broadened range of authorized uses, an increased floor area ratio, a shift from residential to commercial development, or a shift from commercial to industrial development. URBAN AGRICULTURE The cultivation of food and/or horticulture crops, aquaponics, aquaculture, and/or hydroponics. Such use may include the production and sale of food products from food grown on the premises. Urban Agriculture includes the raising of small animals like bees for the purpose of producing honey and chickens for the purpose of producing eggs, but does not include slaughtering or selling meat or the keeping of any large animals. All such activities must comply with all applicable provisions of the Rochester Code of Ordinances. USABLE RECREATION AREA A space provided as an accessory use on the same lot or site as a primary residential use and designed for the conduct of active or passive recreation. USE (OF LAND) The purpose or activity for which land or buildings are designed, arranged, or intended, or for which land or buildings are occupied or maintained. USE, ACCESSORY A use of land that is secondary and subordinate to the primary use of land. USE, PRIMARY The primary use of land or buildings as distinguished from subordinate or accessory uses. UTILITY, MAJOR A facility providing an important regional utility service, such as water, sewer, or drainage, that normally entails construction of new buildings or structures, and that sometimes have employees on the site on an ongoing basis including but not limited to water towers, natural gas regulating stations, electric substations, water treatment plants, sewage treatment plants, above- or below-ground reservoirs, regional stormwater detention ponds, electric power lines that transmit over 110 KV of power, and other large facilities that enable the provision of utility services to large geographic area or a large number of people. Major Utility does not include Geothermal Energy System, Ground- or Building-Mounted Solar Collector, or Ground- or Building- Mounted Wind Energy Conversion System (WECS). Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 459 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions UTILITY, MINOR Equipment necessary to support utility services to development within the immediate vicinity and that involves only minor accessory structures, and that typically do not have employees located at the site on an ongoing basis including but not limited to electric transformer stations and service boxes, gas regulator stations, telephone service boxes, and well, water and sewer pumping stations, and related underground and aboveground pipes and wires, but excluding electric power transmission lines that transmit over 110 KV of power. VARIANCE Any deviation, other than a minor modification or a major modification, from the regulations of the applicable zoning district. VETERINARY AND ANIMAL SERVICES A commercial establishment engaged in the practice of veterinary medicine, dentistry, or surgery, along with those providing animal related services such as kennels, grooming, or breeding services. A single instance of incidental breeding of a household animal is not included in this definition. VERTICAL SUBDIVISIONS The three-dimensional subdivision of space into separate ownership parcels within an existing building or proposed building project by registered land survey. VISIBILITY TRIANGLE The triangular area formed by joining points measured 30 feet along the property line from the intersection of two streets, or by joining points measured 10 feet back along a driveway and lot line from the point of intersection of the driveway and lot line. As an alternative to Subsection a, the City Engineer may, on a site-specific basis, apply American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO) standards based on a site-specific evaluation of intersection visibility. WALKWAY A right-of-way for pedestrian or bicycle that does not meet the definition of a sidewalk, bikeway, or multi-use trail. WALL The vertical exterior surface of a building. WATER-ORIENTED ACCESSORY STRUCTURE OR FACILITY A small above ground building or other improvement, except stairways, fences, docks, and retaining walls, that, because of the relationship of its use to a surface water feature, reasonably needs to be located closer to public waters than the normal building setback including but not limited to boathouses, gazebos, screen houses, fish houses, pump houses, and detached decks. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 460 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions WETLAND An area that is inundated or saturated by surface or ground water at a frequency and duration sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstances supports a prevalence of vegetation typically adapted for life in saturated soil conditions. Wetlands generally include swamps, marshes, bogs, and similar areas as identified in Minnesota Rule, part 6420-0.111. WHOLESALE FACILITY An establishment engaged primarily in selling merchandise to retailers, or to industrial, commercial institutional or professional business customers, or to other wholesalers, or on a mail order basis to individuals or firms, or that serve as agents or brokers buying merchandise for, or selling merchandise to, individuals and companies. WIND ENERGY RELATED DEFINITIONS When used in the context of regulating wind energy conversion systems, the following terms shall have the definitions shown below. WIND ENERGY CONVERSION SYSTEM (WECS) A wind energy conversion system as defined in Minn. Stat. Ch. 116C, as amended (“… any device such as a wind charger, windmill, or wind turbine and associated facilities that converts wind energy to electrical energy”) (MR 7836.0100). WIND TURBINE A machine used to produce electricity by converting the kinetic energy of wind to electrical energy. A wind turbine consists of a rotor, nacelle, tower and supporting cables, and foundation. WOODLAND An area of planted material covering one acre or more with a minimum dimension of 66 feet, having a density of twenty trees or more per acre with a caliper of eight inches or more. YARD A ground level open space that lies between a primary building and the nearest lot line. Such yard is unobstructed and open to the sky except as may be specifically provided for in this UDC. YARD DEPTH The shortest distance between a lot line and a wall of a building located on the lot. YARD LINE A line drawn parallel to a lot line at a distance therefrom equal to the depth of the minimum required yard or setback that defines the required yard area. YOUTH FACILITY A public playground, public swimming pool, public library, or licensed day care facility. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 461 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions ZONING CERTIFICATE A document issued by the Community Development Director permitting a use of a building or on a parcel of land to commence, based upon a finding that the development is consistent with the terms of the zoning certificate authorizing the development. ZONING MAP The map or maps showing the boundaries of the zoning districts listed in this UDC. The zoning map is considered a part of this UDC. Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Adopted September 7, 2022 462 Chapter 60.600: Definitions Section 60.600.030 Definitions Rochester, Minnesota Unified Development Code Cover Photography by AB Photography & Alpha Digital Adopted September 7, 2022 463