The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About4/18/2017 DMCC Transportation Work Session - Agenda and Meeting PacketDMC Integrated Transportation Studies DMCC Workshop Agenda April 18, 2017 9:00 – 11:10 am Mayo Civic Center, Rooms 110 and 111 Workshop Goals: • To obtain input that will help the City narrow the current group of scenarios to something less than 6 • To identify any “red flag” concerns so that they can be addressed Integrated Transit Scenarios have been developed which combine a range of parking location approaches and transit alignments/modes/profiles (also in combination with City Loop route alternatives and Pedestrian Streets/protected bike lanes) to examine how they respond to DMC parking and multi-modal transportation needs. In this workshop, we will discuss how we arrived upon these scenarios and describe key elements of each, allowing ample time for questions and discussion. During the workshop we will also address the timeline and process for narrowing down these six scenarios to a single preferred alternative by the end of 2017. The workshop will conclude with a discussion of materials to be presented at the April 27 DMCC Board Meeting. Agenda: 1) Introduction of Scenarios (Beth B) a. Purpose of scenarios b. Integrated Transit Opportunities c. Integrated Transit Constraints 2) Review of Scenarios (Joni G) a. No Build Scenario b. DMC Modified Scenario c. Scenario A d. Scenario B e. Scenario C f. Scenario D 3) Discussion of Scenarios (All) 4) Timeline for narrowing down the number of scenarios (Beth) 5) Evaluation Framework (Tom B) 6) April 27 DMCC Board Meeting J8618-23_MM_ITSDMCC Workshop__Agenda_20170418.docx J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT OPPORTUNITIES ST. MARY’S PLACE HEART OF THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA ROCHESTER DISCOVERY SQUARE CIVIC CENTER 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center DMC Boundary Rochester PTN Parking Opportunities Key Transit Destinations J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT CONSTRAINTS 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center DMC Boundary Constrained Roadway Portals Constrained Street Corridors Adjacent Existing Residential Areas Steep Topography J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_FULL.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT NO BUILD SCENARIO LEGEND T H W Y 5 2 T H W Y 5 2 BR O A D W A Y A V E E A S T C I R C L E D R VIOLARD NE COLLEGE VIEW RD THWY 14 MA R I O N R D S I M P S O N R D - C O R D 1 BR O A D W A Y A V E 12 ST SW CO RD 2 5 S W CO R D 2 2 S W 2 ST SW COU N T R Y C L U B R D 12 ST SE TH W Y 6 5 THWY 52 THWY 5 2 TH W Y 5 2 T H W Y 6 5 48 ST CO RD 148 CO RD 101 THW Y 1 4 VALLEYHIGH RD 65 ST 75 ST 55 ST 1 8 A V E THWY 1 4 W E S T C I R C L E D R 37 ST NW TH W Y 6 3 CIVIC CENTER DR 0 3,800 7,600 Feet East Park Silver Lake Park Quarry Hill Nature Center Northern Heights Park Foster Arend Park Indian Heights Park Cooke Park Kutzky Park Watson Sports Complex Essex ParkKings Run Park Schmidt Park KR-6 Reservoir KR-7 Reservo ir Manor Park Cascade Lake Park Willo w Creek Reservo ir Gamehaven Reservo ir Smekta Park McQuillan Field Joyce Park Eastwood Park Homestead Park Fuad Mansour Sports Complex Rochester Youth Baseball Co mplex So ldiers Memorial Field Zumbro So uth Park Hadley Creek Golf Learning Center Graham Park Mayo wo od Corrido r Northern Hills Golf Course DMC Boundary Comprehensive Plan Park and Ride Rochester PTN Beyond 20 year PTN Intermediate PTN J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT DMC MODIFIED SCENARIO WITH PEDESTRIAN 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center DMC Boundary Primary Building Entrance Parking (Subject to Freeway Access Feasibility Analysis) Rochester PTN Transit (Streetcar / Exclusive Lane) City Loop Periphery Parking High Pedestrian Amenity Streets J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT SCENARIO A WITH PEDESTRIAN 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center High Pedestrian Amenity Streets DMC Boundary Primary Building Entrance Periphery Parking Remote Parking Rochester PTN Transit (BRT or Tram) Transit (Future) City Loop Protected Bike Lane J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT SCENARIO B WITH PEDESTRIAN 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center DMC Boundary Primary Building Entrance Periphery Parking Remote Parking Rochester PTN Transit (BRT) Transit (Subterranean) Transit (Future) City Loop Protected Bike Lane High Pedestrian Amenity Streets J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 INTEGRATED TRANSIT SCENARIO C WITH PEDESTRIAN 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center DMC Boundary Primary Building Entrance Periphery Parking Remote Parking Rochester PTN Elevated Transit (AGT, AV) Transit (Future) City Loop Protected Bike Lane High Pedestrian Amenity Streets Note: Scenarios A, B and Modified DMC incorporate unique city loop options. Scenarios C and D reflect the Modified DMC city loop option. J8613-23 Integrated Transit Studies DMC_BASEMAP_ENLARGE.INDD: 04/11/2017 0 1,000 2,000 Feet LEGEND CROSSR OAD S DR SW 7 A V E S WFOX KN OLL D R SW 3 AVE NW 18 AVE SW MEMORIAL PKW Y S W 4 ST SE W SILVER LAKE DR 14 ST SW 16 AVE NW CIVIC CENTER DR NE FOLWELL D R SW 12 ST SE 14 ST NE 6 ST SE 16 ST SW WEST SILVER LAKE DR NE BROADWAY AVE N CIVIC C EN TER DR SE 6 AVE NW 3 AVE NW 4 AVE NW 3 AVE SE 2 ST NW 3 AVE SW 4 AVE SW 4 ST SW 10 ST SW BROADWAY AVE N 26 AVE NW 6 AVE SW CENTER ST E 14 ST NW 23 AVE SW CO R D 146 SE 16 ST SE W FRTG RD TH 52 N 7 ST NE 2 ST SW CENTER ST W 8 AVE SE 13 ST NW 8AVESE 9 ST SE SALE M R D S W 9 AVE SW ELTO N HILLS DR N W CIVIC CENTER DR NW 6 ST SW 10 AVE SW 1 4 A V E S W G E O R G E GIB B S D R S W VALLEYHIGH D R N W 12 ST SW 17 AVE SW 3 AVE SW 7 ST NW BROADWAY AVE S 11 AVE N W Slatterly Park Silver Lake Park Indian Heights Park Goose Egg Park Thompson Mill Race Cooke Park Kutzky Park Yo unge Park Plummer House St. Marys Park Central Park Cascade Lake Park Graham Arena Complex Mayo Field Park Soldiers Memorial Field Zumbro South Park Rochester Bike Trail Graham Park Mayo Civic Center INTEGRATED TRANSIT SCENARIO D WITH PEDESTRIAN High Pedestrian Amenity DMC Boundary Primary Building Entrance Remote Parking Periphery Parking City Loop Protected Bike Lane Rochester PTN Transit (At grade north of Civic Center Drive. Elevated south of Civic Center Drive) Note: Scenarios A, B and Modified DMC incorporate unique city loop options. Scenarios C and D reflect the Modified DMC city loop option. 2016 2017 Key Milestones A S O N D J F M A M J J A S O N D 1 Public & Stakeholder Engagement Activities Deliverables • Engagement Plan • Summary of Meeting Input • Evaluation Plan 2 Street Use and Operations Study Deliverables • Data Collection • Portal/Street Capacity • Street Typologies • Model Simulations for Test Scenarios • Block Assessment/Design Matrix • Concept Plans & Visualizations 3 Parking and Transportation Management Authority (TMA) Study Deliverables • Parking Supply Inventory • Parking Demand Estimates • Policy Adjustments (Shared Parking) • Financial Analysis/Rates • Parking Scenario Results • TDM Plan (Framework, Strategies, Mechanisms) • Pilot Program • On-Going Plan 4 Transit Circulation Study Deliverables • Previous Work • Purpose and Need • Initial Modes & Alignments • Screening Results • Detailed Alternatives Cost, Ridership & Impacts • Preferred Alternative • Study Report 5 City Loop Study Deliverables • Previous Work • Baseline Conditions • Precedent Guidance • Impacts of Initial Concepts • Preferred Concept • Study Report Rochester Integrated Transit Studies - Milestones and Deliverables Revised April 11, 2017 • Stantec • WSB • Kimley-Horn • AECOM • SRF n Progressive Consulting n Stonebrook n Stonebrook n Community Design Group n Progressive Consulting n MN Best • Kimley-Horn • Nelson\Nygaard • UrbanTrans • SRF • Nelson\Nygaard • HDR • HDR • Kimley-Horn • Cross-Spectrum Acoustics • SEH • Alta • Barr Eng. • REA Workshops & Meetings EvaluationSummary Visualizations Workshops & Meetings EvaluationResults Pilot Programs On-Going Plan Preferred Alternative Detailed Impacts Study Report Study ReportPreferred Concept Workshops & Meetings Design Matrix Delivery Mechanisms Policy/Financial Adjustments Initial Parking Scenario Results Final Parking Scenario Results Screening Results Initial Alternatives Workshops & Meetings EvaluationFramework Portal/Street Capacity Typologies Test Results TDM Strategies Demand Estimates Baseline Conditions Precedent Guidance Impacts of Initial Concepts Workshops & Meetings Engagement Plan 10/27 Transit Technology Event 10/27 DMCC Board Update 12/15 DMCC Board Meeting 1/26 DMCC Board Meeting 4/27 DMCC Board Meeting 7/27 DMCC Board Meeting 11/2 DMCC Board Meeting Data Collection TDM Framework Parking Supply Inventory Previous Work Purpose & Need Previous WorkNotice to Proceed Notice to Proceed Notice to Proceed Notice to Proceed Prototyping Concept Plans Identify Purpose & Need Develop Universe of Alternatives Identify best combination of transit, parking, and bike concepts to meet needs and fit constraints Evaluate initial combination of ideas as Tier 1 Screening Present “draft” results of Tier 1 Screening to public and other stakeholders to identify best test scenarios - incorporate comments Finalize Tier 2 Evaluation Criteria Finalize 3 test scenarios Analyze and evaluate 3 test scenarios Present “draft” results of Tier 2 evaluation to public and other stakeholders to identify most promising option Screen out poorest performing scenarios and components Incorporate comments Stakeholders select “draft” most promising option in early October Identify impacts of most promising option and develop visualizations, finance and implementation requirements Present “draft” most prom-ising option to City Council and DMCC Board Compare impacts and results of most promising option to no-build Present results to public and other stakeholders - incorporate comments Finalize preferred alternative September - Public Conversation #1 - Staff Work Session October - Transit Technology Event January - Public Conversation#2 - Staff Work Session September - Public Conversation #4 - Work Sessions (COW, DMC Board, County) August - Staff Work Session October - Staff Work Session December - Public Conversation #5 - Work Sessions (COW, DMCC Board, County) May - Public Conversation #3 - Work Sessions (COW, DMC Board, County) March - Staff Work Session April - DMCC Board Work Session (4/18/2017) - DMCC Board meeting (4/27/2017) September 2016 – January 2017 February – March 2017 May 2017April 2017 June– August 2017 September 2017 October – November 2017 December 2017 MEETINGS AND WORK SESSIONS » ROCHESTER INTEGRATED TRANSIT STUDIES | PROCESS TO DEVELOP AND EVALUATE ALTERNATIVES TIME LINE » Many Options ≈6 Options + No-Build 6 Options + No-Build ≈3 Options + No-Build 3 Options + No-Build <3 Options + No-Build ≈1 Option + No-Build 1 Option NUMBER OF OPTIONS » ACTIONS »